Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 41413.44
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Top 40 : 3353.49
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Financial 15 : 12096.10
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Industrial 25 : 47171.07
    UNCHANGED0.00%

  • ZAR/USD : 9.4046
    UP 0.05%
    ZAR/GBP : 14.2711
    UP 0.34%
    ZAR/EUR : 12.0825
    UP 0.12%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.0911
    UP 0.18%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.1622
    UP 0.28%

  • Gold : 1360.1000
    UP 0.37%
    Platinum : 1455.0000
    UP 0.28%
    Silver : 22.2600
    UP 0.16%
    Palladium : 738.5000
    UP 0.61%
    Brent Crude Oil : 104.640
    UNCHANGED0.00%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Sat May 18 11:11:54 SAST 2013

Textbooks crisis a national shame

SIPHO MASOMBUKA, PERTUNIA RATSATSI and AMUKELANI CHAUKE | 28 June, 2012 00:1343 Comments
ANC Head of Policy Jeff Radebe.
Image by: ELIZABETH SEJAKE

Senior ANC leader Jeff Radebe has admitted that his government's failure to deliver textbooks to Limpopo schools was a national "shame".

Speaking to reporters at the ANC policy conference in Midrand yesterday, Radebe - who is also the party's head of policy - said the deepening textbook crisis had brought more questions than answers.

His comments came as the Department of Basic Educationscrambled to meet a new deadline its officials had agreed on with non-governmental organisation Section 27 to supply all Limpopo schools with textbooks by yesterday.

The NGO had brought a court application against the department over its inability to provide pupils with textbooks. In his judgment, Pretoria High Court Judge Jody Kollapen instructed Minister Angie Motshekga to devise a catch-up plan to remedy her department's failure by June 15.

After it failed to do so, the department and Section 27 agreed on a final delivery date - which was yesterday.

Radebe was speaking as President Jacob Zuma was attempting to convince conference delegates to agree on proposals contained in the ''second transition'' document which, the party says, will help to eradicate poverty, unemployment and inequality in the country.

"A bad thing has happened. Six months into the year, our children are still without textbooks," he said.

"So it is a matter of shame that this has happened."

Radebe, who is also minister of justice and constitutional development, quoting radio reports, said as far as he understood, 95% of textbooks had been delivered.

"To add insult to injury, textbooks are being burned."

Radebe was referring to reports this week that books had been destroyed by the Limpopo provincial department of education. The books included a biography of former president Nelson Mandela and William Shakespeare's Macbeth.

"I do not understand which textbooks can be burned, which textbooks cannot be used and which should be burned," Radebe added.

As he admitted to a "shameful deficiency" on the part of the Department of Basic Education, its officials were working frantically to meet yesterday's deadline.

Hope Mokgatle, the department's spokesman, said 98% of the schools had received their books by 5pm yesterday.

According to Mokgatle, the books were loaded from a depot in Polokwane and taken to district warehouses, from where they were to be distributed to schools.

She said there were no books left in the depot by 5pm.

Mokgatle said the department did not have the "luxury" of time as it had to "ensure that by midnight textbooks have arrived at schools".

"The districts have ensured that principals are ready to receive the textbooks," Mokgatle said.

Education officials have urged pupils to use the winter holiday to catch up with their studies.

The DA's Desiree van der Walt said of a sample of schools monitored in Polokwane and Modimolle alone, at least 40 schools still had not received any books or had received incomplete orders.

Van der Walt said it appeared many of the core textbooks were still outstanding in many of the schools. She said Grade 10 pupils at Kola Leboho Secondary in Blouberg, in the Capricorn district, had received only life sciences and agricultural science textbooks.

To add to the hapless department's woes, nine members of the African Publishers Association have lodged papers in the Pretoria High Court to stop it from distributing textbooks in Limpopo.

The publishers want to interdict the department from selecting textbooks not chosen by the schools, claiming they had lost more than R20-million in printing costs.

Nkhebeleni Phaswana, the association's secretary, said catalogues with various textbooks had been sent to schools by publishers for teachers to select those they wanted - as usual - but the department wanted to find its own books.

