Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 41079.55
    DOWN -0.81%
    Top 40 : 3341.05
    DOWN -0.37%
    Financial 15 : 11832.90
    DOWN -2.18%
    Industrial 25 : 46966.65
    DOWN -0.43%

  • ZAR/USD : 9.4623
    UP 0.33%
    ZAR/GBP : 14.4195
    UP 0.15%
    ZAR/EUR : 12.1853
    UP 0.16%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.0922
    DOWN -0.21%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.2426
    DOWN -0.21%

  • Gold : 1385.6500
    DOWN -0.52%
    Platinum : 1475.5000
    DOWN -0.64%
    Silver : 22.5325
    DOWN -1.38%
    Palladium : 746.5000
    UP 0.47%
    Brent Crude Oil : 104.870
    UP 0.07%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Tue May 21 03:40:14 SAST 2013

'Insensitive' Manyi sacked

DENISE WILLIAMS | 28 August, 2012 00:14
Jimmy Manyi. File photo.
Image by: ROBERT TSHABALALA

Controversial government spokesman Jimmy Manyi has been shown the door.

His three-year contract expired on Saturday and will not be renewed.

Though Collins Chabane, the minister in The Presidency responsible for performance monitoring and evaluation, said yesterday that Manyi had " made a good contribution to government communications ," i t is understood that a number of cabinet ministers wanted him sacked.

They were particularly unhappy with his habit of making what they considered to be insensitive remarks. These complaints had apparently been reported to Chabane.

One of the remarks that caused a stir was about e-tolling of highways in Gauteng .

Manyi said in February that the public must accept the tolls because they were not "just a bad dream".

"It's a reality, it's going to happen. No one should have any illusion whatsoever that this thing is going to go away," he said.

It is understood that Manyi's remarks irked some ministers, who claimed they only helped to harden attitudes and political resistance to e-tolls, and created the impression that the government was uncaring.

Earlier this month, the Sunday Times reported that Manyi's contract would not be renewed and that ANC veteranJessie Duarte would replace him.

Manyi joined the public service in August 2009 as director-general of the Department of Labour. In February last year he was transferred to Government Communication and Information Systems after his relationship with then labour minister Membathisi Mdladlana soured.

As CEO of Government Communication and Information Systems, he was the cabinet's spokesman.

DA spokesman Mmusi Maimane welcomed Manyi's removal, saying he had "consistently showcased behaviour unbecoming" of a government spokesman.

But Maimane asked whyManyi had not been relieved of his duties sooner.

"During his three years as government spokesman, he only soured the relationship between the government, the media and the public. The only question is: why wasn't Mr Manyi removed earlier?

"And indeed, why was he allowed to take up such a senior position in the first place, given his history of inappropriate conduct?"

The co-chairman of the Parliamentary Press Gallery Association, Donwald Pressly, said Manyi's relationship with journalists had often been strained because he viewed them with suspicion.

He said a prime example was at last week's post-cabinet briefing, in which he accused a journalist of being angry and chasing headlines when asked if the government had plans to prevent a repeat of the Lonmin Marikana disaster.

"When it was pointed out that this was a sensible and responsible question, he simply said the government needed to garner more facts before it commented."

Manyi would not be drawn on the details of his departure, saying only that he had finished his term.

The deputy CEO of corporate services, Phumla Williams, will act in the position until a permanent appointment is made .

SHARE YOUR OPINION

If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.

truthwins

Posted 265 days ago
Avatar
There are many others I think who are far more deserving of getting the boot i.e. Mac Maharaj, Patel, Blunt Blade, etc.

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 265 days ago
Avatar
Shame Manyi, an 'oversupply' of arrogance has been your downfall - 'live with it'.

Guaranteed, there are a lot of very happy journalists today.
Avatar

Stirrer

Posted 265 days ago
Good riddance, Manyi - quite clearly there was an oversupply of mamparas.

