Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE &
Business LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
Sun May 20 02:57:44 SAST 2012

No more free flights for former presidents

CHANDRÉ PRINCE | 24 November, 2011 23:5741 Comments
Former Presidents FW De Klerk, Nelson Mandela and Thabo Mbeki in Cape Town, South Africa, May 6, 1994. File photo.
Image by: GUY TILLIM/AFP

Former presidents and deputy presidents will not be allowed domestic travel paid for by the state until next year.

Former presidents Nelson Mandela, Thabo Mbeki and FW de Klerk, and former deputy presidents Phumzile Mlambo-Ngcuka and Baleka Mbete, are among those affected by "serious budgetary constraints" being experienced by President Jacob Zuma's office.

The Times can reveal that the former top politicians were over the past two weeks notified that their travel and subsistence allowances for the rest of year have been cut but would resume in the new financial year, which starts in April.

The two-paragraph letter, headed "Benefits of Executive Office", reads: "The Presidency is currently experiencing serious budgetary constraints and unfortunately the budget that was allocated to you for travel and subsistence has been exhausted. We are therefore not in the position to fund any further flights until 31 March 2012. This benefit will resume with effect 1 April 2012."

The policy of executive benefits allows former presidents and deputy presidents an unlimited number of journeys on scheduled commercial domestic flights.

Yesterday, the offices of both Mbeki and De Klerk confirmed that the former heads of state had received letters notifying them of the temporary cancellation of their benefits, but they refused to elaborate on how this would affect them.

Mbeki's spokesman, Mukoni Ratshitanga, said the development would "obviously impact negatively on the former president's programme, as indeed on other similarly situated officers".

"He has received the letter from the Presidency and so he accepts what the Presidency has got to say. It is not as if he has a choice about it," said Ratshitanga.

De Klerk's personal assistant, Brenda Steyn, confirmed that he received the letter on Wednesday.

Mlambo-Ngcuka's letter, dated November 9, was signed by the secretary of the cabinet on November 14.

Mlambo-Ngcuka is in the UK and is not aware of the cuts.

Nelson Mandela Foundation spokesman Sello Hatang said he was not in a position to comment.

A senior government official yesterday questioned the cuts, describing them as "quite a bizarre situation".

"Was the money exhausted on Zuma and all his wives? The Presidency needs to explain what happened to the budget," said the official. He added that some ex-presidents still did state-related work supported by the allowance.

Presidential spokesman Zanele Mngadi said last night that the cuts had been necessitated by the economic climate and that staff have been told to reduce expenditure.

"The Presidency is also exploring economy class travel for senior managers up to chief director level as part of the cost-saving measures. All units within the Presidency have been informed about cost-cutting measures and they have all accepted what is now called inside the Union Buildings the 'financial diet'.''

She said it was "grossly misleading" to suggest that Zuma's spouses were considered a serious cost factor as the spousal unit was a "very tiny component" of the Presidency and was also participating in the cost-cutting campaign.

In September, Zuma was accompanied to New York by both his wife Thobeka Madiba and fiancee, Bongi Ngema-Zuma, to attend a session of the UN General Assembly.

In March last year it was revealed that taxpayers would spend more than R15-million on supporting Zuma's three wives and some of his 20 children for the 2010-2011 financial year.

The travel cut comes six months after Mbeki was forced to take four different flights to reach war-torn Sudan after charter flights, paid for by the Presidency, were withdrawn.

In February, the Sunday Times revealed that the Presidency was unhappy about Mbeki's travels to Sudan. An internal memo said they were costly, "unsustainable" and "will require some changes".

The government spent more than R20-million on 11 charter flights for Mbeki's Sudan missions between April 2009 and October last year.

