Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 40119.55
    DOWN -1.63%
    Top 40 : 3333.90
    DOWN -1.57%
    Financial 15 : 10940.19
    DOWN -1.59%
    Industrial 25 : 46023.22
    DOWN -1.78%

  • ZAR/USD : 10.2706
    UP 0.83%
    ZAR/GBP : 15.8890
    UP 0.76%
    ZAR/EUR : 13.5739
    UP 0.28%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.1048
    DOWN -0.53%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.4417
    DOWN -0.09%

  • Gold : 1308.1000
    DOWN -2.63%
    Platinum : 1400.5000
    DOWN -0.53%
    Silver : 20.3100
    DOWN -4.24%
    Palladium : 681.0000
    DOWN -1.16%
    Brent Crude Oil : 104.150
    DOWN -1.86%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Thu Jun 20 11:16:04 SAST 2013

Secrecy bill opposition reaching fever pitch

CHARL DU PLESSIS | 22 November, 2011 00:0315 Comments

Image by: Sunday Times

Almost 14 years ago to the day, former president Nelson Mandela told journalists that press freedom would never be under threat in South Africa for as "long as the ANC is the majority party".

That was on November 19 1997, but now all that looks set to change, with political parties, media organisations, civil society groups and trade unions saying the ANC's feared Protection of State Information Bill will stifle the right of the media and whistle-blowers to expose corruption.

The ANC is expected to use its majority in the National Assembly today to pass the bill, which makes provision for the classification of state information and imposes stiff penalties, potentially of up to 20 years' imprisonment, on journalists who divulge classified information.

Ahead of the vote this afternoon, opposition to the bill has reached fever pitch.

Editors from around the country are in Cape Town to join a picket by the Right2Know campaign - a nation-wide coalition of individuals and organisations opposed to the bill - outside parliament.

The National Press Club's campaign calling on South Africans to wear black in protest at the bill had gone viral on social networks by last night.

The SA National Editors' Forum sent a letter to all MPs this morning, urging them to vote against the legislation.

The letter stated that, despite important work on the bill in the past 18 months, there were still "serious remaining flaws" in it. Chief among these was the lack of a public interest defence. "In its current form, the bill represents an attack on principles of open democracy that are deeply embedded in our Constitution and our national life," read the letter.

Prominent human rights activist Rhoda Kadalie lashed out at the ANC yesterday, saying it had confused what was in the best interests of the public with what was in the best interests of the party.

"When liberation democratic parties feel threatened, they go for the judiciary, they go for the media and they go for freedom of speech," said Kadalie.

The SA Municipal Workers' Union added its voice, saying the bill would "disadvantage whistle-blowers and workers who are fighting corruption".

The union called on all unions "to ensure that the secrecy bill does not become law".

The coalition had planned protests in Johannesburg, Durban, Pretoria and Cape Town.

A joint statement, issued by activist groups Equal Education, the Treatment Action Campaign, Section27, the Social Justice Campaign and Ndifuna Ukwazi, said that they all oppose the bill, and if it became law "members of parliament will be saying to South Africans that it is okay to punish the people who disclose and write about corruption and mismanagement in government and the corporate sector".

Dene Smuts, the DA spokesman for justice and constitutional development, said yesterday that she still hoped that there would be further discussions on, and amendments to, the bill.

The ANC has defended the bill in its current form, with chief whip Mathole Motshekga's office yesterday saying that the lack of a public interest defence was in line with "international best practice" and that a "serious country" would not "compromise the security of its citizens for the sake of a scoop for the media".

  • Sapa reports that Archbishop Emeritus Desmond Tutu lashed out at the bill, which he described as ''flawed''. "It is insulting to all South Africans to be asked to stomach legislation that could be used to outlaw whistle-blowing and investigative journalism ... and that makes the state answerable only to the state," he said in a statement.
To submit comments you must first

Join the discussion & Debate

Secrecy bill opposition reaching fever pitch

For Commenters Consideration | Please stick to the subject matter

COMMENTS [15]

nkosipeter

Posted 576 days ago
Avatar
The old ANC is dead....

R.I.P.

BobbyBob

Posted 576 days ago
Avatar
The country was betrayed ..........

Liberal-Soul

Posted 576 days ago
Avatar

.....22 November 2011........This DAY will go down in history as a day that South Africans (black, indian, white and coloured) will learn and remember the dangers of electing an UNEDUCATED president..........

HancuLouw

Posted 576 days ago
Avatar
In a society in which profit is king and the truth a tool of the elitist class - in Marxist terms - I would think that "we" the educated minority would be more active in our pursuit of greater democracy in the media sphere. As information gathering and producing individuals working in a system which could be described as serving the interests of the "thought police" the onus is on us to oppose and promote free and independent press not governed by notions of profit maximisation which serves the ideological hegemony of Western Capitalism.

Rightway

Posted 576 days ago
Avatar
One small step for the ANC one great leap backwards for all South Africans . The ANC are traitors and betrayers of the people of South Africa. No wonder Noble laureates and ex ANC say that this draconian Bill will take us beyond Apartheid.

22 November 2011 will be known as a day of infamy when we lost our right to a free media all because of corruption that needs to be hidden.

