Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 40855.89
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Top 40 : 3351.01
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Financial 15 : 11688.69
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Industrial 25 : 46366.22
    UNCHANGED0.00%

  • ZAR/USD : 9.5589
    UP 0.43%
    ZAR/GBP : 14.4338
    UP 0.41%
    ZAR/EUR : 12.3520
    UP 0.23%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.0941
    UP 0.66%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.2561
    DOWN -0.12%

  • Gold : 1393.3050
    UP 0.12%
    Platinum : 1456.0000
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Silver : 22.5985
    UP 0.11%
    Palladium : 738.5000
    UP 0.75%
    Brent Crude Oil : 102.340
    DOWN -0.10%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Fri May 24 07:42:16 SAST 2013

SA on knife edge

SIPHO MASOMBUKA, TJ STRYDOM and AMUKELANI CHAUKE | 13 September, 2012 00:39
Strikers at Marikana platinum mine, near Rustenburg, who are joining forces with nearby Amplats workers in a wage battle that threatens to paralyse platinum mining Picture: DANIEL BORN

As miners vowed yesterday to shut down South Africa's platinum industry, high-level meetings were being planned to rescue the strife-torn mining sector.

According to ANC insiders, an urgent national executive committee meeting will be held within days to discuss how to bring under control the chaos in mining and the unfettered power of expelled former youth league leader Julius Malema.

"We should be at the centre of what is happening now in the mines without undermining Cosatu. Being quiet will not help us. We need to show that we are a governing party together with our alliance partners," a senior ANC insider said.

Last night, mining bosses met senior government officials and union leaders in an attempt to stem the violent strikes that started a month ago at Lonmin's Marikana mine.

Anglo American CEO Cynthia Carroll said they were "in touch with the authorities at the highest level" to identify how they could work together. The "authorities" were both government and trade unions, according to a spokesman.

The National Union of Mineworkers has called a special national executive conference tomorrow also to discuss the events at Marikana and other platinum mines.

"We are highly concerned because these people can lose their jobs," NUM spokesman Lesiba Seshoka said last night.

He pointed out that both Amplats and Goldfields had issued retrenchment notices in June and July and NUM was concerned that the strikers were handing mining companies the power to retrench them.

Yesterday, striking miners at Marikana and the nearby Anglo Platinum mine outside Rustenburg formed a "war room" to fight together for salaries to be raised to R12500 a month. Almost 10000 miners from Amplats are expected to join the strikers at Lonmin.

A mining executive, who did not want to be named, described the sector as "a runaway train".

"The best-case scenario for the mining sector is to return everything to 3pm on the afternoon of the shooting at Marikana. But that still is a nightmare for management, workers and shareholders because it would mean job losses, mine closures and economic decline."

The platinum industry, he said, had been in severe pain already for a number of quarters. The mines simply could not pay higher wages, and workers seemed unwilling to back down.

Marikana had been a loss-making operation before the shooting in mid-August, as were many mines, according to a research report by JP Morgan, he said.

The executive was not aware of any industry-wide measures to save the industry nor of talks between government and companies.

To normalise things, he said, someone had to stand up and speak the uncomfortable truth that wage increases would not happen but mine closures would.

In North West, mineworkers rejecting the formal unions have formed a Rustenburg Workers and Communities Forum under the leadership of the Democratic Socialist Movement, affiliate of the Committee for Workers' International.

Executive member Mametlwe Sebei yesterday tried to persuade miners that a general strike should start in Rustenburg and be followed by a national strike and march to the Union Buildings.

"This battle can be won only if we are united," Sebei urged at a mass meeting at Amplats.

An estimated 12000 miners went on strike at four Amplats shafts on Tuesday night, demanding salaries of R14500 a month.

One of the strike leaders, Evans Ramokga said they had been trying since May to get NUM to take their demands to management. "NUM rejected us and we decided to do everything ourselves."

In Marikana, Bishop Joe Seoka said an end to the impasse was in sight as workers' representatives agreed to participate in the CCMA-facilitated negotiations, which will resume today.