To submit comments you must first

Join the discussion & Debate

No more free flights for former presidents

For Commenters Consideration | Please stick to the subject matter

COMMENTS [41]

BornintheRSA

Posted 176 days ago
Avatar
Well, this is reality for the rest of us. When the budget is finished, then we can't spend any more until the next paycheque or new year budget becomes available.
Now parliament needs to address Zuma's ever growing household as well.
Avatar

Truth-Speaker

Posted 176 days ago
LOL, you are right there BORNINTHERSA. They are calling it the "financial diet", perhaps our president should consider "marital diet". The man is old, but yet he is still a PIMP, man I envy his libido. 20 kids? I have 2 and am going out of my mind with expenses, but yet another man has 20. I wish RSA would give us an option of citizens taking the equivalent of their tax money and putting it where they want, I would keep it away from politicians.
Avatar

theBrother

Posted 176 days ago
@Truth Speaker
If the president wants to take another wife, it is fine. There is nothing wrong with an African man to have more than one wife. If he adheres to certain guidelines then it is fine.
Avatar

VNdaba

Posted 176 days ago
1) Although FW was and Apardheid president , he was also unbanned the ANC and called for elections etc . Not to mention that he actually was Vice president in the Gov. of National unity and he continues to be a respected political mind in think-tanks around the globe and an garner accolades for our country in much the same way Mandela does (obviously not much ) ,so he deserves the perk .

2) How is this budget appropriated ? 2m for 11 flights is over R 180 000 per flight ! is that even possible , not forgetting that its still in 1 continent ?

3)Surely any cuts would be based on merit , eg : Mandela's medical visits and general health should outweigh flying a member of an ever expanding first family member from zululand to Joburg for a wedding/get a hug / whatever

4)How are these very different agendas under 1 budget ? Obviously if you are going to buy 2 new jets for the pres & vp you would knowingly exhaust it if its all in one pot !

5) Has it occurred to anybody else as it has to me , that whatever team of fools that is managing this budget is also somehow involved in how the country manages our other tax income !?
Avatar

Nostradamus

Posted 176 days ago
@VNdaba, I think that you overlooked a zero, its actually R20M not R2M!!!
Avatar

Nostradamus

Posted 176 days ago
@theBrother
How can you be so ignorant???? I don't think that anybody has a problem with your polygamist culture or how many wives the President chooses to take, but how do you justify R15M/annum in tax money being allocated for his oversized family which keeps growing. Budgets are being exhausted and the President sets a wonderful example, obviously oblivious, or indifferent to the appropriation of tax payers money.

I984

Posted 176 days ago
Avatar

Isn't the travel allowances fund for FORMER presidents and deputy presidents separate from the fund for the CURRENT ones? And what happened to the budget indeed? Ah, let me guess - classified information...

PRADO

Posted 176 days ago
Avatar
20 mill in 11 flights. How much did it cost Zuma in 1 flight to New York ?
Avatar

amaKK

Posted 176 days ago
The R20m was spent by Mbeki over two years flying to the Sudan, and not Zuma.
Avatar

Nostradamus

Posted 176 days ago
@amaKK, Its is immaterial whom was on the flights. The point that I think @PRADO is trying to illustrate is that if a flight to Sudan cost +-R1.82M on average, how much would a chartered flight to New York cost!
Avatar

PRADO

Posted 176 days ago
amaKKK, I know that the 20 mill was for Mbeki - why are Zuma's flights so much more expensive ?
Avatar

PieterVenter

Posted 174 days ago
Earlier this week it was replied in parliament that the flight waterkloof to new york and back cost R6,3m.......

Mzungu

Posted 176 days ago
Avatar
every day in seffrica is a First of April Fools Day.

fresh jokes every day!!

4 wives, +20 kids, umpteen concubines, what else?

amaKK

Posted 176 days ago
Avatar
Too many misgivings:

- Temporary/fill-in office bearers (Mothantle, Mlambo-Ngcuka and Mbete) should never be permitted to retain full benefits of the office they hold as a stop-gap.

- Why on earth are two of Zuma's spouses taken on the same trip? Did they not say it was one wive per trip?

- It costs us R15m p.a. to maintain the randy one's family?

I work full time and take on occasional extra "piece" jobs to make ends meet and the blerry taxman says I owe him, over and above those hefty monthly deductions to maintain the lifestyle of these folk.

Irks me to no end.

Imbeciles.

Wort

Posted 176 days ago
Avatar
Boo hoo ... no free air-tickets for one whole MONTH! They'll have to dip into their millionaire pensions just like the "ordinary" folk... Sob!

