Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 40998.58
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Top 40 : 3361.59
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Financial 15 : 11703.85
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Industrial 25 : 46637.62
    UNCHANGED0.00%

  • ZAR/USD : 9.5763
    UP 0.07%
    ZAR/GBP : 14.4987
    UP 0.23%
    ZAR/EUR : 12.3835
    UP 0.04%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.0947
    UP 0.14%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.2551
    UP 0.14%

  • Gold : 1386.6000
    UP 0.03%
    Platinum : 1452.5000
    UP 0.31%
    Silver : 22.4000
    UP 0.16%
    Palladium : 727.0000
    UP 0.55%
    Brent Crude Oil : 102.640
    UNCHANGED0.00%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Sun May 26 10:33:37 SAST 2013

More woes for Motshekga

NASHIRA DAVIDS | 26 June, 2012 00:10
Basic Education Minister, Angie Motshekga. File photo.
Image by: The Times

Education Minister Angie Motshekga has been denied a third extension for filing her answering affidavits in the Bisho High Court. Non-profit organisations Equal Education and Legal Resources Centre have launched a landmark case to have a minimum norms and standards policy adopted for school infrastructure.

The organisations brought their application against Motshekga, the MECs for education, and Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan in March.

The first part of the case deals with emergency relief for two Eastern Cape schools. According to the Legal Resources Centre, the negotiations to reach a settlement are continuing.

The second focuses on the implementation is of minimum norms and standards for school infrastructure.

Most of the defendants , including Gordhan, have filed replying affidavits in which they say that they will abide by the court's decision, but Motshekga has indicated that she will oppose the action. She will have to justify her opposition to the court.

The Legal Resources Centre's Cameron McConnachie yesterday said that Motshekga had on Monday last week asked for a third extension for filing her answering affidavits, but the centre opposed the application.

"She keeps on postponing and we don't want to jeopardise the case by waiting any longer than necessary. So we went ahead and applied for a court date," said McConnachie.

Equal Education coordinator Doron Isaacs said Motshekga "cannot hold up this case indefinitely".

Court papers filed by the organisations paint a bleak picture of schools around the country. They say that many schools have to make do without proper sanitation, furniture, libraries or laboratories.

The organisations want to discuss short- and long-term interventions and asked the minister to prevent the "complete collapse of the public education system".

On Friday, Motshekga hosted a press conference at which she called for "perspective" on her department after widespread bad publicity.

She was quoted in the Sowetan newspaper as saying that there was "no crisis" in education and that litigation against her department in Limpopo and Eastern Cape was a ploy intended to "sensationalise delicate matters".

The Limpopo and Eastern Cape education departments have been placed under administration.

"I cannot say it is perfect. It is not easy because it is complex and has challenges, but MECs make it manageable," she said.

In response, Equal Education and other civil society organisations wrote an open letter expressing their concerns, which included failure to combat sexual violence at schools, irregularities in the awarding of education departments' tenders, and failure to "revise the national policy on [schoolgirl] pregnancies".

  • Motshekga could not be reached for comment yesterday .

SHARE YOUR OPINION

If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.

Timbuck9

Posted 334 days ago
Avatar
Serious people.... with such an ATROCIOUS TRACK RECORD.... more PROOF that she does not give a stuff about educating the rural masses.... SHE RETAINS HER INNOCENCE and JOB???


Something is ROTTEN in the State of EDUCATION........must be her Bad Breath...
Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 334 days ago
''''''''''must be her Bad Breath...'''''''coming from the vacuum in the skull !!!
Avatar

GregQuinn

Posted 334 days ago
I honestly believe the ANC is killing the education system on purpose.
More uneducated votes, means more easy votes for the ANC.

And if the ANC's plan is to create a civil war and rioting in this country, they are doing bloody well at executing this plan.

It's only a matter of time now before things get out of hand. I do believe they have been tasked to destroy this country. And where this is being driven from I have an idea, but I'm not sure.
Avatar

FreeVoice

Posted 334 days ago
GregQuinn you've got it spot on. They are doing this on purpose...
Avatar

Maxi

Posted 333 days ago
GregQuinn
How would an under performing Minister push South Africans to engage on a civil war? Can you please explain this to me?
Avatar

AfikileSikwebu

Posted 328 days ago
Unfortunately this piece of new, like the rest of the news in South Africa will last for two to three weeks then vanish into thin air. The state of our education in our country as Quinn has put it seems to be a deliberate action to keep our nation uneducated.
Both the Education and Health Dpt in the Eastern Cape are busy crumbling beyond one's imagination and yet the MEC's keep crying 'no crisis'. Just come and stay in the Eastern Cape then you will see the reality of the situation.

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 334 days ago
Avatar
South Africa, alive with possibilities - just not the possibility of being educated or anyone being accountable for their incompetence.

How many more 'lost generations' can our country have before it all goes to hell in a handbasket?

mzansi-wanda

Posted 334 days ago
Avatar
I recall a friend of mine who said the education of the Black child is compromised intentionally by the ruling party so as to keep him at the whims of the ruling party. I disagreed with him vehemently. However, the lastest developments have convinced that there might be truth to his statement.

