Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 41603.28
    DOWN -0.51%
    Top 40 : 3423.68
    DOWN -0.57%
    Financial 15 : 11930.71
    DOWN -0.58%
    Industrial 25 : 47228.71
    DOWN -0.90%

  • ZAR/USD : 9.5126
    DOWN -0.36%
    ZAR/GBP : 14.3481
    DOWN -0.83%
    ZAR/EUR : 12.2934
    DOWN -0.29%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.0924
    DOWN -0.87%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.2757
    DOWN -0.95%

  • Gold : 1386.0000
    UP 0.88%
    Platinum : 1468.0000
    UP 0.76%
    Silver : 22.6253
    UP 0.78%
    Palladium : 749.5000
    UP 1.28%
    Brent Crude Oil : 103.260
    DOWN -0.63%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Wed May 22 13:19:12 SAST 2013

MPs: medical parole a sham

THABO MOKONE | 08 August, 2012 00:1943 Comments
Jackie Selebi. File photo.
Image by: The Times

Members of parliament yesterday slammed the government's release of Jackie Selebi, saying it tainted the credibility of the medical parole system.

MPs told Correctional Services Minister Sibusiso Ndebele that the release had not been transparent.

Selebi was released from Pretoria Central Prison on the recommendation of the 11-member Medical Parole Advisory Board so that he could receive treatment for kidney failure.

At the time of his release, Selebi had served only 229 days of the 15-year sentence handed down by the Johannesburg High Court for corruption.

Questions over his release persist, with critics suggesting he enjoyed preferential treatment because of his political credentials.

DA MP James Selfe said Selebi's release could not be divorced from that of fraudster Schabir Shaik, who was said to be "terminally ill".

"The real problem that we face in this system is around the credibility of the medical parole system as a whole . because what we have is a very clear situation of a particularly high-profile member of the ruling party who is as fit as a fiddle and swans around Durban playing golf and living the high life.

"So when another high-profile member of the ruling party is released on medical parole, you have a credibility problem. The person on the street does not believe that the system works properly," Selfe said.

Another MP, Bushy Mnguni of COPE, said the legitimacy of medical parole had become tainted.

"We must try to resuscitate [it] and to make it fair," said Mnguni.

But the national commissioner of Correctional Services, Tom Moyane, defended Selebi's parole, saying it had followed the law to the letter.

He said the parole board, a statutory body of the department led by Dr Victor Ramathesele, had overseen the entire process to release Selebi.

"In this particular instance, I believe we have done what is acceptable by law, and within the parameters of ethics within which we practise," said Moyane.

"I would like to believe that had it not been because of the profile of the individual, it could have been something different . but I say that the treatment of inmates is equal before all correctional officials in our department."

Moyane said that in the same month Selebi was released, the parole board had considered 12 requests for medical parole, including from three applicants who had died while their documentation was being processed.

No application had been received from Clive Derby-Lewis, who is serving life for the murder of SACP leader Chris Hani, Moyane said.

Derby-Lewis's wife, Gaye, has told The Times she would apply for her husband to be released on medical parole on the grounds that he has prostate cancer.

To submit comments you must first

Join the discussion & Debate

MPs: medical parole a sham

For Commenters Consideration | Please stick to the subject matter

COMMENTS [43]

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 287 days ago
Avatar
No wonder our poor cops are so demotivated that many of them don't even bother any more. It took them more time to get Selebi into jail than he spent there.

By the way, if parole is granted on the basis of someone having a disease or condition that is incurable, does that mean that (theoretically) every rapist who is HIV positive is eligible?
Avatar

nkosipeter

Posted 287 days ago
Nice one Momma. FYI parole (medical or otherwise) is granted on the basis of who you know.

Avatar

Thuka-Thuka

Posted 287 days ago
Frankly, we shouldn't bother with even having the court case. What we should do is give the perpetrator the equivalent of half of the court costs and send him/her on his/her way.... Oh wait. That happens anyway right?

Stirrer

Posted 287 days ago
Avatar
All healthy incarcerated people doing time, should toyi-toyi about the release of "sick" fellow-inmates! It's not fair - besides spending more on "sick" prisoners (medical expenses in prison), the "sick" also get fast-tracked for release from the penitentiary.
It's not the healthy prisoners' faults that they didn't "draw bad card" in the health stakes!

mbongwamugabe

Posted 287 days ago
Avatar
I dont see a reason why Ndebele has to be questioned if parole is given to an african soul. If Selebi was pale skinned there will be no noise from these Da MP's.
Avatar

seablot

Posted 287 days ago
playing the race card early?
Avatar

mbongwamugabe

Posted 287 days ago
seablot

Let it be that the fact become race into your narrow mind pel.
Avatar

SamuelMagana

Posted 287 days ago
pulling the race card it shows how ignorant and how in denial you are
Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 287 days ago
mbong

Next time you post here, please make sure that you string at least three words together, and in the right sequence, to form an intelligent sentence.

