Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 40855.89
    DOWN -2.34%
    Top 40 : 3351.01
    DOWN -3.17%
    Financial 15 : 11688.69
    DOWN -2.36%
    Industrial 25 : 46366.22
    DOWN -2.21%

  • ZAR/USD : 9.5279
    DOWN -0.41%
    ZAR/GBP : 14.3939
    UP 0.09%
    ZAR/EUR : 12.3262
    UP 0.33%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.0935
    UP 0.79%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.2834
    UP 0.30%

  • Gold : 1392.6300
    UP 1.79%
    Platinum : 1462.5000
    DOWN -0.17%
    Silver : 22.6750
    UP 1.81%
    Palladium : 740.5000
    DOWN -0.07%
    Brent Crude Oil : 102.550
    DOWN -0.05%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Thu May 23 20:58:48 SAST 2013

MPs give school catch-up plan a 'fail'

DENISE WILLIAMS | 08 August, 2012 00:1930 Comments
File photo
Image by: BRETT STEELE

The Department of Basic Education was sent packing yesterday by angry MPs who rejected its catch-up plan for Limpopo schoolchildren affected by the textbook shortage.

The MPs described the plan as an "insult'' to the pupils and to parliament.

Briefing the basic education portfolio committee, Trish Watson of the department's special projects division outlined a plan to be implemented in Limpopo in line with a court order.

But MPs deemed the plan "vague", "nowhere near adequate" and as lacking in urgency.

The department and its minister, Angie Motshekga, have come under severe criticism over the failure to get textbooks to thousands of pupils more than halfway into the school year.

Even the ANC has condemned the failure. Secretary-general Gwede Mantashe said last week: "The NEC also considered the lack of delivery of books in Limpopo shocking and unacceptable, and believes whoever is found to be responsible must face stern action that might include criminal charges."

The catch-up plan offered by Motshekga's department yesterday included:

  • Setting up boot camps in preparation for trial Grade 12 examinations that take place in September;
  • Establishing a "Winnings Team" programme to support maths and science teaching at 590 underperforming schools; and
  • Providing "Mind Gap" study guides in four subjects - life sciences, accounting, geography and economics.

The department said it also planned to create "war rooms" in each district of Limpopo, where schools would submit bi-weekly reports to the district, the province and to the national office.

But MPs dismissed the plan, saying it did not deal specifically with the challenges in Limpopo.

ANC MP Nomalungelo Gina proposed that the report be rejected and that the department be called before the committee again next week to provide further details about the impact of the textbook crisis on pupils and detailed plans to remedy the situation.

"It's really not what we were expecting. I propose that we leave this for today," she said.

Silence Makhubela, an ANC MP from Limpopo, said the plan did not address the specific requirements of the province, but sounded more like routine work the department undertook in all provinces to ensure pupils were up to date with the curriculum.

DA education spokesman Annette Lovemore was more scathing, saying the plan provided little detail on steps to be taken to ensure support for pupils affected by the textbook shortage.

"We reject this. It's nowhere near adequate and it's an insult to ourselves and the Limpopo pupils."

Lovemore said the two senior officials who made the presentation did not provide parliament with a coherent plan to get Limpopo out of the crisis.

"We were disappointed by the quality of the presentation today and by the fact that the two deputy directors-general were unable to answer a number of key questions posed by committee members. [These included] whether all pupils now have access to textbooks, whether additional tuition will be provided for affected pupils and how implementation 'of the plan] will be monitored," she said.

There have been numerous calls for the axing of Motshekga, whom many blame for the poor handling of the textbook crisis.

The minister, in turn, has blamed the crisis on sabotage by service providers contracted to deliver the books - this after thousands of books were found dumped.

The furore has led Motshekga to open a hotline to establish how many schools are still waiting for textbooks. She also announced that a plan was being drawn up to help affected pupils catch up academically.

