Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE &
Business LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
Fri May 25 15:22:52 SAST 2012

Mdladlana: Criminalise wage 'thieves'

Sapa | 12 October, 2010 15:090 Comments

Employers who do not meet minimum wage levels are no better than thieves and should face criminal sanctions, Labour Minister Membathisi Mdladlana says.

"What I am proposing, and I know that many people are going to fight with me... we want to criminalise people who do not comply with the law," he told the annual meeting of the clothing industry bargaining council in Cape Town.

"I'm ready for the battle."

He said some clothing manufacturers appeared to regard non-compliance with wage levels set by the council as "the norm".

However, even in the apartheid era, non-compliance with labour law had been a criminal offence.

"I'm very simplistic about this matter. I don't know the difference between a person who steals somebody's television, and a person who steals somebody's fundamental human right," Mdladlana said.

He said the council had done all it could in terms of "accommodating, massaging, soothing" non-compliant firms.

"So what do you do in a situation where you are even begging people to comply?" he asked. "Yours is to enforce the law [sic]."

The council should not be quick to put up a white flag of surrender in its battle against offenders.

"The war is not over. It's probably just the beginning," he said.

The minister's remarks follow controversy over pay at some clothing factories in the Newcastle area, where the statutory minimum wage is R324 a week.

The council says, though this is disputed by the Newcastle employers, that some workers are getting as little as R90 a week.

Some of the factories shut down briefly in August, saying they could not afford the minimum.

However Mdladlana told the council on Tuesday that those employers were making a "political statement".

"Because that's not a business statement: that's a political statement," he said.

Employer spokesman on the council Johan Baard told Sapa employers fully supported re-criminalising the Labour Relations Act.

Before 1995, any employer in breach of a bargaining council agreement would appear before a magistrate, who would either ask them to remedy the breach, or impose a punishment such as jail.

"It just seems to us that in the absence of an effective deterrent, the current civil remedy is certainly proving to be ineffective and is being abused by many employers," Baard said.

He said the most severe sanction under the current system was a high court writ of execution to attach the assets of a company against its indebtedness to its workers in respect of underpayment of wages.

Currently the council was busy with writs against several hundred companies, of which it had served and executed 55.

It has agreed to a moratorium on serving the rest pending an industry summit convened by Economic Development Minister Ebrahim Patel.

General secretary of the SA Clothing and Textile Workers Union, Andre Kriel, told Mdladlana in the council meeting that the union was grateful for his support on compliance.

The matter had come to the point where there was no option but to "forecefully enforce" the council's decisions.

He said the unions had sponsored a resolution on criminalisation at the Cosatu national conference last year, whcih was adopted.

Mdladlana in Tuesday's speech also criticised the way the industry had established differing wage levels for particular regions, in terms of which workers in the Western Cape, for example, are paid more than their counterparts in semirural Botshabelo.

"I'm leaving you to think seriously about it, because sooner rather than later you might find yourelves in the Constitutional Court for discriminating against people."

To submit comments you must first

Join the discussion & Debate

Mdladlana: Criminalise wage 'thieves'

For Commenters Consideration | Please stick to the subject matter