"Who is paying for the books that were printed and used for marketing? We do not want compensation, but we want the department to buy books that teachers have selected.

"We have the material - they are there. All other provinces have ordered normally. So, as publishers, we are saying now we are in debt because of the government."

Phaswana said some of the association's members had used their homes as surety.

"We stand to lose our houses and this is something we cannot let go without a challenge."

Association spokesman Sakie Shabangu said: "The administrator intended to order some textbooks without the schools selecting them as agreed. When we objected, the administrator withdrew the orders and claimed he needed further consultation with the department."

Mokgatle said she was unaware of the court case .

She said the department did not rely on teachers to select or recommend textbooks to be ordered.

"We have subject advisers and academics who write textbooks and the department prescribes the books."

To submit comments you must first

Join the discussion & Debate

Textbooks crisis a national shame

For Commenters Consideration | Please stick to the subject matter

COMMENTS [43]

Timbuck9

Posted 324 days ago
Avatar
ANC is a NATIONAL CRISES!!!!!!!!!

Vote these CRIMINALS OUT!!!!!!

Our CHILDREN have "DRAWN THE SHORTEST STRAW".... but who cares.... ?

Cetainly NOT the ANC!!!!
Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 324 days ago
"We are saying, it's very unfortunate," African National Congress spokesman Jackson Mthembu told SAfm.

================
It is also very unfortunate that Angie Motshekga is just as incompetent as the rest of the anc and that she, like most anc cadres, is not even worth a fraction of their over inflated salaries !!
Avatar

FreeVoice

Posted 324 days ago
Well said...

Theye

Posted 324 days ago
Avatar
We have subject advisers and academics who write textbooks and the department prescribes the books."
The publishers want to interdict the department from selecting textbooks not chosen by the schools, claiming they had lost more than R20-million in printing costs.

Besides the obvious fact that the education dept are getting salaries but just not doing the job that they are paid to do, what is very unsettling is the interference by the dept in the books that teachers are choosing yet are being rejected by the dept> Why??? It seems that the dumbing down policy of the ANC has become so deeprooted that the Education dept is so busy in deciding how dumb the pupils should be by choosing their material that they study, that they forgot that to even deliver the books that will make the pupils dumb. Well don't worry ANC , no books means they will be even dumber than you wanted them to be in the first place.
Avatar

Ozgood

Posted 324 days ago
The Nats did this with their Bantu Education - they are just following in the footsteps of their former white masters

Les4uu

Posted 324 days ago
Avatar
So Jeff Radebe you just realise this now..... Oh very Good Morning to you, too little too late because we need action now and nor rhetoric statements.

BornintheRSA

Posted 324 days ago
Avatar
This is a matter in which Zuma as the leader of the ANC should hang his head in shame. If he genuinely feels for the poor, he would be fixing this. All it takes is enthusiastic and disciplined management. There must be many professionals in the education system who could do better than Angie Motshekga and her side-kick.
Avatar

Theye

Posted 324 days ago
They hold up their heads with pride. These fiasco's are planned. It is done on purpose. They have made sure that the limpopo province will be uneducated and dumb for decades to come , dependant on ANC handouts. "You vote ANC or you got nothing coming to you" mass blackmail

Theye

Posted 324 days ago
Avatar
Thats why the ANC hate the Western Cape's DA. The ANC destroyed the Eastern Cape education system but to their horror the citizens of the province moved their children to DA run schools. Education Refugees from Limpopo will soon be streaming to the Rainbow Province, Madiba's dream land, the Western Cape

deebee

Posted 324 days ago
Avatar
Now Radebe can you tell us who is going to be FIRED for this????? I don't give a damn about your mealy mouthed platitudes and bumbling statements - I want blood on the carpets of the Education Department, starting with the callous and inept Minister and every piece of useless trailer trash involved with this scandal.