And replaced by a "coloured" nogal - hell yeah!!
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 265 days ago
Oh well done Stirrer, I had completely missed that bit of poetic justice. A female colourd replacement - how that must sting :)

ArseneLupin

Posted 265 days ago
Avatar
Jimmy Manyi, now you can eat your words!
You are NOT untouchable.
You are not superior. The wheel turned for you...
Now you can perhaps go back to your field of study: "Economic geology".
(For the rest of us, it is concerned with earth materials that can be used for economic and/or industrial purposes...)
Avatar

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 265 days ago
"Economic geology" ? Is this what these "Black" everything want this country to produce? I suggest that he leads by example. If it sells (produces first), then we will definitely follow - if we fall in the skin colour category he may grant us.

MicaParis

Posted 265 days ago
Avatar
I want to thank Comrade Chabane (The Animal) for relieving us of this ''trauma and burden'' called Jimmy Manyi, thank you very much Comrade Chabane, keep up the good work Comrade! Do not worry Jimmy we will get you something ''off'' the limelight.

When we ''advise'' at list certain Comrades listen! I thanks also the Commander in Chief, Comrade Msholozi for making sure that we get the ''sell outs'' out of the Government!

That is what you get when you ''sabotage'' the President by ''poor'' underground means! Try again Jimmy, but not with ANC is too much bigger than you, my Chief!?
Avatar

QPCLCD308

Posted 265 days ago
If I am the President and my spokesperson please my enemies by sabotaging me with wrong ''speeches'' to sacrifice my leadership integrity I would have fired him as well, I would have done the something thing. I agree, you advised the Minister well to tell the President to fire this nationally acclaimed fool!? ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,Jimmy deserve the dustbin for sure!!.................

So this proved to be another wrong appointment by YOUR ANC LEECHES, Kwaaaaaaa!!?? And sooner or later ''Comrade'' Rhiya Phiyega will be next to bite the dust as she is currently running like a headless chicken and blowing hot stinky air every time she appears on public!!

LOL that is the mighty caANCer for you Mica, enjoy the results!! All this from your ANC leeches!!
Avatar

MicaParis

Posted 265 days ago
Comrade QPCLCD308

We will always differ in our intellect and understanding but however I will go down to your level so that we can always disagree to agree!

Intellects and research will tell you that Politicians all over the World are the same on motive and self interest, now to make a distinction and political motive on moral and political reality will be a statement that can fool only children but only through the ''eyes of variety of colored sweets''!! Which will clearly suggest your solutions without the effect of the ''sweets'' issue, which means that even children will not believe your lies even if they cannot apply their minds well to adult world of politics!?

Let me tell you the honest truth, whether DA or ANC, the political motive will always be the same but the difference will be on political ideology and policy but the political general results will always be the same, that general rule does not only apply in South Africa but all over the world!

In every ''good'' there is always ''evil'' that statement apply to ''all'' political parties in our country!

amaKK

Posted 265 days ago
Avatar
ROTFLMBAO!!!

J Manyi "fired" for insensitivity...J Duarte to replace him.

A fantastic case of frying pan to fire.

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 265 days ago
Avatar
Zuma is gradually ridding himself of all individuals we told him not to appoint in the first place. Just as he did in appointing them, he finds it convenient to rid himself of the scourge, in a bid to get his "Second transition". Almost without fail, they have acted exactly according to our predictions, including himself. The final, and honorable thing left is for him to rid us of himself, and save this country, built by the sweat and blood of our forefathers. Together with the Afrikaners and the colonialists, they built this country for their, and their children, survival and prosperity, and not for the ANC elite to claim its ownership. We owe our right to build it for future generations, not to the ANC, but to our ancestors, "Black", "White", or whatever colour or creed they classified themselves. No politician has a birthright better than all South Africans, to it.
Avatar

MicaParis

Posted 265 days ago
Comrade M1si2zi3nzo4
I share the same sentiments! That is the ''reality and unity'' that I have always been referring to!

