FEEDS |

Some dreams should not have crumbled with the Berlin Wall

Nov 7, 2009 7:38 PM | By Mondli Makhanya

Mondli Makhanya: In many capitals around the world they are celebrating the 20th anniversary of the fall of the Berlin Wall, an event that heralded the implosion of communism.


Current Font Size:
Mondli Makhanya
Mondli Makhanya
quote We adopted some of the worst manifestations of godless capitalism and some of the worst tenets of Stalinism quote

In some quarters there will be some mourning of the event which drove a knife into the heart of Karl Marx's dream of an egalitarian society.

I must confess I am one of those who does not have fond memories of that November of 1989. It was with horror that I and my friends watched those scenes of Germans dancing on top of the wall and merrily chipping away at it.

We found it inconceivable that people would be celebrating the end of their socialist Utopia and that they were handing themselves over to the evil ways of the capitalist West. The German Democratic Republic (or GDR as the freedom songs we sang said) was dying a very dramatic death.

Two years earlier, US president Ronald Reagan had delivered that ringing speech at the Brandenburg Gate in which he made this appeal to then Soviet Union leader Mikhail Gorbachev: "If you seek peace, if you seek prosperity for the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe, if you seek liberalisation: come here, to this gate. Mr Gorbachev, open this gate. Mr Gorbachev, tear down this wall."

In the end it was the people of Berlin who tore down the wall, opened the floodgates and freed themselves from tyranny.

Little did my friends and I know then that the fall of the wall was only the beginning of our trauma. Over the next few months and years communist governments would fall, to loud cheers in western capitals. Czechoslovakia, Romania, Bulgaria - models of Utopia - fell like dominoes. This was to culminate in the overthrow of Gorbachev and the break- up of the Soviet Union.

It was clear then there would be no socialism in our lifetime. (Okay, now we know that this was a good thing - but back then it did not seem that way).

So spare a thought for some of us who will not be cracking open champagne bottles. Spare a thought for some of us who will be reliving sad memories.

Of course, even those of us who were devastated back then now know better. When the Iron Curtain came down, it revealed a dismal world of sad people and cruel rulers. We discovered that the "propaganda" that the western media had been feeding us about the state of affairs was actually true. It was as bad, if not worse, than what had been portrayed.

But with the collapse of communism the world also lost something good. In the triumph over communism, we as humans threw the baby out with the bath water (by the way, did anybody ever actually do that?)

We forsook the moral foundations of socialism, which, at the outset, were premised on human beings being just to human beings. In those triumphalist days when the West was dancing on the Eastern Bloc's grave, we simply replaced godless communism with godless capitalism and created an amoral world.

And with that we were thrust into the godless 1990s, a period of greed and heartlessness.

It was that greed that led to the horrendous meltdown of 2008 and plunged the world into the worst recession in nearly a century. The same greed that is feeding corrupt practices the world over, including our country.

In South Africa, the post-Cold War period had its own effects. We adopted some of the worst manifestations of godless capitalism and some of the worst tenets of Stalinism.

When the ANC returned to the country in the early 1990s, the residue of the Soviet Union was still very much in their blood. Yes, most of them had embraced the reality that the socialist experiment had failed and that the free market was the most efficient way of allocating resources.

But in terms of political style they knew only one way to operate. In South Africa they found a vibrant democratic culture that had been nurtured in communities. The returnees' first order of business was to impose their leadership style on the internal democratic movement, whose leaders and activists were still star-struck at the revolutionary heavyweights in their midst.

It was a grave mistake, for which we continue to suffer today. The political culture imposed on the internal structures stifled the democratic culture that had been so key to weakening the apartheid state.

This was a culture of secrecy, authoritarianism and intolerance.

It was this culture that enabled the motley clique that ran our country for the past decade to get away with murder. Even though the Polokwane revolution was about displacing that culture, one senses it creeping back into our political space. Bad habits are hard to kill.

The great irony is that, while retaining the Eastern Bloc's political culture, on the other end we adopted the materialist culture of the so-called imperialist West. This, as Cosatu boss Zwelinzima Vavi pointed out the other day, has fed the corruption beast that we are battling today.

If there is a present we South Africans should give ourselves to mark the 20th anniversary of the Berlin Wall's fall, it will be to find a way of reining in these tendencies.

We cannot go back to the pre-Polokwane political culture and we cannot allow corruption and materialism to eat away at our democratic dream.


 or  to comment

Comments

Nov 8 2009 12:18:02 AM
Keto
user name
In my first article I was concerned with the evils resulting from any system of DOGMAS presented for acceptance, not on the ground of TRUTH, but on the grounds of social utility.

The brotherhood of man is a present possibility. New men with a new instinct to unify, to share, serve, and sacrifice are possible.

Professor Sarvepalli Radhakrishanan : Fellow of All Souls College , Oxford University ( 1936-1956) and a former President of Indiaclose friend of Bertrand Russell.
Philosopher :Bertrand Russell : Nobel Prize winner for Philosophy 1956.and Former Professor of Philosophy and Logic Cambridge University.
Nov 8 2009 04:01:10 AM
guardian vampire
user name
I spent the first part of my life in one of those communist Utopias and can honestly say that every Christmas I am reminded of the best gift I ever got- FREEDOM. Communism was just another expensive mistake in social engineering and I'm glad it's gone. So, to those of you out there who remember those days, break out the champagne and pray for another 20 years without dictatorship...
Nov 8 2009 04:13:20 AM
Tackler
user name
My friends and I yahooed and cheered loudly as that despicable Communist wall was demolished, along with the entire edifice of the murderous and brutish socialist ideology which built it. And, to this day, I'm unashamedly thrilled that it fell.
Nov 8 2009 07:55:29 AM
mcritic
user name
I saw and went through the Berlin Wall at check Point Charlie to East Germany. The wall was a sin against mankind and the people inside Berlin were prisoners in their own city.

