FEEDS |

Shown up by West Africa

Toothless, timid SADC would do well to emulate Ecowas

Oct 20, 2009 10:44 PM | By S'Thembiso Msomi

S'Thembiso Msomi : As Zimbabwean Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai embarks on yet another emergency regional tour, searching for help, he must be wishing that his troubled country was in West Africa, where political leaders are made of sterner stuff.


Current Font Size:
quote Contrast all of that with the SADC's pussyfooting around Zimbabwe's Mugabe quote

He must have read with envy at the weekend the news that the Economic Community of West African States had imposed an arms embargo on the military junta-ruled Guinea for "mass human rights violation".

Read more columnists

Even as he headed for South Africa for the first in a series of meetings he hopes to hold with regional leaders, Tsvangirai would have known that there was no hope of the Southern African Development Community adopting a stance against Zimbabwean President Robert Mugabe as tough as the one taken by Ecowas on Saturday against the leaders of Guinea and Niger.

In case you have missed your continental news, here is an update: Following the massacre of, reportedly, more than 150 people at an opposition rally in Guinea last month, Ecowas convened an emergency summit in Abuja on Friday.

But unlike those "crisis summits" we have become accustomed to in the southern part of Africa, the Ecowas meeting was no talking-shop.

West African leaders, headed by Nigeria's Umaru Yar'adua, reacted by slapping Captain Moussa Dadis Camara's regime with an arms embargo.

They also mandated Yar'Adua to lobby the African Union, the European Union and other international bodies to do the same.

In a statement issued after the summit, Ecowas described the state-sponsored violence in Guinea as a "real threat to the peace, security and stability" of the entire West African region.

"All steps must be taken immediately to stop the spate of killings of innocent Guineans who are yearning for immediate restoration to constitutional order," Yar'Adua later said.

The summit also threatened to impose "full sanctions" on Niger if President Mamadou Tandja went ahead with his unconstitutional plans to serve a third term as head of state.

Now contrast all of that with the SADC's pussyfooting around Mugabe, who continues to give regional leaders the middle finger. For that is what he has done by plunging the SADC-sponsored, and shaky, Zimbabwean government of national unity into a fresh crisis.

If he were serious about making the unity government work, Mugabe would have stopped his foot soldiers from harassing Tsvangirai's close ally and the MDC's deputy minister-designate, Roy Bennett.

Bennett's most recent detention was calculated to provoke Tsvangirai and the MDC into pulling out of the unity government. But the collapse of the unity government would not only be a blow to those within Zimbabwe seeking peace and stability, it would leave the SADC - especially South Africa - with much egg on its face.

For years, the region has successfully persuaded the rest of the world that it should not intervene in the Zimbabwean crisis because the SADC leaders were the best placed to resolve the conflict.

Then, a year ago, it seemed that the SADC - and especially former president Thabo Mbeki - would be vindicated, as Tsvangirai and Mugabe concluded a historic power-sharing deal.

But it has been downhill ever since, with the Zanu-PF leader reneging on key components of the agreement.

Despite calls for help from a desperate MDC, the SADC has done very little to ensure that Mugabe meets his end of the bargain.

Would Ecowas have allowed such total disregard of its authority by a member state? I think not.

Academic Adekeye Adebajo once said that bodies such as Ecowas and the SADC need "local hegemons like Nigeria and South Africa" to provide leadership. Nigeria is now doing just this for West Africa, while we in the south are left asking: Where is South Africa?

 Loading...

 or  to comment

Comments

Oct 21 2009 11:01:34 AM
Wonder
user name
SADC is just a toothless body of buddies who continuously meet to have a chat about this and that, who has bought what amongst them, brag about things they did not even help achieve and then go back to their respective countries. SADC is a disgrace.....!!!!!!!!!
Oct 21 2009 12:19:59 PM
mcritic
user name
Worse than a disgrace - it is a in the main a collection of looters and murderers and worse. This lot should be given the boot and told by the AU and the UN that unless they start meeting and ensuring international standrads they will all be excluded from international bodies and financial institutions. Worst still the hand outs to them will stop.

Then we will soon see them running for cover and acting against the crooks in Zimbabwe..
Oct 21 2009 01:33:53 PM
Mommacyndi
user name
SADC has consistently proven itself to be toothless. They have yet to act on anything
Oct 21 2009 01:45:24 PM
Are whites Africans
user name
I wish you could all shut up. Its like you lot live in Heaven. Highest crime rate ...in the WORLD. Highest HIV. Highest poverty. Most shack dwelling people. And you want to talk as if tho everything is okay in your country. We had loads of People from ur country in Zimbabwe during apertheid. But now you burn and kill us. My country is better than yours. Rich companies are ripping you off left right and center.Most of you have never been to Zim. If you had you might never come back. No crime, no shacks every where. Less inflation. We have our problems , yes. But they are nothing compared to yours. Concentrate on your own.. And you cant see that the white man dont want Zimbabwe to prosper. Put on your thinking caps.
Oct 21 2009 01:49:22 PM
zimbo263
user name
some of us saw all this coming when these two (or supposedly three) parties jumped into bed together. there are very few people who can fathom mugabe's ability to get away with anything, sadc included. the only option here is to wait until God calls him home. the old man is too cunning. he will just wait for the next sadc playschool gathering (and he is captain of course) and pull the wool over everyones eyes. zuma must not think mbeki was stupid; as he is finding out now, the man was up against a super-genius gone mad.
Oct 21 2009 03:10:14 PM
Nquza
user name
@ Are white african?
The article is not about whites being african or not - SA being better than Zim or not. It is about SADC being an organisation that does not have the moral high ground to deal with Zimbabwe. It is also about lack of leadership in the part of SADC in general.

You seem to be shooting off the wrong tangent. Are you by any chance condoning what Mugabe is doing? If you are then I feel sorry for the people of your country.
Oct 21 2009 03:50:49 PM
Kunta_Kinte
user name
They are all c#nts, including these Zanu thug calling himself whites being African.
Oct 21 2009 10:59:54 PM
Africa_need_No_link_to_europe
user name
The propaganda in support of the puppet of the British devilish government show how pink "white" supremacy operate in order to preserve their supremacy against us.

They even use ignorant Africans to help them achieve their objective.

The same as during the struggle against the deeply evil and satanic apartheid; the evil, satanic, devilish, primitive, insane, criminal, barbaric apartheid, used IFP to fight ANC in order to stop freedom from coming.

It is not new to us how those devils operate.

Our time to stop pink supremacy madness is now.

Nationalize the apartheid era news agencies and make sure it is proportionally own among all the race groups of the country based on the size of each race group.

And that way the enemies of justice will not have free hand to push evil against justice.


Today's Topics