Avatar

mbongwamugabe

Posted 287 days ago
SamuelMagana

let it be why care? you dont know me, i dont wanna know you loser.
Avatar

TDM1

Posted 287 days ago
Racist much!!! Got a chip on your shoulder. Would you like some sugar water with your dummy. Has nothing to do with race, Selebi was found guilty, appealed, still guilty, sentenced to 15 years and released in 229 days. With, I might add, a very serious kidney disorder. BOOHOO shame poor old Jackie. From Police King to crying little boy in hospital!!!
Avatar

mbongwamugabe

Posted 287 days ago
TDM1

I doubt if i am here to teach you anything but i awaiting for new dictionary that describe racist. Feel free to call me whatever your views are not relevent to me. If african should rot in jail till their die then it should be the same to pale skinned.
Avatar

TDM1

Posted 286 days ago
Judging by how you write, you certainly won't be teaching me anything. Listen chap, and listen carefully, the story IS ABOUT JACKIE'S DUBIOUS MEDICAL PAROLE, okay, not black or white or whatever you read into it. Does not matter whether he is green with purple spots, he was found guilty, after appealing still guilty and he should be in jail with his buddies. I know of prisoners who are a lot worse than this pr1ck but who are just ignored. And they are black by the way. So don't play your only card in life, you joker
Avatar

mbongwamugabe

Posted 286 days ago
TDM1

I, the son of the soil is waiting for all pale skinned criminals who committed atricities against us to be jail. How many hollocost did we had in this country? Women were butchered, Sophiatown,innocent children were brutally killed in 1976, family man and women were jailed to life and sent to Robern Island with no sinns but fighting for their freedom and some were braai in Port Elizabeth. No one was arrested and we should just forget and pretend nothing happened. Sorry man i dont get you.
Avatar

mbongwamugabe

Posted 286 days ago
TDM1

I forget to tell you that you shouldn't be worried on how i write, i will never ask you to feed me or my family.
Avatar

TDM1

Posted 286 days ago
So basically you want all white people either dead or in jail. Okay so now we have gotten to the bottom of your problem. You live with hate, some serious hate. Apartheid was evil and cruel, no doubt. No-one is above anyone, we are all the same. But you my man need to go and see someone, speak out, scream ,shout do whatever you need to do to get rid of your hate. It must be eating you up inside. I am AFRICAN too, born and raised, I have AFRICAN blood, but alas, I am white. Dam what you gonna do now. Guess that p1ssed you off!!!
Avatar

mbongwamugabe

Posted 286 days ago
TDM1

shame you must be crazy to thing you can make me p ssed off. Please read and understand what i said not what you want to hera from me.

seablot

Posted 287 days ago
Avatar
This is wrong and makes a complete joke of our justice system. There is no accountability for wrong doing it seems if you are connected to JZ...Banana republic stuff indeed. wake up South Africa!

AnotherTaxPayer

Posted 287 days ago
Avatar
Personally the only thing that would make us believe in the true merit of the working medical parole system is when Shaik is re-arrested and brought back to prison and a full medical exam is done on him to check how his terminaly ill condition got fixed so quickly.

Then on the other hand you have Derby-lewis that probably spent more time in jail than Selebi and Shaik combined that is left without parole....check and balance...
Avatar

mbongwamugabe

Posted 287 days ago
Personally the only thing that would make me believe in the true merit is to see all those committed worse atrocity toward african being jail or hang.
Avatar

Thuka-Thuka

Posted 287 days ago
@mbongwamugabe - presumably you're including Angie and the rest of the education dept in your statement?
Avatar

ByronSmit

Posted 287 days ago
Whoa hold on, if one African does something wrong to another African, and that African has to be hung, then should the person who hangs the African also be hung? And if so, I would like to be last on the list of people who have to hang someone who has wronged an African!
Avatar

mbongwamugabe

Posted 287 days ago
Thuka-Thuka
Posted 16 minutes ago

Yep including your idol with 783 charges hanging over him.
Avatar

Thuka-Thuka

Posted 287 days ago
My idol? Brilliant. Actually, he sings quite well, he should be an idol....
Avatar

mbongwamugabe

Posted 287 days ago
ByronSmit
Posted 9 minutes ago
Whoa hold on, if one African does something wrong to another African, and that African has to be hung, then should the person who hangs the African also be hung? And if so, I would like to be last on the list of people who have to hang someone who has wronged an African!
..

You not making sense what do you mean by something wrong because self was taking about atrocities committed by pale to african.
Avatar

AnotherTaxPayer

Posted 287 days ago
@ mbongwamugabe explain how dying from a bullet is different from dying from hunger?
Think a bit about who's in power and who's doing what to who?

