Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE &
Business LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
Sat May 26 08:26:17 SAST 2012

Russell Tribunal a 'kangaroo court'

PHILANI NOMBEMBE | 07 November, 2011 00:0312 Comments
Cosatu general secretary Zwelinzima Vavi. Picture: TEBOGO LETSIE

Cosatu general secretary Zwelinzima Vavi has shrugged off criticism that the Russell Tribunal on Palestine is a kangaroo court.

The tribunal is billed by its convenors as an international platform for the promotion of peace and justice between Israel and Palestine.

About a dozen protesters calling themselves "concerned Jews" and outside Cape Town's District Six Museum, where the hearings took place yesterday, dismissed the tribunal as "biased". One brandished a placard reading: "No to kangaroo courts, Yes to consultative dialogue".

Vavi who, along with Winnie Madikizela-Mandela, participated in the tribunal, said Cosatu was proud to have sponsored the event.

"Cosatu will remain committed to using workers' money to ensure that welfare and justice are available to all people in the world, just as we received support from people in other countries," he said.

"Palestinians are being forced out of their country and, as people who received support from other countries, we are saying that it shouldn't happen."

Vavi said he was moved by testimonies to the tribunal and described the plight of Palestinians as "worse than apartheid".

The two-day session in Cape Town was the third in a series of hearings around the world. Sessions were held in Barcelona and London last year, and the final session will be in New York next year.

Alan Fischer, who led the group of protestors, said they wanted a chance to tell their story.

He slammed Cosatu for sponsoring the tribunal with workers' money.

"We are here because we believe the process is patently unfair. This Russell Tribunal . has on it everyone who has already taken an anti-Israeli position," said Fischer.

The members on the panel included author Alice Walker, 93-year-old Holocaust survivor Stephane Hessel and Ronnie Kasrils, a former cabinet minister.

Witnesses drew parallels between the policies and practices of Israel with regard to Palestinians and those of the apartheid government in South Africa.

When Archbishop Desmond Tutu opened the tribunal on Saturday he lashed out at Israel for the suffering of Palestinians.

"They have forgotten their own history. They have forgotten what their own prophets have said about our God," said Tutu.

"We worship a God naturally biased in favour of the suffering, the underdog, those who are suffering underfoot.

"In the Holy Land, the Palestinian people are the ones suffering."

Fischer said Tutu should deal with the matter "even-handedly" and "in a way that will be conducive to bringing about a peaceful settlement".

The tribunal will announce its findings today.

To submit comments you must first

Join the discussion & Debate

Russell Tribunal a 'kangaroo court'

For Commenters Consideration | Please stick to the subject matter

COMMENTS [12]

nkosipeter

Posted 200 days ago
Avatar
It is pointless to take sides on this issue.

Understandably Israel seeks security and Palestine seeks dignity.

Both sides are going about it in the wrong way, in this most unholy of lands.

Desmond Tutu should know better than to take sides.

Mariévan_Wyk

Posted 200 days ago
Avatar
Russell tribunal
The so called white people who were probably the strongest alllies of the struggle, were the Jewish people in SA. Eg when Mandela was desperate, it was a Jewish law firm that employed him and protected him and yesterday in Die Burger's By, we read about Albie Sachs who fought in the struggle without receiving anything, but rather losing an arm and sight in one eye!! Please open the books on what the role of the Jewish people was and is in the history of the struggle and current government in SA. Then answer me, Mr Vavi: why did you accept them when they struggled with you for your liberation, yet you are not willing to support them in their struggle for survival against the killing machines of the so called Palestinians?
Marié van Wyk
Avatar

AshneSegal

Posted 200 days ago
Marie van Wyk, I salute you! Well said. About time someone got the picture.
Avatar

nkosipeter

Posted 200 days ago
Vavi is a political oppertunist of little value or substance.

Ignore him.
Avatar

Desmond-ct

Posted 200 days ago
Maire van Wyk, the Jewish State (Isreal) did not support the struggle against the Apartheid government of Vorster, et all, instead, they were the bigggest suppliers to the then Nationalist Party government. We are living in the 21st Century and yet the Isreali's still perpetuate their aggressive onslaught against the Palestinians. Both sides in my opinion must end its hostilities against each other and give peace a chance. Bothe sides are guilty of atrocities against humans and are equally guilty of crimes against humanity. Its pointless rambling about who is right and or wrong, what is required now is leadership, respect for human rights and dignity and the restoration of a people who can co-exists. But first and foremost, there need to be a halt to all hostilities and aggression. We can write as many arguments for and against but the at the end of it all, there is a lack of political will to end the aggression especially seeing that Isreal and its allies hold the key to this.
Avatar

Emmanuel_goldstein

Posted 200 days ago
I'm not sure why you are equating the actions of Israel with Jewish people. Many Jewish people have spoken out against the actions of Israel and, while you are correct that many Jewish people played a role in, and supported, the South African liberation struggle, the reality is that the state of Israel was one of the main supporters of the apartheid regime.

msazona

Posted 200 days ago
Avatar
The struggle for the liberation of Palestine is not about colour or Jews people. Marie to quote progressive Jewish people people like Albie Sachsand many of them who struggled aganist apartheid and who actually are against the oppression of the palestinian people does not assist in resolving the conflict in Isreal. To attach Vavi either does not assist at all. Ronnie Kasril,a jewish South Africanis participating in the tribunal because he believe in the struggle for the liberation of the people of Palestine.

BobbyBob

Posted 200 days ago
Avatar
"Cosatu will remain committed to using workers' money to ensure that welfare and justice are available to all people in the world, just as we received support from people in other countries,"

Now that's just rubbish. Vavi has no business spending workers money on international issues. His brief is the worker, and helping the economy create more jobs . Too long in the job comrade?
Avatar

Emmanuel_goldstein

Posted 200 days ago
Lucky that trade unions around the world that supported COSATU during the apartheid era didn't take your view!!

Emmanuel_goldstein

Posted 200 days ago
Avatar
Your article fails to mention that the Israeli government was invited to attend and put their side of the argument forward. They refused to do so, so to claim that Israel has not been afforded an opportunity in this regard is just nonsense.

buddi

Posted 200 days ago
Avatar
Hasn't Vavi got enough local problems to spend his time and money on? Its not his money to spend.

Thela

Posted 200 days ago
Avatar
The Germanys under Hitler caused enormous harm to the Jews but for Israel to suddenly forget and inflict such pain and humiliation to the Palestinians is something to be condemed by all humans. As an African myself if we were as of today declare that we do not want anyone who is not an African in this country as what Adi Amin and Robert Mugabe did, can anyone who jusify the inhillation of Palestinians accept that? If I am prepared to live side by side by Europens and all races who accept this country as theirs what fails Jews and Arabs in Israel to impliment that? Tutu said it all. I hate racism, I hate tribalism and I hate discrimination with passion let those who support the humilliation of Palestinians to please leave this country and joins those who supress others in that Holy land. Robert Mugabe is hounting whites because he is a racist evil man who is justfying his act let those who support Israel apartheid to please leave our country.