Madiba 'betrayed'
Image by: MIKE HUTCHINGS / REUTERS
As birthday wishes for the world's most famous statesman reverberated across the globe, his former wife, Winnie Madikizela-Mandela, and Archbishop Emeritus Desmond Tutu, lashed out at the government for failing its citizens.
In their birthday messages to Nelson Mandela - who celebrated his 94th birthday yesterday - the two struggle veterans said South Africa's leaders and the ANC had forgotten the former president's legacy and the party's role in improving people's lives .
Madikizela-Mandela - who in a letter last week accused the ANC of subjecting the Mandela family to "shabby treatment", and of abusing the Mandela name - said yesterday: "Our country is in deep trouble as we make promises and the promises are not fulfilled."
Speaking at the opening of an additional building at an orphanage in Ngqeleni, in Eastern Cape, Madikizela-Mandela warned the ANC of the effects its failures had on those who voted the party into power.
"These children are lucky that we [the Mandela family] made promises and these promises have been fulfilled. We see our people today in the streets demonstrating against us. It's one of the most painful things to observe that, 18 years down the line, we still have people who say we have failed them."
Madikizela-Mandela said it was "tragic" that Mandela was celebrating his birthday during a period of instability in the ANC.
Warning that the party was in "deep trouble", she told the SABC: "We cannot pretend all is well in the ANC.
"According to the secretary-general of the ANC, [Gwede] Mantashe, the ANC is imploding, and that is not the ANC that he [Mandela] gave his life for and that is not the ANC we all wanted it to be - especially on his birthday."
She said the country's leaders should not forget the meaning behind Mandela's birthday celebrations because his legacy was everlasting and intended to improve people's lives.
Tutu, speaking in Bloemfontein, had harsher words for the ANC.
Referring to the Limpopo textbook scandal, Tutu said the situation of pupils without books in the third term of the school year, and classes under trees, was unacceptable and betrayed what Mandela had fought for.
Tutu - who has over the years been critical of the government for failing the poor and vulnerable - said he was certain Mandela was not entirely aware of the state of education in South Africa.
"If he knew what was happening he would be crying ... it's totally unacceptable."
Tutu said there was no justification for problems such as people living in shacks still plaguing the country.
"We hoped to inspire them to do things we hoped would characterise the new South Africa.
"That we have people going to bed hungry is unacceptable," Tutu told students at a global leadership summit meeting.
He criticised the 30% matric pass requirement.
"This is why we still struggle, maybe," he said, adding that people did not go to jail and die for such results.
Adding to Tutu's and Madikizela-Mandela's warning about the ANC's blunders, Cosatu general secretary Zwelinzima Vavi urged the ruling party to get its house in order or risk losing black support to the opposition DA.
"We are not in good standing; we are not in a good space," he said in Pretoria yesterday.
Judging by the growing black support for the DA, Vavi said, the party's leader, Helen Zille, was luring the most marginalised section of the country's population in an attempt to wrestle power from the ANC in the 2019 general elections.
Speaking at the opening of the bargaining conference of the SA Commercial, Catering and Allied Workers' Union, Vavi said two decades ago it would have been unthinkable for more than 3000 mainly black young people to march on Cosatu House. It would have been unthinkable that a political party such as the DA could celebrate May Day and draw a bigger crowd than Cosatu at some of its rallies, he said.
Vavi warned that the ANC-led tripartite alliance should "wake up and smell the coffee".
"Don't underestimate the fact that already 5% of the blacks in the townships are voting for the DA ... it is not a small matter, it is not about promoting the opposition, but it is about 'vuka maw'lele' [catch a wake-up].
"Don't beat the messenger [let us] look [at] ourselves in the mirror," Vavi said to thunderous applause.