We have to overcome our ''worst fears'' if we have to achieve that! We must first accept each other as equal human being in terms of section 9 of the constitution!

Why tenders and Government posts are given to politically connected black people or only white politically connected people?, Our leaders need to overcome that ''fear'' if we have to achieve general fairness and righteousness whether black or white!

Nepotism, Cadreship Deployment, Corruption and Sexual favors only satisfy and advocate only 00,1% of our population (electorate) which leave almost 100% of the majority out side, if only we can have at list 50/50 % kind of a situation and take it from there, our country will be a better place for all of us.

Hiding behind affirmative action and BBE to cover for cadres, family members and girlfriends will never take us anywhere!?

You can tell the people lies but the very same folklore will never last for a long time as natural justice and actual reality will always deal you a fatal blow!?

SuiGeneris

Posted 265 days ago
Avatar
MicaParis for government spokesman....I think he will do an excellent job to sugar coat the multiple wrongs of this anc goverment just the way they want it.
Avatar

l984

Posted 265 days ago
LOL! Shhhh...! Keep quiet, obey and pay attention when a high-rank comrade is speaking!

Seriously, I stopped reading his comments after he wrote that despite admitting all the damage, corruption, poor performance and destruction the Zuma administration inflicted - he is actually supporting his re-election for a second term simply because it is seen as humiliation and defeat if a comrade is not necessarilly elected and allowed to do 2 terms (no other or good reasons were stated)... Mind boggling and scary!
Avatar

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 265 days ago
I thought he said he operates from Zuma's office, at our expense. I always regard him as his master's voice, which makes it difficult to reason with, without talking directly to the master. Before Polokwane, most of these agents were planted (deployed) in all every township funeral, to sing songs of "uMsholozi" even to non-political bereaved. Now that the YL is on the other side, one wonders who does this dance over honest people's corpses for one man.
Avatar

MicaParis

Posted 265 days ago
Comrade M1si2zi3nzo4

What could you have done if you have clear legit evidence that your most trusted is sabotaging your leadership integrity as a leader for example!

Turn the picture and think if it was yourself! Despite working with Zuma he is not one of my favorite ANC leader but as my leader I respect his leadership status and I do not wish for his re-election but who I am I to do what if reality suggests his re-election!

If we fail to accept reality even though is not our favorite wish, we will never go anywhere! It will be a futile exercise if we try to ''campaign against the sunset'' as our vital motive!

''Floods and muddy waters'' does not last forever in ''the river'' as such the floods and muddy waters which have surrounded the ANC at the moment will get to its natural ''sell by date'' there is no hurry, leadership is a marathon that you cannot win within 10 seconds, we need to be patient without causing our country ''serious damage''? if we have to get things right!

Zuma will eventually go when his time is done and we will have another person to take over there is no need to rush even though the pain and burden is unbearable, perseverance is the mother of success.
You have to be ''extra ordinary'' intellect to understand certain issues it is even worse when you are too far to understand and apply your mind to the issues to understand the real truth!

SindiM

Posted 265 days ago
Avatar
I agree M1S2zzzzzz, "The final, and honorable thing left is for him to rid us of himself..." and he must take Blade with him.
Avatar

Robrt1Mugabe99

Posted 265 days ago
Out of all the ministers we have why single out Blade, why Blade is hatred like this, is he a decision maker or what, is it because he recalled Mbeki
Avatar

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 265 days ago
Blade is very much in it for the 'Money' too. Remember the 1/2 million bucks in the plastic bag? His fortunes are so tied to Zuma's 783 unanswered corruption charges, and he doing a great job avoiding it. The same goes with Mac.

wilhelm.snyman

Posted 265 days ago
Avatar
What a relief... wasn't he the one who tried to engage in private business dealings with a Norwegian delegation? I stand to be corrected. An arrogant, destructive attitude that made one think the ANC had given birth to the universe through the bottom end of its alimentary canal...

manga2

Posted 265 days ago
Avatar
All the best Comrade Jimmy, you still have Manyi rivers to double-cross.

