Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 40998.58
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Top 40 : 3361.59
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Financial 15 : 11703.85
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Industrial 25 : 46637.62
    UNCHANGED0.00%

  • ZAR/USD : 9.5763
    UP 0.07%
    ZAR/GBP : 14.4987
    UP 0.23%
    ZAR/EUR : 12.3835
    UP 0.04%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.0947
    UP 0.14%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.2551
    UP 0.14%

  • Gold : 1386.6000
    UP 0.03%
    Platinum : 1452.5000
    UP 0.31%
    Silver : 22.4000
    UP 0.16%
    Palladium : 727.0000
    UP 0.55%
    Brent Crude Oil : 102.640
    UNCHANGED0.00%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Sun May 26 10:12:12 SAST 2013

Animal activists storm circus

MHLABA MEMELA | 30 July, 2012 00:1132 Comments
Animal rights activists protest at the use of wild animals in Brian Boswell's Circus in Durban, yesterday Picture: THULI DLAMINI

Usually a place for a fun family outing, the Boswell Circus in Durban had its hands full yesterday as protesters descended on it to voice their concerns about cruelty to animals.

As almost 800 people jostled to get into the large marquee at the Sun Coast Casino, motorists hooted and waved at the protesters, some of whom carried placards condemning the "slavery and cruelty" of the circus's handling of the animals.

Steve Smit, leader of Animal Rights in Action and one of the people who protested for three hours, said the animals were subjected to "enormous abuse" in the name of entertainment.

"We want to change the public perception that keeping an animal in a cage is entertainment. Animals must live a natural life and nature takes care of them," he said.

Brian Boswell, owner of the circus, said his employes did not abuse animals and his animals were in good condition.

"People should see for themselves before believing the allegations of animal cruelty made by a group of activists. I think these activists only want publicity," he said. Boswell said he was the fifth generation of his family to be involved in running a circus. His great-grandparents started the business more than 101 years ago.

"We love animals and we believe we are also playing a role in teaching our children. The children attending our shows have never seen [these] animals in real life."

Boswell said he travelled around the country with eight lions, two elephants, eight dogs (only three taking part in the shows), three pigs, six horses and six ponies.

"We take care of these animals with a staff of 60. Our animals are safer than those in the wild, which have to fight for territory and die because of sicknesses. Here there are vets who treat our animals."

Smit - who has been fighting the use of animals in Boswell's circus for 27 years - said the "animals are turned into slaves".

"The elephants are kept running in the cage and chained during the circus. They are denied their right to enjoy nature," he said.

Smit said the use of animals in circuses had been stopped in progressive countries and South Africa should follow suit.

"Most people who attend the circus in KwaZulu-Natal might be those who do not care about animals. But the great majority of people do not attend these circuses because they understand the message," he said.

Protest organiser Jaryd Sage said circuses have been a source of human entertainment for centuries but the public was oblivious to the cruelty and suffering of animals. "People must understand that the abuse is not only about beating animals. Putting an animal in a cage for such a long time is abuse and has to stop. These animals need to have a normal life."

Harvan Naido said he enjoyed watching the animals perform.

"I have no idea about what the protesters are saying but my family enjoys the show," he said.

To submit comments you must first

Join the discussion & Debate

Animal activists storm circus

For Commenters Consideration | Please stick to the subject matter

COMMENTS [32]

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 300 days ago
Avatar
"The elephants are kept running in the cage and chained during the circus"

Well that has to be the biggest hamster wheel of all time. Hook it up to Eishkom and our electricity woes are behind us.
Avatar

JodyBlake

Posted 299 days ago
Characteristically troll-ish remarks do not warrant much attention. Do you have a point?
Avatar

MegalooO'Horran

Posted 299 days ago
Uhm ..... would you mind being just a little bit more thoughtful in your responses? What IS your point?
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 299 days ago
My point is that that sentence is ridiculous.
How do you take anyone seriously when they make statements that over the top?
Avatar

Francis

Posted 299 days ago
Jode Blake & MegalooO'Horran with support,

Visit the veterinary clinic at your home town or even better, follow veterinary science at Pretoria. You will find numerous abused animals from "loving" owners. I guarantee you will be shocked.

What happens today when sick or injured animals in the wild are found? They are brought to care centres where they are properly looked after and if possible to be returned into the wild when healed.
However, a great part of these animals stay in shelters for the rest of their lives as they will not survive in their natural habitat. What do you propose to do with them?
Most town dwellers get their first contact with a circus animal. A circus cannot afford to have sick, unhappy or bad treated animals.
I learned that sentimentality is not a good adviser and South Africa has enough human pain to show empathy in our spare time.


