FEEDS |

Slaughter ban inflammatory - judge

Dec 1, 2009 10:43 PM | By Nivashni Nair

The Pietermaritzburg judge who must decide if the ritual killing of a bull will go ahead in KwaZulu-Natal at the weekend said that an interdict to stop the slaughter could lead to rebellion.


Current Font Size:

Photograph by: .

Related Multimedia

Related Articles

Animal Rights Africa has taken the Zulu monarch, King Goodwill Zwelithini, to court because it believes the killing of a bull in the Ukweshwama harvest ceremony is cruel.

Zulus say the animal is killed quickly and painlessly by breaking its neck.

Judge Nic van der Reyden said he could not be blind to the consequences of stopping a tradition that had been part of Zulu culture for centuries. He said the resulting protest could be similar to the 1976 Soweto uprising, in which black pupils rebelled against a government order that they be taught in Afrikaans.

Van der Reyden said he hoped his comments would encourage Animal Rights Africa, the Zulu king, KwaZulu-Natal Premier Zweli Mkhize and three government departments to a resolution to film the ritual and send the footage to Parliament for a decision.

"There are some points for consideration. Look at our history when authorities forced Afrikaans on those children. We need to resolve this through consultation," the judge said.

He will rule on Friday, a day before the ritual is to take place.

 Loading...

 or  to comment

Comments

Dec 2 2009 10:06:46 AM
Imperialist
user name
Stop eating meat!
Dec 2 2009 10:09:44 AM
Straight-talk
user name
The Times,will u please make a plan to get the footage so that we can see how this bull is killed!!!
Dec 2 2009 10:15:46 AM
Sbonelo
user name
I have a question that maybe one of the animal rights activists can answer, why for all these years has there never been any comment about the ritual and now while SA is on a world stage due to the world cup is this suddenly being raised and at a date so close to the ritual? Please will someone correct me if im wrong but I think it is very suspicious.
Dec 2 2009 10:24:42 AM
Justice_for_Zazu
user name
BAYEDE......WENA WENDLOVU.....BAYEDE WENA WENDLOVE....BAYEDE...WENA WENDLOVU...

Straight-talk visit me this weekend will take you there and you'll see for your self. I stay 20 minutes away from my Kings Palace, -Enyokeni la Kwa-Nongoma.
Dec 2 2009 10:40:40 AM
Vlad
user name
THis is a svage ritual.... you cannot tell me that Bull Killing is a Zulu ritual...

The 1st time the Zulu's ever saw a BULL or COW was when Piet Retief and his party arrived in Natal....prior to that they wrestled each other...

SO where the hell this "AGE OLD" ritual cr4p comes from is just that... CR4P!!

Trying to pull a Pity Party here...
Dec 2 2009 10:41:34 AM
Tackler
user name
Traditions must be dumped when they offend. White people no longer flog offenders, buy slaves or burn witches. These had been traditions for over 2000 years, but they have been dumped. They're offensive.
Dec 2 2009 10:50:55 AM
flashdisk
user name
Yes, it is true that the bull is subjected to severe pain and torture. What is troubling me is that the people who are deeply concerned about this part of the ritual are also not blame-free(abekho msulwa )when it comes to cruelty to animals. As we speak their freezers and refridgerators are full of dead animals which were killed/fished to fill-up their stomachs. They even enjoy the spit braai (Eish!). They also eat eggs (poor things eaten before they hatch).They also wear leather shoes and jackets which are made of animal skins. Only vegetarians and vegans can complain. Even the vegetarians can only state their views but not to take our King to court.
Dec 2 2009 10:53:39 AM
tjokometana
user name
Zulu's Zulu' man there is nothing ths do tht amazises me anymore.Picture ths Me nd Zulu conterpart.Sure Bongs do u nw tht frnd of mine Kgetsa no but I can hit hi in Zulu it wil go like Nga mshaya thts Zulu.
Part two Their so called great king ever Shaka Zulu if u come back frm a battle with scatch behind ur back brother he kills u himselve u r considered a coward,That could've been one his best skillfull worriors who killed more nd he just got away with just a scatch frm behind frm some sniking frm behind nt 4getting tht he also killed tht sniking guy Zulu's.
Part three they kill a bul bear handed kgane is there some wrong with ths guys answer is no they just being Zulus pls let them be u cnt convince Zulus of anything they r hard headed thnks god i am nt Zulu!
Dec 2 2009 10:57:51 AM
Complex
user name
It is only fair that a judge understands the possible consequences of fiddling with culture/tradition/custom. Animal rights activists must just concentrate on issues that do not make people angry. For them to drag this issue to court is a sign of lack of respect for His Royalty. This has been done from time immemorial and they can't expect to win and they must not be allowed to win. Sbonelo: I think we are going back to the olden days of divide and rule.
Dec 2 2009 11:00:16 AM
SONDIYA
user name
The judge has said it he can not decide on this matter. Therefore we are going ahead on Saturday. Nongoma here i come.

You can not tell us about our culture cause you dont understand it and will never. As the judge held "Young Xhosa boys die yearly during circumsion but it will never be stopped bcos it part of their culture"

This is indeed like telling catholic to stop communion.

I urge all the Nguni's to stick to they culture and not be intimidated by people who dont understand our culture.


Today's Topics