Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE &
Business LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
Sat May 26 13:43:34 SAST 2012

Holocaust survivor's dramatic plea to Zuma

Anna Majavu | 08 November, 2011 00:5610 Comments
Death camps survivor and Russel Tribunal jurist Stephane Hessel addresses a press conference yesterday after delivering a letter to President Jacob Zuma appealing for protection for an Israeli MP who testified at the tribunal in Cape Town yesterday

A 94-year-old survivor of Hitler's death camps has made an impassioned plea to President Jacob Zuma to protect an Israeli MP from being stripped of her citizenship for testifying at the Russell Tribunal on Palestine.

After sitting in Cape Town at the weekend, where it heard evidence from a range of witnesses, the tribunal declared that Israel was guilty of practising apartheid and called for it to be isolated.

The finding sparked fury from the South African Jewish Board of Deputies and SA Zionist Federation, which denounced it as "a vehicle for anti-Israel propaganda".

Yesterday, Stephane Hessel, who survived the Nazis' Buchenwald concentration camp and later became part of the team that wrote the Universal Declaration on Human Rights, delivered a letter at Zuma's home in Cape Town asking him to protect Haneen Zoabi, an MP for Israel's Balad party.

This came after another Israeli MP, Otniel Schneller of the conservative Kadima party, reportedly asked her country's parliament's ethics committee to strip Zoabi of her citizenship after she said the Israeli state was "racist".

Hessel and his fellow jurists, including former cabinet minister Ronnie Kasrils, acclaimed author Alice Walker and Irish Nobel Peace Prize laureate Mairead Maguire, told Zuma they were concerned other Israelis and Palestinians who testified at the tribunal would also be persecuted. They want Zuma to get an assurance from the Israeli government that all witnesses will be given safe passage home.

Zoabi told The Times: "Any Israeli citizen who talks about full national and civic rights for the Palestinians is normally targeted. It is more of a political persecution," she said.

Zuma's spokesman, Mac Maharaj, referred inquiries to the Department of International Relations and Cooperation, whose spokesman, Clayson Monyela, did not respond to questions.

After declaring at a press conference in Cape Town yesterday that Israel was guilty of practising apartheid, the tribunal called on world governments to institute sanctions against it and break off diplomatic ties.

Apartheid is defined under international law as a situation in which two distinct racial groups can be identified and inhumane acts committed against the subordinate group with state backing, according to the tribunal.

Jurist and veteran British lawyer Michael Mansfield said Palestinian territories consisted of ''a series of separate reserves with the two groups [Palestinian and Israeli] segregated. He added that Israeli expert witnesses had said this policy was even called hafrada, Hebrew for "separation".

"There are two entirely separate legal systems. Palestinians are subjected to military law, which falls far short of ... due process and Israelis living in settlements [inside Palestine] are subjected to civil law," said Mansfield.

"Israel subjects the Palestinian people to an institutionalised regime of domination amounting to apartheid as defined under international law."

But South African Jewish Board of Deputies chairman Mary Kluk said the tribunal was staged to "depict Israel in the most damning light possible", and that it had "confirmed predictions that it would be no more than an unbalanced vehicle for anti-Israel propaganda thinly disguised as a quasi-judicial investigation".

A small group of the board's supporters protested outside the press conference, some dressed as kangaroos.

Kasrils slammed them, saying that a kangaroo court was a situation in which a helpless individual was dragged into a short trial before being sent "to the gallows".

The tribunal, he said, was only passing moral judgment and had no power to punish Israel.

To submit comments you must first

Join the discussion & Debate

Holocaust survivor's dramatic plea to Zuma

For Commenters Consideration | Please stick to the subject matter

COMMENTS [10]

Razzo

Posted 200 days ago
Avatar
This is very sad.....for a state that fought persecution from the Germans and survived total anihillation, its sad that now it is them that are persecuting the Palestinians. I am very perpexled at this.....They are denying people basic freedoms enshrined in democracies: freedom of speech, freedom of association and the right to speak ones mind. This is ridiculous. and then they want the world to feel sorry because of the Holocaust but this is what they are prepared to subject others to........I dont believe this.......
Avatar

Jaguarfight

Posted 98 days ago
Well, if you don't believe it it's because there's a lot more to the story than this conference lets on. Durban has already been the site of a scandalous anti-Israel conference, now there's another. The fact is that Israel has to cope with a real terrorist threat. Palestinians have murdered thousands of Israelis in terrorist attacks aimed murdering innocent civilians. Men, women,and children have all died in attacks on private homes, restaurants, busses, and so on. As a result, Israel must take real measures to defend its citizens. This has nothing to do with the Holocaust, racists, or anything else. This situation exists because Jews have the right to protect themselves, regardless of the dirty remarks others make about them.