But IFP MP Alfred Mpontshane called yesterday for heads to roll, saying the department did not display seriousness in the plan it presented to the parliamentary committee yesterday.

"I don't get the sense of the urgency of things. Please can we get that sense [and] of what actually went wrong. As a committee, we would like to hold those people accountable."

The acting deputy directorgeneral for Basic Education, Paddy Padayachee, was unable to answer many of the committee's questions, or shed light on what the impact of the crisis had been.

"Once we answer one question we have to answer all of them and some require a detailed response," he said.

These, Padayachee promised, would be responded to in writing.

"We take our presentation seriously. If there's any fall-out then we need to stand by it," he said.

Portfolio committee chairman Hope Malgas ordered that the department report to parliament again next week with a more detailed plan.

"What was expected was some kind of programme of action with the time frames attached."

She said a report following an oversight visit to the province would also be on the table when the committee and the department met again.

"In that report we are going to make people uncomfortable . By next week we should have a complete picture on Limpopo," Malgas said.

To submit comments you must first

Join the discussion & Debate

MPs give school catch-up plan a 'fail'

For Commenters Consideration | Please stick to the subject matter

COMMENTS [30]

BornintheRSA

Posted 288 days ago
Avatar
Give the jobs of Minister of Education, deputy and MEC's to professional educational experts with managerial skills. Start with Prof Jansen as Minister of Education, let him appoint the rest.

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 288 days ago
Avatar
It is AUGUST.

Unless they can find a time machine or miraculously create a couple of months between now and the end of the year, a 'catch up' plan is never going to work. This is going to have to be spaced to cover next year as well with exams in the province delayed until March at the earliest.

The spaza shop mentality has got to stop, This is the futures of our children and our country that we are faced with.
Avatar

Theye

Posted 288 days ago
And this is all that these kids have got to look forward to is spaza shops . This generation will be called "the Loose cigarette Generation"
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 288 days ago
That is only if they have been lucky enough to learn to count well enough to make change. The old 'hewers of wood and drawers of water' idea seems to have caught on with our Minister.

How many 'lost generations' can SA have before something gives?
Avatar

Theye

Posted 288 days ago
It has given. The Loose cigarrete generation are starting to riot already. And the ANC have only two choices, stop them and lose popularity or join them and blame apartheid and verword and the whites. From what happened with the spear painting they have made their choice. It;s the whites fault
Avatar

DonaldKnight

Posted 284 days ago
Oh, Momma, you're so right...it's thoroughly exasperating. There are only three or four months of the school year left. I teach in Taiwan, where the textbooks for the next academic year, which begins on August 30th, were already at the schools before I left for the summer vacation on July 1st.

Mike123

Posted 288 days ago
Avatar
So I guess Angie gives herself another 8 out of 10?
Avatar

Thuka-Thuka

Posted 288 days ago
9.5. C'mon, she's come up with a plan....!!
Avatar

KafreeMoneykey

Posted 288 days ago
@Mike...the numbers 3 and 8 have a tendency to look similar especially if your handwriting isnt that great, which might be a possibility for Angie!

I do not understand why people are going on and on about Angie, she failed several times and we personally took her department to task when she was the Gauteng MEC for education. Angie is a politician through and through, a useless and powerful one that is. Remember it was the same Angie who attempted to abolish the home schooling system which was against the human rights as prescribed on the UN Convention. This was the same Angie who when Minister Pandor called on the indaba/conference for all the MEC's of education she did not attend and went on to support Zuma during one of his trials in Bloemfontein, remember that incident? When she was asked why didnt she attend the conference she said she was working for the ANC, nothing happened to her as always...But wait a minute, the same ANCYL who is complaining now wanted Minister Pandor removed coz she voiced her valid concernes around Angie's conduct...

Let us reverse back to check the conduct of the DA at the time...They were given timelines to provide input into the Provincail Gazzete on education and wait a minute, they too did not give any input and they had all sorts of excuses as to why they did not want improvement on the current education system as it stands. The know the real reasons behind the excuses they gave, at least they are now implementing the same things that were suppose to be done then in the Western Cape now...