You want the economy transformed? How? With what education? Your Verwoerdian education Minister is a disgrace. Fire her - she doesn't have the decency to go quietly.

zindela

Posted 324 days ago
Avatar
"To add insult to injury, textbooks are being burned."

...so what is new; the ANC preached their support of such conduct for many years and now, suddenly, it is frowned upon.
Avatar

Ozgood

Posted 324 days ago
Remember their slogan in the early 90s LIBERATION BEFORE EDUCATION

Ozgood

Posted 324 days ago
Avatar
There is more chance of the Pope's converting to Islam than voting out the ANC in the 2014 election!
Avatar

BornintheRSA

Posted 324 days ago
That should not mean we all live with a sub-standard government, poor education and other. If the people can't make the connection of poor schooling to poorly performing ministers, then all other 'transitions' will be fruitless.

nghunghunyane

Posted 324 days ago
Avatar
This is easy they should just fire Angie, so she can go for facial scrubbing and dental reconstructive surgery
Avatar

Francis

Posted 323 days ago
@nghunghunyane

Your education friend was too strongly involved with the communists like 783, yengeni, gordhan, maharadjy, the list in the anc is long. Please know, there is no cure against mongolism.

POST94

Posted 324 days ago
Avatar
Lovely Angie should just RESIGN. It's that simple.

sahomeschoolers

Posted 324 days ago
Avatar
The whole saga seems to be caused by the decision by the national department of eucation to centralise the procurement of textbooks. Read an analysis of this incident on the website of the Associations for Homeschooling. It is just impossible for politicians to run an education system, as the current as well as the previous government has proved. This is why parents are increasingly choosing home education.

deebee

Posted 324 days ago
Avatar
And what is the Spear of the Nation™ doing whilst this is going on? Singing his utterly puerile 'Mshini Wam to an audience of tenderpreneurs, back stabbers, idiotic communists who're living in the past and can't get past their pathetic 1950's slogans and other assorted parasites and clingons. What a collosal t!t.

MsLee

Posted 324 days ago
Avatar
Bottom line, are the people responsible for this fiasco going to be held to account and, at the very least, fired from their jobs. Or are they just going to be 'deployed' elsewhere and given new opportunities to create chaos.
Avatar

DonaldKnight

Posted 323 days ago
The people responsible for this fiasco are the voters...

RogueTrooperv2

Posted 324 days ago
Avatar
The current education crisis is a blight on our nation as a whole. The ANC may be to blame for the collapse but the voting public should bare the blame for giving them the mandate to govern this country. We need to take back our country from these thieving, corrupt, inept fraudsters that pose as politicians but are liars and bigots.
The children of this country are the future of this country and for as long as the ANC continues to lie and steal for their own gain we are on a one way road to a FAILED STATE...we are almost there already!!! The ANC as a whole have no interest in the ordinary man on the street and no interest in the future and sustainability of this country. They are fat cats that need to have the trough ripped out from under them...soon, before they take us all down with them.
The tragedy here is that it's the innocent children that are going to suffer, their parent beloved ANC is failing them outright and ensuring that they follow their parents into a life of poverty and suffering through a lack of education. The worst thing the idiotic ANC delegates did at Polokwane was elect an uneducated and corrupt fraudster to the position of president because it set a precedent! Who needs to be educated when as an uneducated man you can become president of the republic? His lack of education has shown itself in how he handles his personal affair, how he deals with criticism, how easily he is manipulated by those that control his puppet strings and most distressing, how he 'leads' the government. He is an embarrasment and needs to be removed as a matter of urgency before he does something really stupid like hand our future to the up and coming new colonialists, China or worse just allows the current rot to accelorate to the point of us standing on the handout line next to Zimbabwe!!!
I repeat, the children of this country are the FUTURE of this country and as such deserve maximum support from this government...after all this kids are the future taxpayers which means more food for the trough so the ANC best get their sh!t together and make education the No.1 priority.
Lastly, for the current state of affairs in basic education...I think that dear Angie Mothshekga should be arrested and put on trial for gross human rights violations and child abuse for her complete ineptness!!!
Avatar

BornintheRSA

Posted 324 days ago
RogueTrooperv2 - I don't disagree with your sentiment but when the voting time comes, what will the alternative be to the ANC? The ethical and morally strong members of the ANC need to fix the ANC.
Avatar

RogueTrooperv2

Posted 323 days ago
@BornintheRSA...right now, anybody but the ANC because their track record to date is shameful and borderline criminal. Why have the ethically and morally strong members of the ANC still not come to the fore and 'fixed' the ANC? I'll tell you why...the gravy train is still on the tracks and they haven't all had their fill yet!!!

