Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 40784.31
    DOWN -0.53%
    Top 40 : 3387.09
    DOWN -0.49%
    Financial 15 : 11117.02
    DOWN -1.12%
    Industrial 25 : 46858.79
    DOWN -0.34%

  • ZAR/USD : 10.1975
    UP 1.98%
    ZAR/GBP : 15.7908
    UP 1.02%
    ZAR/EUR : 13.5568
    UP 1.26%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.1058
    UP 1.00%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.4623
    DOWN -0.28%

  • Gold : 1351.4000
    DOWN -1.22%
    Platinum : 1415.0000
    DOWN -1.67%
    Silver : 21.4065
    DOWN -1.19%
    Palladium : 696.5000
    DOWN -1.49%
    Brent Crude Oil : 105.690
    DOWN -0.41%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Wed Jun 19 23:31:17 SAST 2013

'Teachers should not strike'

THANDO MGAGA | 19 June, 2012 00:02
Membes of SATU protesting for higher wages with one poster threatening: "give us our OSD now or no exams". File photo
Image by: Mlondolzi Mbolo / © Daily Dispatch

The ANC in KwaZulu-Natal is to propose to the ANC at its policy conference next week to classify teaching as an essential service.

Briefing the media in Durban on Monday on the last day of the two-day policy workshop, provincial secretary Sihle Zikalala said teaching was a critical component to South Africa's growth and that it should be protected from industrial action.

"Teaching should be regarded as one of the essential services. Therefore it must be classified as such. So that we address a situation where people strike during critical periods. We believe that education is very important for the future of our country," he said.

Zikalala said that the ANC would engage teacher unions such as the SA Democratic Teachers' Union on the matter. The party is to hold a policy conference next week where a number of policy discussion documents are to be debated.

The policy discussion paper that has taken centre stage is the one on state intervention in the mineral sector, which the ANC Youth League wants implemented.

On the nationalisation of mines, KZN has decided against outright state takeover of the sector.

Zikalala said that, as the ANC enters the first decade of its second century, economic transformation should be high up on the organisation's agenda. "The state, private sector and labour should play a meaningful role. [However] we believe that a classical nationalisation of mines will be expensive.

"It will cost the state about R1-trillion. It will have massive economic consequences for our country, and on top of that the report [on nationalisation] is clear that it will be unconstitutional, unless we say we'll pay."

Zikalala said government should convene a national convention on economic transformation, which must develop binding agreements and programmes on the comprehensive economic transformation for South Africa. "It should be binding on all including the capitalists."

Touching on matters that directly affect the ANC, Zikalala said that in the organisational renewal discussion documents there is a proposal that the disciplinary committee should be composed of people who are not in executive structures or executive committees of the party.

He said that the documents proposes that at national level only the national chairman of the disciplinary committee should be a member of the national executive committee.

"We outrightly reject this proposal as it will undermine the political authority of the leading structures of the ANC."

He added that, NEC members should refrain from giving evidence or making representations against a member charged by the committee.

This would also go for the lower structures of the organisation, he said.

"[We will also propose] that no member of a structure that has evoked disciplinary action against a member of the ANC should be allowed to represent the member who is charged."

He said that the province will also call for lawyers not to be used by charged members in the disciplinary committee proceedings.

Zikalala said the province would propose the banning of songs that profile individuals other than a sitting president or fallen heroes of the organisation.

SHARE YOUR OPINION

If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.

SecretVoice

Posted 365 days ago
Avatar
I agree.
Avatar

BobWakfer

Posted 365 days ago
If there ever was an essential service, particularly in South Africa, teaching and education is it. Teachers should not be allowed to strike. Pay them properly, treat them with respect, but don't allow them to strike.

Let the Union negotiate on their behalf, but if agreement cannot be reached go to mandatory arbitration. Not to a strike.

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 365 days ago
Avatar
The issue is not about striking. The issue is about the violence, frequency and ridiculous reasons for the strikes. Our own Minister of Basic Education threatened the wellbeing of children during her time as head of Satu whilst striking.

If the teachers went out on strike about falling down schools or lack of books then I'd be marching beside them. When they decide to hold our children to ransom for an extra 2% salary and trash the streets, then I want to go postal.

Unions have completely forgotten what they are there for. They have become political pawns with narrow, self centred agendas

Wort

Posted 365 days ago
Avatar
Teachers, individually, are totally powerless in the labour-market. Unlike other professionals they cannot operate alone in private practice. They operate collegially in a school context, as equals, with equal wages. (And they earn paltry wages compared to lawyers, engineers, architects etc.) Individually they are easy to exploit, by spinning the myth that teaching is a "calling", like God mystically and spiritually "calls" priests to serve Him. In fact, teachers are workers -- paid employees like any other. And powerless workers everywhere have a democratic right to gain strength through their collective union -- as it keeps employers honest and afraid of bad consequences for their project if ever they break faith or exploit staff. So the right to unionise and to strike is fundamental to any democracy. "Essential services" MUST mean nothing short of causing immediate and proximate loss of life (e.g. doctors, nurses, firemen, paramedics, policemen) or, at the very extreme, likely to result in catastrophic and irreversable destruction. By no stretch of the imagination do teachers on strike cause these things, so they must be allowed to strike too.

