FEEDS |

History 101, anyone?

A new book chronicles the struggle in a laughable manner

Sep 12, 2009 10:46 PM | By Mac Maharaj: In Confidence

Mac Maharaj: I am reading a book that has me oscillating between laughter, tears, anger and irritation. I am left to speculate how many trees were felled to humour its author.


Current Font Size:
quote Vlakplaas represents one of the darkest chapters of South Africa's history. For Jeffery, it stands as a place of sanctuary from the evil ANC quote

I was suckered. The book promised "New light on the struggle for South Africa". Its author holds law degrees from Wits and Cambridge and a doctorate from the University of London. Its end notes take up 29 pages, the reference footnotes span 161 pages and the select bibliography runs into eight.

Like Pavlov's dog I was salivating. I had visions of rigorous analysis and scholarship and new veins of golden historical sources that have not been mined.

For my R279 the author uses 634 pages to tell me that my life has been a waste (to say nothing about truly illustrious sons and daughters of our soil).

I spent hours skimming its pages - kind of nibbling to get my taste buds tickled. My nose began to twitch. Since I stopped smoking, my sense of smell has sharpened. To where was I being led? I did a fast-forward to the conclusion. It told me that our country has been left with "little more than the outward shell of a democracy".

I kid you not. That quote is from the last two lines of People's War by Anthea Jeffery.

What about our constitution and its Bill of Rights, our Constitutional Court, our four successive elections that are admired the world over? The scholar in her dismisses these as false perceptions and consigns them to a box labelled "outward shell of democracy".

I am a glutton for punishment.

She hints that the Soviets pushed us into launching Umkhonto weSizwe. She is more daring when it comes to the people's war which began, she says, with a visit to Vietnam of a delegation led by ANC president Oliver Tambo. The party did so at "Moscow's behest". The aim of the visit was "to put the ANC in touch with astute Vietnamese strategists such as President Ho Chi Minh and General Vo Nguyen Giap".

That's it. A bald statement of fact. Not even a footnote to enlighten us about the source of this information. Dr Jeffery says so. Therefore it is true.

Some 32 pages on, lest we forget, she repeats that "At Moscow's urging a senior delegation ... visited Vietnam in October 1978". The delegation, she says, consisted of Oliver Tambo, Joe Modise, Joe Slovo, Chris Hani and Alfred Nzo.

I do not hold a doctorate and I am not a lawyer. But what if I told you that Ho Chi Minh died on September 2 1969, some nine years before the Tambo visit to Vietnam; that Chris Hani and Alfred Nzo were not in the delegation but Moses Mabhida, Thabo Mbeki and Cassius Maake were there (see Oliver Tambo: Beyond the Engeli Mountains by Luli Callinicos)?

What about the 1994 elections? We, the voters, were pepper-sprayed. She explains: "... a people's war is primarily a war of communication. One of its main aims is to throw dust in people's eyes: to put forward a false theory of violence which is plausible in many ways ... once this false theory has become deeply rooted ... it becomes progressively more difficult to believe that it could be mistaken and misleading."

In Jeffery's universe, the countless lives lost in the violence that ravaged our country were not the result of apartheid and a state-backed Third Force, but of the people's war waged by the ANC.

She stops at nothing to whitewash the apartheid state and its surrogates. She peddles the idea, advanced in 1989 by US academic Leo Raditsa, that askaris were simply dissidents who took advantage, when sent into SA on military missions, to break with the ANC. "In some instances, police caught them, but in others they surrendered willingly. The government set aside a farm called Vlakplaas ... to accommodate these askaris ... and kept its location secret to protect them from ANC retaliation." Does Jeffery really believe this romanticising of askaris and Vlakplaas will wash? If not, why does she resuscitate Raditsa in 2009?

Vlakplaas, haven of death squads, was a secret police operation made up of a bunch of thugs who tortured and killed their victims in the most gruesome ways. With a penchant for the macabre, they created the term "buddha-ing" for seating their victim in the posture of Buddha and disposing of the body by dynamiting it to shreds.

Vlakplaas represents one of the darkest chapters of South Africa's history. For Jeffery, it stands as a place of sanctuary from the evil ANC.

I am saddened. For all her three university degrees, Jeffery does disservice to scholarship, her country and herself.

I shall be doubly saddened if, despite this column, one more person is suckered, like I was.

 Loading...

 or  to comment

Comments

Sep 14 2009 08:14:34 PM
Matshelane
user name
The truth hurts, doesn't it ?
Sep 15 2009 02:41:40 AM
Tackler
user name
That sham of a constitution of which you are proud also explicitly and shamelessly entrenches ongoing racism in the notion that some sort of racial advantaging (one where blacks ipso facto benefit from simply being born non-white and whites therefore simply cannot) is all hunky-dory. All those who don't believe that all this hyper-publicised constitutional number twos really isn't chocolate mousse after all are going to side with Andrea rather than you. She wins; you lose.

Sep 15 2009 07:23:44 AM
Johnny
user name
Dear Mac
The few misreprentations you picked up disappear to insignificance when compared to the wholesale hoax of your struggle against so called apartheid --- It was all about power. Fullstop. And that very same power treated you as disposable, maybe their is some truth in your "wasted life" comment.
Sep 15 2009 07:36:24 AM
webathandwa
user name
Themba, I am with you mfowethu. This new website is a pain in the ass.Have you memorised the password yet? Mine reads like the Da Vinci Code. Thank God I read the hard copy first.

Anyway, thank you Mr President for welcoming our sporting heroes at the airport and not wait for them to come to Mahlambandlopfu. This is a first, keep it up.

Well done mabhokobhoko!!!
Sep 20 2009 12:42:55 AM
wilhelm
user name
I agree the knowledge of history is appalling in SA. If you say Mussolini, people think it's an aftershave. It's just such a pity that the struggle has proven itself to be merely a struggle to get at the trough, not a struggle for dignity or anything remotely standing for what t purported to be.


Today's Topics