SHARE YOUR OPINION

If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 253 days ago
Avatar
"..demanding salaries of R14500 a month."
Is that a typo or are they really demanding more?

I'm afraid that this is not going to end well. The mines are going to be forced to mechanise and, as a result, a lot of permanent jobs are going to be lost forever. Malema won't care.

The scariest part of all this is that most of those are not even employed at the mines - they are simply a rent-a-mob who are intimidating and murdering those who want to work.
Avatar

SecretVoice

Posted 253 days ago
And to cap it all many of these strikers are not even South African citizens. We must be the only country in the world to allow expats to dictate. The ANC truly failed as a political party. I agree with you the sheit is going to hit the fan very soon and in a big way.
Avatar

mbongwa-sonofthesoil

Posted 252 days ago
R14500
Where do you get your amount as far as we all know it's R12500,spreading lies again as usual?
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 252 days ago
Bong,
Overcome your immense phobia against reading, break out the Lipice and READ THE ARTICLE.
Avatar

mbongwa-sonofthesoil

Posted 252 days ago
An estimated 12000 miners went on strike at four Amplats shafts on Tuesday night, demanding salaries of R14500 a month.
..
This is another bad reporting from former apartheid journalist spreading lies about africans.
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 252 days ago
Well done Bong !
Rest your lips for a while now as that is why I was asking if it was a typo (meaning an error made during typing of the article)
Avatar

madlapha

Posted 252 days ago
The people shall govern; and all the resources of this land should be distributted to every south african, guess who said this? i think this song sing by Mr Mandela ;Mbeki ;Motlante and Mr Zuma......so how?
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 252 days ago
madlapha

Who owns the minerals?
The state

Who owns the state?
The citizens of SA.

Who approves companies to gather those minerals and who is in charge of monitoring and enforcing legislation regarding those mineral rights?
Avatar

mbongwa-sonofthesoil

Posted 252 days ago
RSA.MommaCyndi

Listen mama your governement who supposely monitoring or guarding our natural resources is too weak and pre-occupied with corruption and lazyness. So dont be surprised when people are fed-up with them,there will be another revolution that will revolutionalise people. The myth of freedom or democracy[whatever you call this sh!t] since from 1994 is not working for us africans.
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 252 days ago
Bong,
Well OUR government was voted in by the majority. Maybe you should start going out and lobbying for them to vote a different way instead of cheering on the complete destruction of our country?
Avatar

mbongwa-sonofthesoil

Posted 252 days ago
RSA.MommaCyndi
Posted 7 minutes ago
Bong,
Well OUR government was voted in by the majority. Maybe you should start going out and lobbying for them to vote a different way instead of cheering on the complete destruction of our country?
..

You reckon? The shame governement was created out of lies and blood of our relatives who were brutaly killed by the ANC,INKATHA and pale skinned who funded INkatha to kill our parents especialy in my republic[Transkei]. It's very easy for you to talk without understand the root cause of the problem. Again africans were failed by Tutu in his TRC sh!t. How long must we tolerate failures in our soil?
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 252 days ago
Yes Bong. And your solution is to create more bloodshed and destroy our economy. How is that going to work out for the best?

We either go with the majority vote or we don't. Those are our options. The whole reason that we dismantled apartheid was to get everyone that vote. Don't blame the ANC if you are too bone idle to go out and canvas for enough votes to get the thieving sods out of government.
Avatar

mbongwa-sonofthesoil

Posted 252 days ago
RSA.MommaCyndi
Posted 12 minutes ago
Yes Bong. And your solution is to create more bloodshed and destroy our economy. How is that going to work out for the best?