RogueTrooper

Posted 576 days ago
Avatar
It doesn't matter how you spin it...or how many times you spin it...the mere fact that Cwele REFUSED to even consider let alone include the requested 'public interest' clause that ALL oppsition parties AND the ANC ally COSATU wanted included already indicates the real purpose for which this bill will be applied. It will be used as an intsrument to punish dissent and criticism of the ANC. The ANC have time and time again PROMISED to act on corruption...where and when has this happened? It NEVER does...they nail a select few (Selebi is actually the only one that comes to mind) that face criminal charges and or action...the rest?...lateral deployment or golden handshake. Some of the electorate out here are not idiots...we CAN see the wood for the trees. We CAN see through the lies of what was once a moral party based on ethics and equality...the ANC is morally bankrupt and it's leaders are thieves and charlotans of the highest order and are now bandying together to find ways of hiding their nefarious activities.
Today marks the 1st step in the devolution of RSA...and you (supporters of this bill) are party to that...nay you are an agent of the destruction of this wonderful country. I hope you can live with that in the years to come when the true nature of this bill becomes evident!!!

Rightway

Posted 576 days ago
Avatar
Sapa reports that Archbishop Emeritus Desmond Tutu lashed out at the bill, which he described as ''flawed''. "It is insulting to all South Africans to be asked to stomach legislation that could be used to outlaw whistle-blowing and investigative journalism ... and that makes the state answerable only to the state," he said in a statement.

...

Well put Desmond. If only you and Mandela were younger. You could have saved South Africa from the new ANC.

jil

Posted 576 days ago
Avatar
THE ANC WANTS TO SEND THIS BEAUTIFUL COUNTRY OF OURS BACK TO THE STONE AGE. WITH THEIR NEW SECRECY BILL THEY WANT TO HIDE THEIR BLATANT AND EVER INCREASING CORRUPTION AND SEVERELY PUNISH PEOPLE WHO BLOW THE WHISTLE ON THEM. THIS HAS GOT TO STOP NOW! THIS COUNTRY BELONGS TO US ALL AND NOT ONLY TO A CERTAIN FEW PEOPLE WHO BECAME STINKING RICH OVER-NIGHT. JUST LIKE IN THE APARTHEID ERA, WE MUST NOT KEEP SILENT BECAUSE EVIL TRIUMPH WHEN GOOD PEOPLE KEEP SILENT.
I TAKE MY HAT OF FOR MR. TUTU. HE HAS THE GUTS AND MORAL FIBRE TO SPEAK OUT AGAINST THESE THUGS. I, HOWEVER, AM VERY DISAPPOINTED AT THE "WORLD'S HERO" MR. MANDELA. HE HAS BEEN QUIET FOR TOO LONG. HE NEVER SAID A THING WHEN MR. MBEKI ALLOWED THE XENAPHOBIA AND THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE TO DIE OF AIDS, HE NEVER SAID A THING WHEN MR. ZUMA BECAME AN ILLEGAL PRESIDENT WHO WAS SUPPOSE TO GO TO JAIL WITH MR. SCHAIK AND HE NEVER SAID A THING WHEN MR. MALEMA ALMOST GOT IT RIGHT TO DIVIDE THIS COUNTRY RACIALLY. I THINK HE IS TOO AFRAID OF THE ANC AND IN MY BOOK ANYTHING BUT A HERO. WE, THE PEOPLE OF THIS COUNTRY, ARE THE ONLY ONCE THAT CAN STOP THIS EVIL BILL!!!!

DITABA-DITABA

Posted 575 days ago
Avatar
But the word SECRECY.......where does it come from?.is it just present in the media's own imagination or its realy part of POIB..?I mean the headline reads Secrecy Bill reaching fever pitch...The media needs to be sensitive when reporting on this issue of PIOB if they are to win any public support.
Avatar

nkosipeter

Posted 575 days ago
How does "Protection of Corruption Bill" sit with you Ditaba?



PeterAdlard

Posted 575 days ago
Avatar
@ Ditaba - have you READ the bill? It gives the government carte blanche to withhold information that threatens the country or any 'entity' against any threat, including defamation, threat to profit (?!), threat to persons, threat to security of state and persons...fracking will happen without recourse, Malemea wil not be tried, Zuma and the arms deal fiasco will disappear, politicians and theit friends will become incrdibly rich, their opponents will disappear without trace - public, economic, political, faith, ethnic - with no possibility of challenge and recourse to victims. If the system is challenged, it will take decadse and thre whim of politicians to make information available, and if the law is broken by a journalist they can be held for up to five years without the State Security Association (!!) having to get involved, but automatically get a 5-10 year sentence minimum, possibly a fifteen year sentence. If a state employee fraudulently classifies information (for personal ends) they face a fine or a jail sentence not exceeding three years. It's the ANC institutionalising themselves as the govcernment, and positioning themselves to milk the country of it's wealth and freedom for personal, private, ends. Anyone who says otherwise is a traitor to the country.
Avatar

Mnbvcxz0

Posted 575 days ago
All I can say is wow. You learnt all of that from the Bill? <and if the law is broken by a journalist they can be held for up to five years without the State Security Association >, < Malemea wil not be tried, Zuma and the arms deal fiasco will disappear, politicians and theit friends will become incrdibly rich>, You gather all of these from reading the Bill? Please read it again.

BokFan

Posted 575 days ago
Avatar
ALUTA CONTINUA

Phansi Secrecy Bil Phansi
Phambili Democracy Phambili

DonaldKnight

Posted 575 days ago
Avatar
Time to start those prayers for the demise of the ANC!!

ShiranSingh

Posted 554 days ago
Avatar
A nation of sheep spawns a government of wolves.