FEEDS |

Traditional leader sorry for violent circumcision

Oct 7, 2009 1:21 PM | By Biénne Huisman

A traditional leader from the Eastern Cape has apologised to 21-year-old Bonani Yamani, who was violently circumcised two years ago.


Current Font Size:

Related Articles

In a drastic about turn, the chairperson of the Congress of Traditional Leaders of South Africa in the province, Nkosi Ngubo Mgcotyelwa, apologised for previous remarks by the congress that men who refuse traditional circumcision should be ostracised.

He also called for an end to forced circumcision.

In a settlement document filed at the Bhisho Equality Court on Monday, Mgcotyelwa said Contralesa accepted that "the Constitution of South Africa gives the right to each adult male individual to choose whether or not he should attend traditional circumcision school according to his religious beliefs.”

Yamani claimed that, shortly after he turned 18, his father and 10 other men abducted him from his home in Masele township near King William’s Town and subjected him to circumcision against his will – and then forced him to eat the skin cut from his penis.

This, he said in a court affidavit, happened three months after he tried to reach a compromise with local chiefs by having the procedure done at the Frere hospital in East London.

The second-year microbiology student at the University of the Free State became embroiled in a clash between constitutional rights and Xhosa tradition.

He said: “After that experience I decided to do something about it so no other child is put through that.”

With the help of JASA – the Justice Alliance of South Africa, a non-profit legal organization – he challenged the views of his parents and traditional leaders in court.

John Smyth, the director of Jasa, has pushed for forced circumcision to be declared illegal; and for an order forbidding chiefs from encouraging ostracism of a youth who refuses circumcision.

He was pleased with Mgcotyelwa's statements: "It's an extraordinary thing really. I think it's very courageous," he said on Tuesday.

Despite the traditional leader’s apology, Yamanis’ parents are not relenting.

“Bonani’s father continues to maintain through an affidavit sworn by his wife that what he did in arranging for a group of traditional leaders to abduct and forcibly circumcise his son was right,” said Smyth.

Yamani will face his parents in court on Tuesday next week.


 or  to comment

Comments

Oct 7 2009 01:49:30 PM
Bart Gee
user name
How the hell does one become VIOLENT when one goes thru the act of cicumsizing?
Do you swear, cuss, rant & rave?
Or do you beat the circumzee into submission?

Boy are we in a 3rd world or what?
Oct 7 2009 01:52:47 PM
mongadik
user name
I salute the young man for his unwavering courage, and for choosing the only religion that insists on one's freedom of choice. But he must make sure he honors his parents,as the word commands because it does not say honor them if they are good.
Oct 7 2009 02:05:14 PM
dogmil
user name
Maybe they should get a Jewish Rabbi to help.
Oct 7 2009 02:08:52 PM
Mommacyndi
user name
Brave young man that.
Heres hoping that his bravery will help others
Oct 7 2009 02:15:13 PM
mathongo
user name
guys lets face the reality now,its not wise for the young boys to go through the cicumsisn period and this mainly occurs in the eastern cape and these boys are dying,when handling this matter we have to be very proffessional as well as traditional
Oct 7 2009 02:16:22 PM
Kunta_Kinte
user name
John Smyth, the director of Jasa, has pushed for forced circumcision to be declared illegal; and for an order forbidding chiefs from encouraging ostracism of a youth who refuses circumcision.

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

John I am Xhosa and glad that you chose not to look at the matter through pre-concieved stereo types.

Ostracisation is done tacitly, you have no say in your family matters, you will not mary a Xhosa women traditionally, i.e. paying lobola etc. There's unfortunately not much the chiefs can done here and there's a call for their disbanding by Shiceka in anycase.
Oct 7 2009 03:26:51 PM
spencerc777
user name

Africa's problems stems from its roots, its rejection of Christ and its persistent consultation of the demonic realm - the ancestors.

The "ancestors' have done nothing for Africa other than mislead them into mismanaging a most resourceful and promising continent. The colonialists have merely been an obliging tool in Africa’s self-destruction. Africa's rejection of Christ has denied them the very freedom and prosperity that they have sought for so many generations.

Traditional circumcision, like labola, is the produce of this demonic consultation.

Oct 7 2009 03:29:31 PM
Quo_Vadis
user name
Tradition is problematic - only that which is of any significant value , should be retained as tradition .

I think that certain traditions amonst negroid populations eg circumcision schools . vaginal circumcision , sex with virgins cures aids and the like , have been hi jacked and perpetuated by elements with an agenda .

My perception is that these are Xhosa traditions . As far as circumcision is concerned , the jewish methodology in a sterile hospital ward , should be embraced by the Xhosa tribe immediately .
Oct 7 2009 03:41:56 PM
smallbee
user name
I wonder if 10 old mans including a parent can be so stupid or evel that they can just deside to send their children to helle? I found it hard to beleave that a parent can just send his child to a place for no good resean.

this is a old tradition(elisiko lidala linempandla) its a shame how some people are so not proud of who they are.and how much they undermine their tradition.
Oct 7 2009 04:41:03 PM
Mommacyndi
user name
Oct 7 2009 03:26:51
spencerc777

Mmmm remember when I said that I would remind you of your words? Now seems a good time.

Remember your 'judge not' epistle and your 'let he who is with out sin' comments?