We either go with the majority vote or we don't. Those are our options. The whole reason that we dismantled apartheid was to get everyone that vote. Don't blame the ANC if you are too bone idle to go out and canvas for enough votes to get the thieving sods out of government.
..
I like your last sentence really me canvasing for these thieves? They nearly killed me in1994, i was only 18 yrs then. In was saved by my late father from these criminals,if he was weak man i would be history by now. Have great day i am leaving this office now.
Avatar

bugsy

Posted 252 days ago
These mineworkers are taking their cue from their leaders, you see, earning obscene amounts of money with little or no formal education. It works for Zuma, Malema et al. The other outrageously rich (nouveau rich), like Sexwale, Ramaphosa, Motsepe et al, the new mine owners/shareholders have got no technical expertise at all. They sit on the boards, yes, but if the geologists, geographers and other scientists, engineers and technical experts should pack up and go, there will be nobody amongst the BEE rich to actually operate the mines. The new rich are getting money for jam, and the workers on the ground want to get in on the act. Simple really.

l984

Posted 252 days ago
Avatar
Given the opportunity Julius Malema can successfully lead any league, any party, any economy and any country into complete and permanent chaos and destruction. It just comes naturally to him.

It is always so easy to render a city, province or industry ungovernable.
Of course the real challenge is to make them governable - and well governed at that!
But that of course is the last concern on his/their minds.

Is Mangaung and the ANC with its endless internal conflicts and dirty wars really worth the price that SA as a whole will have to (and is about to!) pay? How far are Malemas and their opponents actually prepared to go? I wonder if all those who insisted that Malema is a nobody that should be ignored or laughed at still hold their opinions?
Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 252 days ago
While he was an anc member and the ancyl president the anc had control over him, but now that he is just a private individual, they have completely lost control over his actions.

Many people were jubilant when he was expelled and hoped he would simply disappear from the scene, but now we have an uncontrollable individual with a vendetta against zuma, seeking his revenge.

I still maintain that someone or most likely a group of people are financing him.
Avatar

manga2

Posted 252 days ago
President Zuma had control over Malema while the latter was an ANC member. But now, we just cannot expect our President to run around taking on lunatics pound for pound. He can influence such manouvres from behind the scenes. I still maintain that Malema will eventually finds himself in a difficult corner. For now, the mining bosses must just hang-in there and stomach the losses. If they capitulate, we'll be in more $hit.
Avatar

mbongwa-sonofthesoil

Posted 252 days ago
manga2

Listen here boy the president of yours has no capacity of running my country. The ANC should just recall this human being,he is wasting our time.

manga2

Posted 252 days ago
Avatar
Remind me, besides Malema, who said it was cold outside the ANC? Maybe in the long run, for now Fatboy is running the show. But like all such crusades, he'll come crashing like a ton of bricks. While he can afford to down his expensive whisky on an empty stomach, I doubt the striking workers will sustain this gig.

I hope the mining companies, the Unions and government will remain resolute and not succumb to this nonsense. If they do, it's all exponentially downhill henceforth.
Avatar

madlapha

Posted 252 days ago
This is a second month of this story of Marikana in your mind,but this story start last year.that time it was numsa only.they came back to workers and say the employer can not afford this amount and in our history we did not see such an increase.thats where the workers start to engage themselves in money fight.and the biggest people who run this shares is our ANC vip"s (Like Motsepe,Khulubuse Zuma,Tokyo,etc)....Did u know how much Zuma spend in one day and his family, let me tell u...+-R15000,dont forget that where ever he goes he has a pocket money of +-R5000.Did u know how much a loaf of bread +- R9.00 today?
and if the government is able to pay +-R290.00 to every child in south africa why dont he put hand to these mines.we are going to change the leadership in Mangaung and that will give us a new memory not change...i prefare the new leadership will tell us new lies than that of Zuma

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 252 days ago
Avatar
"Knife edge"? Come on now! The "first term" saw a mass mobilisation of everything, the use of courts, intelligence, BEE's, MKMVA vigilantes, etc.

