SUNDAY TIMES - Power Report: how pushy dealers fiddle ghost sales
Sunday Times The Power Report By MEGAN POWER, 2016-02-14 00:02:00.0

Power Report: how pushy dealers fiddle ghost sales

Image: Thinkstock

Every month undisclosed numbers of new cars in South Africa are reported as sold - without having left the showroom floor.

This industry-wide phenomenon happens because of pressure on car dealers to meet monthly sales targets set by car manufacturers. In return for reporting a car as sold - even when it clearly isn't - dealers are rewarded with incentives.

Not only is this practice decidedly dodgy, it messes with consumer rights in a most fundamental way.

Here's how: motor plans for new cars are activated when a sale is reported, starting an immediate countdown.

So by the time a customer drives off in their dream car, it could have lost months of precious motor plan time. Not that the customer is usually any the wiser; at least until it's time for a service, and the disbelieving car owner is asked for payment.

Then begins the painful process of back and forth, with the customer (and equally confused service agents) trying to unravel how and why the car owner has been cheated out of their motor plan.

Fortunately I'm not the only one alarmed by this.

"Consumers generally have to go through a whole process to get their fair due, and it is just plain wrong," said the motor industry ombudsman Johan van Vreden.

"Meetings are being planned to take this matter up at the highest level," he said.

He said in cases of pre-reporting, there should be no argument from the dealer, and a consumer's rights in terms of such motor plans must be honoured.

"Alternatively, consumers must be informed [of shortened motor plans] at the time of purchase and, should they agree to accept this, receive some form of credit up front."

Van Vreden said the phenomenon took place across the industry.

Indeed. Worldwide, cars are prematurely "sold" for the same reason.

Gary McCraw, company secretary of the Retail Motor Industry Organisation and director of the National Automobile Dealers' Association, confirmed that pre-reported sales took place to reach agreed targets, as well as to earn variable incentives.

"As NADA, while we understand that this practice is not only a local phenomenon in the automotive industry, but is a global practice too, it is not a practice that we condone or support by its nature, but do accept as a reality," McCraw said.

He said the time loss on the plan was not normally "more than a few months at most" and consumers buying pre-reported cars "generally enjoy the benefit of reduced pricing or a higher trade-in allowance in lieu".

Dealers were expected to give full disclosure and confirm it in writing when concluding the sale, McCraw said.

But what about the possible skewing of new car sales statistics? Although pre-reported cars are not counted twice, the risk of distortion of monthly figures is surely a real concern? Van Vreden agreed, saying the "potential to influence" sales figures existed.

Not so, said Nico Vermeulen, director of the National Association of Automobile Manufacturers of South Africa. The association releases monthly sales figures, described as "significant barometers of the country's economic activity, consumer trends and general fiscal health". The figures, supplied by manufacturers and importers and analysed by a data company, are published on the Department of Trade and Industry's website on the first working day of every month.

Said Vermeulen: "Rumours about pre-reporting of vehicle sales have been a feature of the automotive industry for decades and whilst, from time to time, there could be some limited instances of pre-reporting, largely as a result of incentive schemes, we need to take account of inherent checks and balances.

"The reporting of new vehicle sales is governed by statistical reporting guidelines which ... require that a sale of a new motor vehicle should be reported when the actual sale has taken place," said Vermeulen.

"Naamsa does not support any form of pre-reporting."

He said an agreement had been signed with the Department of Transport to align the association's database with that of the National Traffic Information System, eNatis, to verify the accuracy of data.

"Where instances of pre-reporting have happened, it has been dealers who pre-reported ... Naamsa has no influence over the activities of dealers."

True. But it has influence over manufacturers, whose incentives are behind the practice. It's no wonder Vermeulen's door is the first on which Van Vreden intends to knock.

Contact Megan Power


Follow Megan on Twitter: @Power_Report

Tune in to PowerFM 98.7's 'Power Breakfast' (DStv audio channel 889) at 8.50am on Monday to hear more from Megan

Please note: Other than in exceptional circumstances, readers sending me complaints must be willing to be identified and photographed.