Two provinces near economic collapse
Image by: GCIS
In an historic first, the ANC-led government has admitted that two provinces are on the brink of economic collapse and in dire need of financial bailout.
It emerged yesterday that widescale maladministration and possible criminal intent in Limpopo, Free State and Gauteng has forced the National Treasury to dip into reserves amounting to billions of rands in an effort to prevent a looming crisis.
The economic embarrassment has forced the cabinet to place eight departments in Limpopo and Free State under administration, effectively meaning that the National Treasury will play big brother to their finances.
In a shocking statement, cabinet spokesman Jimmy Manyi revealed how the three provinces - with Limpopo faring the worst - plunged into financial difficulties, forcing the government to urgently review provincial spending and devise elegant solutions to a situation analysts describe as "embarrassing to the country".
A cash-strapped Limpopo alone has asked Treasury for a R1-billion bailout on top of a R757.3-million overdraft to pay for November salaries.
Gauteng needs R627-million to pay for salary increases and faces "chronic problems" with large accrual and other financial disasters. It is not clear how much Free State has requested from the Treasury.
Manyi said the cabinet had been "concerned" about the state of financial management and governance in the three provinces for some time and that the drastic move was necessitated by trends of unsatisfactory spending, overspending and challenges with supply chain management.
"The Minister of Finance Pravin Gordhan was asked by cabinet to urgently review the situation in Limpopo and other provinces and report back to cabinet on proposed actions to be taken to improve the financial situation and its impact on service delivery and provincial functions," said Manyi.
The intervention, as decided by the cabinet yesterday, will entail:
- Key departments in Limpopo and Free State being placed under administration;
- The cabinet assuming responsibility for Limpopo's treasury, education, transport and roads, health and public works departments;
- The cabinet issuing directives for Free State's treasury and police and roads and transport departments;
- Gauteng signing agreements with ministers of health and finance to address financial challenges in the provincial health department;
- Gauteng being assisted with financial management and supply chain management issues;
- Forensic investigations with strict deadlines to be carried out; and
- A monitoring committee under Gordhan's leadership, assisted by six other national ministers.
And though the ANC might have egg on its face over its failure to adequately deal with its finances in the three provinces it holds majority power over, the cabinet said heads would roll if the investigations uncover any illegal conduct.
MECs, heads of departments, chief financial officers and other appropriate officials will also be replaced by the national acting deployees on a case-by-case basis.
According to Manyi, a cash- strapped Limpopo had used up its R757.3-million overdraft facility with the Corporation for Public Deposits and had asked that its facility be increased by R1-billion to pay salaries and wages on November 23.
"This request was declined but alternative arrangements were made for an early transfer of their equitable share," said Manyi.
Efficient Group chief economist Dawie Roodt said yesterday: "I don't think government realises the kind of damage something like this does to the economy. At the moment, as things stand, we are barely managing ... we are not in trouble as yet, but we are not comfortable," said Roodt.
He attributes the provinces' financial woes to incompetence and the ANC's cadre deployment tendencies.

SHARE YOUR OPINION
If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.BornintheRSA
Posted 172 days agoooooooooo
MsLee
Fedupguy
A team led by astronomers at the University of California, Berkeley, discovered the two gigantic black holes in clusters of elliptical galaxies more than 300 million light years away. That’s relatively close on the galactic scale.
“They are monstrous,” Berkeley astrophysicist Chung-Pei Ma told reporters. “We did not expect to find such massive black holes because they are more massive than indicated by their galaxy properties. They’re kind of extraordinary.”
The previous black hole record-holder is as large as 6 billion suns.
In research released Monday by the journal Nature, the scientists suggest these black holes may be the leftovers of quasars that crammed the early universe. They are similar in mass to young quasars, they said, and have been well hidden until now.
The scientists used ground-based telescopes as well as the Hubble Space Telescope and Texas supercomputers, observing stars near the black holes and measuring the stellar velocities to uncover these vast, invisible regions.
Black holes are objects so dense that nothing, not even light, can escape. Some are formed by the collapse of a super-size star.
It’s uncertain how these two newly discovered whoppers originated, said Nicholas McConnell, a Berkeley graduate student who is the study’s lead author. To be so massive now means they must have grown considerably since their formation, he said.
Most if not all galaxies are believed to have black holes at their center. The bigger the galaxy, it seems, the bigger the black hole.
Quasars are some of the most energized and distant of galactic centers.
The researchers said their findings suggest differences in the way black holes grow, depending on the size of the galaxy.
