Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 41836.02
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Top 40 : 3460.70
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Financial 15 : 11971.78
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Industrial 25 : 47413.26
    UNCHANGED0.00%

  • ZAR/USD : 9.5884
    UP 0.22%
    ZAR/GBP : 14.4111
    UP 0.21%
    ZAR/EUR : 12.3101
    UP 0.19%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.0928
    UP 0.10%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.2626
    UP 0.07%

  • Gold : 1360.3350
    DOWN -0.57%
    Platinum : 1461.5000
    DOWN -0.24%
    Silver : 22.1076
    DOWN -0.74%
    Palladium : 741.5000
    UP 0.07%
    Brent Crude Oil : 102.220
    DOWN -0.37%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Thu May 23 03:56:42 SAST 2013

Angie reads riot act

Dominic Mahlangu and Chandré Prince | 25 July, 2012 00:30
Basic Education Minister Angie Motshekga. File photo

Basic Education Minister Angie Motshekga and her top officials read the riot act to the managers responsible for Limpopo's textbook scandal.

Amid mounting calls for her axing and that of Limpopo education MEC Dickson Masemola, The Times has established that Motshekga and her team of education experts travelled to Limpopo to "enforce a turnaround strategy" that might include Masemola being redeployed.

While his department was battling last month to explain the non-delivery of textbooks to hundreds of schools in the province halfway through the school year, batches of books were discovered dumped next to the Giyani River, while others were shredded near Seshego.

This was after the department had failed to heed a court order to deliver overdue textbooks to scores of Limpopo schools by June 27.

While no details of yesterday's meeting were released, The Times has established that Motshekga demanded detailed reports from Limpopo officials on how ''catch-up plans'' would be rolled out to help pupils affected by the late delivery of textbooks.

The meeting, which lasted several hours, also dealt with the acquisition of textbooks for next year.

Motshekga's team will wrap up its visit today.

Her spokesman, Hope Mokgatle, said she would not be giving interviews before then.

Motshekga's intervention comes a week after former higher education director-general Mary Metcalfe released a damning report on the provincial education crisis and called for Masemola to be fired.

The ANC Youth League in the province echoed Metcalfe's call at the weekend.

The league, which also wants Motshekga fired, has accused Masemola of creating the textbook crisis by failing to use the education budget when it became apparent there was a problem.

Masemola, who is also the ANC's provincial deputy chairman, said he was not responsible for the textbook crisis, and that his department had been hamstrung after the central government placed it under administration in December.

Those privy to the discussions yesterday said Motshekga had demanded details of steps the province would take to make sure books are delivered on time come next year.

''For the first time the minister cracked the whip. She wanted definite answers and a programme of action. Politics took a back seat and the problem we are facing was put on the table and discussed openly," said a senior official.

He said Motshekga made it clear that President Jacob Zuma had demanded answers and wants the textbook crisis solved quickly.

However, more problems surfaced yesterday, with the department being blamed for delivering the wrong books to schools.

A school for the blind in Thokgwaneng village near Lebowakgomo received books for sighted pupils.

The SA Democratic Teachers' Union, which was not present at yesterday's meeting, said it was worried about the ''general collapse of education in the province'' and that it would take an inclusive approach to solve it.

The union's provincial secretary, Matome Raphasha, said Motshekga's visit made no sense .

''We cannot be excluded as our members are the ones who must drive the programme. Time is not on our side and we hope that she will meet with us."

The union will meet Masemo la tomorrow and a catch-up plan to assist affected pupils is expected to be discussed.

Raphasha said it would support ''whatever plan'' as long as teachers were compensated.

Motshekga has for seven months failed to act decisively on the crisis, and yesterday's stern approach follows Zuma's warning two months ago that those responsible would be "held accountable".

Zuma defended Motshekga on Monday , saying there was no need to fire her - despite thousands of pupils in Limpopo having been deprived of education material for months.

In a radio interview, Zuma said: "Well, I'm not sure about that criticism and I'm sure if, each day there was a report and I fired people, I would be [harshly] criticised that I don't follow processes of the law."

Zuma said he could not just fire Motshekga as she sits in an office in Pretoria. He first had to establish who was responsible for the problem in Limpopo before heads could roll.

Metcalfe's report recommended key reforms the province needed to implement urgently to avoid a repetition of this year's debacle, and called for Limpopo's education department to be micro-managed by the national department.

A special ministerial task team, set up by Zuma, is also investigating the non-delivery and destruction of learning materials.

The Limpopo government is conducting its own investigation.

Announcing the presidential task team at the beginning of this month, presidential spokesman Mac Maharaj said: "The president has directed that all who are found to have played a role in delaying or stopping the delivery of books should be held accountable."