Avatar

kim.trent

Posted 298 days ago
The above sentence has prompted me to respond. The person quoted as saying this happens to be one the most prominent and most ARTICULATE animal activists in South Africa. He has extensive knowledge in most animal matters and in particular with this and other circuses. He has written hundreds of articles and been interviewed numerous times on national television. For the life of me, I unreservedly conclude that this is a genuine error on the part of the journalist.
Avatar

Slamdance

Posted 298 days ago
What actually happens is the Elephants and lions pace up and down their cage,(this is what the person said bad reporting) Dont be a"TROLL" In animal behavior this is stress. High acid build up in the blood this causes major discomfort for the animal also seen in Zoo animals. Zoo keepers try and stimulate the animals behavior with cage enrichment, sadly in such a small cage they have no choice. It is like anxiety attack.
Avatar

SteveSmit

Posted 298 days ago
"... running in the cage"??? Fact is that nothing of the kind was said to the journalist. The point under discussion that led to relevant comments was that the elephants not only spend many hours on the road confined in their travel boxes, they are also chain-tethered by the foot for hours at the circus sites. Like the other wild animals used in the circus the movement from one site to another, all over the country, is hugely stressful as it denies them the natural need to to have a home range with favoured, safe areas. Maybe the journalist was having a bad day!

KyleYoung

Posted 300 days ago
Avatar
Circus folk are so arrogant to think that keeping animals in these conditions is not abuse and add insult to injury by saying they love there animals, that's not love.

JarydSage

Posted 300 days ago
Avatar
We need to STOP listening to the people who run the circus, they will say anything to convince the public that the circus is the best place for animals. It's a ridiculous argument, but one that they stand behind because their money-making depends on it. NGO Public Watch did a two week investigation and their findings refute everything Boswell says about the love he has for animals, and how safe they are with him!
Search BOYCOTT Brian Boswell's Animal Circus on Facebook and educate yourself on the REAL situation here! The public needs to stand up against this abuse.

JarydSage

Posted 300 days ago
Avatar
If you search BOYCOTT Brian Boswell's Animal Circus on Facebook, you will find information, investigations, myths and the truth, videos and photos regarding animal circuses in South Africa and worldwide. Have a look so that you can make an informed decision!
Avatar

MegalooO'Horran

Posted 299 days ago
I will do my research re: Brian's circus, but having already researched the issue of animals in circuses, I doubt I will find anything new there. Transportation alone is very stressful to these animals and having them doing tricks for the public's entertainment is a travesty. They must be trained to perform and behave in ways that are anethema to their nature. Is there really anything else that needs to be said? Brian argues that they are better off in the circus than they are in the wild which is the most ridiculous argument I have ever heard. Unfortunately, it is not the first time I've heard it.

DesRamsay

Posted 299 days ago
Avatar
If you love animals, and also enjoy, as many do, visiting game reserves, I am sure you will agree that a circus is by its very nature a foreign and stressful environment for any animal, let alone a wild one. This is even not taking into account the added stress of being "trained to perform" tricks that are totally foreign and unnatural (no matter how kindly the training is done, and no matter how they are fed and watered, all this is bad enough). So, even if everything Mr Boswell says is true, its a nightmare existence for them. As an animal lover I abhor the thought of majestic beasts being treated in this way. Circuses are wonderful, exciting and enjoyable. Look at Cirque du Soleil, Madame Zingara and so many others. There is absolutely no need whatsoever to have wild animals in a circus to make it enjoyable. As to whether "saving" an elephant from culling and subjecting it to this life is an improvement, sorry, it is not. Death is the way of life in the wild. Animals die continuously as they are hunted by predators. It is only a human who would think being shackled and caged is better.
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 299 days ago
Yes, sorry, my ability to write in English does not equate to your ability to comprehend.

Should we go out and kill off all the animals in captivity? So much nicer for them all and all those little orphaned baby animals should just be left to die of starvation as it is far more 'natural' than preserving the genetic diversification.
Avatar

JodyBlake

Posted 299 days ago
I am in agreement with you DesRamsay. As for RSA.MommaCyndi's opinion, please could you coherently post your objections to the claims made by the people in support of this protest. I really am trying to understand what you are saying but am battling to see past what seems to be the unsubstantiated remarks of a troll.
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 299 days ago
Jody,
If you actually bother to READ the comments:

1. I have clearly stated that I am against the use of animals in the entertainment industry - I don't even like zoos even though I can intellectually appreciate their value.