Ma speculates these two black holes remained hidden for so long because they are living in quiet retirement — much quieter and more boring than their boisterous youth powering quasars billions of years ago.
“For an astronomer, finding these insatiable black holes is like finally encountering people nine feet tall whose great height had only been inferred from fossilized bones. How did they grow so large?” Ma said in a news release. “This rare find will help us understand whether these black holes had very tall parents or ate a lot of spinach.”
Oxford University astrophysicist Michele Cappellari, who wrote an accompanying commentary in the journal, agreed that the two newly discovered black holes “probably represent the missing dormant relics of the giant black holes that powered the brightest quasars in the early universe.” One of the newly detected black holes weighs 9.7 billion times the mass of the sun. The second, slightly farther from Earth, is as big or even bigger.
Even larger black holes may be lurking out there. Ma said that’s the million-dollar question: How big can a black hole grow?
The researchers already are peering into the biggest galaxies for answers.
“If there is any bigger black hole,” Ma said, “we should be able to find them in the next year or two. Personally, I think we are probably reaching the high end now. Maybe another factor of two to go at best.”
PhutianaMolepo
I984
Posted 172 days agoEish comrades. The house of cards.
Shongweni
Posted 172 days agopan
Posted 172 days agoYet the province with the highest infux of poor people as a percentage of population, and the second highest in actual numbers, is just fine. Thanks DA for not embarrassing us like the ANC have.
The GREAT news is that the very people who blindly vote the ANC are suffering the most. I'm loving it. Karma.
pan
Posted 172 days agoGordhan tells us tax payers to tighten our belts, so the PIGS at the trough can get more? Is THAT how it works, hey Gordhan?
I984
1.757 billion. Finally the way has been found - the unsuspecting taxpayers are directly filling comrades' pockets. It's free for all. The party never ends. Juju's dream has finally come true!!!
brencis
Posted 172 days agoOf course this problem is very easily solved! Vote the ANC out of office, give someone else a chance. Even if you give them just 5 year - test the waters, see what happens. IF they do well we keep them if they fail we return to the devil we know. Other countries are doing it why shouldn't we?!
danny.archer1
danny.archer1
NeoBlack
If you throw a hungry dog a bone, and it stills refuses to grab it, then maybe you need to take another look at the bone, and not just blame the dog for being attitudinal.
I984
Everything in this world and life is ALWAYS a two-way street and NEVER simply black-or-white (pun not intended)
Perhaps the opposition parties need to seriously up their game.
Or perhaps we are dealing with a dog which has decided it would rather starve to death - than accept a bone from someone other than his Master?
NeoBlack
I agree, there is always a grey area.
It could also be that maybe the dog has learnt over the years not to trust strangers. I think the stranger is really interested in the welfare of the dog, and not just interested in spiting its master, he will do a little bit more to earn the trsut of the dog.
NeoBlack
danny.archer1
"I think this is actaully a serious indictment on opposition parties in South Africa"
I think this is actually a serious indictment on the brain capacity of the majority (and we all know who the majority are).
"If you throw a hungry dog a bone, and it stills refuses to grab it, then maybe you need to take another look at the bone, and not just blame the dog for being attitudinal."
The bone being thrown to the dog is a 600 gram cut of AAA grade prime T-bone. But the dog remains focussed on gnawing away at what it has; a fetid, rotting piece of horse meat, chucked over the fence by thieves to incapacitate the dog. The dog is rabid. It is out of its mind.
NeoBlack
ahistoricism is a problem of a defective mind. If only you could put your ear on the ground and listen to the voices of the subaltern, you will appreciate their perspective. You will begin to imagine and see life from their point of view. The problem with people like you is that you fail to contextualise and deeply understand the impact of experience on human behaviour. You may think that you have the medicine to cure all the ailments that people are suffering from, but if fail to win people's trust, then you may scream as loud as you wish, your medicine will never be considered. If you are really a self-reflexive person, you begin to ask yourself deeper questions than merely dismissing people as idiotic.
It is all about TRUST, the wreched of the earth do not trust teh so-called alternative voices out there.
NeoBlack
I know the DA for instance is not comfortable with the 'majority'/ 'minority' speak as these tend to be cast in racial terms, and to them race ain't a big issue in SA. 'It is only the ANC that is obsessed with that' , so goes the logic. So please lay bare your thoughts so that we all could follow.
danny.archer1
"then you may scream as loud as you wish"
I am not screaming. I am laughing at them. I am taking great pleasure in my haughty knowledge that they are suffering because they make decisions based on emotion and not fact. "We told you so," feels pretty good right now.