Mine strikes always pit the migrant workers and necessarily, society against the capital, which uses the state and the ruling party. This is because the workers are forced to live within their working environment, due to the migrant labour system. The Mynwerkers Unie clubbed with capital, and the National Party, against the entry of NUM into the industry. Almost all the workers were recruited from the TVBC homelands, as well as the neighbouring African states. Hence any strike was played out as some form of insurgence. A similar polarisation occurred in the farms, but now the farms are largely on their own. The cloud is created by the unproductive BEE's who own the unions, the mines, the party - and by the same token - the state, simultaneously. The former homelands are now part of the state, and their leaders depend on the elite, and not their constituents for their elections. This drags the whole society into Mangaung, unwittingly.

The principle here is that if a capitalist cannot play the game, he should get out of the playground.

MicaParis

Posted 252 days ago
Avatar
A permanent solution is of vital importance if the government ever dream of eradication of these kinds of fallacies. It will be a futile exercise to punish the government for deliberate perpetual failure on the part of their irresponsible friends / Cosatu.
The whole pandemonium is nothing but a total mischief on the part of NUM / Cosatu and poor government lackeys are now left destitute to lick the bleeding wounds.
To avoid future cataclysm, legislation must be promulgated to separate government and union responsibility thereby also forcing the government to be accountable to indecent impact management.
This kind of catastrophe must be avoided for all intend and purpose nevertheless as they say, failure is the mother of success but however Unions must be the combination of parishes for joint administration of relief for the poor in any healthy labour law abiding government.
Where trade unions are most firmly organized, there are the rights of the employees most respected.
Avatar

SecretVoice

Posted 252 days ago
Once again you waffle a lot of words and say nothing constructive at all. The fact of the matter is that the ANC failed as apolitical party. What is happening now is clear proof of this fact.
Mining in a mess
Health care in a mess
Defense force in a mess
Education in a mess
Local government in a mess
Policing in a mess
Etc,etc,etc
Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 252 days ago
SecretVoice

There is a true saying - Empty vessels make the most noise !
Avatar

MicaParis

Posted 252 days ago
SecretVoice

I will never defend the ANC or the Government, which most political parties are part of and thereby collectively ''fail'' together.

I share your sentiments but blaming the government without any reasonable solutions with only lame non constructive criticism will never enable us to see the light of the day on issues relating to general complains and problems such as the Marikana saga.

You mentioned lots of Government's hogwash haystack but still did not lead us to any permanent or temporary solutions.

The government is ''magnificently'' failing and any South African adult compatriot does not need any telescope to see that in fact it is a national crisis.

But what do you suggest we should do since voting ANC out of power proved to be a temporary impossibility for a permanent relief!

Let me put you on the spot, what should we do, what other options do we have, let us talk and stop advocating hatred and ''they will never get it'' right syndrome, remember South Africa is our country and anything which happen within our borders will affect us all across the border as such we both collectively have a mutual mandate to make things correct.
Avatar

Thespear

Posted 252 days ago
I think the solution is there in goverment, remember mining charter? what about Cooporate social investment, did it happen in Marikana, don't you think if it did, then we will be talking something positive, goverment failed not only the workers, but SA'ns in totality, they come with legislation, after legislation but no implementation, remember AA, EE, all reversed since 2006, and goverment has no powers, to either force this, through penalties, etc, Remember the minimum wage bill, not forced, now we are compromising and want to subsidies, via youth wage bill, so who is failing us, goverment? NUM is a (PTY), they are shareholders, hence their langauge is not different from that of business.
From where I stand the ANC need Cosatu more than Cosatu needs it, if it was not of the cosy relationship, NUM would have pushed both goveremnt and business to implement mining charter, and CSI in areas were they operate, now we are indeed in a mess, but the mess is still within, unlike the Malema mess, which is outside, and the president has no powers at all, except his Hawks, and SARS, but this need political engagements, which is anathema, of ate in the ANC, some believe disciplinory hearing is political solution, where do you start to advice when some believe stupidity is a right not a priviledge, hence the arrogance..
Avatar

MicaParis

Posted 252 days ago
The honorable Thespear

I agree with you my Chief!
But however remember that South Africa is a Constitutional State in terms of Act (108 of 1996). Promulgation of legislation is still a vital solution.
As such section 2 of the Constitution stress on respect and supremacy of the ''Constitution'' which gives us leverage to a permanent solution in terms of the law and access to courts!

