Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 41478.39
    DOWN -0.81%
    Top 40 : 3408.65
    DOWN -1.01%
    Financial 15 : 11924.99
    DOWN -0.63%
    Industrial 25 : 47086.91
    DOWN -1.20%

  • ZAR/USD : 9.5149
    DOWN -0.33%
    ZAR/GBP : 14.3571
    DOWN -0.76%
    ZAR/EUR : 12.3017
    DOWN -0.22%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.0924
    DOWN -0.77%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.2787
    DOWN -0.92%

  • Gold : 1386.1100
    UP 0.89%
    Platinum : 1467.5000
    UP 0.72%
    Silver : 22.6351
    UP 0.82%
    Palladium : 749.5000
    UP 1.28%
    Brent Crude Oil : 103.140
    DOWN -0.74%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Wed May 22 11:35:46 SAST 2013

Our councillors are vulnerable - ANC

DOMINIC MAHLANGU | 25 June, 2012 00:04
Gauteng's ANC executive member and chief whip in the legislature, Brian Hlongwa
Image by: Sowetan

Just 18 years into power, ANC representatives in most black townships across the country are being forced to flee their homes as frustrations about a lack of service delivery are vented on them.

In just two years, nine houses belonging to ANC ward councillors have been burnt down in Gauteng alone.

The situation in other provinces is no different.

As the ruling party meets this week to decide on the policy direction the government must take, the ANC in Gauteng will push for a policy that would empower councillors to meet their work obligations.

Speaking to The Times, Gauteng's ANC executive member and chief whip in the legislature, Brian Hlongwa, said a policy shift was needed if the ruling party were to improve service delivery.

Since the beginning of the year, the scale of service-delivery protests has increased, as did the number of councillors' houses that have been attacked.

Hlongwa said this week's policy conference should look intohow public representatives at local level must be safeguarded while increasing service delivery through state support.

"Our councillors are on the face of service-delivery protests. If we lose them, we must forget about improving service delivery," Hlongwa said.

He said the ANC in Gauteng would, among other policy issues, lobby the party' s members to push for greater protection for ward councillors to prevent their properties from being attacked.

According to a number of councillors who spoke to The Times, being a ward councillor was a risk no longer worth taking.

One councillor in Ekurhuleni said he was being pressured by his family to resign his position.

"Every day my wife asks me whether I will be able to protect them the day the community decides to vent its anger on us. It's becoming difficult to assure them that they are safe. Every week you read and see on TV how councillors are losing their houses ... the risk of doing this job is not worth it."

Last year President Jacob Zuma deplored the attacks on councillors but failed to give practical advice on how to avoid them.

Hlongwa said the ANC should take bold decisions, especially when dealing with matters of the legislature.

He said the ANC's policy document on the legislature and governance should also look into the frustrations faced by ward councillors.

Hlongwa said a policy that would provide security for councillors, as was the case for other government leaders, should be looked at.

"When their homes are attacked and burned down, there is no cover for them," Hlongwa said.

In its legislature and governance document, the ANC points out that the extent of community protests suggests weaknesses in its local structures.

The document also blames erratic communication between local representatives and communities as one of the leading causes of protest.

"Though we shout that our government is people-centred, we are, however, failing our ward councillors. They are the first line of defence when people make demands, yet there is minimal support for them.

"As things stand, ward councillors are set up to fail. That is why when there are problems on the ground, they are the first to be attacked."

The ANC is to discuss a number of policy documents at its indaba this week with the hope of making fundamental changes to society. Among those that will attract fierce debate is one on state intervention in the minerals sector.

The ANC Youth League, which has pushed for the Zuma-led government to nationalise mineral resources in the country, will find it difficult to persuade the conference following the rejection of its policy proposals by a number of provinces.

The study, which was commissioned by the ANC, has also dismissed the youth league approach, saying it would cost the economy dearly if implemented unchanged.

Yesterday, Cosatu, one of the ANC's key allies, said the ANC discussion document outlining its "second transition" was littered with contradictions and misconceptions.