Mike123

Posted 324 days ago
Avatar
Even the NATs used to do a better job of running the schools.
Avatar

AfroTai-CHI

Posted 324 days ago
Probably not a good idea to go there Mike123, as many shortcomings as the ANC has it would be prudent to remember where all the problems it has to deal with stem from. From ill disciplined ill trained government representatives to the sorry state of our education system EVEN NOW can be laid squarely at the feet of dozens of years of neglect on the part of your NATs and others like them.

Perhaps its better try and think of SA as a country which was established in 1994, then you will not fall prey to the snare of thinking about the good old days... they are old days but certainly not good.
Avatar

ILoveTheTruth

Posted 324 days ago
@AfroTai-CHI

I beg to differ with you. Eventhough I grew up during apartheid, life was simpler. The school fees were minimal and eventhough my mother like many others could not afford it, I was not chucked out of school. We received our books like clockwork at the beginning of each year. There were never any hassles. It was a joy to go to school. Parents did not have to worry about the safety of their children as crime was almost non-existant. We had a library in the community which I utilised to the fullest. I borrowed and read about 10 books each month. I matriculated in 1985 with some higher grade subjects. Food prices were affordable, and today we cannot say the same. Eventhough we were poor, we did not complain and enjoyed the little we had. Yes, life was simple and good. I think that today's problems stems mostly from greed. Greed of the politicians, business people and citizens alike. So yeah, I would like to go back to the good old days, as it was simpler, but everyone looked out for each other. You could still borrow a cup of sugar from your neighbour.
Avatar

ILoveTheTruth

Posted 324 days ago
Another thing, how long are you still going to blame the NATS for what is happening today? We have idiots in government, period! If you put the right people in government, life can become easier for everyone. But in this country the people deserve what they get, as they want a corrupt and inept government!
Avatar

i_stub_born

Posted 323 days ago
.....The ANC was supposed to keep the NATS working structures and extend them to the population who was disadvantaged and elevate the level of education of the majority, not to chase away the effective educators and headmasters and staff, etc and to replace them with ignorant, useless and greedy cadres and unions alike........

Same situation with Health............Today, both systems are destroyed. It will take years and years provided that right people is in command to reconstruct efficient structures...........
Avatar

ILoveTheTruth

Posted 323 days ago
One last thing. Maybe we must give another political party a chance to govern. If they fail, we then vote for someone else, and so on. It is just wrong for one party to have it all, as it breeds corruption to the fullest!
Avatar

Mike123

Posted 323 days ago
@AfroTai-CHI: My NATs? I never supported the NATs. In fact, I found them as despicable as I find the ANC today. Nothing more than a bunch of liars and thieves.

Nevertheless, the FACT remains, that even though the apartheid education system was targeted at only benefiting a few, at least those few got a good education. Which can not be said for the total abortion which the education system is today.

It's never a good idea to level the playing field by pulling everything down to the lowest level.

i_stub_born

Posted 324 days ago
Avatar
""" The ethical and morally strong members of the ANC need to fix the ANC.""

......BIIIIIIG QUESTION: Who are they IF ANY????.....and if by any chance there were somebody, how strong can they possibly be???.....The 99,99% of the members seem to be corrupt, thieving, deceiving and conniving one more than the other...... How are these fraudsters going to be plucked out ???...........

mbongwa_mugabe

Posted 324 days ago
Avatar
Our darling anc still allows Angie[the failures] to be part of conference instead of chasing her away to fix the mess and come back only when the problem is sorted out. Another reason for me never vote ANC.
Avatar

Smaiza

Posted 323 days ago
I was reading the comments and I asked myself to many questions, without success of getting answers.