2. I have been involved with animal orphanages before and, whilst returning them to the wild is the primary goal, that is not always possible.

3. To take an adult animal that has been hand reared and habituated to humans and then plonk it into the middle of the bushveldt is past cruel and inhuman.

4. To simply leave an animal to die because it is 'nature' is ridiculous. Many species are suffering from a lack of genetic diversification. Human habitation has forced species into little enclaves where they are forced to interbreed as migration is not possible. That creates a situation where diseases and genetic disabilities become pronounced. Saying they should just let it 'die' (along with it's possible genetic assistance to another tribe) because it is the 'way of the wild' is short sighted and ridiculous.

5. Animal activists make themselves into a laughing stock by using absolutely ridiculous language. They undermine many of the works done by real conservationists by making "Malema" statements like elephants 'running in cages'. They should THINK before opening their mouths as elephants can't 'run in cages'. That much bulk needs room to get up to a good run - don't you think?

As some people have clearly indicated here, the knowledge of conservation and animal behaviour is sadly lacking in our country. It would appear that things like rhino horn hunting or ivory poaching is approved of as 'Death is the way of life in the wild' and animals orphaned by the slaughter should just be left to die of starvation or a passing predator.
Avatar

JarydSage

Posted 299 days ago
RSA.MommaCyndi,
I can understand some of what you have to say, and agree with you. Unfortunately you cannot argue that the protest spokesperson has said something ridiculous and then liken what some people have described as "the way of the wild" to poachers killing for rhino horn or ivory.
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 299 days ago
JarydSage

May I respectfully request that you get off your soapbox long enough to educate yourself on the subject that you are banging on about or at least come up with a viable alternate solution.

Dead is dead. I'm pretty certain that the name, address and social standing of your murderer would make it any less undesirable.

JarydSage

Posted 299 days ago
Avatar
The point is that the argument of saving these animals lives only to hold them captive in tiny cages for up to 19 hours a day and then force them to do tricks for profit is just ridiculous.

jeff.marett

Posted 298 days ago
Avatar
All these people protesting against cruelty to animals is ironic. I bet on the way to the circus to protest they drove past all the people begging on the side of the street and homeless kids with nowhere to go without even batting an eyelid. Where's their dignity or "chance to enjoy nature"?
Avatar

JarydSage

Posted 298 days ago
Maybe the real irony is you telling the protestors that they should be doing something about street children, when you probably have made no effort of your own to help them. If people really believe that animal rights activists should be doing something else, at THE VERY LEAST they should be involved in those causes. People need to understand that everyone has something important to them. Just because someone takes a Sunday afternoon to protest for the poor, defenceless, imprisoned animals in a travelling circus does NOT mean that they don't care or do anything for street children (or others who are in need). It's a very pessimistic conclusion to jump to, with no reason.
Avatar

Slamdance

Posted 298 days ago
Are you for real?

ToniBrockhoven

Posted 298 days ago
Avatar
Given the choice, no animal would choose to live an unnatural life of captivity, regardless of the kindness of the treatment and no animal would choose a life that allows none of their natural behaviour. Certainly animals would not choose to be taken from their families to be obliged to amuse us. Circus animals spend months travelling in small, bare cages. The stress of continued confinement as well as the transportation result in long term suffering and a lack of appropriate social interaction, reduction in time spent foraging and the restricted freedom to perform natural behaviours represent stressors for captive animals.

A natural environments cannot be recreated in a circuses due to the travelling, with inadequate acommodation and exercise areas and forced movement, handling by humans, noise along with the confinement results in both short-term as well as long-term behavioural and psychological effects. There is NO educational benefit for children except to teach them that we can enslave and use animals at our whim. Intelligent people do not need to be 'entertained' by performing animals and with all the incredible wild life doccies out there, children (and adults) can learn far more and be entertained by animals beings animals. Furthermore those who make comments about 'street children' are clearly intellectually challenged if they believe that because some people challenge animal slavery means they don't care for humans; often these same people are doing more for the community at large in several ways! (PS i have never seen a duck-billed platypus in real life, strangely, my life has not been dimished in any way)

marianajfe

Posted 298 days ago
Avatar
Firstly @ Mr Boswell who states that children see these animals live for first time. We as parents have a responsibility to teach and educate our children and teach them right. It is not right - it is not normal - it is not natural for our kids to learn that Elephants can do tricks surrounded by a jeering crowd; it is not normal for Lions to be whipped in cages (Yes MommaCyndi, they are in cages) to perform. I rather turn on National Geographic or read them books and show they photos to teach them the righteous truth and facts of where these animals actually belong.

