Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 41413.44
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Top 40 : 3353.49
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Financial 15 : 12096.10
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Industrial 25 : 47171.07
    UNCHANGED0.00%

  • ZAR/USD : 9.4046
    UP 0.05%
    ZAR/GBP : 14.2711
    UP 0.34%
    ZAR/EUR : 12.0825
    UP 1.94%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.0911
    UP 0.15%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.1670
    UP 0.39%

  • Gold : 1360.1000
    UP 0.37%
    Platinum : 1455.0000
    UP 0.28%
    Silver : 22.2600
    UP 0.16%
    Palladium : 738.5000
    UP 0.61%
    Brent Crude Oil : 104.640
    UNCHANGED0.00%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Sun May 19 19:07:01 SAST 2013

'Army must fight gangs'

DENISE WILLIAMS | 09 July, 2012 00:05
Western Cape premier Helen Zille
Image by: ESA ALEXANDER

Western Cape Premier Helen Zille has yesterday called on the South African National Defence Force to intervene in the recent spate of gang "wars" raging in the province.

This follows another shooting at a funeral over the weekend, in which four men masquerading as mourners shot and wounded two people.

Four women, who fled the scene in a separate car to the attackers, were arrested with two unlicensed firearms in their vehicle.

Zille said yesterday that drug-related gangs were now "beyond the capacity of the South African Police Service to control" and that the army had to be called in for support.

"[The police] need the support of the [army] to restore order," she said.

But she said any army intervention should only be temporary.

"Although we correctly describe the retributive violence between gangs as 'warfare', we are not in a civil war. This means that the role of the army is merely to create the space for the police to do their jobs effectively."

However, Zweli Mnisi, Police Ministry spokesman, said no decision had been made regarding the involvement of the army.

"In the Western Cape, we have one of the most experienced provincial police commissioners in Lieutenant-General [Arno] Lamoer and as police leadership, we remain confident that, together with his team, [Lamoer is] more than capable of tackling crime within the province."

Western Cape police spokesman Warrant Officer November Filander said it was still unknown if the recent shooting - at the funeral of known gang member Peter Meyer in Ottery on the Cape Flats - was gang-related.

The men fled in a taxi but the women were arrested shortly afterwards when they, too, sped away from the cemetery in a black Mercedes-Benz.

Filander said police were not able to stop the taxi but when they stopped the car they found four women and two firearms inside.

The serial number on one of the guns had been filed off and the other one had been reported stolen in nearby Grassy Park.

The women were expected to appear in the Wynberg Magistrate's Court today. The condition of the wounded - a 65-year-old woman from Mowbray and a 21-year-old man from Kraaifontein - was not immediately known.

Zille said more than 130 gangs with a collective membership of approximately 100000 existed in the poorest communities of the Western Cape.

She added that tik has intensified the extent of gangsterism in the province.

SHARE YOUR OPINION

If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 314 days ago
Avatar
Sending the army in on your own people is a drastic measure. I hope they have thought this through. Especially with our history, the army going in is not something that should be done unless all other avenues have been exhausted,
Avatar

AFRICAis60%MUSLIM

Posted 314 days ago
"Sending the army in on your own people is a drastic measure"

This is one avenue that was supposed to be exhausted years ago. The last resort is to assign a Specialised Gangs Unit, which will come highly recommended in gang-crime-ridden areas. The police have so much to do, the army should consider this request by the premier.
Avatar

Romy

Posted 314 days ago
Calling in the army is the absolute last resort because the calls for the reinstatement of the SAPS Specialized Gangs & Drugs Unit have fallen on deaf ears. Helen Zille, Dan Plato as well as General Arno Lamoer have all called for the reinstatement of the Unit as a matter of urgency but their calls have been stonewalled by Minister Nathi Mthethwa who is against it, the same way he was against the setting up of a Commission of Enquiry into vigilantism in Khayelitsha. Even Trevor Manuel in his National Planning report has supported the call for the reinstatement of the specialized policing unit because it is the most effective strategy to combat the scourge of gangsterism and drugs in the WC. General Lamoer said "the violent crime and the gangsterism in the WC are all linked to one thing: drugs. If we can stop the drugs, crime will come down radically, and people will be safer". The socio-economic causes of the related problems of gangsterism and drugs also needs to be tackled, which is another story altogether. Essentially it comes down to the family unit, responsible parenting, the presence of a 'father' figure who is not violent, the problem of unwanted pregnancies, lack of adequate education and employment opportunities for young people, poverty alleviation. All these issues need to be look at, as well as the involvement of the affected communities.
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 314 days ago
Romy