History will remeber Mme Motshekga as one of the Minister's who failed our people. Ironically, her husband is an avowed intellectual Africanist with a Doctorate in law yet cannot advise her when you are utterly caffing up.

Something is terribly wrong here. People cannot claim igonarance. Hope another class action is brought against the Department of Education. This time from NGO's throughout SA cause our education system is messed up. More so in townships.

mbongwa_mugabe

Posted 334 days ago
Avatar
Why Angie still a minister? How long must we tolarate failures like Mantu.

SoisSo

Posted 334 days ago
Avatar
If Education for the children is a national priority, why do we tolerate those who undermine the right of the children to a quality education? The answer is that what the politicians say as being a national priority is actually true but not in a sense that you and me understand it. Yes it's a priority number one for the ANC to ensure that education becomes so degraded to a level where Universites decide not to take any first years and insist that O and A levels become a entrance qualification instead of Matric. The ANC is succeeding! They have succeeded in dumbing our children, the future adult. Because a thinking person will never vote them clowns for another 5 years. They are creating a society that depends on the government, they are doing a social engineering and they are succeeding!

Stirrer

Posted 334 days ago
Avatar
Manguang is the ANC's primary focus this year, folks!
Under-education of our learners is merely collateral damage to the rush for pole position at the feeding trough.

SoisSo

Posted 334 days ago
Avatar
This year's matric pass rate will soar to 80%. An 'outstanding' success. The pass mark will be lowered to 20%, with just a pass in one subject and the doing away with the HG/SG system has given the education department room to manipulate the quality subtly, I don't care what uMalusi says. It is a shame when kids with 3 or more distinctions can't read a novel out loud without a great struggle.
Avatar

FreeVoice

Posted 334 days ago
SoisSo, you have said it very well. When Gwede Mantashe was interviewed on LNN (etv) last Tuesday and asked what they say concerning the education issue in Limpopo. He replied that the media should also take note that there is water in some rural areas. I kid you not....

The ANC benefits from illiterate masses, so what would be the point of educating them? That's their thinking. Sad state of the nation.

staren

Posted 334 days ago
Avatar
Yet another year with another minister in complete utter denial about the state of education in this country... you would be forgiven for thinking that the ANC actually goes out of its way to maintain the dismal state of education, given the totally useless and incompetent ministers that seem to find their way to the helm...

We have the resources, we have the money and more than enough energy to mobilise the masses against something as trivial as a painting and yet we still have children sitting without text books... so much for priorities ey

i_stub_born

Posted 333 days ago
Avatar
.....and once again in the field of systematic destruction of Education and Health, we appreciate the 'determination, leathership, (self)interest and (no)vision' of Mr Zuma, the Dik Trashy of South Africa so preoccupied in the Second Wind the ANC desperately needs, but gets tornados rather...........

MyraMoses

Posted 333 days ago
Avatar
Anyone who cannot know or understand the value of educating a child has no business serving in this capacity. Some leaders really need a wake up call.
Avatar

Timbuck9

Posted 333 days ago
...Or a bullet up the BUM!

Sta_Brown

Posted 333 days ago
Avatar
@FreeVoice
"SoisSo, you have said it very well. When Gwede Mantashe was interviewed on LNN (etv) last Tuesday and asked what they say concerning the education issue in Limpopo. He replied that the media should also take note that there is water in some rural areas. I kid you not."

When I listen to Gwede I sometime ask myself that dude what are you said, how is that relevant, we all can hear that you are deviating...

Sta_Brown

Posted 333 days ago
Avatar
@FreeVoice
"SoisSo, you have said it very well. When Gwede Mantashe was interviewed on LNN (etv) last Tuesday and asked what they say concerning the education issue in Limpopo. He replied that the media should also take note that there is water in some rural areas. I kid you not."

When I listen to Gwede I sometime ask myself that dude what are you saying, how is that relevant, we all can hear that you are deviating...

Sam-Mokoena

Posted 333 days ago
Avatar
The Minister of Education must have Senior officials that supervise her, therefore its time our ANC take priority to the issue of Education.

There are certain elements within the movement that are not performing their duties and that does not mean the ANC is now at faults moreover these issue should have been address at provincial levels hence now all the work must be done by National Minister.

Without Educated society we are nothing!

My ANC - My Home.
Avatar

Theye

Posted 333 days ago
Without Educated society we are nothing!

My ANC - My Home.

