Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE &
Business LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
Sat May 26 13:59:39 SAST 2012

'I'm not to blame for blunders'

SIBUSISO NGALWA | 18 December, 2011 02:13
Justice Minister Jeff Radebe says the growing focus on his department is a reflection of its strong leadership Picture: KATHERINE MUICK-MERE

JUSTICE Minister Jeff Radebe has refused to shoulder the blame for the bungling that saw Advocate Willem Heath hired as head of the Special Investigating Unit (SIU) and then resign in disgrace, after making serious allegations about former president Thabo Mbeki.

Heath's resignation has shone the spotlight on Radebe, whose department is blamed for embarrassing President Jacob Zuma after repeated miscalculations have seen some of the government's appointments and decisions successfully challenged.

In an interview with the Sunday Times, Radebe said he was not responsible for hiring Heath despite the latter's controversial relationship with the Kebble family.

The former high court judge worked for the Kebbles and made questionable payments on their behalf using his company's trust account.

"How would you know ... each and everything that people do? This is a former judge of the high court in the Eastern Cape. This is the former head of the SIU ... I'm saying those questions must be directed at him," said Radebe.

He said the fact that Zuma had asked him to investigate Heath's comments - made in an interview with City Press - showed the "seriousness" with which the government viewed what he had said.

Heath had accused Mbeki of orchestrating the rape and corruption charges against Zuma.

Radebe would not say whether Heath had been given an exit package. "That is a matter between him and the SIU. It's a labour issue regulated through the Public Service, so it's between Heath and the SIU."

Radebe was adamant that he was doing a good job and denied giving Zuma bad advice : "I do my job to the best of my ability. It is in the nature of our democracy that decisions, even of ordinary citizens and of government, can be subjected to court challenge and our constitutional democracy entails that the judiciary is the final arbiter ... so it's a reflection of the vibrancy of our constitutional democracy," he said.

But Heath's departure - after only 17 days at the helm of the SIU - was the latest episode in questionable decisions and appointments which have left the government with egg on its face.

The appointment of the controversial Advocate Nomgcobo Jiba as the acting head of the SIU has further raised eyebrows. Radebe defended his department and said the criticism was part of a healthy democracy.

While Mbeki has written to the Presidency demanding that it provide proof of Heath's allegations, Radebe said the matter was now closed. "We have taken action, the matter has ended as far as we are concerned. We were deeply concerned ourselves, that's why we had to have this discussion with Heath which ended in his resignation."

He defended Jiba's appointment saying that it was only temporary and that she was suitable for the position.

Jiba - also the deputy national director of public prosecutions - was previously suspended from the National Prosecuting Authority after allegedly assisting an SAPS investigation into her colleague, senior prosecutor Gerrie Nel.

Nel was leading the investigations into former national police commissioner Jackie Selebi at the time.

Said Radebe: "There is no controversy or cloud hanging over Advocate Jiba's head. There is no issue whatsoever between the NPA and Advocate Jiba ... there was a conclusion of that matter ... she is head of prosecutions in her role as deputy national director, my understanding is that she is working very well with her people there," he said.

Asked why he and not Zuma had announced Jiba's appointment, Radebe said she had been appointed by the president.

Radebe's department has taken flak for the bungling of the extension of former chief justice Sandile Ngcobo's term of office; the appointment of Advocate Menzi Simelane as the national director of public prosecutions, as well as the premature announcement of Judge Willem van der Merwe as the head of the arms deal inquiry.

Radebe would not comment on the Supreme Court of Appeals' ruling that quashed Simelane's appointment . He said the government would challenge the ruling in the Constitutional Court. He added that Judge Van der Merwe had initially agreed to head the arms deal inquiry but had later changed his mind.

He defended the courts, which have been criticised by some ANC leaders as being hostile to the ruling party and its government.

"Our understanding is that the courts are independent, they are subject to the constitution and the law and they take decisions without any fear, favour or prejudice," said Radebe.

He also defended the ANC, saying "it would be wrong to say people should not express themselves".

Radebe said the growing focus on his department was a "reflection of strong leadership being provided".

SHARE YOUR OPINION

If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.

vatiekakie

Posted 160 days ago
Avatar
I guess the devil is responsible, hey Jeff?
Avatar

v_3

Posted 159 days ago
No, it was apartheid's fault.



Eish, the dog eat my report.


No, I was bewitched.

No. It was foreign agents.
No, wait. It was a political conspiracy.
Hang on - I was quoted out context.
Ag. It was Julius.

disillusionedstill

Posted 160 days ago
Avatar
VP Motlanthe is correct when he openly states that many are in it for personal gain.

It brings back the bigger picture of how leadership (both the ANC and DA) has replaced the promise of 1994, the DA with fear and hate, and the ANC with unprecedented largesse.

We need a spring clean.

Maibabo

Posted 159 days ago
Avatar
Justice Minister Radeba is first in line to advise the President, who is not a lawyer, on legal matters.
We have seen a string of bad decisions, with legal implications, starting with the proposals to amend the law to "shoot to kill" and ending with the now internationally infamous Protection of State Information Bill.
Can one really believe that Radebe has had no part to play in all of these bad decisions?
That is in the highest degree improbable.
It has been obvious for a very long time now that the President is very badly advised.
Avatar

RealAfricanDemocrat

Posted 159 days ago
I guess what Jeff is trying to tell us that Jacob Zuma makes his own decisions, does not listen to advice and so Radebe cannot/should not be blamed for his bad decisions. What happens if President Zuma says he wants Mogoeng Mogoeng, Menzi Simelane, Willem Heath etc. All that Jeff can say is that "Msholozi, you know you are going to be critisized for this, but if this is what you want I will stand by you". Or could it also be true that Jeff is actually working for the other camp?

ShLace

Posted 159 days ago
Avatar
Ever since Justice Msimang, Radebe's chief(est) advisor and mentor passed, the Minister has really been left in the ditch regarding decision making. It is clear now how competent our Hon. Minister actually is, and who actually ran the Department.

Well Minister, it does not take too much competence to consult and seek advice from the one and only Judge Sandile Ngcobo. Just do it!