Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 40855.89
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Top 40 : 3351.01
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Financial 15 : 11688.69
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Industrial 25 : 46366.22
    UNCHANGED0.00%

  • ZAR/USD : 9.5451
    UP 0.29%
    ZAR/GBP : 14.3925
    UP 0.13%
    ZAR/EUR : 12.3241
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.0933
    DOWN -0.18%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.2327
    DOWN -0.37%

  • Gold : 1390.9750
    DOWN -0.04%
    Platinum : 1458.5000
    UP 0.17%
    Silver : 22.4623
    DOWN -0.49%
    Palladium : 738.5000
    UP 0.75%
    Brent Crude Oil : 102.420
    DOWN -0.02%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Fri May 24 04:05:08 SAST 2013

No cash for basic services, R11m for car hire

THANDO MGAGA | 15 June, 2012 00:06
Cooperative governance and traditional affairs MEC Nomusa Dube

A KwaZulu-Natal municipality that was once so cash-strapped that its employees had to bring their own toilet paper to work has spent more than R11-million on luxury car hire over the past five years.

Replying to a parliamentary question from the DA, cooperative governance and traditional affairs MEC Nomusa Dube revealed that the Umgungundlovu district municipality spent ratepayers' money to hire 57 cars, including Mercedes Benzes, 4x4s and single-cab bakkies, from May 2007 to last month.

The municipality has a service level agreement to hire cars from the government garage's G-Fleet.

Most of the hired vehicles are part of the fleet that the municipality uses in providing its core functions of water and sanitation.

DA caucus leader Sizwe Mchunu said Dube's written reply stated that the cars were hired "in case there are problems with the municipal cars and to prevent disruption to service delivery".

"The reply further reveals that the municipality is unable to provide a cost breakdown for car hire during the 2007-2008 and 2008-2009 financial years, allegedly because it did not have an automated system at the time.

"The same reply shows that the mayor [Yusuf Bhamjee] hired four vehicles, including Toyota 4x4s and Mercedes Benz Kompressors, allegedly because both his main and back-up vehicles had gone for servicing and panel beating and he needed to attend imbizos.

"The R11-million could be more as there are no figures for two financial years on hired cars," Mchunu said.

The cars were sometimes hired while the municipality-issued cars were being repaired, Dube said in her reply.

Some of the repairs took up to two months.

Two Mercedes E-class vehicles are used by the mayor and his deputy, Mamfucwana Zungu, and their back-up vehicles include VW Golf 5 GTIs.

The Mercedes have been in use since 2008, when Bhamjee replaced former mayor Bongi Sithole as the municipality slipped into near bankruptcy.

At the time municipal staff complained that there was no money to buy stationery such as paper for printers and photocopiers, and they were forced to bring their own toilet paper to work because the municipality could not afford to provide it.

"It is difficult to comprehend how a municipality that is failing to provide proper service delivery to its people can justify spending this kind of money on car hire," said Mchunu.

"The municipality has a fleet of vehicles which it is supposed to maintain in order to carry out its mandate, which is service to the people."

Mchunu said that it was unacceptable for ratepayers to pick up the exorbitant car-hire tab.

SHARE YOUR OPINION

If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.

SecretVoice

Posted 342 days ago
Avatar
Typical ANC behaviour. The question is what will they do about it. Nothing???
Avatar

BornintheRSA

Posted 342 days ago
More re-enforcement of the selfish, self-entitlement ideology of the cadres.
Avatar

Timbuck9

Posted 342 days ago
Proof that the word PRIORITY, is NOT in the ANC's vocabulary.!!!!!

lmonyai

Posted 342 days ago
Avatar
reactive government will always hear reports of their useless employees on the newspaper..

PRADO

Posted 342 days ago
Avatar
And so the city of Pietermaritzburg rots ...
Avatar

Mahlek'ehlathini

Posted 342 days ago
Don't mean to sound pedantic, but this is a District municipality, one of those Useless Entities...PMB = Msunduzi Municipality, yes yes I know..they are just as useless.

mbongwa_mugabe

Posted 342 days ago
Avatar
This women is still serving as MEC come on ANC you are not failing us but disrespectful.
Avatar

Mahlek'ehlathini

Posted 342 days ago
What do you mean wena Stunxa?

Liberal-Soul

Posted 342 days ago
Avatar
ANC branches should just do the country a BIG FAVOUR and choose another leader that can replace ZUMA.