LMAO Ha ha ha man you are so funny. This statement must be the most screwed up statement one can make on an article like this. the article describes how the WHOLE countries education has been destroyed and everyone except the ANC gives a damn. The ANC caused the destruction of the education system not even with the help of apartheid whose Bantu education is now considered superior by ANC stalwarts and you go and say "without education (which the ANC accomplished by destroying the education in this country) we are nothing " and then say My ANC - My home.??????????? Sigh CRY THE BELOVED COUNTRY people like Sam are going to vote for our future!!!! Run for the hills.
Avatar

Real.SA.youth

Posted 333 days ago
We can talk all we want, support wateva party but the real truth of the matter is that non of the politicians are here to help us, its every man for himself god for us all situation.... they dont care about us.
Avatar

Theye

Posted 333 days ago
My ANC - My Home: LMAO!!! Now we know what goes on in YOUR home.
Screwd up Education
Screwed up health service
Corruption
Gangsterism
No services
No flushing toilet

Eish I think if you want respect from others pal I don't think you should compare your home to the ANC
Avatar

DonaldKnight

Posted 331 days ago
HaHa...your home's collapsing around you!

Theye

Posted 333 days ago
Avatar
Sam: You see the problem, you see who caused it and then instead of thinking with your head you think immediatly with your heart and make excuses for the rotting mess that is the ANC's fault. Don't you get it pal??? You look intelligent. Surely you don't miss such an obvious fact???? I understand now why the ANC doesn't give a damn about this country, with fools by the millions who worry more about their presidents pee pee instead of their childrens wellfare they may jusy rule (or dictate) till Jesus returns
Avatar

i_stub_born

Posted 333 days ago
If the Minister does not know what is happening behind her ample back, then she should not say that everything is all right just because all she sees is her back.......That shows only she is not fit to be the General Manager of the Department...........And if she denies the whole affair because she has secondary financial interests, than she is just another crook appointed by the cabal of crooks inside the Mafia Organisation in power........

Sam-Mokoena

Posted 333 days ago
Avatar
The ANC has policies that are transforming education system. Even in HE there are many challenges that needs to be addressed urgently. of-course we can't hide with technicalities however I still strongly believe that ANC has done nothing but few individuals elements that needs to be dealt with accordingly.

Note that the National Education Policy Act of 1996 (NEPA) became effective; and its defines
the powers and duties of the national and provincial education ministries (Carrim
2001:101) thus emphasizing on the role players in all levels.

Furthermore the failing of government doesn't mean it ANC failing noting the composition of state government.
Avatar

Theye

Posted 333 days ago
Furthermore the failing of government doesn't mean it ANC failing noting the composition of state government.

O k good to see that you are not hiding from the fact that the goverment is failing. (That's putting it mildly)The composition of the state goverment is 100% ANC cadre deployment!!!!! So how the heck can you say this is not the ANC's fault> The president and leader of the goverment is the leader of the ANC. The role players at all level in this case the Idiots that were suppossed to ORGANISE the delivery of these books are ANC cadres. The other role players who are not ANC cadres and thus who do not get a say in the running of the education is CIVIL SOCIETY who have taken the Minister to court and won. No place to hide SAM. The ANC is an embarresment to the pride of our Nation.
Avatar

Sam-Mokoena

Posted 333 days ago
According to my understanding yes this department has failed to deliver it mandate more especially in Limpopo and worse for Eastern Cape.

Cadres, the issue that I'm raising is the fact that yes I fully support the Civil Society in taking BE Minister to court and further try to protect the interest of students of this Country and therefore the ANC must harshly deal with all those in power dragging its name in the mud.
Avatar

TheodorTonsing

Posted 333 days ago
What? The most nonsense reply i have ever read.
Avatar

Polony_Lips

Posted 333 days ago
SAM I can see why you are a member of the ANC.... Hreat minds think alike.... If you have no answer, just spin a whole lot of bullmanure and try and confuse the argument... What a load of drivel..... !!

Truth is that this sisi shut run a school tuck shop let alone be minister of education

i_stub_born

Posted 333 days ago
Avatar
""""The ANC has policies that are transforming education system"""........absolutely correct!!....but DUMB to DUMBER is not the way to go !!!!!........

As an example of the way the whole party has "transformed" into a huuge bureaucracy riddled with corruption and mismanagement: The Health Dept in Gauteng, declared in financial chaos, pays 180 deputy directors an equivalent of 90 MILLION BUCKS per year at the Head Office. Let's wait to find out a similar situation in the Education Departments..........

Theye

Posted 333 days ago
Avatar
Wait sorry, there is a place to hide!!!! In the DA. You will get your HOUSE in order very quickly. You will get quality education for your child. Services health and the whole tooty SAM. If your child could suddenly think as an adult for 5 minutes and see the chaos of the ANC and the discipline of the DA and has to make a choice for his future and his childrens future. Even i know an unbiased and un brainwashed mind would immediatly and without hesitation choose the DA. It would be a excellent business decision. no a decision based on.ooooooh my ANC oooooh my home.. That kind of thinking is not intelligent.

Theye

Posted 333 days ago
Avatar
SAM: Action based on informed decisions means reading the article above and all the articles about how the education in this country has become a world joke over the last 10 years and saying enough is enough and taking action which in this case is voting for another party. how do you educate your naughty child?. Do you wait 10 yrs while he wreaks havoc in your house and then STILL be indecisive when all the evidence suggests that the child is past saving and does not want to be disciplined. The ANC is like that they are wreaking havoc on our beloved country and YOU the father with the vote to discipline them fail in your duty to stop the rot