"It is all about TRUST, the wreched of the earth do not trust teh so-called alternative voices out there."
Exactly my point. The heart overrides the head when you continue to TRUST someone who abuses you, when there are alternatives available. Of course, if you have no head, then you are doomed to follow your heart. Like Beelzebub said, I have less sympathy for them than the cockroach he stepped on.
NeoBlack
It is interesting that you cast a clear line between 'facts' and 'emotions' and you can tell if certain ations are derivitive from 'facts'/ reason and others from 'emotions'. I wonder if you ever think of the interplay between the two, if that is beyond your grasp. The truth is facts are always approached and interpreted from particular emotional states/ subjectivity hence when you talk of facts I immediately look into your subjectivity/ value system which shapes and inform the way you interact with your social space and humanity at large. Similarly, emotional states are shaped by real life experiences/ facts and historical memory if you like.
The binary that you put between 'facts' and 'emotions' is unwarranted and is reflective of some fundamental defect in your thought pattern.
Your 'I told you so' laughter is meaningless, as you belong to a different plane of existence vis a vis the people you claim to be laughing at. I do not think they even undertand what you are trying to do, or they even take your theatrical displays seriously.
Lastly, do not forget that the same people you are mocking, do not see you as an alternative. To them you are the former oppressor who is desperate on casting himself anew. You poses do not represent anything they would like to associate themselves with.
BlackTsunami
I can't agree with you more broer. The likes of Acher make as if ordinary black south africans are judging them unfairly. They conveniently forget their complicity in the oppression and economic subjugation of black people in south africa. Well, if they do, they must remember that there are many of us who still remember. They cannot all of a sudden turn into messiahs and want to preach the salvation of the black man.
I understand the crises at hand re: the three provinces and probably many others. However, this does not make our former oppressors are necessarily angels. If they were, why did we rise up against them? Their time has passed.
buddi
None of us have forgotten the past, and many so-called oppressors actually voted against it in a referendum, as you may also remember.
However, while you may not have forgotten the oppressors, I definitely expected more from the liberators. The oppressors looked after their own, while the liberators are only looking after themselves. Note the difference?
danny.archer1
BlackTsunami
There is nothing to be proud of about the referendum of 1992. The standards were too scaled down with the choice being between a mugabe and a george bush. Andries Treneucht CP represented too low standards that no right thinking person would have wanted to associate himself with. Their low base made the NATS look like they were progressives. So if I were you I would not use the 1992 'yes' vote as a yardstick of white's progressive thinking at the time. Also, the fact that CP got a significantly massive vote even in this incredibly lowered standards is an indication of how many whites were still holding onto the past.
Mnbvcxz0
eseyeSAY
Posted 172 days agoOperation Hlasela is now manifesting itself in the Free State. The Provincial Treasury is at the centre of this initiative, and now has collapsed. What the current chairperson of SALGA touches, it collapses. Wonder what will happen to Mangaung Metro. Soon it will be Public Works, whose mandate to build and renovate infrastructure is being carried by Free State Development Corporation. Where the heck have you seen a body which is meant to support business now building clinics? Only in the Free State through Operation Hlasela!
On-Point in Limpopo and Operation Hlasela, there is not difference at all.
mcritic
Posted 172 days agoGo to jail - go directly to jail - do not pass go - do not collect R200
buddi
Posted 172 days agoBut the huge question remains - who is going to bite the dust for this. Quick answer - no-one!!
MsLee
Mnbvcxz0
Posted 172 days agoSuiGeneris
Posted 172 days agoWhat else can one expect when the best candidates for the job will never ever stand a chance of getting it.
Most of whom, and simply because of their competency, are now very successful business owners in the private sector !
This is only the start of many more stunning acts to come in this government circus !
danny.archer1
Posted 172 days agodanny.archer1
pan
Bruster
Posted 172 days agoMsLee
Mnbvcxz0
Posted 172 days agoMnbvcxz0
muk1
Posted 172 days agoMost of the monies go towards salaries into a bloated public sector. I honestly think that we could half the employees and the departments will still function; provided that those that remain know what they are doing and know what customer service is all about. This I know is a bit drastic; but this is the only way out from this mess.
King_Biko
Posted 172 days agopan
It's taken 4 years Biko, but it seems that the hamerster is getting back on the wheel.
BokFan
An interesting opinion, made more so by being quite widely held among the more reckless and incorrigibly irrational anc supporters.
