Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 40784.31
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Top 40 : 3387.09
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Financial 15 : 11117.02
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Industrial 25 : 46858.79
    UNCHANGED0.00%

  • ZAR/USD : 10.1995
    UP 0.13%
    ZAR/GBP : 15.7674
    DOWN -0.01%
    ZAR/EUR : 13.5339
    DOWN -0.01%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.1055
    UP 0.08%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.4484
    DOWN -0.02%

  • Gold : 1347.2750
    UP 0.29%
    Platinum : 1417.5000
    UP 0.67%
    Silver : 21.2790
    UP 0.33%
    Palladium : 689.5000
    UP 0.07%
    Brent Crude Oil : 105.010
    DOWN -1.05%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Thu Jun 20 05:32:53 SAST 2013

Premier fumes at crisis

CHANDRÉ PRINCE | 15 August, 2012 00:14
Gauteng health MEC Hope Papo arrives at Charlotte Maxeke Johannesburg Academic Hospital for an emergency meeting with Premier Nomvula Mokonyane yesterday Picture: ALON SKUY

"On the Mail & Guardian scorecard, Nomvula will get a ZZ. As a political head, I come across as stupid. I'm not going to apologise because I did my part. We should take collective responsibility."

With these harsh words Gauteng Premier Nomvula Mokonyane ended an almost four-hour emergency meeting with the provincial health MEC and medical staff at the embattled Charlotte Maxeke Johannesburg Academic Hospital last night.

Mokonyane, health MEC Hope Papo and the hospital's CEO, Barney Selebano, cleared their hectic diaries yesterday to convene a crisis meeting after a damning report in The Times on life-threatening conditions at the hospital.

A highly irritable Mokonyane spared no one, including her own political staff, for having given her the impression that everything was under control at the hospital.

Yesterday, The Times published shocking details of doctors forced, at times, to play God and decide which patients should be resuscitated and which turned away.

In some cases, doctors have had to compromise patients' safety because the equipment needed to perform sensitive operations, including brain and heart surgery, was either not working or not available.

Mokonyane said she had instructed her staff to give hospital CEOs delegation powers and that she had been assured they had been sent letters about two weeks ago informing them of the decision.

Some of the hospital's problems stem from procurement being handled at provincial offices instead of the hospital.

"I think you guys are not fair to us, really . it is insubordination. Who in hell would delay such things," Mokonyane lashed out at the health department officials at the meeting at Charlotte Maxeke.

"My frustration is that I came here because I could not understand why you [doctors] are complaining."

Her reaction follows yesterday's exposé of letters written by 12 heads of department at the hospital highlighting critical shortages of medical staff and life-saving equipment, compromising patients' lives and safety.

The premier said she had been "shocked" when she had received a call yesterday morning to tell her of the reports about Charlotte Maxeke.

"It can't be Women's Month and we talk and honour Charlotte Maxeke . and this is happening here. I told myself I had to come here," she said.

On August 4, President Jacob Zuma delivered a memorial lecture in honour of Maxeke, a founding member of the ANC Women's League and apartheid activist after whom the hospital was named. It was previously Johannesburg Hospital.

Mokonyane warned her staff that they should take their jobs seriously and that everything was ultimately about the hospital's patients.

"I'm sitting here today and I'm shocked at what I'm hearing."

She warned that those appointed in the health department should be less concerned about getting their government cellphones and personal assistants and instead focus on what their jobs entailed.

After listening to complaints from several doctors, Mokonyane said she understood their frustration, but did not appreciate their going to the media.

"Now you are going to the media. I don't agree . each one of us must take our job seriously. My plea is for professionals to become part of that [fixing the problems]."

One doctor, however, told her: "We are very frustrated. We knock our heads against the wall. It's hard not to get demotivated."

Mokonyane vowed that the problems plaguing the hospital would be dealt with immediately - no matter what.

"We are going to create time to fix them."

Mokonyane gave clear instructions on how she wanted Papo, Selebano and the finance department to sort out the problems.

Meetings will be held later this week and on Friday next week, where Papo will have to present "the way forward".

