SUNDAY TIMES - Movie review: Even the Pope would approve of Scorsese’s ‘Silence’
196.34.62.59
Sunday Times Entertainment By Tymon Smith, 2017-04-21 17:28:43.0

Movie review: Even the Pope would approve of Scorsese’s ‘Silence’

Adam Driver and Andrew Garfield at work deep in Japan.
Image: KERRY BROWN/PARAMOUNT

After the brilliant baroque overload that was 'The Wolf of Wall Street', director Martin Scorsese has changed tack completely with 'Silence', a passion project three decades in the making that directly confronts his career-long obsession with themes of faith, guilt and redemption. 

It's not surprising that he was attracted to Japanese Catholic novelist Shusaka Endo's 1966 book of the same title - after all, the director had planned to become a priest before pursuing his film career.

Set in the 17th century, the story centres on two Portuguese priests - Rodrigues (Andrew Garfield) and Garupe (Adam Driver) - who embark on a foolhardy mission to repressively anti-Christian Japan in order to find out what has happened to their mentor Ferreira (Liam Neeson).

Once there they encounter underground Christian communities desperately in need of their services, and are then captured by Japanese inquisitors who patiently and cunningly work to break down their faith.

There are plenty of nods to Scorsese's cinematic heroes, from the philosophical introspection of Ingmar Bergman, Robert Bresson and Carl Dreyer, to the passions of Pier Paolo Pasolini and the contemplative staging of Akira Kurosawa and Kenji Mizoguchi.

These may give film buffs plenty to nudge each other about, but the film suffers from being too long, sometimes repetitive, and deeply earnest. Still, it presents not only a masterclass in filmmaking but also the closest that Scorsese has come to distilling his complicated relationship to faith and keeping it in spite of the often deafening silence of God.

While Garfield and Driver's wobbly Portuguese accents are initially off-putting, they pull off emotionally sensitive and suitably internally torn performances. They're made to look even better by an excellent group of supporting Japanese actors: Issey Ogata as the chief inquisitor tiptoes expertly between the comic and the menacing, and Yôsuke Kubozuka is pitifully compelling as the repeatedly wretched Judas character Kichijuro.

Slowly and assuredly Scorsese draws the audience into the journey of the priests and the eerily calm violence of the period - but also inside the tortured souls of those faced with making choices that will destroy the basis of their existence.

It's not a hagiography of the heroism of early missionaries, which would ask us to forget the Catholic church's own brutal history of the subjugation of heretics, but neither is it a complete condemnation of the Japanese.

With breathtaking cinematography by Mexican Rodrigo Prieto and a minimalist soundscape, Scorsese shows that he's equally capable in the world of stillness and subdued observation as he is in the madcap visual dazzlings of his gangster films.

WATCH the trailer for Scorsese's latest film, Silence

 

Silence may not be a perfect film but it is one of the best examples of the full range of cinema's potential that you're likely to see for a while.

This time, unlike the furore that saw 1988's The Last Temptation of Christ being protested against by Christians and banned in South Africa, you get the feeling that the Pope will not be displeased.   

WHAT OTHER REVIEWERS SAY

• As visually striking as you might expect, but also overly tidy, clean and decorous, despite its tortured flesh, its mud and its blood. — Manohla Dargis, The NYTimes

• Though undeniably gorgeous, it is punishingly long, frequently boring, and woefully unengaging at critical moments. — Peter Debruge, Variety

• For those not exulted by the inner workings of devotion, it's a slog. — Adam Graham, Detroit New

This article was originally published in The Times.