Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE &
Business LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
Sat May 26 20:52:16 SAST 2012

Winnie star witness against Israeli 'apartheid'

ANNA MAJAVU | 20 July, 2011 00:0840 Comments
Archbishop Desmond Tutu
Archbishop Desmond Tutu
Image by: MIKE HUTCHINGS / REUTERS

Winnie Madikizela-Mandela is to testify at an "international peoples' court" in Cape Town that will decide if Israel is imposing apartheid on Palestinians.

The "Russell Tribunal on Palestine" will be opened by retired archbishop Desmond Tutu in Cape Town in November.

The tribunal has the backing of former intelligence minister Ronnie Kasrils, churches, labour federation Cosatu, former defence minister and former deputy speaker of parliament Nozizwe Madlala-Routledge, and Treatment Action Campaign founder Zackie Achmat.

Two veteran Israeli human rights lawyers, Michael Sfard and Leah Tsemel will also testify, as will international law professor John Dugard, who was the United Nations special rapporteur on human rights in Palestine until recently.

Kasrils joins Nobel peace laureate Mairead Maguire, Spanish Supreme Court judge Jose Antonio Pallin and globally acclaimed author Alice Walker on the jury.

Kasrils said yesterday that the ANC government must follow Cosatu's lead and take "much stronger measures" against Israel.

To submit comments you must first

Join the discussion & Debate

Winnie star witness against Israeli 'apartheid'

For Commenters Consideration | Please stick to the subject matter

COMMENTS [40]

disillusionedstill

Posted 311 days ago
Avatar
Ha!

Ronnie Kasrils would probably have been a cop in Lithuania or Latvia if his forefathers were not forced to flee because of the colour of their religion.

Maybe these guys should rather focus on the mess they have created in SA before trying to be the saviours of a bunch of mainly Jordanian and Syrian (try Hamas rather than Hama for the city's name) refugees?

Maybe Tutu should try his hand at Christianity?
Avatar

AshneSegal

Posted 311 days ago
I agree, Tutu should stick to his ministery, Kasrils should be ashamed of himself and South Africa in general should worry about what is going on their backyard!

snidgeroonieville

Posted 311 days ago
Avatar
Winnie the star witness-hah!She has much experience and her evidence will no doubt convince any jury.We all look forward to this circus-in-the-making.

snidgeroonieville

Posted 311 days ago
Avatar
Any witnesses for the "defence"?
Avatar

disillusionedstill

Posted 311 days ago
God.

PatrickSaunders

Posted 311 days ago
Avatar
Hmmm, accomplice to murder and kidnapping and convicted fraudster. I'm sure her testimony will be believable.

Rightway

Posted 311 days ago
Avatar
While i do not support Zionism i feel this charade is a waste of time. Opinions of those that count have already been made up. What is the point. Embarrass Israel? They can do that on there own. Winnie should go back to confession and make penance for her violent past. This will dilute Tutu,s credibility if he takes sides. He should be neutral if he wants to change people. Like Mbeki and Zuma showing open support for Mugabe and Gaddaffy. Highly embarrassing to be a South African with clue less leaders.

AWA

Posted 311 days ago
Avatar
"International"? Who are they trying to kid.
Sounds like an anti semetic demonstration that will just cause the rest of the world to laugh at SA. And especially with Winnie there. She is no example of integrity to anyone.

Tutu has lost his marbles to become involved in this charade.

Beelzebub

Posted 311 days ago
Avatar
I have been to Israel and I have seen the effects of Israeli occupation on Palestinians. I am not into religion, but I can tell you, whatever GOD those Israeli's subscribe to, they can keep him.

However I don't see the value of having a Winnie Mandela as a witness ... I mean really, she is a murderer damn-it.
Truth be told, COSATU needs to keep out of international politics. What is happening in Palestine is terrible, but we have local concerns to deal with.
Avatar

Aon9

Posted 248 days ago
Are those the effects of Israel or of the typical lawlessness society and lack of human dignity that normally follows an Arab society that is most ruled and intimidated by militant factions?