Truth-Speaker

Posted 176 days ago
Avatar
How I miss my real president, Thabo Mbeki, a man with a moral compass. He didn't have one of those scandals that would shame you in taking pride that he was your president. I know you thinking Manto Tshabalala, but Tupac Shakur once said measure a man from start to finish; don't choose an unsavoury part of him and equate it to his work in life. This was a very smart man. Our president is competing with King Mswati when it comes to taking wives, I think Mswati must have complained to the PIMP committee that Zuma was having an unfair competitive advantage over him because of the money and Zuma just gave him R2,4 Billion to stay in the game. Is anybody thinking contradiction, I mean Zuma once preached to the youth that they must stay faithful and yet he has a woman for every weekday. People living in glass houses should never throw stones.

samsam

Posted 176 days ago
Avatar
Look at Thabo Mbeki before being a Pres , money can change a person ja ne
Avatar

Sabz

Posted 176 days ago
.....stress can change someone

Thuka-Thuka

Posted 176 days ago
Avatar
They've all got enough money - they can pay for it themselves.
Avatar

SeanRedmond

Posted 176 days ago
Yes they do. They get 2 million plus a year,each. They should vote for really old guys to be president then they will not have to pay pensions for too long.

SuiGeneris

Posted 176 days ago
Avatar
Perhaps this will prompt zuma to fly around the world while he still can and keep him out of the country until 2012.....

Selftaught

Posted 176 days ago
Avatar
These other presidents (Mbete's, Mlambo, and even Motlante) shouldn't be given the same privilage. They might as well offer Buthelezi for standing in for Pres Mandela back in the day. Or like his friend Juju, are they punishing him for taking shots at the Kingdom? We clearly love our neighbours (Mandela = Lesotho, Namibia incorporation; Mbeki = pro Zim; Msholozi = pro Botswana). What's wrong with this picture? Who cares about us? Darkies are always victims!!!!!

inkunzi

Posted 176 days ago
Avatar
I see no one has any issues with an apartheid president having benefits that are funded with our tax. And fyi, the budget for former state presidents and their deputies is separate from the current president's budget so if it's exhausted, Zuma and his wives have nothing to do with it. What it means is that De klerk and co. are travelling too much and have exhausted their budget for 2011.
Avatar

BootC

Posted 176 days ago
@inkunzi
I do not know how the Pres' office budget is being allocated, but I still think that the current President and his life style is costing us too much as tax payers. If the former presidents i.e. Mandela, De Klerk, Mbeki & their deputies were in one way or another squandering stste funds, it could have been done scretely. But this one he is a liability to me as a taxpayer.
Now proportionality comes to mind. One can suspect JZ has more budget being allocated for him to entertain his big and still increasing family. South Africa, this is not on!

Ozgood

Posted 176 days ago
Avatar
Will this include funeral expenses?

OTTOOTTO

Posted 176 days ago
Avatar
Reprehensible and inexcusable!, it borders on gross mismanagement of the portfolio. It is easy to estimate this budget by the number of trips these esteemed servants of the nation make a month/year and allocating enough to it, when these trips are exhausted they themselves should know _ obviously. But no, some incompetent official just could not wait to embarrass them and our country. Lucky that official doesn't report to me, i would have fired him/her before they could even finish the sentence let alone writing the stupid letters. I would in addition suspend domestic travel for all officials involved in that department so that they can feel what its like to have your wings clipped. I would also serve them with written warnings, and mark this blunder on their performance reports. In any case the former presidents are set for life and its not as if they don't have money to see them over the stupidity of the Presidential staff. They should and can claim those expenses back once the new budget has been approved. Its just plain incompetence and grossly insensitive.

RealAfricanDemocrat

Posted 176 days ago
Avatar
This is totally unacceptable, more evidence that the Zuma presidency is a liability to the state. First we hear that the presidency needs money/cars to transport the president's spouses and they are obviously entitled to some free flights. Then we hear that millions of rands are required to upgrade the president's official residences. And then ofcourse not so long ago, we heard that millions were spent on hiring flights for the president. And now we are told about budget cuts affecting the flights of former presidents. I am again suspicious that this auspicious move has something to do with Mangaung. I hope the ANC will finance President Thabo Mbeki's flights as he has indicated that he will be taking part in centenary celebrations. However, it does appear that Baleka Mbete (people can be unthankful) who seems to be intent on petulantly isolating the former president, was not too pleased when President Mbeki responded to say that he will be in attendance at ANC centenary celebrations. When Baleka Mbete was Speaker of Parliament, she took some time to attend one of Jacob Zuma's trials, but Mbeki was obviously not happy with a Speaker of Parliament showing up at the trial of someone who was facing such serious charges of corruption. Ofcourse Msholozi highly appreciated that and she was subsequently elevated to Chairman of the ANC and also Deputy President of the country.