Putting all the blame on bad parenting is not fair. Unless you have knowledge of these areas, it is very hard to understand the pressures these kids are under. There is no police service. These kids either become a member of one of these gangs or they are at the mercy of all of them - at least in a gang there is some form of protection. Kids from good families sometimes get out as they have the support but even they struggle to get free once they are in the grip of these gangs.

It is also difficult for good parents as this is the 'norm' outside. It is difficult enough to keep a teenage kid on the straight and narrow without living in an area where human life is worthless and what people want, they just take - be that cars, sex or someone's tekkies.
Avatar

Romy

Posted 314 days ago
No, MommaCyndi. I'm not blaming it all on bad parenting. I'm just saying that it won't help just to treat the symptoms (drug-abuse, gangsterism, crime) without also treating the causes (poor socio-economic conditions) as well. The two must go together or we will never get rid of the problem (if we ever can eradicate it completely). I agree that wealthy parents can afford to send their problem children to drug rehab centres or pay for psychologists, but the children from dysfunctional families and impoverished social conditions are more vulnerable and at risk. In my opinion we need more support structures for these families such as aftercare facilities, safe-houses, sports facilities and other activities for the youth to keep them busy and away from temptation, better education and employment opportunities, etc. as well as more social workers in the communities. The entire community should be involved if they want to see change. That should go hand-in-hand with an effective criminal justice system to eradicate the associated crime and provide protection because no intervention can work in isolation.
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 314 days ago
During my misspent youth, we used to often go jolling in Eesterust (still do on rare occasions). Come about half 12 or 1am, the mothers used to come out with brooms, mops, etc and chase us all because "julle raas maar net mekaar". We'd all laugh, dodge the good natured swats and either go home or dial the party down to ultra mellow. Now days, if they tried that, some little snot would haul out a gat and shoot them. Its not so easy.

A year ago, a good friend of my daughter's was shot, in broad daylight, in his driveway for daring to ask a bunch of youngsters if they could move their car so he could get his car out. That is the level this has got to. A few houses down, an old lady was shot for asking them to turn down their sound system as she had just got her baby grandson to sleep. The cops still haven't arrested them.

mzansi-wanda

Posted 314 days ago
Avatar
"Sending the army in on your OWN people is a drastic measure". Indeed it is.

Whenever I LovetheTruth laments how the coloured community have been let down in the Western Cape he is berated as being "emotional" "angry" and so forth.

I am from Gauteng and I always feel unwelcomed in Cape Town. More so in affluent suburbs. This approach by the Western Cape government doesn't suprise me at all.

That said, I will support an army intervention in Hillbrow, Berea and Yeoville to rid these once beautiful places of crime and drugs. I don't know whether I am being paranoid but I feel as if these places are a ticking time bomb waiting ti explode in our economic hub.
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 314 days ago
I'm also a Vaalie and feel very unwelcome in Cape Town, so don't feel special. It is just how they roll. A more unfriendly city is hard to imagine.

The poor coloured community is always left with the smelly end of the stick. First they were not white enough and now they are not black enough. Even here in Pretoria, they are treated like poor relations who are not worthy of bothering about. It breaks my heart.
Avatar

Romy

Posted 314 days ago
"This approach by the Western Cape Government" has let down the coloured community? Really? The S A Police Service is not under the control of the WC Government. As Minister Nathi Mthethwa keeps on pointing out, it is the responsibility of National Government. The WC Government did in fact propose a Western Cape Safety Bill, the purpose of which would be to improve policing and allow the Provincial Government to determine the policing needs and priorities in the Western Cape. It would grant the Province powers to monitor the police, foster co-operation between the police and communities, and also provide for the appointment of a provincial police ombudsman. Minister Mthethwa told the WC Minister for Safety & Security, Dan Plato, that he would challenge the proposed Bill. Mthethwa is also against the reinstatement of the Specialized Gangs & Drugs Unit, which was very effective in the past. So what more do you think the WC Government can do, considering they have no control over the Police force or the Defence force?
Avatar

