Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 41413.44
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Top 40 : 3353.49
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Financial 15 : 12096.10
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Industrial 25 : 47171.07
    UNCHANGED0.00%

  • ZAR/USD : 9.3984
    DOWN -0.02%
    ZAR/GBP : 14.2843
    UP 0.43%
    ZAR/EUR : 12.0685
    UP 1.82%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.0915
    UP 0.16%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.1944
    UP 0.37%

  • Gold : 1344.2750
    UP 0.08%
    Platinum : 1446.5000
    UP 1.22%
    Silver : 21.2600
    UP 0.97%
    Palladium : 734.5000
    UP 0.07%
    Brent Crude Oil : 104.750
    UP 0.12%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Mon May 20 06:06:16 SAST 2013

Angie's woes mount

AMUKELANI CHAUKE | 27 July, 2012 00:10
Basic Education Minister Angie Motshekga. File photo

Pressure is mounting on President Jacob Zuma to act and fix the textbook fiasco that has left thousands of pupils without all their learning material halfway through the school year.

Advocacy group Equal Education has called on Zuma to appoint a judicial commission of inquiry into the debacle as more complaints surfaced this week that several schools in other provinces besides Limpopo have not received their textbooks.

Yesterday, Public Protector Thuli Madonsela announced that she was conducting her own investigation.

Yoliswa Dwane, head researcher at Equal Education, said that though the group had faith in the inter-ministerial investigative team Zuma appointed earlier this month, a judicial inquiry was needed to "unearth all the rot" and bring all the culprits to book.

Pressure is building on the president to take action against a slew of inefficiencies in Basic Education Minister Angie Motshekga's department.

The department already faces several court cases - including one brought against her by Equal Education, which wants her to implement a minimum uniform standards policy for the infrastructure required by schools.

In another case, Motshekga's legal team yesterday threw in the towel in a high court application brought by the Centre for Child Law and agreed to fill a large number of vacant teaching positions in Eastern Cape.

As the Limpopo textbook scandal drags on, with several schools still without books, Dwane said pupils at scores of schools across the country were also without textbooks.

The most "notorious" provinces, she said, were Gauteng, KwaZulu-Natal, Mpumalanga, Limpopo and Eastern Cape.

"I don't think it is only these provinces but they are the most notorious in terms of non-delivery and incapacity."

Madonsela yesterday said that she would launch a three-part investigation into the issue.

She wants to find out if there was maladministration in a case in which textbooks were destroyed by a contractor in Limpopo.

In another case, she will try to establish whether there were schools in the Free State that had not received textbooks.

Reports on Wednesday said that more than 50 schools in the province had still not received all their textbooks, but provincial education spokesman Howard Ndaba said he was not aware of the situation.

Madonsela will also investigate a complaint in Gauteng that the purchase of books for next year has not yet been approved.

"We have also written to the Department of Basic Education and asked them to state what is being done to prevent this from happening again ... and whether it is clear what books should be delivered to whom by what time," Madonsela said.

Motshekga - who visited Limpopo this week to try to find solutions to the textbook problem in the province - also faces a probe by the presidential task team into the textbook fiasco.

And former Higher Education director-general Mary Metcalfe - who was appointed following an agreement by another advocacy group, Section 27, and the department, to investigate the Limpopo textbook problems - also forwarded a critical report to the president.

Motshekga and Limpopo education MEC Dickson Masemola have refused to take responsibility for the textbooks affair and resign .

Zuma has refused to heed calls that he fire Motshekga and all the officials responsible for the mess.

Political analyst Daniel Silke said that when service delivery is compromised Zuma should move from protecting "close allies" and quickly fire all culpable politicians and bureaucrats.

"Unfortunately for us, we have got used to a situation in which presidents continue to protect those closest to them because they are political allies," he said.

Dwane said that though Motshekga should take some responsibility for the textbook woes, her director-general, Bobby Soobrayan, should also be probed because this was the second time that he had been implicated in education scandals.

In 2010, The Times reported that Soobrayan's future mother-in-law, Salama Hendricks, at the time was linked to a R300-million textbooks tender.

Dwane said reports that linked Hendricks to EduSolutions, the politically connected company that was awarded a multimillion-rand contract to distribute textbooks in Limpopo, should not be overlooked.

Mark Heywood, the executive director for Section 27, said textbook shortages in Limpopo were continuing.