Mokonyane said: "Go and find a solution to our problems.

"I want a plan on how we are going to deal with vacancies, maintenance, equipment and consumables. We are going to make time after hours. Let's tackle these things as they come," she instructed.

Citing a complete turnaround strategy that sorted out problems at Chris Hani-Baragwanath Hospital, Mokonyane said this should be used as a benchmark: "Bara is in control of what it needs."

Doctors at the Charlotte Maxeke meeting praised the premier, saying she was "very supportive and very open".

They said it was "amazing how, within hours of the newspaper hitting the stands, the meeting was convened for 2pm".

"The equipment and consumables may continue to be a problem but at least we will have staff," one of the doctors told the premier.

It is believed that extra money that had been given to Chris Hani Bara has been lent to Charlotte Maxeke. The hospital received only a R1.17-billion budget from the Gauteng health department despite requesting R2.6-billion for this financial year. Gauteng health spokesman Simon Zwane said: "As a department, we would like to fill the posts as soon as we can find suitable candidates. There will be a gradual process of filling critical vacant posts not only at Charlotte Maxeke but at other hospitals."

Advocacy group Section 27, which took the national Department of Education to court earlier this year over its failure to deliver textbooks to Limpopo, called for adequate budgeting for hospitals based on the burden of disease and patient numbers treated.

Spokesman Sha'ista Goga said: "Each time a crisis hits the newspapers, instead of addressing the underlying issues related to overspending, the Gauteng department of health first denies there is a problem. Then it shifts spending from one area to another, effectively fighting fires rather than addressing the core issues with a structured attempt to develop a realistic needs-based budget that facilitates the delivery of healthcare services to the public."

SHARE YOUR OPINION

If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.

Gormogon1

Posted 308 days ago
Avatar
I am very pleased that something is being done, and that perhaps some butt will be kicked and fools fired. However, put the right people into these positions of authority, and maybe these things will be curtailed, before they get out of hand as in this case, and others. Lives are being lost because idiots are placed into these critical positions.

MicaParis

Posted 308 days ago
Avatar
Corruption and nepotism are the root of all this ill inherited evil! What is needed is an understanding of the political, social, cultural, economic and psychological factors that coalesce to make corruption possible, even “desirable”, and eventually endemic. In simple terms, what turns an otherwise “good” person into a corrupt one? Or, in common current public discourse parlance: what turns a liberation hero into a tenderpreneur?

In practical terms, we need to set new standards, we need to deal decisively and demonstratively with the corrupters amongst us and, yes, we need to do the same for the corrupt and the corrupted. Everyone recognises that South Africa has the gold, or at least, silver medal for an unequal society.
The battle against corruption must be fought as part of the war against inequality. The apparently common wisdom that to overcome inequity we must uplift those at the bottom end of the scale is only half the war.
It is only by finding a way to bring down to some sort of reality the indulgent standards set for those at the upper end of the scale that we can begin to remove the temptations and the sheer panicked search for equity that drive the untrammelled consumptive urge and thus the conditions that allow corruption to thrive.
Avatar

muk1

Posted 308 days ago
@MicaParis. I read your comments regularly and keen to hear your views. These problems we have of nepotism, corruption and unequality in living standards is not unique. Look at China, India and Brazil. I know that India definitely has the same problems like us. My take is that we are killing the goose (the middle class) that lays the golden egg; by spending millions on grants to bring up the living standards of the poor. We should provide mass employment (like the NATS did with IScor, Escom, railways etc.) without the interference of unions and all the red tape that goes with firing incompetent staff.

The premier need to do more than just pay lip service to the problems in the health sector. Hopefully the people that let her down will take heed and correct the situation. I for one would like to see at least ONE head to roll; to set an example of what happens to heads that don't make servicing Joe public their priority.
Avatar

RobtMugabe99

Posted 308 days ago
@muk1


Im quiet certain you not clear what you talk about, for you to bring back the administration model of NATS to democratic dispensation is ill advised.