So I will never vote for the DA and will no longer vote for my beloved ANC...

mbongwamugabe

Posted 288 days ago
Avatar
I regret the day Transkei joined this crazy, lawless,disfuntional,corrupt and incompetent state called South africa. I really wish there is way to reverse it,people of Transkei don't deserve to be part of this crazy nation. It's not fair at all to be subjected into this corrupt and crazy nation with no law.

Stirrer

Posted 288 days ago
Avatar
This catch-up plan will be exploited to the max by Angie's bosses (Sadtu)!
Sadtu will demand overtime rates (probably double-time) as they supplement their incomes by reluctantly attending these catch-up classes (which clashes with their drinking time).

nkosipeter

Posted 288 days ago
Avatar
No catch up plan will work if it is left to those who were supposed to do the job correctly in the first place.

Those folk are in their positions not because of their ability or because they care, but because they are political deployees who spend their time making the right noises and looking for any opportunity to ladle some gravy in their direction.

There is no hope for Limpopo school kids.

AFRICAis60%MUSLIM

Posted 288 days ago
Avatar
This is sad site to see! How on earth didn't teachers and the SGB not report on the unavailability of books and learning materials for affected grades. But again, how many of us would be rather happy by being remunirated for what we are employed to do and won't mind if the workload is lessned [willingly or due to circumstances]. I'm afraid that most of us would take the offer with two hands.

It takes a rather commited person/employee to sit their boss down and complain/make aware of the situation where the daily workload is lessining and seek for further intervention from management/boss.

However, essential services workers should never seek to lax and drag their feet at the expense of the future of our nation and the world as a whole.
Avatar

Theye

Posted 288 days ago
Muslim countries in Africa are constantly either religous dictatorships or in armed conflict with their own citizens who do not share their religous views. Aetheist and proud of not believing in fairies in the sky looking after us if we bow our heads.
Avatar

AFRICAis60%MUSLIM

Posted 288 days ago
Sir, worship/worship not, for your deeds on earth shall be accounted for! Do you truely believe that all that is on earth is all just a big coincidence, including you?

All people of the book are warned about Anti-God souls like you, it's just heart warming for me during this Holy month of Ramadan to chat you up. When I picked up the Noble Qur'an for guidence this morning, I CAME ACROSS A VERSE WARNING me not be like you, Alhamdulillah!

I'm so not going to go down/up to your level Aethiest. Enjoy life to the best of your ability, for me life is worshipping and performing my 5 daily prayers and giving charity to the best of my ability.

Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 288 days ago
Brainwashed by the islam religion......

It doesn’t matter whether you are Christian, Buddhist, Hindu, Jewish, or any other religion. If you are not a Muslim, you are the target of Muslim persecution.

You sincerely believe that you are the only people on earth who should be allowed a place under the sun !

Remind me of the flawed anc government !
Avatar

Khadaffi15833

Posted 288 days ago
@Theye & SuiGeneris

How did this whole education saga come to being misconstrued into religion saga? C'mon peeps, keep it within the article's context...your comments over religion of others are unwarranted!!

@Africais60%MUSLIM

Why do u even bother honouring their comments with a reply...

Lets keep to the topic here & leave religion alone!!
Avatar

Theye

Posted 288 days ago
I think if everyone started shoving there misguided religous beliefs on their avatar we would only be debating religion instead of the subject. io woke up this morning and open my porn mag and in it it guided me to a page where it said muslims will stone young women to death if they don't except arranged marriages. so i went on my knees and the fairy God mother said that I should not be like the muslim
Avatar

AFRICAis60%MUSLIM

Posted 288 days ago
Brainwashed? More like reverted [to Islam] if you ask me. I was a Idol worshipper, christian to be frank, and everything never made sense.