Why it interests me is that it progresses from the denial of outrageous corruption in the camp of the "political victims' of the so-called plot and ends up calling for the continuation of the corrupt and destructive practices. This all under the banner of advancing the cause of " Economic Freedom".
Adding zest this mortal struggle is the certainty that not one of those engaging in it is either rigorous, informed or honest enough to add any value to the economic debate.
I would like to ask you, Mr King, what do you think is meant by "Economic Freedom" and how do you, and those now shown to be criminally incompetent, intend to bring it about?
Thanks for your consideration.
I984
Posted 40 minutes ago
I would like to ask you, Mr King, what do you think is meant by "Economic Freedom" and how do you, and those now shown to be criminally incompetent, intend to bring it about? "
See:
"A cash-strapped Limpopo alone has asked Treasury for a R1-billion bailout on top of a R757.3-million overdraft to pay for November salaries."
That's what. And that's how.
King_Biko
BokFan
But I am saddened that it only contains platitudes and slogans like "total overhaul" "transformation" and sundry other meaningless phrases. There is no detail that could be called a strategy, a plan or a program.
So what do these words mean? Lets trace your scheme back, from the till point, so to speak.
Is everyone to receive a piece of the pie put into their hands .How will you decide who gets what? How often? Will this be done individually and by whom? Will they q up like pensioners while you do it. Are you going to use the banking system to distribute the cash? The Nationalised banking system......? Managed by....? Staffed by....?
Please help your Highness I am keen to subscribe to the Economic Freedom Model but I have so many questions that must be answered first.
ShonaBotes
Posted 172 days agopan
The Poor? Pffft, you can't be serious.
Beelzebub
Posted 172 days agoLove it, the idiots voted and got what they deserved. I have more sympathy for the cockroach I stood on last night.
danny.archer1
dougodurban
Posted 172 days agoNeoBlack
Posted 172 days agoThe situation in the 3 provinces is extremely embarassing and should not be tolerated at all. My gut feeling tells me that other provinces are in similar situation. The problem is actually bigger than many could imagine.
buddi
NeoBlack
cadre deployment is not in itself, a wrong principle. It is a usual political practice all over the world. the only problem is if you deploy incompetent, unqualified people. It is only natural that any political administration will deploy (esp in strategic position) people it trusts, and more often these people are within its ranks.
The british did it pre and post the Union of SA in 1910. In fact before the rise of Afrikaner nationalism during Hertzog and Malan era. The NATS proactively did it post 1948. The examples are endless across the world. Like I said, the problem is if you religiously adhere to the principle even if it means employing incompetent people.
BobbyBob
Posted 171 days agoFixing it from central government by yet more cadres wont fix anything, it will just add another costly layer to be fed.
How to fix it? Vote for those "who can", people!
King_Biko
Posted 171 days agoNeoBlack
NeoBlack
wellie07
Posted 171 days agobuddi
Saha
Posted 171 days agoNow I know why the road at my village in Limpopo has stayed incomplete for the past 36 months! Shame on those officials who are as inept as the former homelands crowd they replaced. We thought they will be a fresh breath of air, but we were evidently wrong. Now that local taxis have stopped to run on the unfinished stretch of the road, I have to crawl to work across deep dongas and large boulders in my battered rattletrap while they glide on smooth roads to the nearby municipality offices in their 4X4s. Maybe I and my fellow villagers are not comrades enough. To what else would we attribute this unforgivable neglect?
That's a big, big, big egg in the face, dear rulers - our former heroes.
danny.archer1
How about your vote for the ANC at the polling booth?
MsLee
Posted 171 days agoYet another reason why we need an entirely new system of government in SA.
MabhebezaEC
Posted 171 days agodanny.archer1
BokFan
Posted 171 days agoPosted 20 minutes ago
"I think this is actaully a serious indictment on opposition parties in South Africa."
My friend you have taken the practice of victimhood to the lowest level yet recorded.
You blame the opposition parties for not improving their offering while failing utterly to address your own lack of moral purpose.
You can blame as much as you like. Point a finger as much as you like. Deny as much as you like. The facts are. You and people like you will always support the anc because you are hardwired to vote like a robot. Furthermore you are irrelevant to the future of this country since you are heading for extinction by your own hand.
Go for it boss
NeoBlack
Tell me you are not serious.
I think you one of those guys of old whom when a lady rejects, you go about telling the whole world how ugly she is. Wake up man, and face your own inadequacies.
