Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 41815.36
    UP 1.79%
    Top 40 : 3443.42
    UP 3.06%
    Financial 15 : 12000.90
    UP 1.42%
    Industrial 25 : 47656.81
    UP 1.47%

  • ZAR/USD : 9.5509
    UP 1.27%
    ZAR/GBP : 14.4730
    UP 0.52%
    ZAR/EUR : 12.3294
    UP 1.35%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.0931
    UP 0.84%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.3656
    UP 1.12%

  • Gold : 1375.0000
    DOWN -1.29%
    Platinum : 1462.0000
    DOWN -1.55%
    Silver : 22.3800
    DOWN -2.04%
    Palladium : 746.0000
    UP 0.40%
    Brent Crude Oil : 103.770
    DOWN -0.13%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Tue May 21 21:42:49 SAST 2013

Fight against graft 'dismal'

GRAEME HOSKEN | 02 May, 2012 00:1112 Comments
On duty SAPS member. File photo.
Image by: Daniel Born

A scathing report on government corruption has highlighted "grave concerns" about the lack of commitment to fighting the scourge.

The Public Service Commission report - presented at a recent Independent Police Investigative Directorate conference in Bloemfontein - revealed dismal performance in investigating corruption in state departments.

The report, by commissioner Selinah Nkosi, focused on allegations of corruption made to the National Corruption Hotline since its establishment in 2004, feedback from the police and the independent police watchdog, and the results of national and provincial government investigations of corruption.

Nkosi expressed "grave concern" about corruption and the inability of government departments to investigate it rigorously.

Nkosi criticised both the police and the police watchdog for their failure to report on their investigations.

The National Corruption Hotline had received feedback on only 45% of independent directorate investigations, and on only 53% of investigations by the police . The directorate and the police had closed only 28% and 41% of corruption cases, respectively, Nkosi said.

"The lack of feedback is forcing the commission to consider issuing summonses against [state] departments.

"The commission believes that all government departments must streamline procurement processes to eradicate corruption, with department heads held accountable if disciplinary action is not instituted within 60 days."

Tendersure CEO Werner Coetzee said the cost of corruption to South Africa was estimated to be as much as R675-billion.

"We extrapolated this figure from organisations such as the World Bank and World Trade Organisation, which estimate the total cost of a country's corruption being 20% of the total spent on tenders - which for South Africa is extremely frightening," he said.

Paul Hoffman, director of the Institute for Accountability, said: "Willie Hofmeyr, of the Asset Forfeiture Unit, estimates that R30-billion goes down the corruption tube through government tenders, and arms-deal expert Andrew Feinstein estimates the value of bribes paid in that deal at R2.1-billion."

Independent Police Investigative Directorate spokesman Moses Dlamini said the lack of feedback was due to "some matters still being investigated [or] feedback being given direct to the complainants".

THE FACTS AND FIGURES

137512 calls received;

14300 possible corruption cases identified;

9582 of the 14300 cases sent to government departments for investigation;

Feedback received on only 4859 cases;

Of 4859 cases, 3381 finalised; and

Of those successfully investigated, 603 officials fired, 226 suspended, 134 fined, 16 demoted, 330 given a final written warning, 190 prosecuted - and R120-million recovered.

TOP FORMS OF CORRUPTION

Fraud/bribery;

Abuse of government resources/vehicles;

Mismanagement of government funds; and

Identity document fraud.

To submit comments you must first

Join the discussion & Debate

Fight against graft 'dismal'

For Commenters Consideration | Please stick to the subject matter

COMMENTS [12]

Mike123

Posted 384 days ago
Avatar
Dismal is pretty much the standard for the way things are done in our country. So what's the problem?
Avatar

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 384 days ago
Remember the Mpumalanga murder is still unresolved.

nkosipeter

Posted 384 days ago
Avatar
Significantly it appears that no one has been jailed.

There is no deterrent for the crime of stealing from the poor, which is what corruption is.

