Churchman told to retract stoning call
Image by: LAUREN MULLIGAN
Nazareth Baptist (Shembe) Church spokesman Enoch Mthembu has been ordered to retract publicly a call for the stoning to death of artist Brett Murray.
The Johannesburg High Court yesterday granted the interdict brought by Murray after his lawyers' request to Mthembu to stop inciting violence against the artist fell on deaf ears.
Mthembu has five days to retract the statement in public and to file an affidavit to the registrar of the court confirming he has complied with the court order.
The court ordered that Mthembu pay the costs of the application.
But Mthembu remained defiant yesterday, calling Murray a drama queen who wanted to create controversy with his painting of President Zacob Zuma.
Murray's attorney Okyerebea Ampofo-Anti said the interdict restrained Mthembu or anyone acting in his name and or under his instruction from stating that Murray should be stoned to death or physically harmed in any way.
"The order starts as from today [Wednesday]. And if Mthembu does not apologise he would be in contempt of court and might also face arrest. The judge granted the order against Mthembu, not the church," she said.
Mthembu said he had no interest in apologising to Murray and had the money to fight the artist in court.
"Where in the world can you find a person disrespecting the president in that way? He [Murray] should be the first one to apologise. I will never do that. He is too arrogant. He should have seen that he did wrong by the huge outcry, with some people even defacing the painting .
"I'm also not going to nurse his ego because he did this with the purpose to market himself. Murray knew very well that creating a controversy would make him more famous and make more money as people would want to buy that painting," Mthembu said.
On Monday, Mthembu called for Murray to be stoned to death over the controversial painting depicting Zuma with his genitals exposed.
Some members of the Nazareth Baptist Church clergy have called for Mthembu to be disciplined.
Nkululeko Mthethwa, who said he is, in fact, the church's appointed spokesman, said the church would follow its internal process to discipline Mthembu because his utterances went against Shembe teachings of tolerance, respect and self-discipline.
He said Mthembu did not represent the views of the church.
"Mthembu is the former church spokesman.
"As much as we are not impressed with the painting, the matter had not yet been discussed in the church. The church is preoccupied with its leadership dispute that is in the Durban High Court, and has not reflected its views on this matter," he said.
"Mthembu spoke as a citizen of the country and his views do not represent the church's views."


Join the discussion & Debate
Churchman told to retract stoning call
For Commenters Consideration | Please stick to the subject matterCOMMENTS [7]
SecretVoice
Posted 360 days agoWell done o the members. Now Mr Mtembu let us hear your apology.
truthwins
Most probably not a dedicated Christian, but a fake preacher who abuses the name of God to enrich himself and/or a tenderpreneur who has his snout in the taxpayers trough with his idols.
Only a worshipper of Lucifer would call for such brutal and barbaric action. His congregation would be wise to get rid of this fake.
Francis
Posted 360 days agoKafreeMoneykey
Posted 360 days agoMr President, can you come out and defend the principle? Say it out loud that even though you feel disrespected and undermined by this whole saga, you are not going to tolerate any behaviour that goes against the ethos of our constitution? Let the rule of law take its course via the courts but protect Brett as a fellow South African, that is called leadership My President. Demonstrate leadership and forget about how much votes you may loose by calling the likes of Mthembu to order. If any South African does not respect the constitution, they do not deserve to vote for the ANC, full stop. Mr President, it is time you look for good advisors, it is clear those around you are not doing the right job. You were quick to call for a press conference to protect yourself, why not do the same to protect Brett, as a South African? Leadership requires one to be unbiased and rational all the time, it is indeed a tough job.
Please do not be silent on this one, sort your personal issues however, equally protect what is enshrined in our constitution.
AnotherTaxPayer
Posted 360 days agoProgressiveAfricanDemocrat
Posted 360 days agokksonuk
Posted 354 days agoDepends on which Bible the man reads and believe in... there are certain religions that do not prohibit stoning and killing anyone who does not share the same faith with them...
Maybe they should ask him during the internal procedures at church about what he believe in and which base (bible if any) does he use...
The president has never said anything about the rights of citizens in relation to this matter other than right to dignity. Now people are intimidated and probably facing death mainly because a lot more out there did not understand what the painting meant.