Cosatu said the ANC's other discussion documents did not reflect the "notion" of a second transition.

"The 'second transition', therefore, remains an isolated notional idea; it is not elaborated into a concept that defines the parameters and content of the change that it purports to undertake."

It said the document was "littered with denialism" about the damage neo-liberalism had caused to the country since its emancipation from apartheid and colonialism.

"It is incorrect for the document to suggest that the last 18 years was focusing on democratisation and that our focus must now be on social and economic transformation, as if there exists a Chinese Wall that separates politics from economics and social development," Cosatu said. - Additional reporting by Sapa

SHARE YOUR OPINION

If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.

SecretVoice

Posted 331 days ago
Avatar
There is something very wrong with your system if your own voters attack their own so called leaders. When people vote for a party and the party decides who will lead in the council wards you get this ridiculous situation. It is a total distortion of the democratic system and it leads to nepotism,corruption,poor performance and civil disobedience.
Avatar

ILoveTheTruth

Posted 330 days ago
You got it right. With the last local elections, I noticed that the people vote for a party instead of a competent person to manage their wards. There are far more competent people to do the job but they do not belong to the right party. I joined the Cape Party and stood for ward councilor in one of our communities. I was very excited to bring change to the community as you could see that their plight was falling on deaf ears. During our campaign the people were complaining about their DA ward councilor who has not been doing his job. When it came to voting however, they still voted DA. If you go there now, there is no change to their situation. The party do not care, as long as they won the ward. So, I blame the ignorance of the people.
Avatar

Loggenberg

Posted 330 days ago
People scoring own goals are very dangerous. Look at Limpopo.
They will vote for you and then come and attack you if you don't deliver. Watch out for those who do not have a 'viable opposition to vote for."

Theye

Posted 331 days ago
Avatar
Of course now the priority will become security, bodygaurds and high walls for these useless leaders instead of service delivery. Cadre deployment = useless leadership

BornintheRSA

Posted 331 days ago
Avatar
Perhaps these appointed councillors (cadres) should hold their provincial and national leaders to account. After all, that's why they are there. At the same time, I think some of these councillors are doomed to fail - no sooner are minimal services provided to informal settlements and then even more families migrate towards that same settlement, causing a shortage again. Providing special insurance and policies for these councillors is not the solution. Proving proper schools and work opportunities in the rural areas will do better to balance migration and services expectations.

i_stub_born

Posted 331 days ago
Avatar
""""""......... a policy that would empower councillors to meet their work obligations...."""""

sooo...the ANC chosen and elected councillors NEED POWER TO DO THEIR JOBS ???????......HA HA HA.......

Why the hell are they councillors and mayors then???......Just to pick gorgeous salaries and have majority meetings to ideate their increases for "good performance" only ????

As for the "Second Transition" ideated and written (as he claims), by a convict criminal taken to jail on the shoulders of the ANC cadres , and later "liberated" by the Mafia Mother Organisation after a farce period of imprisonment.....He must have inspired himself on Billy Joel's Second Wind lyrics:

""You're having a hard time and lately you don't feel so good
You're getting a bad reputation in your neighborhood""........

Daffy

Posted 331 days ago
Avatar
I blame councillors they are in it for the gravy and have no interest of what happens to the community
Avatar

Timbuck9

Posted 331 days ago
To the ANC it is alot more important to build Soccer Stadiums, than to UPLIFT it's people...

To the ANC it is alot more important to spend money on Toll Gate GANTRIES, than to spend on EDUCATION!!

To the ANC it is far more important to purchase ARMS and AMMUNITION than to UPLIFT the POOR!!!!!!!!

ScarfaceReturns

Posted 331 days ago
Avatar
If you fail to live up to your (in this case peoples) expectations, you do the honourable thing (step down) but unfortunately that doesn't seem to exist in ANC's vocabulary.

InExile

Posted 331 days ago
Avatar
"...Every week you read and see on TV how councillors are losing their houses ... the risk of doing this job is not worth it."
You are misinterpreting the reality: It is the risk of Not doing the job that makes it not worth it. If you do your jobs there will be service delivery.. No Problem!