I could not believe it when I saw the people chipping away at the wall and dancing on top.

Now - I have another problem with teh article. Ther worst thieves and looters were those selfsame communist leaders with massive personal bank accounts in Switzerland. What makes people think that corruption is a sign of capitalism. Corruption is in fact a sign of impunity and is practised most extensively in countries where people think they can get away witth it.

The best example still in existence is Zimbabbwe - a socialist heaven with absolutely no control over the looting by the President and his cronies. It is a state with a patronage system = where there was no difference between government funds and ZANU-PF funds and one can remember a theme song for an erstwhile TV series - where the words go:- "Everyone was dealing, everyone was stealing"

Put Vavi in a position where he can lay his hands on hard cash and see how much would vanish in record time.

I just do not trust state instoitutions and the people working for them. Corruption eas endemic in the National Party regime - albeit more secretive and less glaring - but then the press was under strict contr0ol as well - whilst today the whole saga is played out for all to see.
Nov 8 2009 08:28:43 AM
selcool
user name
Dear Mondli, as a memeber of the ANC Youth & Students based then in Sweden, I often visited the GDR/DDR [East Germany] and stayed awile with our comrades living there, attended conferences and meetings/seminars there and generally travelled around. This was NO bastion of Democartic Socialism I can tell you: one kept looking over one's shoulder to see if the Stasi secret police were around, there was the one-Party dictatorship. Oh yes, training was given to our comrades in MK, but as was seen in Quatro, Viana and the 'punishment/re-education' camps of the ANC in northern Angola in the 1980s, this was training 'of a special kind'! See the recently published book by Jacanda Media 'Inside Quatro' for more deatails if you do not believe me. I never stopped being a socialist after having been in the Eastern Bloc countries but was relieved when the 'Wall came down' as I then thought we could build a truley Democratic Socialism in our own country after 1994, but the lies, deceit and deceptions of the Stalinists in the SACP seemed to be to strong - and now we are again at the edge of the precipice. Thanks Comrade!
Nov 8 2009 08:32:26 AM
debecker
user name
let it be Communism, liberalism etc the World has been corrupted for as long as human beings have been on the Planet. Read your history it is inherent to the human race. Communism was another doctrine to subjugate people / Once again an elite was prospering at the expense of the majority. If you were not a Party member you were nothing. The Party members had their own shops The thoughts behind Communism were very noble but Utopians. Do U know how many millions of people were killed, jailed etc during Stalin's tenure
Nov 8 2009 08:43:39 AM
Africa_need_No_link_to_europe
user name
best Rap ever about the legendary president Mugabe.

watch it on youtube:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FZAhuSxm0jU&NR=1
Report Abuse
Nov 8 2009 09:16:05 AM
selcool
user name
Important links:

http://www.politicsweb.co.za/politicsweb/view/politicsweb/en/page71619?oid=149514&sn=Detail

It is time for more careful attention in South Africa to the collapse of the ANC's former support base in Eastern Europe. Time for more sober realism. Paul Trewhela is the author of Inside Quatro: Uncovering The Exile History of the ANC and SWAPO, Jacana Media, 2009.


The East European LEFT and 1989 ..... The Fall of the Wall in Perspective!

Go to: http://www.socialistworker.co.uk/art.php?id=19440

NOW let us have a sober discussion on the East European States, the Cold War, the Future of the Planet after the Fall of the Wall!

Nov 8 2009 09:17:28 AM
donorfatigued
user name
We found it inconceivable that people would be celebrating the end of their socialist Utopia..//

That statement simply illustrates your skewed way of thinking - but most leftists are like that and will simply not face or admit reality when it does not accord with their pet theories.

Perhaps you should have viewed the fall of the wall and the rejoicing of the East German people as proof that an evil and repressive regime of communism had held them captive for 50 years instead of being puzzled by their rejection of what you term a 'socialist utopia'.

Communism is an entirely failed ideology and can never result in the 'utopia' you dream of for it goes completely against the nature of human beings. This is why it had to be enforced by tyranny and violence and the death of millions wherever it was practiced.

Continuing to believe that there is anything good in communism is like believing that it entirely possible to pick up a turd by the clean end!
Nov 8 2009 09:18:43 AM
florance
user name
"I must confess I am one of those who does not have fond memories of that November of 1989. It was with horror that I and my friends watched those scenes of Germans dancing on top of the wall and merrily chipping away at it."

What???

Dear Mondli,

Put that nostalgia and daydreaming aside, read 'selcool' and 'mcritic's comments, catch a wake up and get real.

No system that INEVITABLY resorts to building walls and iron curtains and taking people's freedom away is worth experimenting with. This would be just as risky and dangerous as injecting yourself with HIV virus to see how long you can live with AIDS and if you can keep it under control.

The world has moved on. Let Africa and SA do the same. Don't even think about it.