FEEDS |

Jansen 'racists' pardon slated

Vice-chancellor 'should have punished' the Reitz 4

Oct 19, 2009 1:07 AM | By KHETHIWE CHELEMU

New University of the Free State vice-chancellor Prof Jonathan Jansen's decision to drop charges against four students allegedly involved in making a racist initiation video has been met with mixed reaction.


Current Font Size:
Free State University vice-chancellor Jonathan Jansen
Free State University vice-chancellor Jonathan Jansen
quote He had to take strong measures against the perpetrators quote

Related Articles

The four are RC Malherbe, Johnny Roberts, Schalk van der Merwe and Danie Grobler, formerly of the Reitz men's residence, which has been closed.

DOCUMENT: Read Jonathan Jansen's full speech

VIDEO: The racist mock initiation video

They face charges of crimen injuria in the Bloemfontein Magistrate's Court next Monday.

Yesterday, the SA Student Congress said that it supported Jansen's decision to forgive the four. But the ANC Youth League said that Jansen had committed his "first blunder" in his new job.

Jansen, speaking on Friday during his inauguration, apologised to the country for the 2007 incident in which four white students duped some black cleaners into eating food that appeared to have been urinated on.

Jansen has banned initiation rituals and the consumption of alcohol at the university.

"Any senior student who lays a hand on a first-year student will not only be brought before a disciplinary committee, but will face criminal prosecution in the courts," Jansen said on Friday.

Yesterday, the Young Communist League slammed Jansen for trying to deviate from the racism issues at the Reitz men's residence.

"He was supposed to send a strong message that his institution will not be tolerant of racist behaviour. He had to be firm in dealing with this issue and also take strong measures against the perpetrators," said league spokeswoman Gugu Ndima.

"This is a race issue and we cannot run away from it," she said.

But yesterday Sasco threw its weight behind Jansen saying students, despite the gravity of their offence, should not be denied their right to education.

"We as the Sasco believe that the conduct of the students was not a spontaneous act of evil," said Sasco president Mawethu Rune.

"We believe that what they did was a serious crime against humanity."

He said the students should be taken through a disciplinary and rehabilitation processes and not be denied the opportunity to study.

"To us, disciplining students means making a better person out of them and not keeping them out of school," he said.

ANC Youth League spokesman Floyd Shivambo yesterday described Jansen's decision as "very unfortunate".

"Those kids needed to be punished for violating the worker's human rights," Shivambo said. "This is Jansen's first blunder on the job. It is totally unacceptable."

Higher Education Minister Blade Nzimande has asked Jansen for an explanation of his decision to drop the charges against the four students.

The DA yesterday welcomed Jansen's decision, saying that he will not be "pushed around by the political authorities".

Meanwhile, Sasco's Rune also took a swipe at a decision by the department of basic education to release this year's matric results in January.

A recent report claimed that students were engaging in prostitution to get money to pay for their tuition. Rune urged them to refrain from doing so.

"The ANC-led government needs to provide books or stationery in order to prevent students from prostituting themselves in order to pay for their education," he said.

 Loading...

 or  to comment

Comments

Oct 19 2009 03:00:39 AM
iPen
user name
It sounds a tad hypocritical when the ANCYL get worked up over racism. And Nzimande is supposed to be focusing on the countries education, not nonsense such as this.

As for whether or not I agree with Prof. Jansen... I haven't made up my mind yet. From what I've heard, the court case would have gone nowhere, and so he may have just saved the university time and money but unfortunately I know far too little to give an informed opinion.
Oct 19 2009 03:48:21 AM
Tackler
user name
So, a handful of young students play a prank which is in awful taste? Gosh, is this really the sky falling? Are raw youngsters making rather poor judgements as far as "humour" goes a brand-new invention, or it is as old as the human race itself? The huge over-reaction by the bleeding-hearted moaning minnies who are older but obviously not wiser is even more off-putting. Harden up and get a grip.
Oct 19 2009 05:58:10 AM
VinceRSA
user name
ahhhh, BUT it is fine when the millions are allowed to do this in their new found warrens like inner cities and Hillbrow, Berea and Jules/Bree Street or other dark covens!
Black supremism over other race minorities is just dandy!

THIS IS THE RESULT OF LEGISLATED RACISM in the stautory books once one anaylses everything thoroughly.
Equally unacceptable action.
Oct 19 2009 06:06:15 AM
razzmatazz
user name
I am not surprised. Jansen, like all other coloureds, is an aspirant boer with no regard for Africans.
Oct 19 2009 06:15:35 AM
DDarko
user name
Jansen decision was a good one, the allegations would never have passed any any kind of test.

Courts do no t convict on emotions, but on facts, and fact is there was never any urine in the food.

The cleaners were willing participants.

All the racist and emotive comments around this issue are merely strong supporting arguments to the fact that South Africa is the most racist country on earth.

Thanks to the ANC.
Oct 19 2009 06:50:56 AM
webathandwa
user name
Any comments from the COPE? I am interested to hear their view in this regard.

Otherwise, Jansen had no right to take such a decision without consulting the victims. It's not only about him. And the victims will probably agree with him. Show some respect Prof and consult accordingly.
Oct 19 2009 06:53:05 AM
Mommacyndi
user name
Oh dear - here comes a race riot on the comments page again!

If the students are behind Jansen on this then the racial stirring of Floyd et al is simply politics. What is it with the ANC YL and them always wanting to start race riots?
Oct 19 2009 06:57:38 AM
Chup
user name
By this Jansen mean that what this racists did to this women is normal and that they can continue doing them. I say that they should not be expelled from school because you are making more illeterate criminals but let them face the music and be punished constructively.
Oct 19 2009 07:02:58 AM
PrettyBoy
user name
@Ddarko:,,One question for you..What would have happened if a white girl was raped by black dude becasue she willingly strolled the residence at night?...this Jansen maggots will he be able to crap the case? in the name of transformatio, reconciliation??..someone tell if Jansen is original from gauten or western cape..couloreds from Zille province they think more of themselves as white..i dont know why but it happens
Oct 19 2009 07:07:46 AM
ThembaM
user name
Seems Sasco is concerned about bigger issues.

Good on them.


Today's Topics