Earpiece 8 - Your Opinion
FEEDS |

Blade Nzimande knifes Jansen

Oct 21, 2009 10:16 PM | By DOMINIC MAHLANGU and NKOSANA LEKOTJOLO

Professor Jonathan Jansen, the new vice-chancellor of the University of Free State, has been asked to step down following a controversial decision to allow students facing racism charges to return to campus.


Current Font Size:
Blade Nzimande
Blade Nzimande
Photograph by: ELIZABETH SEJAKE
quote This is unfortunately an apology for the perpetrators of racism quote

Related Articles

Columnists

While Higher Education Minister Blade Nzimande called on Jansen to "suspend" his decision and convene an urgent meeting with all stakeholders, disgruntled students and trade union federation Cosatu yesterday went as far as to call for Jansen's dismissal.

Students have threatened to go on the rampage if allegedly racist students return, and Cosatu has accused Jansen of attempting to influence their court hearing.

The four students - Johnny Roberts, RC Malherbe, Danie Grobler and Schalk van der Merwe - will appear in the Bloemfontein Regional Court on Monday to face crimen injuria charges. They also face charges in the Equality Court.

The students are accused of urinating in food that they gave to five female cleaners as part of a 2007 video, which they made to protest against racial integration at the Reitz residence.

Beeld newspaper reports that the so-called Reitz four have requested the Free State director of public prosecutions to drop a charge of crimen injuria against them.

Their lawyer, Christo Dippenaar, confirmed to the Afrikaans daily that he had handed in a written request to advocate Andre du Toit, SC.

Last week Jansen caused a stir when he said two of the four students who made the video would be allowed to finish their degrees. The other two students have graduated.

Cosatu's Free State spokesman, Sam Mashinini, said in a statement yesterday that Jansen had misled the country when he claimed "he had consulted with all the stakeholders, including Cosatu, before taking a decision to drop the charges against the students".

"We believe the intention is basically to try and influence the court case that is coming next week Monday," he said.

Nzimande said Jansen's decision was "grossly insensitive" and would cause further racial divisions in the country.

He said in a statement yesterday that Jansen had taken it upon himself "to absolve the perpetrators on behalf of the victims and compensate the victims on behalf of the perpetrators".

Nzimande said: "The view of the department is that we cannot allow victims of racism to be unconditional, unilateral forgivers. This would constitute a superficial trade-off, which further impugns the dignity of the victims and is, unfortunately, an apology for the perpetrators of racism."

The minister said that during his visit to the university last month, he found the victimised workers were "still scarred" and had asked to be redeployed from the residences as they were still "taunted" by some white students.

In his column in The Times today, Jansen, stands by his decision and says, "... the deeper issues of racism and bigotry ... will not be resolved in the courts".

Read Jansen's column today

Contacted for a reply to Nzimande's demand yesterday, Jansen declined to comment, but said he would not back down from his decision as he had made it in the spirit of reconciliation.

"I am aware of what the minister has said, but I will not say anything right now," he said.

Meanwhile, students at the university started a Facebook group, called "Jansen is a sell out", in which they attack the vice-chancellor.

About 400 students had joined the group by yesterday.

Mass demonstrations have also been planned by student bodies.

One student said: "JJ [Jonathan Jansen] needs to go back to wherever he came from. Forgiveness, my foot."

Another called Jansen a "snake", adding "we ought to make sure that he resigns".

Yet another said: "We are always singing the forgiveness anthem, which is our biggest downfall."

The Facebook group calls for students from other universities to join and put pressure on Jansen to resign, or retract his statement.

Jansen's work to integrate the campus was yesterday unwinding.

A move to join the university's two racially divided choirs was unravelling.

The two choirs had sang together for the first time during Jansen's inauguration last week.

Spokesman for the "black choir", Sechaba Ntoi, said after his decision to allow the "racist" students back to the university, they "reject Jansen's request" to form one choir.

"As black students we really feel let down by Jansen," said Ntoi.

But Dr Franklin Sonn, chancellor of the UFS, said he supported Jansen's stance.

"This is a man who had strongly condemned racism and sexist attitudes at the university. I couldn't have supported the decision if it was one-sided, but I have satisfied myself that the decision addressed all sides.

"It is only the media that missed Jansen's commitment to give [support to] those mothers [the cleaners]. He had banned any practices that sought to promote racism," said Sonn.

 Loading...

 or  to comment

Comments

Oct 22 2009 01:23:43 AM
Tackler
user name
Nzimande thinks he has the power to micro-manage all universities and force them, in a Stalinist manner, to obey his commands and his every whim. Well, that is NOT academic freedom. Jansen should tell Blade to clear off, but to use saltier language that this wrtetched chardonnay socialist would understand even better.
Oct 22 2009 01:30:47 AM
Tackler
user name
The students are NOT accused of urinating in the food and the reporter once again got this factually wrong. The water on the food has conclusively been proved to have been nothing more than tap-water. Their prank was exactly that --- a prank. A dodgy prank, for sure. But a prank all the same.

The mad over-reaction is as radical as it is deeply racist -- it's degenerated into everyone eagerly putting the boot (or the blade) into young white men simply because they are white.

And two of the men have already graduated and left -- they CANNOT be kicked out no matter how much the whiny vindictive yowlers may want to.
Oct 22 2009 02:09:27 AM
mcritic
user name
This is getting to the stage that is the ridicoulous getting ahead of the sublime. Has the Satilinist the right to discharge Jansen?