Romy

Posted 314 days ago
It is ironic that the only 'Specialized Police Unit' to survive the ANC Government is the 'VIP Protection Unit'...that says much about the hypocrisy of their arguments against other Specialized Units!
Avatar

ILoveTheTruth

Posted 314 days ago
@mzansi-wanda,

"Whenever I LovetheTruth laments how the coloured community have been let down in the Western Cape he is berated as being "emotional" "angry" and so forth. "

Now we know, that I'm not emotional and angry, but only speaking the truth, as my handle suggests. I am aware that people normally attacks your sanity or person if they want to deflect the truth. Thanks for understanding.

@Momma, I can guarantee you that I am not one of those people. There is a "trust" problem in the WC, and this is something I experience daily, especially on the roads. People have lost respect and tolerance for one another. They do not realise that their ill-deeds give the region a bad name and them an early ulcer.

@Romy,

"The S A Police Service is not under the control of the WC Government."

What is the use of a WC government then if they cannot fight the scourge of crime effectively? I believe the problem sits with both the DA and ANC regarding this matter. Blaming it on each other is not going to solve the issue at hand. The DA being the WC government of the day, must then come up with a solution. This is what makes real leadership, finding solutions, not blaming.

Avatar

Romy

Posted 314 days ago
@ ILovetheTruth.

This is an issue I care deeply about because I have lost two members of my extended family through drug-related deaths (suicide and overdose) and I detest drug dealers with a passion. I agree that this is a problem that needs to be tackled by both the DA and the ANC working together. However, the DA can only act within the confines of the law and the Constitution, and I believe that they are doing the best they can considering that the Constitution empowers them to do very little when it comes to policing and nothing at all when it comes to the Defence Force, the prosecution services and the rest of the criminal justice system. An integrated approach is definitely needed, but that is difficult when the National Minister of Police seeks to prevent and impede every crime fighting initiative proposed by the WC Government, who are working together with Neighbourhood Watches, Community Police Forums, NGOs, as well as members of the communities who are activists. Patricia De Lille has started her anti-drug awareness campaign targeting the youth. The WC Government has also opened their 'Mass Opportunity and Development Centres' which operate at various schools in poor communities after school hours and are designed to keep children off the streets, out of the hands of drug dealers, and engaged in productive activities before their parents return home from work. That is only a couple of examples of what they are doing, but they need the support of an effective criminal justice system.

Stirrer

Posted 314 days ago
Avatar
Desperate times calls for desperate measures! And for families affected by this gang scourge, all avenues should be explored and exhausted to bring normality to their residential areas.
No doubt the ANC will strongly oppose this logical intervention proposal - not because it is bad, but because it is proposed by the DA!

muk1

Posted 314 days ago
Avatar
I am all for trying new methods to combat gangsterism in the Cape; including sending in the army. Will sending in the army help? I think not. Gangs are so much a social issue that is prevailent in poorer communities. Jobs, jobs, jobs, education, education education are the long term solution.
Avatar

Romy

Posted 314 days ago
You are right. The army does not have the same powers as the police service, and can only help to calm the situation temporarily. This is such a complex problem, and the root socio-economic causes need to be tackled for a long term solution. People in the community know who the gangsters and drug lords are but they are too frightened to stand up and testify in court. That is why so many arrests do not lead to convictions. These criminals also provide financial support to the communities, and there is the further problem of corrupt policemen on the payroll of these criminals. It is a vicious cycle.
Avatar

ILoveTheTruth

Posted 314 days ago
The army is a definite no-no. This will open up a whole new can of worms. There is enough police to deal with the matter. The problem is the political will of the "leaders". What always amazes me, is the amount of police you see at big sports events, re: Worldcup 2010 or public marches, but you never see them in the event of a problem such as this. I smell a dead rat somewhere.

