Blade: destroy 'Spear' painting
The final destination of President Jacob Zuma's controversial The Spear portrait is in question following a call by the SA Communist Party for it to remain in South Africa so that it can be destroyed.
Yesterday, Communist Party general secretary Blade Nzimande said the painting by Brett Murray should be destroyed.
But yesterday, lawyers representing the Goodman Gallery reportedly shunned his call and said the defaced painting, which portrays Zuma with his genitals exposed, will be shipped to the German who bought it for R136000.
Speaking to thousands of supporters in front of the gallery yesterday, Nzimande called on the gallery not to sell the painting.
"We are saying, this insulting drawing of the president, we are saying to the Goodman Gallery, 'Don't sell it, it must not leave this country, it must remain here, it must be destroyed once and for good'.
"If we allow this drawing to go to this German person who has bought it, we are actually making our president the second Sarah Baartman.
"So this thing must not be sold, it is not worth anything, it belongs to the museum of shame in this country," he said.
Nzimande was accompanied by ANC heavyweights, including national executive committee members Ngoako Ramatlhodi, Tony Yengeni and secretary-general Gwede Mantashe, ANC Gauteng secretary David Makhura, and Cosatu leaders Sdumo Dlamini and Zwelinzima Vavi.
Yesterday, thousands of ANC supporters marched to the gallery in protest at the displaying of the painting, which they said violated Zuma's dignity.
After two weeks of public exchanges and an emotional court hearing, City Press editor Ferial Haffajee issued a public apology to Zuma's family, and yesterday removed a picture of the portrait from the newspaper's website.
On Monday night, the gallery apologised for displaying the painting after a meeting with Arts and Culture Minister Paul Mashatile.
Shortly after submitting a memorandum of demands, Mantashe told ANC supporters that the gallery's representative had apologised, and had promised to remove the painting from the website "on the spot".
But the gallery's legal representatives said: "The statements made by the ANC spokesman during the march on the Goodman Gallery do not reflect the proposals made by the Goodman Gallery to the ANC in confidential negotiations which did not result in a settlement."
Mantashe later called off the boycott of City Press.
ANC supporters, many of whom were bused in from other provinces, gathered at Zoo Lake, Johannesburg, from the early hours of yesterday, with some displaying placards that read "Naked or not, Zuma for second term".
There was a heavy police presence prior to the march.
Zuma's son, Duduzane, 28, refused to speak to the media before he was whisked away in a black Mercedes Benz.
Emily Tollo, from Brits, in North West, was adamant that Brett Murray did not deserve forgiveness - even if he "repented".
"We're supporting Zuma because he's like our father, and the country's father. The portrait was inappropriate and [Murray] must get on a ship and go back to Europe, or wherever he's from," she said.
Before the march started, a small crowd of ANC supporters burned posters that had been pasted outside the gallery featuring a rhino painted in a style similar to that of The Spear but with the animal's horn replaced by a penis.
Mmapula Fisha, the Film and Publication Board's COO, said the board's classification committee would end its deliberations on the classification of The Spear. - Additional reporting by Sapa






SHARE YOUR OPINION
If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.truthwins
Posted 355 days agoShould there be a change of presidents the Blade will in all probability have to vacate his nice cushy job.
ByronSmit
Posted 355 days agoIn terms of this whole painting debacle, I've come to realise something; no-one I have spoken to about this painting is "against" it. Some don't think its a good painting, some think its crude and disgusting. The general consensus, however, is that it is art (good or bad), makes a point, and not necessarily to everyone's taste. I personally like it.
I see the same vibe from the comments (save for those few individuals who are against it on some moral/ethical/philosophical level). However, it is those few who shout, scream, make a noise, throw threats, and march through the streets. The result? Haffajee makes a formal apology. Artist makes an apology. Gallery takes pictures down. And personally, I haven't spoken to a single person who wanted this outcome. I think we've just let a small group shout loud enough to convince our country they're the majority... Anyone want to march to have those pictures put back up?
mzansi-wanda
On the converse, the people I have spoken to found the painting offensive. By the way, these are, in the main, educated professionals. I guess you are correct that they are a minority.
ByronSmit
SelloMaripane
Romy
newshound
Disgusting!
BlackPride2
Posted 355 days agoByronSmit
Whyetchimp
You have lost perspective completely. The point of contestation is not one or two men's penises, but rather it is the sub-text, the inarticulate that some of us find problematic. It is teh negative profilling of black men that we have a problem with. The sub-text speaks louder than you can imagine, and has a historical narrativity. Please read broadly and stop confining yourself to the apparent to the eye. Your anger in what you have raised makes sense, but it is misplaced. You will need another platform to raise that - instead of conflating issues here. Brett' story is completely diffrent from yours, his, is the negation of blackness which has for years shaped the european idea of a black person.