"The army of unemployed is the African youth in particular, blacks in general and women. [Zille] is trying to [present herself] to this marginalised section of the population that is beginning to lose hope because we seem not to have a solution to their crisis of unemployment," Vavi said. - Additional reporting by Sapa
BIRTHDAY WISHES FOR WORLD'S GREATEST LEADER
- "Happy birthday Madiba. The whole nation loves you dearly" - President Jacob Zuma
- "On behalf of the people of the United States, we would like to extend our heartfelt congratulations to Nelson Mandela on the occasion of his 94th birthday and the fourth annual Nelson Mandela International Day" - US President Barack Obama and his family
- "Happy birthday, Nelson Mandela. Thank you for your inspiration to everyone striving for freedom around the world #Madiba" - Britain's Foreign Secretary William Hague
- "In today's world, there could be no better inspiration from one human being" - Manchester United defender Rio Ferdinand
- "Happy birthday to Madiba. He is definitely one of a kind and the exception that proves the rule" - Adele Levinger
- "We pray for your continued good health and happiness. God Bless" - Ebrahim Osman
- "Happy birthday Madiba, the world's most beloved man. We need the thought of your old soul flickering in this moral wasteland we have created" - Margie Orford
- "Happy birthday, Madiba, Thank you for all that you have done for our beautiful country. Congratulations on your 94th cap" -The Sharks


SHARE YOUR OPINION
If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.i_stub_born
Posted 310 days ago...an oxymoron from an anoxic-moron ????.........If the promises were fulfilled why the people demonstrate against?......Unless she was talking about the boxes of matches........
Is her a general feeling: 'The people of SA is lucky, because the ANC made promises to them" ??????
DaInlaw
Posted 310 days agoi_stub_born
Chichi7
Posted 310 days ago------------------------------------------------------------
This is something that has given me sleepless nights. Education must always been regarded in the most high and it is worrying that there is a possibility of having future doctors with a pass rate of 30%. That is a pure and simple fail and sadly Govt even announces that matric pass rate has increased. Really?
Sta_Brown
I was acctually holding a Grade 10 report, not to mention last time I was holding a report was when I was holding mine in 2003.
I was in shock,30%?? like 30%?? Pass?? mxm I still can't believe how do they really allow that to be, I mean are they cruz
Double-Edge
Posted 310 days agoDonaldKnight
manga2
Posted 310 days agoThe other two die in strange circumstances.
Now, who failed the black people of this country?
MicaParis
Posted 310 days agoAs for Winnie ''Madikizela'' she must first tell us where is Stompie and also explain to us the reasons to dismiss a present unemployed traffic Officer who she dismissed for doing his job!!
Stompi's family is still grieving and Children of that traffic officer are dying of hunger, and you?
How pathetic and ridiculous for a political quagmire of Winnie's caliber to talk about humanity and good services to our people while she is currently part of the Mafia rotten group which is stealing directly from the Government coffers!? A hypocrite and underground mafia will never be a messiah in the eyes of the morally humanitarian inclined reasonable legends such as Tata. A squirrel will never be compared to a roaming World greatest Lion King, which is currently witnessed by national and international masses, no! no! no! impossible!!
Selftaught
Posted 310 days agoMaxi
Posted 310 days agoIntegritas
Posted 310 days agoIt is my personal experience that the vast majority of blacks don't want the current dispensation. Ditto the whites. And everyone else. Could Verwoerd possibly have had more insight into culture and societal values than most?
Most blacks feel shafted, but then so do the whites. They gave away on a whim (because of weak leadership), everything that nations fight and die for. They sold all minorities down the creek by taking away any meaningful political power, and increasingly economic power (AA, BEE, corruption, incompetence, plummeting standards,etc.). A sovereign country that was fought for, like every nation in every country did, and for which hundreds of thousands died; their future generations sold to another oppressive overlord nation.
It is extremely ironic how nothing except the "1 nation" solution was peddled before 1994 (except for appeasing black 'chiefs' and the IFP monarch with their own allowances and land). Compare this with how the ANC is selling the "2 state" solution in Sudan, Israel, etc.
If only everyone knew what went down 1990-1994. How much was each party's leadership paid to compromise their respective nations' ideals of self-determination (e.g. Afrikaners, Zulus,etc). And with what were they threatened by Mandela himself after 1994 to shut up and toe the line, despite Codesa and even the Constitution explicitly allowing for minority self-determination after the elections. Do we know even 10% of who Nelson 'Quatro' Mandela really is? Will the real Mandela please stand up.
i_stub_born
Posted 310 days ago