Really, in 2012, we are still dealing with issues that should have been resolved in 1996. How long should this nation wait for good leadership.

kksonuk

Posted 342 days ago
Avatar
I blame Thetimes for this... Negative journalism. They only report the bad about our democratic government. The ANC is the only ruling party that can lead this nation to the greater heights. Haters must get life and a hiding if they want. There are a lot of good things happening in the municipalities that are not reported. Even the protesters knows that they only come to protest about small things and they don't praise all other things that are good in their communities. For example if people are really hungry, how and where do they get the energy to Toy Toy the whole day and night and be able to run when police fire them with teargas... aaahhhhmmmm. Yawning!!!
Avatar

muk1

Posted 342 days ago
@kksonnum. You are right; bad news sells. So blaming media is not 100% right; society demands negative reporting. The ANC leading to greater hights. hahahaha. Look at the Western Province and see what they have achieved in such a short time. This is because they applied simple business skills and electing people who have skills. In Bronkerspruit (outside Pretoria) a cadre approved funds; but could not read and write. This is what the ANC needs to address fast; put cadres in position; but with the write skills. Where skills are not present; what does the ANC cadre do? He geneally employes a white contractor to do the work. So we land up paying two salaries for the same work. Then to top it all; do you think the cadre learns from the contractor? No, he reads the paper and involves in chit chat. If you think I'm wrong; ask ANY municipal worker about what this.
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 342 days ago
..... so this is okay with you?
Avatar

Fedup

Posted 342 days ago
@ kksonuk

The ANC is the only ruling party that can lead this nation to the greater heights.

Seriously? Your ANC is running SA into the ground. I mean no basic service from the municipality to the people, but the munipality is spending 11m on hired cars. One does not have to be a rocket scientist to see all the corruption, cadre appointments, self-serving attitude of the fat cats, milking of the taxpayers while the majority is living in squalor.
Avatar

Polony_Lips

Posted 342 days ago
@kksonuk.... Sorry you lost me in endless drivel... You use be ANC... when faced with the facts you give 300 pages of useless information to confuse the argument.

Fact is this Sisi has stuffed up.... But she is still in power !

If you truly see the ANC as the only party that can lead this country to greeter nights I say you mist be lemming... Going to greater heights just to run off a cliff !
Avatar

uitlander

Posted 342 days ago
the job description of the press is not praise singer. it is fault finder. BTW I love your "if the peaople are really hungry" argument. priceless. right up there with "you don't need to be a drunkard to own a bottle store."

mbongwa_mugabe

Posted 342 days ago
Avatar
kksonuk
Even the protesters knows that they only come to protest about small things and they don't praise all other things that are good in their communities.
..
I reject your thinking and find it as very unbias, go to uMthatha and tell us why the CBD is like that under ANC rule.
Avatar

Polony_Lips

Posted 342 days ago
Hear Hear.... Well it goes to figure why in Matatiele now has a 46% DA leadership as opposed to 6 % in previous year... You can't lie to people forever
Avatar

TRO

Posted 342 days ago
IF I may ask on what was uMthatha CBD like before 94 is it down graded or the development is moving slow .... Anyway my opinion about uMthatha is that If only the pupuls of that province can bring in the knowledge they have acquired from the other province maybe there will be a fast development there ... You only find that these individuals are pushing the progress of other provinces ...
Avatar

Polony_Lips

Posted 342 days ago
TRO , Im glad u asked !!! As an ex "umtata" ( as it was known then ) inhabitant I can tell u. There was running water throughout the City, the roads had NO potholes. There was NO crime in the city centre and the city was clean. It was a major stop over for people heading to and from KZN and Port St Johns.

Now its a rat infested cesspool of with and crime overrun by bad management and potholes in every road

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 342 days ago
Avatar
"...both his main and back-up vehicles had gone for servicing and panel beating"

How bad is this man's driving and how many times did he need panel beating?

You have to wonder how they are charged with managing an entire municipality when they can't manage to drive without bashing something or re-arrange a vehicle service.
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 342 days ago
Sorry, meant 'how many times did his CAR need panel beating".
Although I suspect there are people in his constituency who would love to panel beat him
Avatar

PRADO

Posted 342 days ago
I think every citizen should get one - a back up vehicle ! JZ is more important, so he is allowed 2 backup vehicles. I am still trying to puzzle out how he would have gotten from one plane to the other if his first plane had problems in an area where he could not land !

Polony_Lips

Posted 342 days ago
Avatar
Ummmm And you can't drive a Toyota Tazz because ????? Why must you have a "luxury" car.
They shut give you a bicycle cause it dud seem you don't know how to drive

BobbyBob

Posted 342 days ago
Avatar
The raiding of municipal coffers for non priority expenditure must stop, before the departments go broke. It would seem that the only solution to waste and graft is to vote the DA in. If that is the case, then so be it.