So much for "the fight against poverty"

BornintheRSA

Posted 384 days ago
Avatar
R 675 billion - that is more than 33 e-toll roads, notwithstanding the fact that the R20 billion e-toll already includes the corruption component. To translate that into opportunity costs for healthcare and housing with water is an eye-opener of note! Why can't the voters see this?
Avatar

TheUnknownTruth

Posted 384 days ago
Why can't the voters see this?

Simple -- intimidation and ignorance.

muk1

Posted 384 days ago
Avatar
I too feel sick to see R675 billion being siphoned off. Just R20billion could saved us endless troubles around the etoll issue. As we speak; there are auditors in Polokwane digging up dirt. Corruption is rife; but NO one will be brought to justice. The problem is your case needs to be watertight to tag someone as corrupt. Most of these culprits get away on techicalities. Lessor corruption crimes; goes unpunished. The big fishes have smart lawyers. Some of these lawyers are in fact paid by us the taxpayers. See how Mduli tried to have the government pay for his lawyers.

I response to voters seeing this corruption and maladministration all I can say is look at Zimbabewe. The urban population favours MDC; whereas the rural top still vote for Zanu PF. The rural lot are easily bullied into voting Zanu PF. The same happens here in our beautiful country. So many of the rural population survive on pension monies; so when ANC says pensions may be "attended" to then people become jittery and keep on voting ANC. This is blackmail; sad but true.

Wiseguy

Posted 384 days ago
Avatar
The fight against poverty = the fight against corruption!!!!!!

We desperately need leaders who put the people FIRST.....and that means all the people of this wonderful country!!!!

If corruption persists and is ALLOWED to continue by the powers that be......... then we the people end up with less and less and finally NOTHING!!

JanChrzciciel

Posted 384 days ago
Avatar
Stop corruption.

Don't vote ANC

buddi

Posted 384 days ago
Avatar
Don't expect things to change while you have a president who has corruption charges hanging over his head. Mduli is a good example of why we should be worried, very worried. And all our leader does is to party and give "feel good" speeches instead of LEADING.

the_original_MommaCyndi

Posted 384 days ago
Avatar
This is what happens when you try to run a county by committee. Nobody is accountable for anything. In any other country, the Minister would be toasted. Here it is not the fault of the Minister, the President, the government or even the Chief of Police.

shelatt

Posted 384 days ago
Avatar
Has anyone noticed a pattern that has emerged concerning maladministration and unauthorized expenditure? It always seems that the current minister blames the fact that he/she took over a department that was already in crisis. A foolproof tactic our govt uses when they do cabinet shuffles. No wonder nobody (high up) gets the chop!!
Anybody reading these comments still voting for Absolute National Corruption???? If so please let us foolish, illogical people know why we are wrong and why we must trust everything that Zuma and his ilk say!

SecretVoice

Posted 384 days ago
Avatar
Jacob Zuma in his freedom day speech boasted great improvements in service delivery over the past eighteen years. We all know that the government has failed on virtually every front exept during this period they became the champions of corruption. The fact that the President is so out of touch with reality is frightning to say the least. His government has failed in the following areas. Education,Security,Poverty relief,Infrastructure development to name a few. Lately the fiasco with regards to the e- tolling of Gauteng roads has again showed up the sheer incompetance of the government. On Friday Ndebele said e- tolling was a done deal. Now that the opposition to E-tolling won an interdict against the implementation thereof I wonder what he will say next. Unfortunately one can not give the real reason for this inability to govern but I think the answer is there for everyone to see. If Jacob Zuma think they have done well then there lies your real answer. Why???This is what he had to say about the guy who he fired recently
"We will... miss his energy, as he was a remarkably hard worker and his impact was greatly felt in the local government turnaround strategy as well as his contribution to the struggle from the early 1980s," President Jacob Zuma said in a statement. What turnaround is he talking about. This President live in never never land. He hasn't got a clue about anything. In the final analysis we have Malema to thank for this failure of a President. He supported him at the Pholokwane leadership election fiasco.