The Mining Charter is not legislation but a policy which does not acquire the force of law as such in terms of the South African legal hierarchy by order of inevitable implementation through forceful legal basis, now, can you notice the real difference?

Legislation will hold the Government accountable through Court action which will inevitably force the Government to act righteously and a Constitutional entrenchment of the ''enacted'' enabling Act will render the aggrieved individuals to appeal in the Constitutional Court were their rights will be absolutely protected and duly enforced as the Constitution and the Constitutional Court are the very last resorts in terms of section 2 of the Constitution and our constitutional state’s basis of the law.

Surely we cannot do it better than that, that is a solution that I think will be well applicable to the material problems. Most notably it might be vital for certain prescripts of the Mining Charter to be included in that Legislation to perpetually solve that kind of problem.
Avatar

QPCLCD308

Posted 252 days ago
'''''''''''''''''''''''''''Kwiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii!!!!................what, SA knife edge, hell no for what and by who .........THE ANC LEECHES ARE AT IT AGAIN........WHO CAUSED ALL THIS....THE cANCer LEECHES!

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 252 days ago
Avatar
Another conundrum for the ruling elite is that, whereas the apartheid state would bus strikers to their homelands, the homelands are now part of the country. Whatever problems they create by bussing migrants away, will remain their problem. This is the highest price not worth paying by everyone, for a power crazed individual to get a 'second term".

BobbyBob

Posted 252 days ago
Avatar
Will the politicians destroy us all ?

truthwins

Posted 252 days ago
Avatar
So, who will be the worst affected if you close down the mines - primarily the miners themselves. and secondary the labour force and the economy of South Africa, as investments
will dwindle and finally dry up as has happened in Zimboland.
Avatar

MicaParis

Posted 252 days ago
Truth!

You have got a visible reference right above the border of South Africa! Let me re-phrase your question for an answer, ''So, who will (is) be (the) the worst affected'' ''in Zimbabwe''?

To be precise, all of us will be affected!

truthwins

Posted 252 days ago
Avatar
The big problem for the ANC and South Africa being the fact that it has to many mates sharing the same bed, and it's demise started when they allowed labour unions under the same political sheet.
Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 252 days ago
'''''......has to many mates sharing the same bed......''''''

inmates ? More appropriate ?
Avatar

MicaParis

Posted 252 days ago
Truth!

Exactly the reason why I am longing for a legislation in a form of constitutional base and enabling Act as a temporary or permanent relief to separate the two structures and their responsibility!

We will never win this war if Unionists are working / practicing to become Ministers and Politicians at the expense of the poor employees and the general tax payers!

Thespear

Posted 252 days ago
Avatar
NUM, is loosing credit: At first they did not know the workers in Marikana who went on an illigal strike, then they accept they are the majority union. They last indicated that Malema's warning of an escallation of Marikana was pure oppotunistic, and it will not happen, now, we've got Gold Field, and others joining, guess what, they are now considering a special meeting, isn't it too late..Since the death of 44, why did they not meet. Isn't it a question of them undermining workers, believeing that workers are nothing without them? Now lesson number one, if you don't take care of your constituency 's demand, someone else will, so now that Malema is winning, aren't they opportunistic, to meet now? We all know that NUM 's focus is to get Zuma re-elected in Mangaung, so thats what matters, workers demand will be put in the back sit, now, get's who is doing catch-up....Malema is indeed a leader of the people, visiting soldiers, cannot be criminal, more so if the master never bothered...

Darwin_Rules

Posted 252 days ago
Avatar
The people of this country would be well advised to look to Zimbabwe and what was starting to happen after 18 years of Zanu-PF rule. The ZCTU was the main force behind the formation of the opposition party, the Movement for Democratic Change a year later. Then all hell broke loose when Mugabe started his land grabs to appear to appease the masses. The rest is history.