And I asked myself again trying to find solution to the challenge but guess what? The solution was poor planning, organizing and monitoring from all school principals, governing bodies, teachers and the unions. when did they planned to buy the text books? If they plan during the re-opening of schools the failed the pupil not the ANC.


None of you here commentators have the write answer.......This comments are just your opinions not facts. SA did not have better education even in apartheid period. My Parent only knew Afrikaans.

They were bad in Maths, Science, English and other subjects.

I dont know whether, we want Jacob Zuma or Mother Angie to go and plan for this schools, teach this school, become the principals of this schools.

I become confuse and worried everyday when people say our education is in crisis.

This education is everyone crisis (the government, the teachers, the people, the unions, the negative thinkers, the losers, the non voters......all the people of this country who lives in it) finish...stop blaming the ruling party.
Avatar

RogueTrooperv2

Posted 323 days ago
@ Smaiza...matey matey matey, this is the ANC's problem. They are the 'ruling' party and education is a government department and therefore they are 100% responsible and 100% accountable for the sad state that the department is in. They appoint the minister (who is ANC) who in turn appoints MEC's (which are ANC in most if not all ANC) who are ultimately responsible for policy and operation of the department.
So your assertion that the ANC is not responsible for the mess is narrow minded and naive but goes a long way to explaining why the band of thieves collectively known as the ANC is still in power...they have people like you who cannot see them for what they are, unscrupulous immoral corrupt self-enrichers, and continue voting for them!!!

Duzula

Posted 323 days ago
Avatar
For how long must we be played for FOOLS by this ANC Government, don't think I didn't vote for them but i did now i am regretting that i did...
Enough is enough now, how can they just said its a shameful thing that this happen, long way to go
Avatar

Smaiza

Posted 323 days ago
Why we have to blame ANC not people who are tasked to do their jobs. Tell me Duzula, how did ANC failed?
Avatar

RogueTrooperv2

Posted 323 days ago
@Smaiza...if you are asking that question then you do not have the emotional capacity to hear the answer!

muk1

Posted 323 days ago
Avatar
I think Mantu has been reincarnated as Angie. I wonder whether Limpopo's admin woes will be made public? Chaps there is serious, serious corruption and lack of skills issues being revealed by auditors.

mzansi-wanda

Posted 323 days ago
Avatar
The chief reason for dividing the Dept of Education into two (Basic and Higher) was that each Minister will focus solely on their respective sectors to ensure effeciency.

Fast foward 3 years later, tax payers have incurred costs to finance BMW's for Blade, his salary as well as that of his staff. The kids they were suppose to give a descent education are worst off. Universities are still financially excluding poor kids. SETA's are an epic fail at tax payer's expense. Our kids are still being taught under trees without texbook's.

Mme Motshekga nawe Baba Nzimande swallow your pride and scale your egos; apologise to nation and resign. You have failed our people. More so the kids of Limpopo, Eastern Cape and rural areas in other provinces. APOLOGISE AND RESIGN!

ppss

Posted 323 days ago
Avatar
why should the nation be shamed by this? It was caused by the anc and the anc should just come out and admit that it was 100% their fault. oh right, there's an election coming up.
Avatar

RogueTrooperv2

Posted 323 days ago
The nation is shamed by this but no more ashamed of the government they voted for...well here's hoping anyway.

WilhelmSnyman

Posted 322 days ago
Avatar
Is it possible to be so stupid and incompetent, is it humanly possible? The ANC belong in a sanctuary...I'ts inconceivable that nincompoops like these are allowed to be put in charge of a modern economy... It's utterly insane. The Nats were bad, and got their twisted textbooks to school on time. Now when the books "might" be better, even these cannot be delivered. Maybe DHL should run the distribution network, oursource it, and maybe we should just outsource the government to the Germans or the Swiss, or the Swedes, or beg the British to recolonise SA...