Opposition parties like your DA must wake up and present a convincing alternative to south africans and stop blaming other people for your own rejection. I would be embarassed if I were you/ DA - the so-called official opposition and yet I fail to make significant inroads when my nemesis is down. The ANC is in its troubled state still has a 'free walk' over you. Instead of doing introspection you go around telling the whole world that black people vote ANC because they are stupid. Dah!
Like I said before, the problem with you and your people is ahistoricism. You have no sense of context whatsoever, you are just floating around hoping that a miracles will happen - to ensure you become the next government.
I not sure if you are sober at all - your 'extinction' point needs more elucidation i do not see its basis? what are you one here, numbers? ideas? or is just one of those things we say in our moment of intellectual lapse?
Believe it or not a vote for the ANC is a conscious, pre-meditated vote. There is nothing robottic about it. I wonder if your prejudiced mind will allow you to say the same about those that vote for parties such as FF plus? Even DA - what makes you not to think that those who vote for the party have no 'resevoir of values' that pre-dispose them to vote like that?
JacquesOlivier
Posted 171 days agoBokFan
Posted 171 days agoGiving the generally poor quality of human capital in SA this is a long and costly process. The DA is not going to try and capitalise on the anc imploding. By doing so it will simply inflate itself with questionable new recruits who will follow the old traditional ways at the first opportunity. The anc WILL collapse naturally when the critical mass of failure has been reached. So while the anc thieves,drunks sex addicts and thugs are feasting themselves to death the DA is building a core leadership schooled in the principles of good governance, service and competence.
Its a testament to their program that very few DA officials have made themselves guilty of anc-like behaviour.
While they maintain this project they will have my support.
danny.archer1
buddi
Rightway
Posted 171 days agoDA please take over and deliver us from evil ANC .
HlabirwaBauba
Posted 171 days ago--- Mauritiaus wedding - 500 guests, all expenses paid, fancy suits, chartered flights, etc
--- ANCYL Congress in Midrand -Juju paid for his re-election - with what money??
--- MGM Motors - Range Rover dealership in Polokwane. This town has the higest number of the supercharged cars.
The list is endless. Unless the provincial government is in the right hands, no amount of overdraft can meet the needs of the people.
muk1
Posted 171 days agoMnbvcxz0
Posted 171 days agoMnbvcxz0
donorfatigued
Posted 171 days agoIt is the ANC government which appointed 'cadres' (there's a good commie word for you!) without bothering to ascertain whether they could count, it is the ANC which failed to bother itself with proper oversight and accountability, it is the ANC which turned, and continues to turn, a blind eye to reports of massive corruption and pillaging of public resources!
The ANC when faced with such a massive collapse of their administration, must resign immediately and call a general election.
Mnbvcxz0
samsam
Posted 171 days agoPosted 16 minutes ago
absolutely nonsense, brainwashed, ill informed, the ANC is an extension of what our great Kings fought against, which was colonialism, Im referring to King Cetshwayo, Dingaan, Hinsa, Bhambatha, etc it is when all the Chiefs /tribes etc came together in mangaung to take the struggle forward thats what Chief Albert Luthili stood for, nt this kind of nonsense was fed on your face
ooooooooo
ScarfaceReturns
Posted 171 days agoNomvula Mkonyane - Gauteng
Ace Magashule - Freestate
All three must go now together with their MEC' s
BokFan
Why dont you just vote the scum out of government then you wont be required to fire them halfway through their contracts.
Jirre maar julle is dom.
PhutianaMolepo
Posted 171 days agoBarryPotgieter
Posted 171 days agolamelooser
Posted 171 days agoAlexio
Posted 171 days agoSo people must work up and use their votes to replace incompetency. Toy-toying is for the past, we are now a democracy.
shelatt
Posted 171 days agoTo all you ANCorruption supporters, don't forget to place your cross next to the ANCorrupt party in the next elections....they do such a good job of ruining your country!!! After that take a picture of your ballot paper and email it to JZ & Co in the hope that they will reward you with a position where you too can loot the coffers.
samsam
Posted 171 days agoPosted 5 minutes ago
"transforamtion"Reform" now I have to teach english hey
these two terms are the same it depands when you use them all they are referring to programme of change, fortunately enough the govt has adopted Land Reform programme, in this scenario it is an informal conversation we are nt writting a thesis/ dissertation
its similar situation when we refer to a company that is whites dominated we call it "not transformed" instead of saying no employment equity
Mnbvcxz0
ooooooooo