We don't want anyone to feel sorry for us. Our efforts to memorialize the Holocaust is an effort to make sure that future generations--Jews and everyone else--will not be subject to industrialized mass murder.

Ndlwananhle-kayi-1

Posted 200 days ago
Avatar
People always accussed Black South Africans of having an ENTITLEMENT MENTALITY and not wanting to let go, always living in the past. I see the same thing with Jews.
Avatar

Jaguarfight

Posted 98 days ago
This is simply untrue. If you visit Israel you will see a modern, vibrant country focused on the present and future. Our connection to the past is our connection to our heritage. If we talk too much about the Holocaust it's so that the same tragedy will not happen again--to the Jews, or anyone.

Mercenary

Posted 200 days ago
Avatar
It's not Jews per se but Zionists who are carrying out these atrocities. These people are the most hardcore right wing people who can come across.

If you wanna see more of the lies being spread by Israel leadership check the link below in which Obama and Sarkozy calls current Israeli PM a liar

english.alarabiya.net/articles/2011/11/08/176012.html
Avatar

Jaguarfight

Posted 98 days ago
Mercenary, this is a fine example of reverse racism. Israel has a right to defend itself.

Also, you should know that Arabs living in Israel enjoy far more rights than in Muslim countries. In Israel, Muslims vote, received free education, gender equality, and the sorts of privileges found in Western democracies. In fact, Israel is the only real democracy in the Middle East and all its citizens enjoy their civil rights. Take a look at Saudia Arabia or Iran. Is that the case there? NO. Then try Gaza which lives beneath a military dictatorship taken in a violent coup. That's the real difference.

AllanRabbie

Posted 199 days ago
Avatar
What HaneenZoabi is doing is called TREASON .
Avatar

Jaguarfight

Posted 98 days ago
You are correct, Allan. In fact, Zoabi participated in the Gaza Flotilla and then returned to the Knesset to badmouth Israel. What if she had been a politician in Gaza who had participated in a pro-Israel event? She wouldn't be around today. Also, as a single woman in her forties, it's unlikely that Zoabi would be allowed to live freely and unmolested in Muslim Gaza.

People want to blame everything on Israel, but take a look at what's happening in the Arab countries right now. Syria--Assad murdering his own people by the thousand. Libya--Gaddafi threatened to annihilate the entire population of Benghazi and only Western forces could stop him. And so on in half the countries in the region. That's the unpleasant reality, made bare for all to see.

Anti-Apartheid

Posted 199 days ago
Avatar
@AllanRabbie
Be careful. Nelson Mandela and many other struggle heroes were charged by the erstwhile racist Apartheid government with TREASON .... remember? If what Haneen Zoabi and Stephane Hessel are doing (by telling the truth about apartheid Israel) is treason, then you know that you are on the wrong side of history. Zoabi and Hessel are true heroes, true Jews, and we pray that the Almighty protects then against the evil of Zionism. It is because of brave heroes like them that the Zionist state of Israel will eventually implode. There is no place for racists - not here, not Palestine, and not on this planet!
Avatar

Jaguarfight

Posted 98 days ago
Watch out Anti-Apartheid. All kinds of people have been accused of treason, not just Mandela--and many of them justly so. Just because these people are against Israel doesn't make them good, honest, democratic, or free of racism. If you want to remain truly free of prejudice, then you can't just jump to conclusions about these situations. They are complex and if you just choose the anti-Israel position as your reflex, then you too are indulging in racism. I say that because that's what it is--anti-semitism, the oldest and most enduring hatred of them all.