The team, headed by Deputy Finance Minister Nhlanhla Nene, is still investigating.

The textbook saga - which Justice Minister Jeff Radebe described as a national "shame" - has seen thousands of books, including a biography of former president Nelson Mandela and William Shakespeare's Macbeth, being destroyed.

The Limpopo education department was one of five provincial departments placed under national administration in December. - Additional reporting by Frank Maponya

SHARE YOUR OPINION

If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.

Thuka-Thuka

Posted 301 days ago
Avatar
Oh! 8 out of 10 Angie is kicking into high gear? Well. Better late than never, hey Angie!
Avatar

MicaParis

Posted 301 days ago
I like your profile expression I overlooked it for a long time until i decide to pay attention to it!! Talking about education/ethukaziene as Julius call it for our ANC Comrades is an embarrassment of a century as that is something they lack holistically. They think that you only go to school to be rich but whilst they are already rich through tenders going to school for them is a waist of time!!

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 301 days ago
Avatar
...those responsible would be "held accountable"

That will be the day that Beelzebub will be ice skating to work.

Love the 'redeployment' idea. I so very much wish that if I made a dogs breakfast of an entire province that I would simply be 'redeployed' to make an equally disastrous mess somewhere else. Unfortunately, I live in the real world where we just get fired
Avatar

THISOTHERDUDE

Posted 301 days ago
Laughing my behind off for your comment :)

Theye

Posted 301 days ago
Avatar
Zuma said he could not just fire Motshekga as she sits in an office in Pretoria.

Obviously this joke for a president has never heard the term "the Buck stops her"

Theye

Posted 301 days ago
Avatar
Her = here...........but then again.........

BornintheRSA

Posted 301 days ago
Avatar
"that might include Masemola being redeployed"
The status quo shows that he was grossly incompetent, even negligent. He should be charged and dismissed, without any further state benefits.

KafreeMoneykey

Posted 301 days ago
Avatar
I really do not understand this redeployment nonsense!
Avatar

Wiseguy

Posted 301 days ago
Re-de-ployment......this is how the ANC/Gov take care of their own loyal cadres!
The fact that their cardes f'ed up, forgot about the people and even possible enriched themselves at the peoples expense/cost.....in this case 6 months of wasted school time for hundreds of thousands of Limpopo juniors.....is not SOOO important! Mxnm.
What is important is LOYALTY....yes, if you are a loyal cadre, the ANC will take care of you, it doesn't matter how much u F up, how much of the peoples money u steal, how much of everyones time and money u waste or how many innocent law abiding tax paying people get trodden on.....if U r loyal....we redeploy U! Loyalty has many different meanings to many....but in this scenario means putting the political party and esp. its esteemed leaders first....before the country, people or children(as in this case).
Think they learned it from the previous regime(the Nats were also big on putting loyalty before the people).....but the ANC have definitely taken it to an all time new level!

Hope that makes this redeployment clearer for u now Kafree? ;)

Manablaze

Posted 301 days ago
Avatar
What exactly were the ANCYL doing all this time? It's their own back yard, surely they must have had pleas from the students in the area. And why so long to (halfway through the year?) to highlight the issue? The department has already been paid to do a job, withhold further payment until the job is complete, use these funds to appoint a new team to help resolve the issue with the long-term goal of replacing the old team with the new team.

And Mr. Pres, last time I checked gross negligence and incapacity to carry out your job is grounds for dismissal no matter where you're sat.
Avatar

Thuka-Thuka

Posted 301 days ago
That's the problem. we have a Youth League that is far more interested in spending time on issues such as the nationalisation of mines and service delivery protests. Why on earth would they be interested in real issues that affect the youth?
Avatar

Wiseguy

Posted 301 days ago
If you readthe reports around this disaster, you will see the ANCYL leaders were too busy organising tenders and kickbacks(self-enrichment schemes) to be concerned over a few tens of thousands of childrens education!
You see, the ANCYL in Limpopo send their children to private schools and hospitals.......so why should they worry about the youth of the provinces education.....only interested in the money....see ?? Youth league refers to the amount of greed and self-enrichment, so they can only get small tenders and small time self enrichment......but once you get to the real levers of power in the mother body......then you get the real big adult style kickbakcs and rewards!

Youth in the ANCYL eyes has nothing/nada/aheko to do with young people......only to do with the size of the self-enrichment....SEE?

Mike123

Posted 301 days ago
Avatar
Angie, with the typical management skills of an ANC cadre, you obviously don't realise that YOU are ultimately responsible. It takes seven months, and a huge public outcry, for you to wake up and do the job you are paid to you. Useless b...