Whyetchimp
Stirrer
Posted 355 days agoSelloMaripane
RSA.MommaCyndi
Its called 'satire'.
Whyetchimp
RSA.MommaCyndi
Posted 355 days agoBlunt needs to limber up his lips and read a couple of newspapers sometimes. The picture has already been sold and was sold long before all this nonsense started. It is also pretty difficult to destroy a painting that has already been destroyed.
It is, however, heartening that they have to ship their protesters in now. Apart from the government employees (who will support anything for a day off) they seem to need to trawl the whole country to get moegoes to march these days
a_stub_born
Romy
mzansi-wanda
Posted 355 days agoHave you started to renovate residents and infracstructure in general, in previously Black institutions of higher learning?
Have you managed to cap fees at previously White institutions in order to make sure that access to institutions is available to all who meet the necessay admission requirements?
How are the plans of building universities in Mpumalanga and Northern Cape going?
Where the monies given to SITAS well spent? If not have you recovered the wasted expenditure?
I too was affronted by the painting but there more burning issues that need addressing than a painting!
Wiseguy
On the issue of the furore regarding this painting, I have one last comment to make:
Be very very cautious about allowing politicians (any politician) or political organisation to persuade/pressurize/manipulate the people into giving up our hard faught for freedoms !! In this case freedom of expression that is up for debate, next it may/will be another freedom, then another, then another ect ect ect!!
So be careful about being manipulated (by ANYONE) into sacrificing any of our hard faught for freedoms, that are enshrined in our constitution.....because it is not only us but our children and their children who will surely pay the price !
And to those who think/assume I am anti-ANC, you are wrong btw, I am pro-freedom and pro-people and pro-RSA and yes my above comment does include an individuals right to dignity as enshrined in our constitution !
I think it is high time it became compulsory to teach ALL our children about their rights as enshrined in our constitution in all the schools arcoss our wonderful land !
Wiseguy
But I do agree with the rest of your comment and your sentiment!
Whyetchimp
stop being silly, not everything lands itself to 'proof'. the discourse of prrof and eveidence as much as they are useful, have serious limitations.
How do you proof for instance, if someone give you a funny look, or a lustful eye? Sometimes we use teh word 'proof' to negate people's rela experiences.
AnotherTaxPayer
Posted 355 days agoThat painting belongs to it's rightful owner. The deal is done. If he feels so strongly about it he can buy it back from the German owner at probably an inflated price. (worth more with the angry paint on it)
The lesson learned here is that cANCer is more concerned about a painting or a picture than feeding the nation and keeping to their election promises.....
Whyetchimp
Posted 355 days agoGood that the ANC did not succumb to the noise of the minority elites.
KarlMarx1
Posted 355 days agoa_stub_born
Posted 355 days ago"South Africa's Jacob Zuma plays victim over 'genitalia' painting"
These are the headlines from the Globe and Mail from Canada, among others.
But you don't need to be or live overseas to realise the real intention behind this grotesque ANC theatre maneuver for ONE painting.
The whole exhibition "Hail to the Thief" (never more appropriate), uses Soviet era and URSS Communist Party and Russian Imperial symbols to depict the current status of corruption and mismanagement of the ANC and ally parties. The sculpture "Party and the People" says all.
AnotherTaxPayer
Nice try cANCer to have all your rent-A-crowed protesters break down and destroy the gallery while you divert attention to the one painting.
POST94
Posted 355 days agoForward ever, backward never.
a_stub_born
They knew they could not win the battle in court, no matter how many Groot Krokodil tears-from-the-heart were shed.........
Wiseguy
@POST94......I don't think any limitations imposed on the peoples right to freedom of expression(within the confines of our constitution) should/could ever be considered a VICTORY! It can only be a step backwards.....as in PRE94, where peoples freedoms were severely limited as we all know !
SeanKeys
Posted 354 days agoAnthonyHill
Posted 354 days agonewshound
Posted 354 days agoDamage to property according to ANC: by all means, Murray's painting and you are a national HERO. Municipal buildings and windows? Hmmm - NO! We send the police to kill you (Andries Tetane.)
HIGHER education minister.....
Whyetchimp
Posted 354 days agoRomy
I hope that dream is still possible. That painting should never have been allowed to become so divisive.