We are very sorry that you had to witness first hand what its like when militant factions like Hamas attack Israel on a daily basis and are fully aware of the effects it will have on the Palestinian people.

Mercenary

Posted 311 days ago
Avatar
Why are my comments being removed on the timeslive page?Other than telling it like it is my comments are not vulgar or discriminatory...very strange
Avatar

disillusionedstill

Posted 311 days ago
Maybe resubmit your comments?

Mercenary

Posted 311 days ago
Avatar
So again im sure Israel would be able to defend themselves but they are likely to boycott the court just like everything other hearing that doesn't go there way.

Also the current participants are ok but they should look to add a few more internationals from both sides,but yeah whatever the findings i can assure you that no action will be taken other than condemnation of the Israeli genocide and a few unhappy spin doctors from the zionists at the SA Jewish Board
Avatar

disillusionedstill

Posted 311 days ago
A bit of hate speech may be the reason why your comments are removed.

No worries.

The Jews are so accustomed to explicit and implicit hate that they returned to their (yep, it belonged to them in year dot AD when they were booted out) tiny (not much different to the Free State) place in a f*cking oilless desert and hoped that the rest of the world would leave them alone.

Your parents or grandparents probably told the Jews to go back to Plestine - they did!

BokFan

Posted 311 days ago
Avatar
What about Stompie? What about them diamonds? What about her calls for genocide by necklace?

I am sure the Zionists are delighted to have such an upstanding citizen testifying against them.

Cant wait for the cross examination.

Spitfire

Posted 311 days ago
Avatar
The silly, self-righteous, anti-semitic Bishop is at it again. Instead of vilifying people who are under daily attack from Palestinians who have vowed to destroy them, he should rather look at the history of his own sick religion. More people have been murdered in the name of the Bishop's church than in both world wars - yet he still prances around, pontificating on the so-called political sins of others. Given the murderous past of his church, it is evident that he finds himself in good company with Mandela's ex, herself being accused of the murder of a small child. This farcical Kangaroo Court is well described in a book the Bishop may be familiar with - Isaiah 36 v 12 kinda sums it up.
Avatar

disillusionedstill

Posted 311 days ago
Good on you mate.

But the Bishop may need the title of the Book.

Rightway

Posted 311 days ago
Avatar
@disillusionedstill

It was Zionism that caused Jews, mainly from eastern Europe to go to Palestine. As you put it a oil-less desert the size of Kruger. What were they thinking? Oh it was religion. The two do not go together like oil and water do not mix.

Great Britain offered them Uganda and Madagascar as a land for settlement after the war. Imagine if they had gone there with there skills and money. Instead of wasting time in a desert and causing the world endless problems they could have made Uganda or Madagascar prosperous.
Avatar

Aon9

Posted 248 days ago
You keep on referring to the Jewish faith as the main vehicle behind the problems in the middle east. What is so funny and ridiculous about your comment is that Israel's stance against a Palestinian state is purely because of security purposes, of course you wouldn't believe that as people are not accustomed to Jews actually standing up for their own personal well fair, and who could blame you, for nearly 20 centuries Jews knew that their place was to simply allow people trample all over them. Now Jews have developed this sinister attitude that they are a proud nation, that will defend their homeland. Its not only religion that ties us to Israel, its the fact that it has been our historical homeland for the past 40000 years.

Going back to your religion argument, what about Hamas and Hisbulah religious outlook on Jews and the Jewish state. I can assure you that this outlook is what is mostly driving an anti Israel agenda, an Israel that is free of Jews, and preferably a world that is free of Jews. Are these the people that we should negotiate with?