He may think he can use that kind of power - but he has not got it. Why is the man determined to tuhn this into a racial fiasco. Appointment of idiots such as this one to Cabinet should be avoided at all costs.

Bugger of the trough with your BMW and stop talking K@K.
Oct 22 2009 04:39:23 AM
saksman
user name
Cosatu's Free State spokesman, Sam Mashinini, said ..."We believe the intention is basically to try and influence the court case that is coming next week Monday,"
==================================

How soon they forget - remember what a fuss they made about Zuma being innocent until found guilty and the role of the media etc in influencing the courts before the trial date - does not the same thing apply here ? (although I don't support what the students allegedly did)

Nzimande said: "The view of the department is that we cannot allow victims of racism to be unconditional, unilateral forgivers.
==================================

Well, that's not the department's right. Why not? Surely the decision to forgive or not lies solely with the victim? If the victim decides to forgive, does the department have the right to override that decision? Utter rubbish and arrogance on the part of the minister.

Oct 22 2009 05:07:33 AM
big-kahunas
user name
Why doesnt blade own up and admit that he is a capitalist at heart and he loves to drink red wine, eat caviar and cruise around in the epitomy of a capitalist car, the BMW 7 series.

This man should be preaching what is morally right as he surely must rate as one of the most morally bankrupt people in this country.

So go back to gulping your red wine and leave the real world to real people.

Lastly, who the heck decided to name him 'Blade' ? He aint that sharp to me!!
Oct 22 2009 05:18:40 AM
DDarko
user name
Another gibbering primate who thinks he can override anyone, trample on the constitution, and rule by his Stalinist dogma.

Why do all these SACP COSATU rejects think they are God?
Oct 22 2009 05:44:09 AM
surfking
user name
Baldrick? Bawwwldrick!!? Hurry up down from lootfreely house an raise us rabble. Bring Caster. Bring Whiny, bring Dullrunner The Poxy with you....come on my son, let's burn Rome, lets waste the useless Jansen, lets exercise our democratic rights and make it all ungovernable, then lets -because, hey! this is what we do - necklace all ASA sponsors that practice interuptus....bus em in fella's.....BMW them up....bring beer....already got the chops.....phukkmesideways. Kader Asmal was being restrained and kind you fools. You give blacks a bad rap.
Oct 22 2009 06:20:32 AM
nomakanjane
user name
Blade - if you could not unseat barney pityana, it will be even more difficult to unseat jansen. these are servants of a master just like you are servant of a master. i suppose the moral of the story is - look for other things to do and stop wasting your time unless of course you have nothing else to do
Oct 22 2009 06:30:19 AM
Bart Gee
user name
What can I say?

Either you do as THEY say.... or you loose your job...

What about ALL those C.E.O.'s pf the Parastatals, and ALL those missing millions? THey get to keep their jobs...

Looks like Professor Jonathan Jansen os definetly NOT a "JOBS FOR MATES" placement!
Oct 22 2009 06:40:52 AM
august rain
user name
See how unbalanced our society is the "4 Fools"
Get all the rage and anger but where is the outpouring of condemnation for the poor victim in the story below?
NOT A SINGLE WORD!
Killer turns against co-accused
2009-10-21 22:31
Pietermaritzburg - One of three men on trial for the gruesome murder and robbery of a Georgedale couple as well as rape of the woman, has turned State witness in the trial which got underway in the North KwaZulu-Natal High Court on Wednesday.
Bongumusa Mdlalose, 24, is currently on the witness stand giving evidence for the prosecution against his former co-accused, Sibongiseni Buthelezi, also 24 and 21-year-old Brian Buthelezi.
The trio are charged with the murder and robbery of Unathi Dyantyi and Thopholozi Ngcobo-Dladla who are described in the State's indictment as husband and wife.
The accused also face a charge of raping Dladla with a candle stick and broom handle or alternatively performing an "act of sexual penetration on a human corpse".
Pleaded guilty
Sibongiseni Buthelezi pleaded guilty to the murders, robbery and the alternative sexual offence on Wednesday, but the State declined to accept the facts as outlined by him in his plea explanation to the court and elected to lead evidence in the matter.
At the start of the proceedings, State advocate Denardo MacDonald withdrew charges against Mdlalose and told Judge Leona Theron and assessors that Mdlalose would instead testify for the State.
The State alleges that Unathi Dyantyi died as a result of a "blunt force injury to his head and penetrating (stab) wounds to the neck", and that Dladla died of penetrating wounds to both her lungs, oesophagus, trachea.
Together at shebeen
In his plea to the court Sibongiseni Buthelezi admitted that he and others were at a shebeen in the company of Unathi Dyantyi on October 10 last year and decided to rob him.
He said they had followed him home and en route stopped and searched him but found no money in his possession.
They then demanded that he take them to his home and give them money. They then assaulted him with "open hands and booted feet".
Buthelezi said when they got to the house a woman opened the door.
His companions had continued to assault Unathi who was then also stabbed.
"I took Thopholozi to where he [the husband] was lying...I saw he was dead," he said.
Took kettle, iron, groceries
The trio then took the woman to the other side of the house and began assaulting her.
He then realised she was dead.
It was then that his two companions - who he identified as Sibonelo Kwela and Dumisani Gwala - carried out the sexual assault on her body, he said.
Before leaving the house they had taken items including an electric kettle, iron and groceries.
- The Witness


Today's Topics