FEEDS |

SA embassy 'not to blame' for anthem debacle

And the embassy claims the South African flag was flown upside down

Nov 16, 2009 4:17 PM | By Sapa

The South African embassy in Paris has denied imposing Ras Dumisani on the organisers of Friday's rugby match between South Africa and France.


Current Font Size:
Ras Dumisani
Ras Dumisani
Photograph by: .
quote The embassy had only one name of a South African singer in France and the embassy provided the name of his agent to the French Rugby Union quote

Related Multimedia

Related Articles

Related Blogs

"In all cases, the embassy merely provides information, but is often not in a position to vouch for the bona fides, credentials or competency of any of the parties," the embassy said in a statement today.

"In this case, the embassy had only one name of a South African singer in France and the embassy provided the name of his agent in France to the French Rugby Union."

"... This was not a recommendation from the embassy, since the embassy had no previous exposure to his performances nor is he a renowned performer."

International relations spokesman Saul Kgomotso Molobi said that at a subsequent meeting on September 8 with officials from the Midi-Pyrenees Rugby Union in Toulouse, the embassy was asked to recommend a singer.

"We can only tell you who are South African artists. The second meeting was for a recommendation and we are shying away from that," he said.

The embassy said the organisers had to discuss the matter with the South African Rugby Union (Saru).

"The embassy had no subsequent dealings with any of the parties and rejects all claims that the embassy chose or imposed the singer. This was entirely the responsibility of the hosts," it said in its statement.

Saru said it had written to the French Rugby Union expressing South Africa's dismay at the performance.

"As a union we were shocked and horrified by the rendition of the anthem and I contacted the French federation on Saturday morning to express our very grave concerns," Saru president Oregan Hoskins said in a statement.

"The performance of the anthem is a treasured part of any rugby international and we take great pains in this country in the selection and rehearsal of artists to ensure that we appropriately honour all anthems.

"Something went seriously awry in Toulouse and the upshot was that offence has been caused not just to the Springboks and Saru, but to South Africans in general."

Dumisani, who hails from Mtunzini in KwaZulu-Natal, has had to weather a storm of criticism over his rendition of the anthem.

While the Congress of the People called his performance a "vocal misfire", the Young Communist League of South Africa (YCLSA) recommended that he stick to singing in the shower.

The YCLSA demanded an apology from French rugby authorities and said the department of arts and culture and international relations should compile a list of people who could sing the anthem to avoid future embarrassment, especially ahead of the 2010 Fifa World Cup.

It also called on the education department to make sure children learnt the anthem and for mandatory singing at morning assemblies Beeld reported that Dumisani blamed his performance on the sound equipment. He had complained about it during the sound check but nothing was done.

"It was war, it was definitely war. If you can't hear yourself, then it is not possible to sing," he wrote in response to a question posted on Facebook.

Dumisani is also on the receiving end of a Facebook site drumming up support for him not sing again.

The embassy said it had also noticed that the South African flag was flown the wrong way around at the event, but that it had been too late to correct the error.

 Loading...

 or  to comment

Comments

Nov 16 2009 04:21:41 PM
Mommacyndi
user name
LOL
Well he is certainly a 'renowned performer' now - just for all the wrong reasons.

I hope the poor sod doesn't hope to sell any CDs in SA
Nov 16 2009 04:23:39 PM
hoodoo
user name
When the dust settles we will all laugh...at least we will all be trying to sing the anthem from now on...with your hand on your heart and the other one holding the booze....
Nov 16 2009 04:25:22 PM
nxila@thepub_with Schabir
user name
The YCLSA demanded an apology from French rugby authorities and said the department of arts and culture and international relations should compile a list of people who could sing the anthem to avoid future embarrassment, especially ahead of the 2010 Fifa World Cup.

that's very constructive and solution minded, now why not try implement it.
Nov 16 2009 04:53:10 PM
august rain
user name
"The African person is genetically programmed for destruction. Everything he touches, he destroys." Frikkie Strauss_AWB

THE ANTHEM WAS BUTCHERED AND THE FLAG HUNG UPSIDE DOWN!

Roll on 2010 the circus is coming to town.


How very African!
Nov 16 2009 05:00:41 PM
surfking
user name
Well, he is no worse than most of the boneheads that release CDs in Pretoria...remember that duo from Idols "Om, ons maak 'n CD soos al die ander Afrikaners....". Damn that was funny and this is too. It's a light squall in a very big tea-cup. They should get him to front Korn or Kiss for a jol!
Nov 16 2009 05:03:53 PM
Stompie se Paai
user name

With the Plastic-shopping bag as SA's National Flower and the Fly as our National bird ...this African version of the 'Anthem' fits in perfectly ...not?!

...even Bakkies Botha can sing better than this turd-haired imbecile!
Nov 16 2009 05:06:31 PM
Mzungu
user name
is it now so difficult for those in power to take responsibilty for such a minor thing..
Nov 16 2009 05:20:54 PM
amaKK
user name
Nov 16 2009 04:53:10 PM
august rain
...

THE ANTHEM WAS BUTCHERED AND THE FLAG HUNG UPSIDE DOWN!

Roll on 2010 the circus is coming to town.


How very African!

---

Freedom of expression does not equate to subjecting the world to your stupidity.
Nov 16 2009 05:49:57 PM
Ras Dumisani
user name
So dont put all the blames to Ras, the flag was hung upside down, there were hack of mismanagement and disorder that was going on there, so as Springbok players they played out of passion ended up accusing off-key sung national anthem.

just get some other news please!
Nov 16 2009 06:00:45 PM
StarGazer-KnowledgeSeeker
user name
Nov 16 2009 04:53:10 PM
august rain

THE ANTHEM WAS BUTCHERED AND THE FLAG HUNG UPSIDE DOWN!

Roll on 2010 the circus is coming to town.


How very African!

---------------------
-So the french federation, which is ultimately responsible for all these Faak-Ups, is run by Africans?...wow, didn't know that one!

You usually come up with sound arguments, this however puts you in the same League as the likes of MbongwaM ......shame on you!

-------------------------------------------------------------
Nov 16 2009 05:20:54 PM
amaKK

Freedom of expression does not equate to subjecting the world to your stupidity.

- :-) Post of the Day!


Today's Topics