MisterWendal

Posted 311 days ago
Avatar
Desmond Tutu is a fully paid-up human being (not many of those around).
As a Christian man of principle, he is biblically obligated to take a stand against any injustices he perceives. Agreeing or disagreeing with his standpoints should in no way diminish his stature as a pillar of humanity.
True son of the soil!
Avatar

Porco

Posted 311 days ago
A bit of a soiled son if you ask me
Avatar

MisterWendal

Posted 311 days ago
Porco, my opinion of Tutu is based on his lifelong commitment to justice for the opressed.
He doesn't turn a blind eye if his principled stands makes him unpopular to some people.
On what basis do you regard him as soiled?
Avatar

Porco

Posted 311 days ago
He might be a great political hero, and a church leader to boot, but as a christian, I have my doubts
Avatar

Porco

Posted 311 days ago
In Africa among his own people, Tutu is in fact a politician who uses the robes of the clergy as a mere publicity tool, and who pretends a concern for human rights, protesting on behalf of the cause of Palestinian Moslems when in fact he is silent in the face of the genocidal extermination of his fellow Black African Christians by the Moslems from Sudan to Somalia, to Northern Nigeria. Tutu also refuses to hardly utter a word as the Mugabe regime in neighboring Zimbabwe perpetrates a Stalinisesque tyranny right in Tutu’s own backyard in an abuse of human rights and dignity that leaves even the ugly injustices of apartheid wax shallow in comparison. At the same time the ANC government brought to power by Mandela with Tutu’s blessings have seen Black infant mortality skyrocket, Black longevity plummet, and Black unemployment mushroom, and corruption run rife. Not a word from Tutu either when the ANC government declared as a political decision (not a medical or scientific one) that AIDS was a social disease but not a retro viral infection better treated with African potato than anti retro viral drugs – a policy sentencing countless Blacks and their children to death - need I go on?
Avatar

MisterWendal

Posted 311 days ago
One of us is either being fooled by Tutu, or the victim of propaganda!
All my research into Tutu points in the opposite direction to your allegations. Based on this, I find him to be a principled man of God genuinely interested in the well-being of his fellow human beings (especially the oppressed), irrespective of their colour, creed or political persuasion.
Avatar

Gus

Posted 310 days ago
MisterWendal
There is a ton of injustice in SA to be sorted out. He may feel free to vocalize his dislike for atrocities abroad, but unless he first physically tackles the local injustices, this "court" remains a joke. A murderess as a witness...nice! That already promotes this to something below a kangaroo-court. Go ahead and waste money, time and make complete fools of yourselves...please.

Mzungu

Posted 311 days ago
Avatar
"Peoples court" says enough.....set the clock back 100 years....Russian revolution comes to mind.

They should at least bring some real people in there and not those "over-years communists".

as if the world cares about those self proclaimed comedians.

Porco

Posted 311 days ago
Avatar
Getting "winnie the poo" to testify is a bit like asking Mugabe to testify against colonialism - they have both made a monumental stuff up ever since both aphartheid in Sa and colonialism in Zim were abolished. She has no integrity, she is an absolute thug and a bafoon to boot. Why could they not rather get Madiba to testify - oh I know why - he's not an anti semite.

the_original_MommaCyndi

Posted 311 days ago
Avatar
Have any of these people actually been to Gaza, West Bank and Israel?
Its a hell of a complicated problem with all sides just as guilty of wrong.

Maybe if Winnie actually did the job she is paid to do - instead of sticking her nose into something on the other side of the world that has nothing to do with her - SA wouldn't still be in an economic 'apartheid'.
Avatar

buddi

Posted 311 days ago
That unfortunately goes for many of our politicians. They spend more time travelling overseas than trying to solve our own problems. I think the president has spent more time on Qaddafi than his own country!

v_3

Posted 311 days ago
Avatar
Not exactly impartial is it?
Can anyone guess what the pre-determined finding will be? (Hint: "sentence first, evidence later" - said the Red King)

The ANC is busy trying to distract from their corruption, delivery failures and faction-fighting.

Wort

Posted 311 days ago
Avatar
So much for Tutu's undertaking to quit being a rent-a-quote attending every opening of an envelope and to retire from public view! Clearly he has a serious and incurable addiction to attention and self-aggrandisement. This "international peoples' kangaroo court" is as big a sham as the farce known -- in prime Orwellian Newspeak --as the "Truth and Reconciliation Commission".