Mr Boswell feeding your animals and taking care of them is not to justify there is no abuse. TO train an Elephant to do tricks (they are not dogs that can learn to dance with snacks) there has to be abuse; rope; chains; beating etc. Travelling circus means these animals are permanently in their cages / boxes / containers whatever you want to call it MommaCyndi and this is a form of abuse and not natural. Rescuing them from being culled to subject them to a life in the circus is abuse. Doing all this for monetary purposes is disgusting and untollerable.

People need to be educated; people need to become aware that their support of the circus adds extra years of tyranny for these animals.

Yes quite right, Francis and Jeff there are many humanitarian causes we should support and a lot of human pain in SA - all over the world. But we cannot save the world, we can only take it a step at a time; cause at a time; and we cannot abandon these poor defenseless animals because there are greater causes out there. I commend all the protesters and their pursuit of this cause. By stopping animal circuses we are making the world a better place for our children to grow in. We are educating our children better and teaching them the right principles on how to treat a human being or treating an animal. That goes a long way to making the world a better place to live in.

And RSAMommaCyndi, i also do not get your point. You rambling on and on and I do not get it. Stop using derogatory remarks against the protesters who are fighting a cause. And start doing something more constructive. I dont know if you have children but i think you need to examine your views and what you are teaching your children.

After all circuses are aimed at children, this is the target market and we need to take a hard look and review what we want to subject our children to. I will never take my kids to an animal circus!
Avatar

ToniBrockhoven

Posted 298 days ago
well said. but it is not that there are 'greater' causes out there, just different. ultimately those defending animals are benefitting people too, as how we treat animals results in how we treat people in some way or another. Callous disregard for the voiceless, in the form of animals, often leads to callous disregard for the human voiceless, children and the aged. And then everyone in between.

marianajfe

Posted 298 days ago
Avatar
Quite correct Toni - different not greater - better wording thanks!

Slamdance

Posted 298 days ago
Avatar
Wild animals are not on earth for our entertainment. Humans want, so humans get regardless of how the animal feels. If you had a choice would you be OK with living in a cage and been dragged across the country day in and day out only to be fed and given medical attention when required. Or would you prefer to roam the open bush land forage, socialize with your own kind, reproduce and raise your children. Given those two choices ask yourself what would the elephant choose?
Do yourself a favor and go and visit the retirement village these animals get after performing there whole lives, take a look at the LION park owned by the circus this is what these animals have to look forward to. All their hard earned cash, Just ask Carte Blanche how disgusting the conditions are at the center. If you still feel that it is OK and the children loved the show then seriously we do not come from the same species known as HUMAN and strongly feel that you are heartless and have no conscience. We will fight this fight with your support or not. Rather support a human circus oh wait they are very expensive as people demand payment.

RhyanRudman

Posted 298 days ago
Avatar
Would the Mr Boswell like to join the discussion or has the lion got his tongue?

SteveSmit

Posted 298 days ago
Avatar
Just gotta take issue with RSA MommaCyndi. Won't waste time making the case against using wild animals in the circus. Its been made over and over again and anyone with half a brain understands it. Whether you care enough to do something about it is another matter altogether. Your comments are more "Malema" than you would care to admit. Whilst you might be "against the use of animals in the entertainment industry", you obviously don't have a problem with poor journalism, as is the case with this article. Just the title of the article, "Animal activists storm circus", alone is ridiculous and speaks volumes about the journalists lack of integrity. But it sure got you going! In your, or Memela's, wildest imaginings a collection of dedicated, spontaneously motivated, animal caring activists arriving at the circus site in ones and twos, a few larger groups with some even including their children, who then spread out on the other side of the road and actually never even protested directly outside the circus gate of even in the car park adjacent to the circus site, could be accused of "storming" anything, never mind Brian Boswell's circus. Come on! Get real! And you really think one can take anything seriously that this journalist writes? Well, you obviously do because through your points three to five your comments show that either you don't get the misrepresentations in the article, or else you just think you are on a good platform to knock animal activists and you don't care what excuse you use to do it. Or maybe both!

petervenables

Posted 295 days ago
Avatar
Both the Activists and Boswell Circus are right.
Any animal living under conditions as imposed by circuses, zoos or similar is abusive and cruel.
That is indisputable.
Boswell Circus is legally entitled to run his business as are zoos.
That is indisputable.
Avatar

Slamdance

Posted 295 days ago
So if we all unite behind the rights of these animals we can change legislation......