BEE outfit that plugs gaps in NGOs' funding

22 November 2015 - 02:00 By ANN CROTTY

Just over 10 years ago, Ditikeni scraped together R2.8-million from its cash-strapped shareholders. With that seed capital, it pleaded and cajoled its way into all manner of black empowerment transactions. Ditikeni now not only boasts net asset value of R100-million but is paying out R1.2-million a year in dividends to those same shareholders. Its total distribution to date is R10.5-million, more than three times the original seed capital.This is not your typical rags-to-riches story, nor yet another story of how some slick new fund manager succeeded in riding an investment wave to generate great returns for wealthy shareholders.story_article_left1It's a story of how black economic empowerment regulations have been used to plug critical funding gaps that faced the 18 non-governmental organisations comprising Ditikeni's shareholder base.Much of the traditional funding for NGOs dried up after the elections in 1994. (Funds now tend to be accessible project by project, which leaves nothing for rent, staff, bookkeeping or any of the other critical, ongoing costs faced by NGOs.)The R100-million may not seem a huge amount in the context of the R317-billion worth of value that consultancy Intellidex has estimated has been transferred to black beneficiaries by the top 100 listed companies since 2001. Even compared with the R69-billion (of the R317-billion total) directed to broad-based community schemes, Ditikeni's R100-million share is not a huge amount. But for the two million-plus lives affected by Ditikeni's 18 NGO shareholders, it is an amazing achievement.These two million are some of the country's poorest and most marginalised citizens; they look to the 18 NGOs for the resources to take part in social and economic life.Some seek advice and support for ways to make a living in neglected agricultural areas; some look for training that will provide skills to help them break out of the cycle of poverty, unemployment, violence, abuse and apathy.Among Ditikeni's shareholders are the Trust for Community Outreach and Education, which focuses on rural development, especially smallholders and small farmers grappling with land issues; the Social Change Assistance Trust, a grant-making body that provides support for about 60 rural, community-based development agencies; the Nonceba Family Counselling Centre, which aims to reduce the level of child sexual abuse in Khayelitsha; the Labour Research Service, which provides research and educational support to many of the largest trade unions; and the Black Sash, which runs seven advice offices providing para-legal and counselling services.story_article_right3Ditikeni chairwoman Sahra Ryklief has little truck with the view that NGOs are not critical players in the economy and that BEE should be focused only on creating entrepreneurs. She dismisses the blinkered thinking behind this attitude, which assumes government and business are the only economic actors in a society, the only entities responsible for the provision of goods and services."The Nordic countries are much more advanced in their thinking on this. In those countries there are several layers of entities, in addition to government and business, that are responsible for the provision of goods and services. This helps to ensure people are much more engaged, and society is more equal and less fragile."Ryklief believes a stable society is impossible without such extra layers.Inevitably, Ditikeni's ability to do deals has been affected by perceptions of the government's shifting BEE emphasis. Between 2007 and 2014, there was a swing to broad-based entities such as Ditikeni and away from high-profile individuals. Earlier this year, the controversial clarification issued by the Department of Trade and Industry (later scrapped) marked a significant shift towards the creation of active black shareholders who could build economies.As one commentator noted, this approach, supported by the Black Business Council, regarded broad-based ownership as too passive and dispersed to influence the economy or strategic direction of companies.Ryklief counters that, although broad-based does not involve control, Ditikeni is frequently entitled to appoint a director to its investee companies.As for influencing the economy, she says that helping to empower two million people means Ditikeni's shareholders exert considerable influence on the economy.NGOs are also usually the most cost-effective way of providing services and because their funders are demanding, they have to be able to provide a detailed record of their impact.Ryklief has little doubt the investee companies that have enabled Ditikeni to create R100-million of value are getting big bangs for their bucks.sub_head_start Portfolio built up with luck and hard work sub_head_endSome luck, lots of tenacity, a refusal to accept rejection and, more recently, access to a bit of cash, have enabled a rather desperate bunch of non-governmental organisations to build up an impressive investment portfolio.Currently worth R100-million, the portfolio will help to guarantee the sustainability of the services provided to two million people by the 18 NGOs.Back in the early 2000s, Ditikeni relied largely on the hard work of its investment adviser, Gordon Young, as well as hefty dollops of luck and goodwill to get access to a few of the many BEE deals that were being done at the time. Payback from minute stakes in Stanlib, the Natural Resources Empowerment Fund and J&J helped put Ditikeni in a position to declare a maiden dividend in 2007.story_article_right2As it established a reputation and built up some cash resources, life got a tiny bit easier. There aren't many BBBEE companies with money, says Young. "Having cash gives you some options." The most important of these is restricting the downside risk.While large BEE companies aren't interested in doing small deals, Young says a lot of formerly small- and medium-sized companies have now grown into the BEE space. They have turnover of R35-million and to avoid being penalised must have some black ownership. With debt, Ditikeni can double up on a R2-million to R5-million cash commitment and get a reasonable stake.The restrictions on selling means the two sides to any deal have to be very sure they're right for each other. Young says that, to date, the inevitably lengthy pre-deal negotiations have prevented mismatches.There have been a number of forced sales as a result of large corporate actions such as an investee company being acquired by a third party, which may have its own BEE partner. This has allowed Ditikeni to bank attractive profits and has added to the cash resources accumulated through dividend income.A third of its cash resources are invested in a passive portfolio of JSE-listed companies, providing cash that now allows it to pay its NGO shareholders an annual dividend. ..

There’s never been a more important time to support independent media.

From World War 1 to present-day cosmopolitan South Africa and beyond, the Sunday Times has been a pillar in covering the stories that matter to you.

For just R80 you can become a premium member (digital access) and support a publication that has played an important political and social role in South Africa for over a century of Sundays. You can cancel anytime.

Already subscribed? Sign in below.



Questions or problems? Email helpdesk@timeslive.co.za or call 0860 52 52 00.