The issue of firing has no problem if you bothered yourself to read LRA ,95 for me you quick to point fingers at someone yet you are incompetent yourself to read LRA,95 what it entails. The employer should follow the procedures correctly unless you tell us the employer must just wake up and tell the employee to take his/her begs and leave like your NATS did.

Plse read LRA,95 Chapter VIII and stop being incompetent yourself.

On the issue of ISCor,Eskom etc, remember you are talking about an old era of industrialisation today we are living in an era of technology where production is automated. Again you fail to realise that it was your NATS model that did nt emphasise the importance of education , specifically amongst blacks, who would be self employed if De Klerk as Min of Education did priorities education and learning

I must say that if this country has someone like you is destined for failure, we need people who are creative and innovative unlike waste like yourself
Avatar

muk1

Posted 308 days ago
@RobtMugabe99

Sjoe brother, you are right to educat me. No, I did not read the LRA Chapter 8; but I know of the lengthy process to dismiss an incompentant staff that does not perform. I also know that our country needs to employ people left right and centre. How do we do this without mass employment? Is not BEE a thinly veiled policy (akin to NATS policy) of empowering the previously disenfranchised? I did not say that we should adpot the entire policy of the NATS model; which was disguisting.
Avatar

Wiseguy

Posted 308 days ago
Again MicaParis, you amaze me with your insightful, honest, clear and broad thinking!
The solution is not so simple but would include the following:
1) Motivating the chain of command to a common goal.....Madiba did this! To me that ultimate goal must be "empowering the people" and "the country"!
2)Instilling a sense of pride and common purpose to All along the chain of command, to work hard, together for the good of the nation and its people.....creating a team approach with a common goal.
3)Creating a strong common bond of patriotism, where the country and its people are put FIRST....above any other agenda! We are after all ALL citizens of this country first.....regardless of political affiliation......and our politicians should and would do well to remember that....especially the ones that are appointed to senior government positions!
4)Choosing leaders correctly......those who lead by EXCELLENT example and to make absolutley sure their example is beyond reproach and in alignment with the above goals....again Madiba is the ultimate example of such a leader! And perhaps more importantly at this stage of our young democracy.....to take a strong and firm stand against ANY leader who sets a bad example with corruption, nepotism or cronyism or any other self-serving agenda that puts the people or country second! The words "you fired" must be used liberally and without fear or favour.....the people and the country MUST come first!!!
5)We need to reduce and even eradicate the animosity and this "us and them" mentality that plagues our democratic political enviroment.......the people and the country must be put first by ALL political parties and politicians. Indeed, if our main political parties could and should set an example of occasionally pulling together and working together successfully for the common good of the people and the country!!
6)There must be a common understanding across the political spectrum.....that ANY political leader or cadre or appointment who doesn't adhere to these simple principals.....will be ejected or disciplined immediately! There is NO place for rewarding PARTY loyalty to any political appointment who has been found to have a self-serving agenda.....indeed, examples MUST be made, and this "redeployment" MUST end !! Tribalism....with its "us and them" basis, must serve no part of ANY political movement, it is by its very nature undemocratic and should play no further part in the political landscape of this country, except to die a quick and certain death! By all means let the tribes have their leaders and respect them as much as they want, but unless these leaders are elected by democratic process, they should have no say in the governance of this country!
7) If anyone is found serving him/herself before the people/country.....there MUST be serious consequances! That includes the political BULLIES who would intimidate and bully their fellow politicians so they can achieve a self-serving agenda......no fear or favour should be considered.....the country and its people MUST come first!! ALWAYS!!