Les4uu

Posted 301 days ago
Avatar
What a joke... Angie should read the riot act to herself.

i_stub_born

Posted 301 days ago
Avatar
"At the ANC we don't destroy you, we fix you.......You go wrong, we fix you again, we don't destroy you".......


.....When ANC-made magnateTokyo Sexwell-e said it about Juju, he was just expressing the ideology of the ANC Mafia Syndicate Inc.

SuiGeneris

Posted 301 days ago
Avatar
Angie is right, she deserves 8 out of 10.....That is according to african standards for the african circus.

Stop being so critical....Nothing will ever change.....'This is Africa after all.....They thrive on crises management.....once they ''sorted'' out this problem, the next crisis will appear and then the next....and the circus will continue forever !
Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 301 days ago
2 days ago on Talk Radio 702, zuma blamed Dr HF Verwoerd for the crisis in the department of education.

Again and as usual, he was trying to minimize his own responsibility and his own incompetence as president and to place the blame on apartheid !

WilhelmSnyman

Posted 301 days ago
Avatar
What a cynical farce this all is. Is it possible to be more stupid and incompetent? I would be surprised if Bantu Education was worse than this. No wonder the Zimbabweans wipe the floor with white and black South Africans. The education system is bad enough, with this nonsense of a 30% pass rate, without this textbook fiasco. It is clear that the ANC just wants to stampede back into primordiality...

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 301 days ago
Avatar
We voiced our disapproval when Angelinah was given the job, because she already shown her scant regard by saying that a matric pass is not important, as well as leaving her job to campaign for Jacob Zuma in Soweto. Prior to that, she had awarded a contract to her son. As for her boss, he showed scant regard, or grasp, of education when he stated that children who were caught out of school would be sent away to exile. And he still has mysteriously managed to evade appearing in court for 783 charges of corruption. All our predictions were proven correct. Not that they need to be, but the point is; such indices are so powerful to be wished away. We sound these warnings not because we care a rat's tush about any politician, or party, but because its our society at stake here, and we pay dearly for destroying it. And we were warned centuries ago that modern forms of democracy have a tendency to shackle the very freedoms that are forever the aim of humanity. Human beings topple dictatorships, only to replace them immediately thereafter.

MicaParis

Posted 301 days ago
Avatar
''those responsible would be "held accountable" !!!!!!!!!
Since when was that possible in Government? The relevant crux of the matter here is that Angie is trying disparately harder to fade away from the fact that she should have rendered her resignation letter to Zuma at list two months ago! What she had done so far is not a failure but a murder of the future of our precious young minds! How dare do you murder anticipated selfless intelligence and still run away with murder! We will only forgive Jacob Zuma if he fire Comrade Angie, Mathale, Masemola and Thamaga, otherwise we will meet in the ballot box in 2014 Comrades, you think this is nice!? It is very painful to be led by illiterates! Our comrades are suffering from lack of intelligence and self interest in our people.

LAR23

Posted 301 days ago
Avatar
Why should we be surprised? This woman has proven herself to be totally incompetent no matter what position she is placed in and deserves to be fired immediately. However, we know that this will never happen and she will continue to blame others for her lack of skills.
I wonder if her education ever included the word "honourable" in it. If it did she would do the honourable thing and just rewsign - now - and spare us from her ongoing blame shifting and ongoing inability to carry out her mandate.

LAR23

Posted 301 days ago
Avatar
Finger trouble (so angry) - I added a "w" ro resign!

LAR23

Posted 301 days ago
Avatar
Finger trouble (so angry) - I added a "w" to the word resign!

buddi

Posted 301 days ago
Avatar
Too little, too late!
Reading the riot act is not enough - heads should roll!
Avatar

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 301 days ago
Its never too late for the politicians who are merely obsessed with 8/10 score. She simply 'predict' a '70%' pass, if all fail. Just like she did last year, with all those strikes and other mismanagement. All she needed was to lower the required marks for a pass. Research has shown consistent relationship between target-setting by politicians and 'cheating' - expelling poor performing children mid-year and other stuff. They then hit the target, but miss the goal of having an educated society. Serving the public was never their thing, remember. It comes in the process of seeking personal gain. Suffer the little children, who must be sacrificed at the alter!
Avatar

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 301 days ago
'hit the target, miss the point'

buddi

Posted 301 days ago
Avatar
Masemola, who is also the ANC's provincial deputy chairman, said he was not responsible for the textbook crisis, and that his department had been hamstrung after the central government placed it under administration in December.

@Masemola - and why was it placed under administration? Because it was such a well run department before that?
You are solely responsible for this entire mess!

RogueTrooperv2

Posted 301 days ago
Avatar
She should be on trial for treason...what she has allowed to happen is criminality of the highest order!!!