Avatar

MicaParis

Posted 252 days ago
Darwin-Rules

The irony of your explanation curtails just one most important vital issue which is coincidence? Surprisingly the very same Robert Mugabe and ZANUPF are still well right at the helm after all those years of sufferings, lethal poverty and agony!?
Now if I may ask, if we turn a blind eye about our situation do not you think the Zimbabwean saga might be a coincidence to our reality!?
Remember politics and lethal poverty often coincide and the same thing might apply to be the fatal consequences of the ''malema - zuma'' aroma of deep hatred in which every South African citizen might be caught with their pants down in this cross-fire!
Avatar

Wiseguy

Posted 252 days ago
@Mica-Paris......"in which every South African citizen might be caught with their pants down in this cross-fire! " .......and who would ultimately benefit or be the main beneficaries from a Zimbo style situation.....why the "elite group" behind this political play, as happened in Zimbo land....thats who!!! Not the miners or the people...that is for sure!

So that begs the question, who is the elite grouping behind this political play?
Avatar

MicaParis

Posted 252 days ago
Wiseguy

Thabo Mbeki sidelined Tokyo, Phosa, Winnie, Modise and Nyanda in his Cabinet. Mbalula was never a significant powerhouse during Mbeki and the same thing applied to Paul who was MEC of Finance in Gauteng which was a weak position to make any meaningful value to main stream National Cabinet politics.
The tripartite alliance had since totally collapsed when Zuma took over, The Mbeki bureaucrat political lifestyle had since kept a visible distance away from the masses on the floor and ANC seemed to be losing its meaning and political mandate under Mbeki.
As a result poor Zuma came in and quickly try to be smarter than Mbeki to win all the disgruntled parties! Poor Zuma brought all the stooges from political extinction by Mbeki back into the main political stream and they responded by fatally sabotaging his image, integrity and leadership capacity, by feeding him wrong advisers and advices that exposed his weaknesses since they know them and exactly got him at the corner!
In a bit to unite the alliance he made Gwede an SACP core cadre an SG of the ANC the move which core ANC comrades like Mbalula and former Juju saw it as a taboo and a move which undermined core ANC cadres.
Zuma introduced the Monitoring and Evaluation Department, that I am currently attached to, led by Minister Chabane to force Government employees and political heads to touch base with ordinary citizens on the ground t remove the bureaucratic syndrome created by Mbeki. That is why we have compulsory Public Participation Programmes by all political heads and Senior Government Officials.
As such comrades who were brought up from political death might be liable for that and is now that Zuma realises why Mbeki sidelined them in the first place! But however his bid to unite the alliance had been successful considering the way it was bad under Mbeki! Zuma burned his fingers by returning the political deadwoods sidelined by Mbeki and poor Juju is just being used as the scapegoat as he was technically expelled from ANC by dark business forces such as Oppenheim, Wiese, Dippenaar and Rupert so that they can foil nationalisation of powerful assets which belong to this hefty business men!

I hope the whole background answers your question of ''certain'' individual who might be fuelling the fire behind the ''Juju panda''.
Avatar

QPCLCD308

Posted 252 days ago
Aiiiiiiiiiii........comrade Mica is trying desparatly and very hard as ussual in hollow ANC promises.
Avatar

shelatt

Posted 252 days ago
What does all this prove....? That the majority of all govt ministers, DG's and the like are totally incompetent and should never be allowed to make decisions. They are like fish in a diminishing pool of water, flapping around in a panic to try and survive. By survive I mean protecting their newly found (stolen) wealth and positions of power. Could someone out there try establish how much Zuma's asset value has increased by since he took over. He was practically bankrupt and couldn't even balance his cheque account (see Shaik's story)....!!

Wiseguy

Posted 252 days ago
Avatar
I think Mugabe and JOC are backing Malema and his group!
Avatar

QPCLCD308

Posted 252 days ago
meanwhile the ANC leeches are at it again and leading the country to possible economic collapse.