Well, thats my 2 cents worth.....and just a start!;)


Avatar

MicaParis

Posted 308 days ago
I totally share the same sentiments Comrades and could not have said it better myself. Comrade Bob Mugabe, there is no need to deny and advocate daylight current truth as we currently witness! We need to build up the common vicious idea and solutions for a better South Africa in our distinct diversity as fighting useless foolish ''off side'' political issues will render as both empty tins which spew noise like your current expressions which I oppositely ''respect'' for that matter. For prosperity, I would like Comrade Mugabe to think like a youth cabal who were born in 1990, there is no use to discriminate between DA and ANC for apparently no reason, it is futile and suicide to discriminate rich knowledge from the above comrades on political history while our Constitution at section 1 and the Preamble suggest against your middle aged thinking.
Avatar

AntoineRocher

Posted 308 days ago

MicaParis: the problem we have is that there is no consequence in SA when committing any type of crime. Recently the minister of defence resigned in Germany amid allegations of plagiarism in his PhD he did 20 years ago. In contrast to this our President who has standard 8 has still not being trialled for corruption in the arms deal...yes I know Germany was involved, but the German parties involved did not commit any crime in there jurisdiction.
I think (as a non-expert) the problem lies in the level of education and the (VERY liberal) justice system. A large portion of our society is just not at a level of education where you can expect them to have a social consciousness like first world countries. I sometimes think, we still need to have a "chop off a hand that steal" policy to fit our sense of social responsibility. Maybe a bit radical, but the current system is too radical in the opposite direction. I admit the problem possibly lies with implementing justice rather than the law itself. Being in the public orthopaedic medical sector, I can assure you if you clamp down on crime you’ll save millions of rand to plough back into crime prevention. All you need to do is to visit a main city public hospital on a Saturday night end of the month; you will see millions of tax payers’ money pouring out at drunken nonsense violence.

Jimbo56

Posted 308 days ago
Avatar
A far more positive, dare I say mature?, response than I had expected. Normal reaction to this kind of thing is to complain that staff had no right to let the cat out of the bag and to threaten all kinds of dire consequences which culminate in shooting the messenger.

So, off to good start to fix this problem....

BornintheRSA

Posted 308 days ago
Avatar
Minister Aaron Motsoaledi is a kind soul with good medical skills which would be better placed as a medical practitioner in the hospitals. He should not be a politician. He has not been able to reverse the damage done by his predecessor, instead he is encouraged to meddle with the private health sector which works (despite being expensive).
Nomvulo is also posturing because she can’t claim to have been unaware of this. It is not yesterday's problem, it should have been on her personal radar for years.

KafreeMoneykey

Posted 308 days ago
Avatar
Nomvula should take a leaf from Malusi Gigaba. He reduced the board of Transet and recently fired the board of SAA Express...

RobtMugabe99

Posted 308 days ago
Avatar
Having gone through the article critically I realised the problems at Charlott Maxeke hospital range around facilities,/equipments, procurement procedures, medical staff, cell phones, vacancies.

Having noted all these issues , I fail to understand why department of Health in GP does nt realise to recruit Zimbabweans professionals since we are at advantage in terms of currency.

On the issue of procurement yes indeed it should remain with hospital other than the provincial administration , unless someone in the provincial administration has interests to benefit otherwise in the procurement of these facilities which may lead a certain fool being implicated in corruption

The cell phones I never thought it should be such a major issue unless somebody was interested on the job that can provide cellphone,car and cash and forget about his/her responsibilities

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 308 days ago
Avatar
"..fighting fires rather than addressing the core issues.."

Exactly.

Nomvula should have known about this. It is her job to know. Unfortunately, overseas shopping trips and hairdressing appointments seem to be far more important to the MECs and Premiers than doing their jobs is.

Thank the gods for our media. Without them putting the issues onto the front pages, nothing would ever be done.
Avatar

Wiseguy

Posted 308 days ago
Exactly Momma and well said! Imagine if the secrecy bill had been passed.....the people would be suffering more and more!
Avatar