Firstly, how can one embrace a so called 'religion' that was used to oppress the black majority, talk about brainwashed!? Secondly, how can you call/name yourself after a messenger, Christ, Budha, Juda etc. and come to my house and claim you're God worshipping?

Here's a briefy about Islam: Muslims believe that God is one and incomparable and the purpose of existence is to love and serve God. Muslims also believe that Islam is the complete and universal version of a primordial faith that was revealed at many times and places before, including through Abraham, Moses and Jesus, whom they consider prophets.

And guess what, I'm actually loughing because Idol worshippers like you will never stand in debate with a Muslim. I love you for the sake of God though!

Timbuck10

Posted 288 days ago
Avatar
AAAAAHHHHHHHH!

Once again Motshekga and her band of MERRY PEOPLE think they can HOODWINK the public....

Will some PLEASE ....PRETTY PLEASE, put Motshekga and her Cronies in the Education Dept "OUT TO PASTURE".....

Appoint NON POLITICAL, QUALIFIED PROFESSIONALS to the positions.... and there will be NO PROBLEMS!!!!!!

They will firstly need to REPAIR what the ANC has BROKEN.... going to be difficult though!

Theye

Posted 288 days ago
Avatar
Before deployemt the ANC headquarters tell there cadre gang. Go out and steal as much as you lcan, you have the bank accounts you need to put our share in. When you are caught and the person catching you is white call him rascist, if it is a goody goody ANC member report him to us, we will deal with him. if you find that you are getting deeper into trouble blame verword. If you find that you cannot defend yourself from accusations of corruption any longer and the residents are rioting due to no service delivery call us immediately we will send in white cops to beat up a few resident and we should be able to blame white rascists for the problem that have occured. If all else fails we will get you out of jaoil for medical reason. But God forbid if you don"t give us our share of the tenders........ it;s cold outside the ANC
Avatar

mbongwamugabe

Posted 288 days ago
I blame your parents for not doing there job not you. Everybody has choice in this country use than winging here.
Avatar