So Tutu and Winnie and Red Ronnie and every leftie Tom Cobbley and all with mouth hours and hours of their usual formulaic anti-semitic anti-zionist vitriol? What a big fat yawn!
"

JerryYatriq

Posted 310 days ago
Avatar
Well done for the mother of all Stompie Stompers.
Why should Israel be allowed to defend themselves against the nice Jihaddi Human Rights activists such as Hamas, in Gaza, who only wish to bring about the realisation of their "Hamas Covenant", in particular Article Seven thereof which only calls for genocide not only against Israelis, but against all Jews wherever they are?

Ndlwananhle-kayi-1

Posted 310 days ago
Avatar
Its amazing that most comments abt Mama Winnie, have nothing to do with her testifying, but rather abt her past (some of it which were never proven in any court)
Avatar

dwnwitjuju

Posted 310 days ago
What in the hell is she going to testify too?
Does she live in Isreal? NO.
Is she Palestinian? NO.
Is she Jewish? NO.
So what? Please tell me?

Like others have said - SA needs to focus on SA. Winnie is of no consequence to others in the world. Just ask anyone, who is Winnie? Answer: Wasn't she married to Nelson Mandela at some point. (full stop)

MarcusMagnus

Posted 310 days ago
Avatar
Hey Winnie ever think about Stompie or have you for gotten about him

dwnwitjuju

Posted 310 days ago
Avatar
Winnie and "star" should NEVER be used in the same sentence!

weizmann

Posted 310 days ago
Avatar
Whatever the mock court is trying to achieve other than publicity is not going to solicite support for the Palestinian cause. These are the facts:

Israel is an Apartheid state with a bunch of sociopaths running the government and military.
Zionists have hijacked Judaism to further their own agenda. Torah true Jews do not support the zionist cause.
Without the support of the uber strong, politically and financially, American Jewish lobby AIPAC, Zionist Israel would be nothing.
Israel is at war with itself passing draconian laws like the anti-boycott law and anti-free speech laws designed to suppress dissent.

Judging from the comments above, South African Jews have assimilated so well to the caucasian race they have begun to subscribe to their racists undertones. Tutu is beyond reproach and shame on you for denigrating a man of God who has given much of his life to the underprivileged and destitute.

Stop hiding behind the anti-semite card and be honest with yourselves.
Avatar

JerryYatriq

Posted 309 days ago
So, Article Seven of the "Hamas Covenant" does not call fo genocide of all Jews?
(If unsure see avalon dot law dot yale dot edu for the English translation)

Though Hamas did not hijack Islam for their own agenda. The genocidal agenda goes back about fourteen hundred years.

In turn, the good retired Archbishop of branch of Christianity invented by a British monarch for his own ends, has been always forgiving towards the Mother of All Stompie Stompers, but expects the Jews to accept unceasing barrage of deadly Hamas and other Islamist terrorist faction, and if not to offer the other cheek, to offer the other kindergarten or school bus.

Where are the "Human Rights Activists" flotillas protesting the massacres of pro-democracy Syrians?

Where are the flotillas to Famagusta to protest the continuing unlawful Turkish occupation of Northern Cyprus?

What about the slow but continuing genocide of Kurds in Turkey, Iraq and Iran?

What about the daily massacres of Christian Kopts in Egypt?

There is an ongoing genocidal war, disguised as merely criminal activity against Afrikaaner farmers and small holders in this country.

The world seems to happily tolerate all these, while many, including ANC bigots in South Africa seem disappointed whenever the Jews in Israel are able to defend themselves against extermination.
Avatar

Aon9

Posted 246 days ago
The comparison between the Apartheid regime of South Africa and the State of Israel is a false comparison which is criminal in nature. Israel does not have an Apartheid constitution or legislation; in fact Israel celebrates equal rights of all its citizens regardless of nationality, ethnic background or religion. This is a fact, the Old City of Jerusalem is more than equally divided into quadrants that respect, protect and support religious observances of Christians, Muslims and Jews. Arab Israelis receive all our rights and are represented in our parliament.