Yes, gangs are a social issue, but we all know who the engineers were and still are to this day.

Yesterday, I watched a video of David Icke(youtube). Did you know that 80% of the wealth and power of this country still belongs to the same handful of people, as pre-1994? Makes you think doesn't it?

Sta_Brown

Posted 314 days ago
Avatar
But again coloureds must also stop with this behaviour of fighting and killing amongst their own people. that's not the way to be noticed. They must rather unite and prove everybody wrong.

I wonder if this killing was in the ANC dominated province what would media and blogers would have said about the ANC and the Government.
Avatar

muk1

Posted 314 days ago
@sta_brown. You mean well; but you talk about us and them. The same problem rears its head as theft in Gauteng. Once you are in the getto it is very difficult to escape from there. The only was out is to give people their dignity; by providing jobs. Last time the people did something was the formation of Pagad. Do you want to go down this route of vigilantism? No; since violence begets violence.
Avatar

ILoveTheTruth

Posted 314 days ago
At the moment, the coloured people do not have leaders with backbones, who can unite the people. But the real issue is in uniting all races, as this would make for a better country. From your words it is obvious that this is going to be a difficult task, as you are referring to coloureds , as "They", which means you see yourself as different and superior. Maybe sometime in the future we can refer to all South Africans, as "Us".

UDFSupporter

Posted 314 days ago
Avatar
Watch Messrs. Fransman and Ehrenreich encourage the DA to call out the army and then wait for the resulting violence. Comrade Tony will then mobilise all the people in the squatter camps and mount a messy campaign against the heartless DA and their blood-thirsty army. Watch as buses are again filled with fresh refugees from the Paradise of the Eastern Cape to swell Comrade Tony's troops.
Avatar

Romy

Posted 314 days ago
It is the affected communities who have asked for a state of emergency to be declared and the army to be brought in. Helen Zille is supporting that call because the situation is out of hand, and there is little the WC Government can do without the co-operation of National Government. If Fransman et al try to interfere it may backfire on them because people have had enough.

ILoveTheTruth

Posted 314 days ago
Avatar
Gute Morgen folks. Hope you are all doing well. It is another cold day here in Cape Town, Brrrrr!

Yesterday I browsed an article in a newspaper about a (white)youngster in his 20's that overdosed on heroine. His friends said that they normally buy drugs in Voortrekker Road from Nigerians, Somalians, Moroccans, etc.

Three-fold point here. First point is that drugs is a multi-racial problem in the WC, so all communities must step forward to solve this.

Second point, pre-1994 the WC had problems with drugs, but it was nowhere as bad as today. The problem is directly related to the influx of foreigners to our shores. Everywhere you look these people have setup shops in poor communities. They treat the people "poorly", as I have seen with my own eyes, and act as if they have more rights than the people of Cape Town. I also believe that they use these shops as fronts for their drug trade. So, if Helen Zille really wants to help the communities of Cape Town, start here. If you don't believe me, ask the people, as it is common knowledge who the major suppliers of drugs in these communities are.

Third point, I am not sure that our "leaders" are serious about eradicating the drug scourge. As with poor education, poor services in general, this problem works in their favour, as it keeps them in control. Every week you read about police confiscating drugs and arresting some "small fish". etc. Does that ever solve the problem? No! Where are the "big fish" then? I am sure that most of us know where they are hiding. They are hiding in plain sight! They are the "friends" of highly placed officials in this country and the world.

These people prey on fear and as long as the people live in fear, they will win. We have to start speaking up and forcing the truth out of government. We have given them too much power already, that it has become a dictatorship.

Remember, so-called freedom is not really freedom, but only a way of giving the illusion of freedom, so that people do not fight back.

As for the army, I have said it before, the outside enemy is an illusion(made up), the real enemy is within(the people), and sending in the army on the people, proofs this on a daily basis, as can be seen worldwide. We are mere pawns in the game of the Aristocrats(previously Babylonians) to control the world. I'll say it again, we have to take back the power from them and give it back to the ordinary person, as we are the majority.