MicaParis

Posted 308 days ago
''Overseas shopping trips and hairdressing appointments seem to be far more important to the MECs and Premiers than doing their jobs is''
```````````````````````````````````````````````````````
I totally agree with you Comrade Momma, that is the most vital and desirable thing that our high profile Comrades enjoy and it will be very prosperous and of core value to our country for our Comrades to take the electorate serious before they actually turn their back against the ANC! The speed at which the public anger and impatience is currently travelling at will not last the ANC two terms to tolerate from now! The ANC will eventually collapse and obviously fade away to an everlasting extinction which will only be evidenced by the dark history books of our once glorious slowly ghost turning gigantic movement! An intelligent person who loves our precious movement should by now, be clearly sensing the fall of liberation heroin which is absolutely inevitable judging by the way Comrades are perpetually stealing for financial safety during looming dark ''face out'' which the ANC is currently seriously facing without any exception! The law of the nature as proved by Isaac Newton suggested that ''What ever goes up must ultimately come down'' This notion is inevitable for the ANC!
Avatar

i_stub_born

Posted 308 days ago
....??? HUH ????.......Good Heavens !!!!....ha ha ha ha ha ha........

chrish

Posted 308 days ago
Avatar
Nice Audi - that's R1.5m worth of vehicle that could have been put to better use at this hospital it sounds like. Eish.

sancy4

Posted 308 days ago
Avatar
" As a political head I come across as stupid."

Of course you do. Because you are. And arrogant. Stupidity and arrogance - not a good combination.
Avatar

Jimbo56

Posted 308 days ago
Always remember Hanlon's Razor.... "Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity"

Amsterdamage

Posted 308 days ago
Avatar
Talk is cheap !
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 308 days ago
Not in SA.
The Lekgotla for this alone will set us back a couple of million. Not to mention all the 'probes' and 'committees' that will be required

jamesnaker

Posted 308 days ago
Avatar
The ANC slogan "We should take collective responsibility (for nothing)."

The ANC has in 19 years managed to destroy everything that worked. This hospital was one of the best around. It has now become a squatter camp!



raborinj

Posted 308 days ago
Avatar
Knee jerk reaction! I had the luck of reading a piece listing all the shortcomings at this hospital yesterday. This list was on this newspaper. Don't know if many of you read it. Advocacy group Section 27 has posted a detailed piece on why this attempt will not work. Find them and make up your mind.

Just like in many crisis centres, a politician comes along, deliver a message everyone wants to hear and vanish into thin air.

I am just tired to live every day of my life tolerating mediocrity. What can I do to change that? That is other than voting or sitting in front of my PC writting all these words nobody of note will read. Maybe I should join Section 27.

Avatar

MicaParis

Posted 308 days ago
Comrade Raboin J, I totally disagree with your statement on ''these words nobody of note will read'', that perception is wrong Comrade, it should have read ''turn deaf ear''! It is very rare that you actually get to know what is truthfully happening in the chambers. Let me tell you that the President does not miss anything on media platform and some of the stories are even created by him for a certain purpose to achieve a certain political course! is not easy to get to know this kind of truth but believe it or not is true! There is a committed Unit in the GCIS and the Presidency which is currently having the duty to analyse every media related issues to Government and Private sector in order to advise the President accurately. I for one, also take notice on media issues which concern ANC and Government Legal Policy and some of your suggestions are very helpful to map out the way forward on future public prospects! We clearly read and take hit of your valuable suggestions. I am finalizing the New ANC Leadership Election Manual which we hope that Comrades will adopt in Mangaung for implementation in 2016. On Government front we are busy drafting a Green Paper on Election of Top Government Leaders, which we drafted after lot of electorates complained that we discriminate on leadership based on political affiliation and couler! Both the ANC and the Government policy which will ultimately be legislative measures come amid serious out cry of the people on discrimination based on political affiliation in Government tenders and job opportunities in favour of ANC comrades, the measures which seek to rectify that perception by which individuals will be enabled to take Government to court if necessary. On political front, people will for the first time if comrades adopt the manual have a chance to deny or accept the leaders that ANC shortlisted for the leadership positions from the respective various branches which if people accept basing on explicit academic reasoning, high moral content and by the rule of reasoning , will they be accepted as our democratically socially emanated elected leaders, if people does not want a certain comrade ANC will have no choice but to drop that comrade only on Government but not party politics as Government is the people's property! All this initiatives came after the scrutiny and notice of your COMMENTS on this platform and other media platforms that we perpetually gather as an on going concern for further research and development.