FEEDS |

Selebi judge refuses to step down

Oct 30, 2009 12:28 PM | By KIM HAWKEY

Judge Meyer Joffe has refused to recuse himself from the corruption trial of former top cop Jackie Selebi.


Current Font Size:
Jackie Selebi
Jackie Selebi

Related Multimedia

Related Articles

Selebi, who has pleaded not guilty to corruption and defeating the ends of justice, has argued that Judge Joffe was “subconsciously influenced” by a “smear campaign” by the media even before the case started.

DOCUMENT: Selebi's Application for Recusal

DOCUMENT: The State's Heads of Argument

In court papers, Selebi cited the South Gauteng High Court judge’s “rudeness and hostility” towards the defence, as well as the effect of media coverage of the allegations against him.

But Joffe ruled moments ago that he would not step down from the trial.

After going through a brief history of the trial to date, Joffe then answered each of Selebi’s main complaints.

He dismissed each one, saying they were “without merit, ill-founded, unfortunate, incomprehensible”, and simply, ”wrong”.

Joffe said there was nothing in Selebi’s argument to show “actual or a perception of bias”.

The trial resumes on Monday.

 Loading...

 or  to comment

Comments

Oct 30 2009 12:33:54 PM
ugen
user name
Why should the judge step down anyway? Who is on trial here?
Oct 30 2009 12:36:19 PM
hoodoo
user name
money...what money?

Selebi will trot out of there a free man.

Oct 30 2009 12:36:26 PM
Stirrer
user name
How dare this counter-revolutionary judge tell Selebi to eff-off!
Oct 30 2009 12:43:56 PM
OBigOneKenobi
user name
He dismissed each one, saying they were “without merit, ill-founded, unfortunate, incomprehensible”, and simply, ”wrong”
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So should I recuse myself? In a word, "no".
Oct 30 2009 12:47:43 PM
LouLou
user name
Well done, Judge Joffe!I wish a few more judges in this country were as strong and straight forward as you!
Oct 30 2009 12:49:02 PM
LouLou
user name
Another thought! any bets on how long it's goning to take julius to jump on this bandwagon?
I think he will start spewing his vitriol before the end of the day!
Oct 30 2009 12:52:58 PM
siganoga
user name
RACIST....RACISM....LADYMAN!... " NOT ONE OF US"... KILL HIM....CEMETRY TO.... DEMAND! DESTROY....must be surely!!
Oct 30 2009 12:59:22 PM
rampant1
user name
All these thugs are now following the "President's" example...delays, delays, delays...

You can be sure this case will end up at the highest court in the country...
Oct 30 2009 01:07:38 PM
Dzel
user name
Joffes my boy!!!!!
Oct 30 2009 01:09:46 PM
Mielie
user name
Well, this trial is costing the taxpayer plus minus R70 000.00 per day, so it is not one of the cheapest trials... Pity 4 Selebi, if he jumped the Thabo boat he would have been able to just plead guilty and then receive a pardon! LOL!


Today's Topics