Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 41413.44
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Top 40 : 3353.49
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Financial 15 : 12096.10
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Industrial 25 : 47171.07
    UNCHANGED0.00%

  • ZAR/USD : 9.4046
    UP 0.05%
    ZAR/GBP : 14.2711
    UP 0.34%
    ZAR/EUR : 12.0825
    UP 1.94%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.0911
    UP 0.15%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.1670
    UP 0.39%

  • Gold : 1360.1000
    UP 0.37%
    Platinum : 1455.0000
    UP 0.28%
    Silver : 22.2600
    UP 0.16%
    Palladium : 738.5000
    UP 0.61%
    Brent Crude Oil : 104.640
    UNCHANGED0.00%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Sun May 19 09:27:58 SAST 2013

Congress divided over Zuma

HLENGIWE NHLABATHI, OLEBOGENG MOLATHLWA and GEORGE MATLALA | 21 September, 2012 00:01
Delegates at Cosatu's 11th National Congress at Gallagher estate in Midrand, were divided over who should lead the ANC, with some singing for Kgalema Motlanthe to take over.
Image by: DANIEL BORN

Despite Cosatu leaders avoiding the contentious ANC succession debate, delegates yesterday sang songs in support of their preferred candidates.

Some sang for President Jacob Zuma, some for his likely opponentKgalema Motlanthe.

When the National Union of Mineworkers and South African Democratic Teachers' Union tried to get the congress to discuss the issue of the ANC leadership, they were shot down.

Cosatu secretary-general Zwelinzima Vavi said the matter has been referred to the federation's central executive committee and could not be discussed by congress.

Earlier, ANC secretary-general Gwede Mantashe showed his support for a second term for Zuma when he referred to a "Zuma moment" instead of a "Lula moment" as called for by Cosatu.

The "Lula moment" is a reference to former Brazilian president Lula da Silva, who failed to please workers during his first term (2002-2006) but turned the country around during his second term (2006-10), dramatically improving the economy and creating hundreds of jobs.

Mantashe said a "Zuma moment" could be achieved with Cosatu's help, particularly in ensuring that agricultural land was used optimally.

Lula introduced radical economic policies that reduced inequality, poverty and unemployment.

Cosatu is proposing the government follows the same direction.

"We agree with the thrust of the socioeconomic document of Cosatu's central executive committee, but we want to add a few issues and their contribution to make the Zuma moment a reality," he said.

"Cosatu must join the ANC in [sifting] out what minerals should be nationalised as the discussion will be key in Mangaung," Mantashe said.

Earlier, delegates showed deep divisions over whether to support Zuma or Motlanthe ahead of the ANC's elective congress in December in the Free State.

While some affiliates broke into pro-Zuma songs, others called for change - using the substitution signs seen at soccer matches.

Two groups marched around the hall trying to outdo each other.

There were conflicting positions among members from the National Union of Metalworkers, with some shouting "sifuna uKgalema" (We want Kgalema).

One member danced on top of the table and held up a framed photograph of Motlanthe.

Vavi took to the podium and asked affiliates not to bring discord and division to the congress.

"There is nothing wrong with the singing about any leader of the alliance but it is wrong to show signs. Once you show signs, you divide the congress," he said.

At one point, National Union of Mineworkers secretary-general Frans Baleni held up a V-sign for victory as he and Cosatu president Sdumo Dlamini danced next to Vavi.

Vavi's call for members to stop making signs was met with a lukewarm response by those keen to have the leadership debate dealt with .

Dlamini charged to the podium and pleaded with delegates to stop the commotion.

"The Chiefs and Pirates signs must stop now. Please take your seat," he said after which order was restored.

The congress had resolved on Tuesday to defer political discussions to the central executive committee for deliberation.

SHARE YOUR OPINION

If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.

SuiGeneris

Posted 240 days ago
Avatar
Expelled ANC Youth League president Julius Malema had the right to feel aggrieved that he was prevented from speaking at Marikana, Deputy President Kgalema Motlanthe said.
“The Bill of Rights gives me the right not to agree with what you say. But I have to respect your right to say it," said Motlanthe,
"If you do not give voice to your thoughts, it is impossible to know what they are."

==================================

He is right about the bill of rights.....but.....I can smell a dead rat here about this ''friendship''
Avatar

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 239 days ago
“The Bill of Rights gives me the right not to agree with what you say. But I have to respect your right to say it," said Motlanthe,
"If you do not give voice to your thoughts, it is impossible to know what they are."

This is the typical Kgalema I know. This is what he has consistently displayed - he was the only one who stood up to Mbeki's alleged manipulation of the scorpions. What surprises me is the boldness, at a time when the securocrats are making the most noise, and even mowing down any dissenting voices. But you cannot fault the man for principle, which is what the country urgently needs, before it degenerates into the annals of history.
Avatar

VictorRapulane

Posted 239 days ago
Motlanthe should tread carefully.. he should give Malema a wide berth. If he is seen to be sympathising with him it could lead to his downfall.. Malema is a political hot potato to be avoided at all costs..
Avatar

fransvan_erk

Posted 239 days ago
Pls. read The Devil in the Detail from Paul Holding and Hennie van Vuuren page 416 about his corruption in the loans to Pamozi Holding via IDC and Landbank in a period that the share value of Pamozi had fallen by 98 percent by the time the loan had been issued.
The loan is mentioned as: a substantial portion of the Landbank's total available capital.

Turning the clock back to 2001 when your suitable candidate president was buying Sadam Hoesein's oil for supper inflated prices to be paid by the SA government from which plus 50% disappeared.