"All these learners, except those in former model C schools, are being affected by the failure of the Department of Basic Education to provide learners and teachers with the necessary learning and teaching materials," he said.

Heywood said the textbook shortage might continue into the next school term because the provincial department had spent its book budget for 2012-2013.

He said the textbook saga was initially not the fault of the Basic Education Department but it took responsibility the day it intervened.

SHARE YOUR OPINION

If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.

BornintheRSA

Posted 296 days ago
Avatar
Step 1 - take budget, order books. Step 2 - collect books from printer, Step 3 - hire truck, Step 4 - deliver books to school. A few iterations required, some in parallel. Step 5 - school children read books and learn. How difficult can that be?
Avatar

THISOTHERDUDE

Posted 296 days ago
As easy as learning your ABC's (pun intended)
Avatar

Stirrer

Posted 296 days ago
Don't be silly, BornintheRSA.
That's not how they roll!
Step 1 - pay no heed to budget.
Step 2 - approach cadres to form a front for white printing company.
Step 3 - award tender to highest tenderer (front company - who scores 100% for BEE)
Step 4 - approach family members to lend a few second-hand trucks and set up company.
Step 5 - award transport contract to highest tenderer (family members - who score 100% for BEE).
Step 6 - don't set any time-frames for delivery of books.
Step 7 - find scapegoats to blame for non-delivery.
Step 8 - sit back and wait for promotion to re-deployed position!
Avatar

IAnonYm

Posted 296 days ago
HaHa - Fail at Step 1 - What is a Budget?
Avatar

shelatt

Posted 296 days ago
No, it's as difficult as your ANC's...! Intelligent people know their ABC's.

muk1

Posted 296 days ago
Avatar
All these investigations only reveal one thing; lack of skills. Until we have competant people with powers to act; the public service will just be a heaven for redtape with little feel for intended destination of their actions. We see the same thing in the healthcare sector. Those processing invoices fail to see that a supplier is waiting for their money to pay wages, their suppliers, rent etc.
Avatar

JanChrzciciel

Posted 296 days ago
Lack of competence is no excuse for lack of taking responsibility

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 296 days ago
Avatar
"He said the textbook saga was initially not the fault of the Basic Education Department"

Do we not have organograms in SA?
It is inconceivable that the person who is given the specific job of ensuring that the various provincial departments do their jobs is now suddenly not accountable. Angie is the MINISTER that means that she is the one who has to ensure that provincial MECs for education are doing the blerrie job they are appointed to do.
Avatar

Francis

Posted 296 days ago
MommaCyndi,
Is organogram part of 783's knowledge for whom corruption before education is the slogan?
We sit on the bottom decks of the SA(ti)tanic while the anc is enjoying the top decks knowing that all of them get reserved seats in the lifeboat.
In 2012, the list of the saved is already very long, starting with mandela and we sit now on selibi.

THISOTHERDUDE

Posted 296 days ago
Avatar
Asking JZ to act on this is like asking a junkie to give up his habit,will never happen.I dont have much faith in the "presidential task team" so Madonsela should just conduct her own investigation and then present her findings to JZ,maybe then he will act.Touch wood.

Ntebaleng

Posted 296 days ago
Avatar
The education of African children has long been set to fail. From when Kadar Asmal took over that was the begining of the collapse. Mom Angie went in straddled and the was no way that she could save this situation as all eyes were targeted at the province for its stance on nationalization , land restitution and economic freedom of the African child in their life time.

When fixing the problem was supposed to be the focus attention was given to putting the province under administration. Most of the time was spend of finding loop holes in the lagislation that can make it possible to paralyse the power of the who advocated nationalisation, land restitution and economic freedom of the African child in their life time. Media is hell bend on raising the side show without advancing and challenging the real problem. Zuma is also blaming Vervoerd but the problem is current, yes the desseminator of the virus is Vervoerd but now attention must be on eliminating the virus.Africans are made to blame Vervoerd and each other thus giving the virus a longer life span so it can annihiliate the African childrens mind.