This incident has nothing to do with race or ethnic groups. This is the release of criminals that are politicly connected and spent more time in a comfy hospital bed than a cold cell doing their time for their crime....That's the real issue
Avatar

mbongwamugabe

Posted 287 days ago
AnotherTaxPayer

I am not condoning the release of criminals but what about those criminals who never set foot in jail after their atrocities toward africans?
Avatar

AnotherTaxPayer

Posted 287 days ago
@ mbongwamugabe
hence we have a police chief in jail. He did not bother to find those people you're talking about. He was more interested in the next line of crocodile leather shoes in a high end shop in sandton than chasing criminals. The fact that he had one of the biggest criminals as a close friend was even more worrying. But sad to say I agree with you. All criminals should do the time for their crime..It's the law of this country.
Avatar

mbongwamugabe

Posted 287 days ago
AnotherTaxPayer

The problem with this website[asikhulume] is that some snobs would like anyone believe their version of things but reject other views as if their views are more important than anyone else. But that might come to end sooner than they wish,i am the reason why blockers can't use certain words[valgar,abuse etc] here. I trust myself to clean again all these snobs again from this website.
Avatar

ppss

Posted 286 days ago
@mbongwamugabe stop pretending to be an intellectual. you argue from the point of view of race only when race has absolutely nothing to do with the issue at hand. and hitting the "report comment" button whenever you come across an opinion you don't like only makes you look like a child.
Avatar

mbongwamugabe

Posted 286 days ago
ppss

I never claim anything here but i am african that i am so of, you shold stop assumptions about other people. i don't give damn about you or what you say.

Theye

Posted 287 days ago
Avatar
Guys i don't want to be funny here but all you people commenting on mbonwamugabe post tend to start sounding like him. Stupid. he is is calaas A example of the mentality that leads the ANc don't get caught up in his ignorance. It's dangerous for the well being of your own intelligence

Theye

Posted 287 days ago
Avatar
calaas A = class A ( for Mbonwamugabe)
Avatar

mbongwamugabe

Posted 287 days ago
Why you care what is what to self?

MicaParis

Posted 287 days ago
Avatar
We do not have any problem when everybody is given a medical parole by rule and procedure of legal and evident health reasoning! But however we do have a problem when the same equally inclined medical parole in terms of section 9 of the Constitution, is discriminatory in terms of political affiliation and friendship coupled with segregation in terms of a certain couler of our skins! We do not want to strategically replace the Group Areas Act with another form of totally unfair and illegal 'Comradeship' contaminated aroma in terms of politically quackmired rotten antics. We want to call ''our'' ANC Comrades to order by reminding them to stop advocating and protectively trying in fatal failure to defend none defenseless generally wrong antics thereby 'raping' our clearly defined clean Government correctional commitment! We would like to remind our cadres that the Government in terms of section 3(2)(c) and the Preamble of our Constitution belong equally to all South African citizens regardless of couler and political affiliation!

ILoveTheTruth

Posted 287 days ago
Avatar
In SA, whenever there is a problem, people always play the race card. What in heavens name does white people have to do with the stinking corruption of the current government? The problem at hand is the early release, on the basis of so-called medical parole, of connected people, not what white people did 18 or 300 years ago. We have to learn to forgive and work on growing up instead of always defending the imbeciles that is currently in power. It is tantamount to a person becoming a rapist or murderer, and when caught blames his parents for abusing him. No judge in his right mind will find such a person innocent, unless his name is Innocent, lol. As we grow up, we are supposed to be able to discern between good and evil. What happened to reconciliation? People must start fixing the evils that currently rules our society and not live in the past. And don't think I am white, I am not, I am just a person who knows that everyone has skeletons in their closets.

As for stinking corrupt politicians and co, their glory will be short-lived and their reward for eternity! Mark my words, I know what I'm talking about.

i_stub_born

Posted 287 days ago
Avatar
....It would be very interesting to know the qualifications of the doctors recommending the parole on medical grounds. If they are MBChb(CLICKS)(SA)..........
Avatar

nkosipeter

Posted 287 days ago
Easy, Bangkok Univ, $5 mail order degree, no problem. (Same as Manto)

mthi4life

Posted 287 days ago
Avatar
When you give someone Medical Parole You must consider :
-The crime
-The danger to the public
-Recommendations from the Victim or Victims family
-Length of sentence
-If the inmate is physically incapable performing basic functions because of terminal illness or other reasons
-There are means of taking care of the inmate outside prison.
So Clive Derby-Lewis will loose on the first three points.







































































































































































































Avatar

nandima

Posted 286 days ago
sorry, the parole board recommended the release on medical parole for clive derby lewis but your own politician overruled it, unfair?
Avatar

nandima

Posted 286 days ago
sorry, the parole board last year recommended the release on medical parole for clive derby lewis but your own politician overruled it, unfair?

i_stub_born

Posted 286 days ago
Avatar
....and before all those, the most important is whether you are ANC Mafia member, and who you know, so....that other criminal cannot qualify.............

nandima

Posted 286 days ago
Avatar
we need to go there to release clive derby lewis by force since the very same parole board recommended his release last year