Candidate president Motlanthe is not one hair better than all this corrupt anc cronies.
Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 239 days ago
I think malema's mind will be occupied much more from now on with his warrant for arrest being issued an hour ago !
Avatar

swona1

Posted 237 days ago
zuma has failled to manage malema, dont blame malema for this mess, bt zuma, Kgalema is right, in pure and sound leadership, you dont deny those who oppose you a platform to raise and criticise your leadership, but you allow them and you dont push them away as zuma is doing, at times invite them to your public apearances and give them the theme, let them talk 1st, and I promise you, someone you gave a platform wont critisize you while you looking at them, bt throughout his turnure zuma allowed malema to do as he pleased, malema would adress people in Mpumalanga and zuma in KZN, that made malema to think he is popular, yet at times ppl would attend becuase provincial branches played a role in numbers attended! and now, it is too late, he cannot close the gab between him and this twart!

i_stub_born

Posted 240 days ago
Avatar
.....The Spear vs The Blob............what a miserable choice.......

MicaParis

Posted 240 days ago
Avatar
Comrade Kgali is right, the denial of Malema’s entry into the stadium violated section 18 and 21(1) of the constitution respectively on freedom of association and movement like any another South African citizen including but not limited to those who were in the very same stadium he was denied entry by the police, the action which was abuse of political power by Zuma and Nathi.
At list the ''Goatee'' is reasonable as he is playing the ''the constitutional supremacy game'' than those who are playing ''selfish political dirty games''

The President must be the first most reasonable senior citizen who should respect and uphold the constitution, amid all the legal blunders he had ''deliberately'' made, that reality is nothing but ‘’the’’ opposite fact.

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
Well, they threatened to 'kill' for Zuma. They will have to summon great courage to 'kiss' for him now. Perhaps they can use Malema as their guide to understand that the public cannot be wrong, and wasn't.

Yotywa

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
Everybody knows that retaining them is not a sign of unity but a compromise as each faction does not want its cadidate to be contested.
Avatar

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 239 days ago
Sadly, the COSATU elite sabotage what little remains of modern democracy- the vote of the branch member. Politicising the mind of participating union delegates, runs counter their political rights. COSATU members constitute 1 out of 4 total employed, and some of those do not support Zuma's ANC. And only a few are eloquent enough to speak in these ceremonial events, designed to influence the broad political landscape.

Antonio Gramsci once said that when political ideology settles, it distorts material reality. Thus lowly-educated workers cannot see anything beyond the high eloquence of the dictators like Nzimande's and Mantashe's. This enslaves them to the wishes and dreams of the elite dictatorship, making even their vote subject to their dictates.

VictorRapulane

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
If Zuma cared about the country and his party he would step down with what is left of his pride still intact..
Avatar

Robrt4Mugabe99

Posted 239 days ago
Yes of course he cares more than you think , Zuma knows very well about his ANC he fought for , the man who sacrificed his life to defend the ANC when the MK members were brutalised by CCBs . Zuma was a man who fought toothe and nail to defend the MKs as result the MKs become very strong force to reckon in his presence in the 80s immediately he was appointed as Chief Intelligence , in that regard he wont be worried about cheap politicking of tenderpreneurs who want to destroy the ANC for their self enrichment. He knows what he is doing and knows where the ANC is heading for.
Avatar

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 239 days ago
Yes, he cares, of course. Who would care less about a people he costs R100 million a month, and to whom he owes the most luxurious life and perks for his concubines? The elite are going to resists any effort to separate this cow's snout from the public purse green plane, for as long their filthy rich hands can still draw some milk from it. They are quite aware that even the seriously stupid rural branch member does not buy the biblical "he so loved the world that he sacrificed his only son", progidy. People realise that even Mandela had to gain his fame of "sacrifice" by exploiting the plight of the potato farm workers. Such altruistic considerations become even more blurred to people who never faced the brutal apartheid force directly, like the real heroes who faced arrest daily. The truth is that any "care for one's country is a myth. Human beings are incapable of even caring for their own familial relatives and procreation. To expect them to care for a country they never know how it came into existence, would be asking for too much.

madlapha

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
Ur right,but hd must not resign we will vote him out and if we fuil to I will vote another party.not to fight. I want peace not power and history.i dont have a hero at home nor one of my family for mk.if Anc want Zuma I will move my vote to another party.
Avatar

ProgressiveAfricanDemocrat

Posted 236 days ago
Comrades, it is time to send Zuma packing back to Nkandla. Those COSATU leaders who think that can push jacob Zuma down our throats should think again. They should stop repeating these lies that vote for a second term for Jacob Zuma is a vote for stability. One thing is clear from Jacob Zuma's tenure in government and the ANC; a vote for Jacob Zuma is a vote for anarchy, chaos and stagnation. Some of COSATU leaders confuse stagnation with stability. These leaders are skating on very thin ice. They should not think that young people in the ANc will again support a man with Standard 2 who has spectacularly failed to lead the ANC and the country. There are so many young people who are unemployed and many people living in grinding and abject poverty in this country, and they cannot be consoled with a song and dance from Jacob Zuma. It is time to search for real solutions to this country's challenges of poverty, unemployment and poor service delivery. We cannot keep on voting for the same man who has shown himself to be grossly incompetent and expect differebt results. That is madness.

Young people must make their strong voices heard come 1st of October, otherwise all these Zuma loyalists and factionalists will continue to assume that we support them. Young people who are ANC members must swell the ranks of ANC branches around the country and nominate a collective of ANC leaders who will be able to take this country forward. It is our democratic right as ANC members to choose our leaders, and nobody should even attempt to take that right away. The failure and crisis of leadership we have seen in the ANC over the past five years must be completely rooted out. For how long are we going to hang our heads in shame because of the leadership of the ANC. Mangaung presents a golden opportunity to get rid of this incompetent leadership collective led by Jacob Zuma.