Good luck with your next lucrative deployment.

WhatTheHack

Posted 265 days ago
Avatar
"Zuma will eventually go when his time is done and we will have another person to take over there is no need to rush even though the pain and burden is unbearable, perseverance is the mother of success" Mica i do not see a leader in Zuma especially as he does not seem to know the basics of economics. GEAR policy is whats keeping this country going to this day. Trevor manual for president and Mbalula for deputy(in my dreams)

WhatTheHack

Posted 265 days ago
Avatar

WhatTheHack

Posted 265 days ago
Avatar
"there is no need to rush" wena Mica usijwayela kabi. One thing that Zuma has done since taking over as the president of this country? just one thing that stands out?
Avatar

MicaParis

Posted 265 days ago
Comrade WhatTheHack

If only we could defeat the odds of reality I will not re instate Zuma as the State President for obvious democratic reasons! (He is not ruling alone by the way!!)

Unfortunately we live in the wrath of ''false democracy'' that is why I suggested a lot of time on this blog that we need to transform our political system to be 'peoples driven' from private party driven so that we can at list access true majority voice and political righteousness!

If people were going to vote for the President, clearly Zuma will not win, but guess what ANC is going to vote and the reality is that Zuma will be re- elected unopposed!!

Is party politics! me and you cannot do anything about that!! Is a reality that will prevail but will be solved by the natural justice which its edge is inevitable and not even political favor will defeat! In simple term Zuma will finish his terms and go, simple as that and if he turns autocratic he will eventually die just like Kamuzu Banda and Idie Amin!!

You are too far to understand the reality behind all that!! The interest of the country must come first we do not want to be like Rwanda and Syria, if only you people can understand!!

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 265 days ago
Avatar
Must politics always turn on a lie and dishonesty? Any segment of truth one can get from a politician is when he is vying for office. Even that comes with a pinch of salt, just to market himself to lay his dirty hands on the public funds. Thereafter, it becomes a wholesale lie, until he becomes an ex-president. Then he regains his moral compass, and becomes a member of another elite "Committee of the Wise", or something of that sort. How he cannot be wise when he needs to be, is anyone's guess. And what makes them think they can be 'advisers' after their term, is the stuff made only of politics.

WhatTheHack

Posted 265 days ago
Avatar
Mica i get exactly what you are saying but for you to carelessly say that there is no rush?
I might agree with fellow coms that we support zuma as as collective because i don't want to be sidelined but come Mangaung............ So it is not really a clear cut win for Zuma.

Brisvegas

Posted 265 days ago
Avatar
good riddance...

i_stub_born

Posted 265 days ago
Avatar
HA HA HA HA ..........Really!!........I simply cannot get to understand the obtuse mentality that governs the cadres, notwithstanding the fact that politicians (any color) defend to death the most absurd of ideas.....

....Our "tovarich in residence" contends that in spite Mr. Zuma is corrupt and has no insight nor ability to govern nor be a leader of the nation, he (and I suppose cadres alike) has to respect his 'leadership' and accept tacitly his re-election.......

A President of a Nation (any), is the citizen representative, and acts on the citizen's behalf.....If I have a thief, a moron, a rapist, a murderer, etc, whatever, representing ME and acting immorally on MY behalf.........what does it say about ME????...................And worse !!!!....If I abjectly defend HIM because of MY party or my skin color, then I am painting myself with his same faults, am I not????.......

Why is it that foreigners come here (Africa/Third World country)with the intention of bribing first, before making any deal anywhere????........

Not because it is such widespread behavior here and there, we must shrug our shoulders and carry on with impassivity, must we not??????..........

POST94

Posted 265 days ago
Avatar
The timing of the announcement says a lot. Something else is in the pipeline for Comrade Manyi. Somewhere his overzealous tendencies will be tolerated.