The department of education is the focus when all departments are paralysed and also all provinces departments and governance in a process of decay. The NDR has been diluted by neo- liberal tendency that mophs real debate on understanding and resolving the real problems besetting the African population
Avatar

Bono

Posted 296 days ago
Ntebaleng
Do yourself a favour and source a letter written by David Bullard under the heading…The ANC's "selfless strugglemobile" it has nothing to do with the screw-up in the dept of basic education but it encapsulates why and how the Government got itself into this mess.
If the government cannot even get the basics right as BornintheRSA demonstrated, you and the ANC will blame Verwoerd and the media forever…I’m sorry my friend but you cannot carry-on defending the ANC and go through life with blinkers over your eyes. There is life beyond the ANC believe it or not.
Avatar

Wiseguy

Posted 296 days ago
"economic freedom of the African child in their life time".......has been sabotaged by complete and utter incompetance!

Real economic freedom...can ONLY be achieved through one means>>>EDUCATION, learning and hopefully for those who are motivated enough....hard work!

To blame this current distaster on Verwoed or anyone else is propogandaristic to say the least.

No one is disputing the fact that these communities are previously disadvantaged....and that these imbalances need to be addressed, but surely that is all the MORE reason to make certain these children have the correct textbooks at the correct time!!

To those responsible for this disaster.....the children are OUR future, so....YOU FIRED YOU FIRED YOU FIRED!

VUKILE ABANTU VUKILE
POWER TO THE PEOPLE
PHANTSI CORRUPT POLITICIANS PHANTSI
PHANTSI CORRUPT PUBLIC SERVANTS PHANSI
PHANTSI CORRUPT TENDERTREPENUERS PHANTSI
POWER TO THE PEOPLE.....and that means all the people!!!
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 296 days ago
First, it was Sibusiso Bengu who implemented the disastrous OBE.

Verwoerd must be hosing himself. Even he couldn't have imagined screwing up the African child this completely. It makes Bantu education seem elitist.

I wonder if you know what 'neo-liberal tendencies' are?

JimiVan_der_Westhuizen

Posted 296 days ago
Avatar
And now all these non-performing ministers will be collecting R2million pa for not taking responsibility. What a farce.

Francis

Posted 296 days ago
Avatar
The better government schools with school fees going from R 10.000 to R 45.000 buy their most important books (maths, science etc) themselves at the beginning of the year and the learners can keep them.
Whatever they have been supplied by the government must at the end of the year be returned by the learner to the school or he/she has to pay a fine and the value of the book.

Who is collecting the moneys from the books, supposedly to be delivered by the government, of all these high flyer schools?

Ntebaleng

Posted 296 days ago
Avatar
@Bono

I did not blame Vervoerd, i know he is the achitect of all this but what i said is that Zuma is dieverting attention from real issues to address by throwing back the clock. We all know what is wrong and i do not see why everybody focus on blaming instead of focusing on the problem at hand
Avatar

Bono

Posted 296 days ago
"We all know what is wrong and i do not see why everybody focus on blaming instead of focusing on the problem at hand"

everybody knows except the Government as they are so occupied in their own internal struggle for power within the ANC they are unable to see the wood from the trees....THEY have lost the focus as well as the ability to Manage the country (not that they ever had it in them anyway) and do what they are paid for......but instead they are looting the resources and your Tax money for their own personal agendas and lifestyles. They are corrupt to the bone (with a few exceptions) and needed to be replaced!!!

Ntebaleng

Posted 296 days ago
Avatar
@Bono

There i will agree with you comrade, even Angie was just dragged into this when the target was the Limpopo leadership. I read in THE STAR that there are spies in the country pushing their agenda in this country who sway people thinking to advance their course. With a president like Zuma i think we are in trouble since the only thing he thinks is through the zippers of his pants and impregnating some naive woman with the promise of marriage and a better life of living a life of a president's wife.

We have good cadres in the NDM but they are cowards, for starters Panyaza and Angie should have exposed Zuma and Treasury when they discovered the problems in education but the went along with JZ and Goran's plan without flinching. Now the Angie and Panyaza look like morons when in actual fact they were used in this battle for the control of Limpopo

Mike123

Posted 296 days ago
Avatar
Shame! Poor thing! And on top of all of those woes, it was recently discovered that she has a watermelon where her brain should be.

LingLong28

Posted 296 days ago
Avatar
Wena Minister you should be fired - nothing else

WilhelmSnyman

Posted 296 days ago
Avatar
Ag, I don't know why one even bothers. It's crystal clear the ANC couldn't care a damn and they happily will let SA stampede back into the Stone Age...