I think to balance the budget, they must reduce the free flights for the president's spouses and children and also cut wasteful expenditure to upgrade the president's official residences.

Selftaught

Posted 176 days ago
Avatar
@Nkunzi

I totally agree with you. How can offer the Apartheid government anything at all? Stomach chaining! The man lost the presidential race....Darkies!
Avatar

amaKK

Posted 176 days ago
Stomach chaining!
---
Churning???

A little history lesson...guess who was one of the deputy presidents in 1994...until 1996? Yup, that very one. According to the rule book, all presidents and deputy presidents are covered. Hence, even FdK is entitled to the priviledges.

Saif

Posted 176 days ago
Avatar
No story here, they exhausted their own Budget period...! whether on state related trips or personal they should just wait for April, and it has nothing to do with the Zuma's.
Avatar

ooooooooo

Posted 176 days ago
Saif
"The Presidency is currently experiencing serious budgetary constraints and unfortunately the budget that was allocated to you for travel and subsistence has been exhausted. We are therefore not in the position to fund any further flights until 31 March 2012. This benefit will resume with effect 1 April 2012."

Very ambiguous statement indeed. It can literally mean anything. To me it looks like Thabo Mbeki might be the culprit. His continuous flights into Africa as peace broker ( I might add without any success) is costing the tax payers dearly. If the budget has been exhausted it means there is no money left so I agree with you they must wait for the next budget cycle.
Avatar

King_Biko

Posted 176 days ago
Everytime there is a normal day in Africa including here Mbeki is the to be thanked!

King_Biko

Posted 176 days ago
Avatar
Only Mbeki has the real interests of Africans at heart and he should be the only one flying! Those who go abroad to smile and reassure the Queen and her imperialists soldiers that their (read our) money is safe here should not have any business going abroad! If needs be the ANC must pay for Mbeki's trips because he plays a very strategic role in putting the African agenda on the Global table!

Loggenberg

Posted 176 days ago
Avatar
Zuma spent over R6m for one trip to New York. Why can't he share with other comrades?

dougodurban

Posted 176 days ago
Avatar
This is very bad journalism. The headline says one thing, while the truth is something else. These people have not "Lost" their free travel perks, they have had these perks withdrawn for some weeks, a big difference. Get the headline right!

afrocentric

Posted 176 days ago
Avatar
@RealAfricanDemocrat
I think u should just shut up,u don't know what u are talking about.
Avatar

RealAfricanDemocrat

Posted 176 days ago
Oh man, the truth hurts. You cannot argue with the facts. Shame on you for defending the indefensible! You cannot honestly tell me that you are proud of JZee's record.
Avatar

afrocentric

Posted 176 days ago
What facts? I don't see any facts in that hollow comment of yours.

lamelooser

Posted 176 days ago
Avatar
Adding the R15 million allowance for wives and kids together with the generous pay package (more than the Canadian/Indian/Russian... PM's) must make zuma the highest paid presidebt in the world.

bis_k'hallawaya

Posted 176 days ago
Avatar
....The typical members of the African Medal Exchange Club love the jet-set life...after all they can afford it with our money, thank you very much..........Why the prez club members have to travel so much??? Who do they think they are in the world context?????.......What are the benefits so far of all these trips for the country???......Mbeki, the denialist par-excellence, Zimbodia's coolness lover, and his quiet diplomacy........Zuma, the Estates-Man, all the time outside while the fires are burning inside, with international blunders one after another, always supporting publicly the colleague dictators in the other african islands, just to be embarrassed when they are violently deposed.......What the hell are the SA missions and embassies overseas for?......to hire chauffers, preferably with blue lights included and book millionaire hotel suites and business class tickets?????...........

onlythetruthever

Posted 175 days ago
Avatar
This ███████████ is classified. Nothing for ███ ██████ to see here.