Barring teachers from striking just because it "causes major disruption" is not good enough. It's the thin-end-of-the-wedge in clamping down on any and all other protest on the same pretext that it "causes disruption" as this term is a weasel-word. No marches, no placards, no banners, no leaflets... Just like Mugabe's absolutely-undisrupted yet absolutely-cataclysmic undemocratic Zimbabwe.

Teachers MUST not be denied a right to strike because they can act infinitely more destructively and disruptively when NOT on strike but at work, "working" on a go-slow, a work-to-rule and not doing a thing not explicitly agreed to, item by item, in their written employment contracts. And they can stretch this disruption out for years as they can't have their pay docked as what happens in a strike. When strikers strike, they lose all pay and that concentrates their mind mightily on ending the deadlock very quickly as they all have bills to pay.
Avatar

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 365 days ago
But as part of the ruling class, they earn from both the taxpayers' money, as well as the tuition costs, paid only by those who can afford an honest decent livelihood. The state also pays for the 'free' tuition of the poor, from the same tax paying few.
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 365 days ago
If a person goes into the teaching profession with ZERO love of knowledge and ZERO compassion for children then they have chosen the wrong career path. Go be a receptionist somewhere instead. Any 'teacher' who threatens the wellbeing of a child because they want a 2% increase more than what has been offered should be banned for life from having or teaching or being anywhere near a child.

Teaching is a calling. All career choices are a calling. Not a religious calling but a calling towards what is the natural aptitudes and attitudes of the candidate. You don't get many Cyberphobics going in for computer programming and you shouldn't have anyone who detests children going into teaching

cANCerSurvivor

Posted 365 days ago
Avatar
Teaching used to be a calling. It used to be one of the most noble professions. In Scandinavia, teachers are revered. To be accepted to a teaching college over there is a big achievement. In this manner, their brightest minds are selected to educate and mould their youth. And it should be here to. Its a big responsibility to be entrusted with shaping the young minds of the future. We really really need this.
Avatar

Wort

Posted 365 days ago
A "calling" is carried out by some spiritual being. Priests believe they are "called" into the priesthood or as a missionary by a spritual being called God/Allah/Buddha/Vishnu etc whom they worship.

Teachers are not "called" to their service profession by anything of spiritual origin and some of the best teachers are atheists and agnostics. They merely feel -- as do doctors, engineers lawyers, accountants etc -- that this is a good way to earn a living and that they would be good at and still enjoy doing for the next 40 years.

Teachers are indeed revered and also lucratively paid in Scandinavia. On a par with doctors and lawyers. Highly-educated too, as a Master's degree plus postgrad teaching diploma is the minimum to enter the profession there.

Using the "teachers have a calling" ruse has long been a way of telling teachers that they must be happy with the same achingly small stipends paid to monks and vicars who have genuine spiritual callings and who even swear vows of poverty.

mzansi-wanda

Posted 365 days ago
Avatar
With respect Sihle, your attempt at scoring brownie political points was dismissal. I am not moved.

First institute disciplinary against yourself and most of KZN regions for endorsing Zuma when there was a clear directive against same. Thereafter apologise to Thabo Mbeki for ridiculing him whilst you were Dep Secretary of the YL.

Though belated, rebuke Zuma supporters who wore T-shirts in his support before he was ANC president. Together, with his young clown turned nemesis, Malema havethe honour of having t-shirts bearing their fat cat faces before they were ANC presidents. Lastly, rebuke Zuma for being the first SA president not to attend the Youth Day commemaration.

You guys have turned once a glorious movement into a joke. One cringes whenever you open your fork tongued mouths. Hayi maan, niya khenya!

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 365 days ago
Avatar
Lindi should call Zuma's bluff, and drag his cronies - Blade, Angie, and Motsoaledi, to negotiate with their respective unions, first. No one can negotiate with someone else's employees. Because negotiations are about the employees' worth or value. She cannot tell what value they add to the citizen, and only the responsible departments can.

She can then oversee the administration of such agreements, and incorporate them into the regulations and legislation, based on their soundness. The budget should come from the line departments, and not the Minister responsible for overseeing administration and service.

The Trade Unions' parasitic relationship with the ruling elite, should also come into the negotiating table. They earn the taxpayer's sweat, to enrich the trade union bosses, who are also part of the ruling class. These trade unions also run lucrative BBEEE contracts that get government contracts, in direct conflict of interest, like the e-tolling and the SACTWU corrupt deals. It is the taxpayer who must work his @r$e out for the ruling class elite double-whammy.