KafreeMoneykey

Posted 342 days ago
Avatar
I cannot believe there are people who are defending this pathetic behaviour where politicians show disregard to their constituencies and the tax payers through their lack of proper prioritisation. These people are really having a nice time and they are not being held to account!
How can you explain having a car out on a service for 2 months?

@BobbyBob, I will vote the DA in if they agree to revise Section 25 of our constitution, otherwise no thank you *wink*
Avatar

BobbyBob

Posted 342 days ago
I wouldn't want anyone to mess with our constitution. The powers of the state in terms of section 25 are already quite broad. There is really no need to change, but there is a need to implement. There are also massive state landholdings which can be used, but one should be careful that whatever is implemented achieves something worthwhile. You dont for insatance want landgrabs as in Zimbabwe where only mugabe's cronies get land, and the people get nothing... all in the name of equity.

Mike123

Posted 342 days ago
Avatar
What do they need toilet paper for? They could just wipe their butts on a taxpayer.

Patrioticbut

Posted 342 days ago
Avatar
I don't know why all of you complain about the ANC and the presidency... This is normal .....you should be use to it by now.... It doesn't help you venting here or auguing with one another its pointless... Just pay up even if it kills you and move on hey.....Nobody is going to Listen to you...
Regards, Your a small boy / girl you can do nothing....

Polony_Lips

Posted 342 days ago
Avatar
Its quite simple, put these cadres and ministers on minimum wage - coupled with performance evaluation and you will see how quickly things will change

kksonuk

Posted 342 days ago
Avatar
aaahhmmmm Yawn! This time I start by yawning than ending with it. Sorry to those who understood exactly what I wrote. My aim was for you not to get it! LoL! Actually what I was trying to put is: The ANC think exactly the way I wrote it above and nothing else. Remember what the Humprey Memezi man said about his purchase of a painting at McDonald using government credit card: I may quote it incorrectly: "Just a painting! There are millions out there that people are using, also that painting was bought by my staff". The man did not see anything wrong in investigating R7000 when other are squashing millions. Not sure if he meant he himself has misused millions and nobody said anything about it.
The ANC will rule till jesus (sic) comes so they say. But one need to realize how the ANC get votes: "Keep them (voters) uneducated and marginalized their rational thinking by keeping them primitive and ill-informed, mainly be relating all to apartheid and economic imbalance". This strategy has worked and it keeps working. Cna you imagine how easy can I sell my statements abpve to Rural people out there and they buy it. For example, where I come from, they tell elderly people and those young once that if they do not vote ANC their OLD pension grant and children grant will be stopped. The result of that is a 99% vote for ANC.

If you give a child a grant till he is 18 (the year he/she is suppose to finish high school), then the poor (literaly) you person has no goo educational foundation (basically failed matric), and thus out of grant as well because of age.. what do you expect next (because he/she is going to be unemployed in any case)? That child is going to make another child... In fact it will be a bonus if they wait till matric. They will make babies at 17 or so. By the time they get out of School, they already have the grant guaranteed for the next 18 years and the cycle continues! This hurts a lot to this beloved country!
Avatar

Polony_Lips

Posted 342 days ago
klu klux sonuk.... Sorry,

Ummm but the ANC won't rule till Jesus comes... Sadly

In Matatielle DA 47% ANC 23 , Ugie DA 43% ANC 31 and Lady Frere DA 52% ANC 43 up over 75%....

Matjhabeng - Welkom - DA 77.22 % ANC 21.32%

So no.....

I don't think they will rule for much longer, if you carry on stealing and lying, you won't govern

kksonuk

Posted 342 days ago
Avatar
I was just hoping my first post would sound as sarcastic as I thought it is! Maybe am not good at it. LoL!
Avatar

muk1

Posted 342 days ago
@kksonuk. Your comments seem to be a ANC defennder. Maybe use the phase "tongue in cheek" to make it know to us what you feel. I'm glad to hear you've sober and have your wits about you. hahaha

Spitfire

Posted 342 days ago
Avatar
Dube should be charged with criminal negligence and sentenced to jail for a long time.

Loggenberg

Posted 342 days ago
Avatar
The South African public loves the ANC
Avatar

kksonuk

Posted 342 days ago
Because they (SA Public is still living in apartheid era mentality that tells them Mandela is in Jail and black people are suffering because of the white minority RULE! sigh!
Avatar

Polony_Lips

Posted 342 days ago
Hence the "struggle " mentality....