FEEDS |

Miss World, junkets as city drowns in debt

Mayor leads 16-member delegation on costly Asian trip despite R2.8bn debt write-off

Dec 1, 2009 10:32 PM | By Sipho Masondo and Buddy Naidu

The City of Johannesburg has written off a staggering R2.8-billion in debt - or a 10th of its 2009-2010 budget.


Current Font Size:

Related Multimedia

Related Articles

Despite this shortfall, city mayor Amos Masondo led a 16-member delegation on a costly 10-day trip to four countries last month as part of a "study tour" aimed at bolstering "service delivery".

Johannesburg has also come under fire for spending R45-million to host the Miss World pageant for the second year running, amid accusations that the city is cash-strapped.

In a written response to questions by DA councillor John Mendelsohn, the finance chief of the mayoral committee, Parks Tau, said 323074 unpaid municipal accounts from 2008-2009, totalling R2.8-billion, had been written off.

This shocking figure is revealed when the city's finances are under severe strain, and after Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan ordered provincial and local governments to tighten their belts and slash unnecessary expenses.

The Times has established that, between November 7 and 17, Masondo took members of his mayoral committee and executive team, including three aides, to Mumbai, in India, Ho Chi Minh City, in Vietnam, Shanghai, in China, and Saint Petersburg, in Russia.

His spokeswoman, Nkhensani Makhobela, confirmed that the trip "wasn't a sponsored one but a study tour", meaning ratepayers paid for it.

She promised to give more information about the cost of the trip but did not; neither had she responded to detailed questions from The Times at the time of going to print.

Last night, the city's communications chief, Gabu Tugwana, said he was also unable to give further details, including the cost of the trip.

An earlier press release from the city said the trip was intended to "share experience and expertise in the hope of securing good relations among the cities".

"The city is committed to improving its performance by building international relations in order to learn and possibly adapt what other cities in the world are doing in similar areas of service delivery," the press release said.

It is understood that the trip is one of many taken by several members of the mayoral committee in the past six months.

The Times recently reported that Johannesburg had cut its operating budget by R1.1-billion to fund the completion of Soccer City stadium because of cost overruns. Our report also revealed that the city was struggling to pay some of its suppliers, forcing some to close shop.

Referring to the massive debt write-off, another city spokesman, Virgil James, said it ''is not abnormal".

"The city is neither cash-strapped nor in debt," he said.

"[Writing off of debt] is part of cleaning the books. All necessary channels to recover the money were exhausted."

But economists said the R2.8-billion write-off was highly irregular and could put the city in financial distress.

T-Sec economist Mike Schussler said: "That is quite a huge chunk [of the budget that] we can't afford to write off."

"You can't write off more than 10% of your budget in one go. It is a very, very big amount."

"Should power utility Eskom succeed in securing its 35% tariff increase in each of the next three years, all cities can expect a huge spike in electricity account defaults, which will probably lead to more write-offs," Schussler said.

According to a report in possession of The Times, until June the city's departments, plus PikitUp, Joburg Water, City Power and the City of Joburg, are now owed more than R6-billion.

Investment Solutions economist Chris Hart said the city could now be in the unenviable position of having to borrow money to cover the R2.8-billion lost.

"This could lead to a cash-flow crunch and the city could lose access to service providers where services are outsourced.

"It appears that the city is living beyond the payment means of its citizens," Hart said.

He added that the rating companies could downgrade the city's risk rating, forcing it to pay a lot more interest on its debt.

 Loading...

 or  to comment

Comments

Dec 2 2009 12:29:42 AM
Tackler
user name
So "writing off debt" is quite normal, is it? That sounds like "struggle accounting".
Dec 2 2009 12:31:06 AM
CharlesDarwin
user name
In Harare, the people who send out the rates invoices simply write in a large number that will boost the coffers so that they can pay themselves. If the ratepayer contests the bill, his power is switched off until he pays. This is quite a powerful tool, and will doubtless be used in Johannesburg, and elsewhere in SA.
Dec 2 2009 12:39:27 AM
Sechaba-is-not-a-fake-Communist
user name
This paper sounds like a mouth piece of DA everyday. Why does it have to publish all wrong rumours that DA always puke?
Dec 2 2009 03:31:28 AM
Mole85
user name
@Sechaba, R2.8bln in rumours? Come on buddy surely not every story is propoganda? Maybe just maybe there are so many stories due to incompetence of uneducated officials in positions of power that if abused have serious implications for the rest of the population under their management

The Gau train needed an additional R1.3bln to be completed on time, and the city is more than ready to write of more than double that.
Dec 2 2009 03:54:48 AM
Puffudder
user name
Mole85 has it exactly right. Incompetant, uneducated (anc) officials in positions of power (who should'nt require lavish Asian trips to learn how to do their jobs)

Dec 2 2009 05:44:12 AM
Tackler
user name
If you "wipe" someone's debt, it means that someone else has to pay that bill for a good or service they haven't actually used themselves. It's like you being ordered to pay the restaurant bill of another diner who simply has run away without paying.
Dec 2 2009 05:45:20 AM
Mommacyndi
user name
If the figures are correct then the average was R8.66 that was written off on each of those accounts.

Writing it off still sounds a lot cheaper than paying a lawyer to write a letter to them.

The junkets are ridiculous though.
Dec 2 2009 06:02:08 AM
Jimbo56
user name
No Mommacyndi, it's almost R9000 not R9 average... it's billions not millions; R2 800 000 000
Dec 2 2009 06:05:33 AM
enie
user name
"It appears that the city is living beyond the payment means of its citizens"

well done loyal cadres!!!

cream it until its dead...

who??? what???? the taxpayers???

bwahahahahaha.. thats a joke.
Dec 2 2009 06:08:02 AM
Mommacyndi
user name
Dec 2 2009 06:02:08 AM
Jimbo56

You're right.
That is considerably more worthy of a lawyers letter.

I really shouldn't be allowed to read these things without my glasses on :)


Today's Topics