MicaParis

Posted 288 days ago
''But God forbid if you don"t give us our share of the tenders........ it;s cold outside the ANC''
````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````
A very good one Comrade Theye, only a short minded idiot can deny the fact that the ANC is embarrassingly discriminating against white South African citizens, which is one of the vital factor which cause dismal perpetual distinct disunity and moral ''affair'' in our domestic society at large! All tenders are given undeservedly to politically connected inexperienced black South Africans who 89% of them registered their companies just three months before issuing of those tenders for the sake of the just that reason! Why do 95% of Government employees are blacks? Do not we have ''also'' capable white citizens who can equally do the job in terms of section 9 of our Constitution!? It is very foolish for our Comrades to preach unity and reconciliation by word of mouth but failing meticulously in implementation of their false hypocritical political gospel! We would like to remind our ANC Comrades that Western Cape is still one of the Provinces of South Africa as enshrined on section 103 (1)(i), coupled with section1 (d) of our Constitution! We want to urgently call our President and Comrades to order by reminding them to stop sabotaging our precious Province notwithstanding the fact that they should immediately stop regarding Western Cape as 'Europe' in South Africa, we do not have a 'state within a state' in South Africa. Comrades should not confuse a 'trial within a trial' in court proceedings with a 'state within a state' in terms of none constitutional substance. Time to hide behind affirmative action and general Black Empowerment has passed it's sell by date! If Comrades deny this than they should explain black and white children who were born in 1993, are they not the same in economic and social substance and advantages!!?? I am an ANC Cadre who is committed to true unity in our distinct diversity!!
Avatar

Theye

Posted 288 days ago
mbong i would love to comment on your comment but i haven't a frigging clue what you said

MicaParis

Posted 288 days ago
Avatar
The future of our children had been compromised so fatally by the President and the Minister, we will never ever reverse the situation nor recover the knowledge and the precious time that our children has lost as there is no use to cry over spilled milk! We want to assure our poor and marginalized citizens who cannot take their kids to Schools in USA and Britain (like Zuma and Angie) due to financial constrains that Jacob, Angie, Cassel and Dickson will never ever be forgiven for this kind of a degrading merciless mess! To some of us this brings an emotional pain and stress as we know where and how the movement and our black society suffered and come from! It is very embarrassing and too down-low to witness in disbelieve our most trusted Comrades taking their own blood and souls as ''cheap material'' which deserve ''toilet'' wilderness dumping in a very careless disrespectful manner! We are tired of hyenas who are wearing the leather of the colours of the ANC ''gesturing'' as hopefuls and faithfuls in search of self enrichment and fame so that they can sleep with all the models in the world and explore their global and domestic sexual fantasies with the tax payers money under the banner of the ANC as their scapegoat, singing false opportunistic hypocritical struggle tunes in the name of 'service delivery' and false financially inclined honesty and deceitful passion to our historic movement! Time will come in the ANC were we will directly deal with this lot of dung and gut! We will spew them out of our movement to the dismay of their disbelieve! Away with illiterate tsotsis and taxi drivers in our precious movement! Alluta!!! Time to get rid of hyenas in the leather colours of the ANC is now!
Avatar

Theye

Posted 288 days ago
Viva Viva. There is an easy way of doing this . Don't vote for them. vote for anyone but them. If soiuth Africa was a zoo ( not saying it isn't) the vulture would be in power.

InExile

Posted 288 days ago
Avatar
This is beyond contempt for the constitution. It is beyond contempt of Court. It is a betrayal of the trust of a generation of innocent children: a hard won trust that the highly paid public servants in high places would earn their remuneration by simply doing their jobs.
It will not be remedied by this year or next. For them it will never be remedied. Someone will have to explain to them soon why multi-billion Rand arms deals were needed by a country at peace with the outside world but squandering it's children's future.
Cry The Beloved Country for the unborn child who will inherit the consequences this betrayal and for the memories of heroes past that are being treasoned.

Theye

Posted 288 days ago
Avatar
Cry the beloved country that our reward for breaking the shackles of Apartheid was the ANC. The tears of shame are running down the faces of our dead heroes while our present hero, Zuma's only concern is that he weaqrs out his pants Zip to fast.

KafreeMoneykey

Posted 288 days ago
Avatar
Party leader Helen Zille wrote, “…we in the Western Cape have experienced Minister Angie Motshekga as one of the few – perhaps the only – education ministers since the dawn of democracy 18 years ago who genuinely understands the needs of the school system and is prepared to take some tough decisions to fix it. She stands virtually alone, in the wasteland of education's ‘shell state’, where many incompetent cadres masquerade as top officials with fancy titles, but have little understanding of and even less commitment to the needs of education.”

Thank you Helen, but you know exactly what you have done 7 years ago. You could have asssisted in making those decisions 7 years ago when Angie was still the Gauteng MEC for Education, mind calling Tony Leon and ask him for that blatant indecision?

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 288 days ago
Avatar
"There is no place for [the Bantu] in the European community above the level of certain forms of labour ... What is the use of teaching the Bantu child mathematics when it cannot use it in practice? That is quite absurd. Education must train people in accordance with their opportunities in life, according to the sphere in which they live." - Hendrik Verwoerd.

The difference, if any, between the above and the current ruling elite conception of education, is cosmetic. Verowoerd's idea seems even more sensible than the current complete control of mental life for total subservience through patronage. What was referred to as 'Bantu' elite has used its political right to achieve its own freedom. The economic inequality between them and the voting human terminals has become so great to enable it to exert decisive political influence over the rest of society. It will not let people free as long as dependence on 'leaders' yields the maximum vote. And so education does not amount to any more than achieving a 80% matric pass in mathematically downgraded exams. "Education must train people in accordance with their opportunities in life, according to the sphere in which they live". People will remain 'free' as long as they are obsequious and readily respond positively to the 'leader's' commands.