MsLee

Posted 331 days ago
Avatar
The chickens are coming home to roost ...

Just a point of fact, though, ward councillors are directly elected at ward level; only proportional representation (PR) councillors are 'deployed' to key positions - like those of Mayor and members of the mayoral committees (MMCs). And this applies to all parties, not just the ANC - it's a feature of the proportional representation system. Nevetheless, voters are not involved in any way in the selection of candidates for election, which is done within party structures (again, in all parties), so the only option they have is to vote for a pre-selected candidate from one party or another.

That said, ward councillors have little real power over service delivery, as many municipal-owned entities, like Pikitup and Joburg Water for instance, are 'independent' companies, usually under the management of a deployed cadre.

Municipal complaints systems also aren't 'closed' systems i.e. complaints can be marked as 'resolved' without the original complainant agreeing that the matter is resolved, which effectively means that complaints can simply be ignored for a period of time and then marked as 'resolved' without anything having being done.

Corruption amongst rank and file workers is also a huge problem, with many refusing to address compliants unless they receive some kind of bribe.

Add to that poorly-conceived and badly-managed IT systems, part-time councillors who hold down other jobs or who run their own companies, and deployed mayors who're - at the very least - out of their depth, and it's a recipe for disaster.

In short, instead of pondering ways to protect councillors from enraged communities, perhaps the 'ruling' party needs to acknowledge the fact that we need AN ENTIRELY NEW SYSTEM OF GOVERNMENT, STARTING AT LOCAL LEVEL - and defined ways of measuring councillor performance. We also need to put in place a process that will enable voters to remove underperforming or non-performing councillors from office. As things stand, these people are simply moved around the system, creating chaos wherever they end up.

MsLee

Posted 331 days ago
Avatar
P.S. In the City of Joburg, the City Manager will - as of 1 July - be earning an annual salary package of R3.5 million, compared to the President's annual salary package of R2.4 million. Calls for the Independent Commission for the Remuneration of Public Officials to investigate this have simply been ignored. As a 'deployed' cadre, he is effectively untouchable, regardless of performance. So if anyone wants a clear example of why the current system of local government is failing, this is just one.

kwanda1212

Posted 331 days ago
Avatar
I think Mr Hlongwa is missing agreat opportunity here. He needs to look at the cause not the sysmptom. Address first what is the reason the communites are so bitter and then when you sort that out the security issue will take care of itself. I can sense that you want to suggest another blue light brigade layer for counsillors at our expense. Chill, deliver services and you will be fine. Enjoying your millions by the way?

mcritic

Posted 330 days ago
Avatar
There is no doubt that the Councillors are in fact to blame for service delivery. However, they are not the key deliverers - but it is the municipal employees that should actually do th work. The one thing the latter is good at is striking - work performance is not their field of operaation.

The input by Coiuncillors have more to do with employment of incomptetents than anything else. The norm in appointments is based on racialism, cronism and connection - not on merit. I mention racilaism because I am aware of at least one Municipality where there has been a program to get rid of competent White and Indian staff and replace them on the basis indicated.

Councillors also have other nasty traits - they can include things like employment fees and backhanders. In the case mentioned the incompetent new employees who are advised on improvement label the advice as being against ANC policy or some other issues - not their own incomptetence. If they do wrong - they say that they are protectecting ANC policy.

The whole process seems to be countrywide. Appointment of cronies and destruction of staff infrastructure to ensure that instead of money being spent on community projects - you spend it on looting of resources and appointment of looting friendly contractors.

In the Municipality referred to the situation has deteriorated badly over the past six months and I give it another year before the provincial government would have to intervene to stop the rot.

The syustem in local government has collapsed over the past 18 years and the collapse is getting worse all the time. Cadre deplyment destroyed 90% of them and the result is a totally incompetent set up that would be impossible to reverse.

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 330 days ago
Avatar
I tell you what, get us the safety and security and then the councillors can benefit from that too.

What a bunch of expensive plonkers!