Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 40998.58
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Top 40 : 3361.59
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Financial 15 : 11703.85
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Industrial 25 : 46637.62
    UNCHANGED0.00%

  • ZAR/USD : 9.5763
    UP 0.07%
    ZAR/GBP : 14.4987
    UP 0.23%
    ZAR/EUR : 12.3835
    UP 0.04%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.0947
    UP 0.12%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.2810
    UP 0.40%

  • Gold : 1386.6000
    UP 0.03%
    Platinum : 1452.5000
    UP 0.31%
    Silver : 22.4000
    UP 0.16%
    Palladium : 727.0000
    UP 0.55%
    Brent Crude Oil : 102.640
    UNCHANGED0.00%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Sat May 25 12:37:10 SAST 2013

'He talked peace then killed him'

Mhlaba Memela | 16 October, 2012 00:14
IFP supporter Siya Dlamini lies dead outside the Ntuzuma Magistrate's Court, north of Durban. File photo.
Image by: TEBOGO LETSIE

Minutes after I had interviewed National Freedom Party working committee member Mzonjani Zulu about the obscene number of lives lost in KwaMashu, he became a killer.

The insults and threats from IFP supporters, carrying pangas and spears, became louder as we walked out of the parking ground at the Ntuzuma Magistrate's Court, north of Durban.

"I must tell the police to hold back these people so the NFP can walk out," Zulu said, walking away from me towards the police officer in command.

Just 2m from me, an IFP supporter jumped in front of Zulu and raised his spear.

Like a cowboy in a western, Zulu took two steps back, drew a firearm from his jacket and fired two shots.

I could not believe what I was seeing.

There were screams as police officers, journalists and protesters ran in different directions.

When the spear-wielding IFP supporter, Siya Dlamini, fell to the ground, my mind went blank.

Though I have witnessed many shootings in my life, my heart began to race when I saw a pool of blood form around his head because I realised that I, too, was in the firing line.

I knew I had to run, but my legs turned to jelly and before I could squat to hide, policemen grabbed Zulu and raced him out of the area.

I watched the mayhem around me but could not move. Fear had taken control of my body.

I could see terrified faces peering from classroom windows in the school next to the court.

Women and men were on the ground, their hands over their heads. There were people under cars and behind trees, and TV news crews were caught between capturing the drama and running for their lives.

Soon the screams of fear became screams of grief.

IFP supporters realised Dlamini was dead. Some had gone to his body. Others carried a woman who had fainted at his side to a nearby car.

"Siya," the IFP supporters shouted.

NFP members quickly retreated to the court grounds.

Police cordoned off the area and Dlamini's body was covered. The smell of blood hung in the air.

People were whispering and I got the sense that battle lines had been drawn. The IFP and NFP supporters were separated by the crime scene.

Zulu sat in the back of a police vehicle in the court grounds and looked towards Dlamini's body.

Ironically, just moments before shooting Dlamini, Zulu had told me: "Too many lives are being lost because of people's hatred."

He had said: "The killings in KwaMashu have been going on for some time and the NFP has buried so many people. I can't understand why an NFP member was arrested for the Saturday killing because he was with us with [Police Minister] Nathi Mthethwa at the meeting to discuss the killing.

"Police have not been doing any investigation into the number of people who have lost their lives here and are just acting on any information that they get. Too many lives are being lost because of people's hatred. Since we left the IFP, too many people, especially members of the NFP, are being killed."

Crime scene investigators and members of Zulu's party spoke to him as he sat in the police van. He continued just staring ahead.

When the cover was removed from Dlamini's body women sobbed. Curious pupils moved nearer to their school fence.

After the body was taken away, fear again filled the air when IFP supporters refused to leave because they wanted to catch a glimpse of Zulu.

IFP national organiser Mfanje Mbango spoke softly, begging angry IFP supporters still carrying weapons to go home.

But they waited until the police van carrying Zulu left the court.

A group covered the blood in the road with soil.

Minutes later, a refuse-removal truck arrived, children walked home from school and tuck shops were busy again. - Additional reporting Nivashni Nair

SHARE YOUR OPINION

If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 221 days ago
Avatar
Being in KZN politics must be a nerve wracking business.
This new habit of bringing weapons to a protest is getting out of hand. For what does a person need a spear at a court room? .... or a gun for that matter? In fact, how did he get into the court room with a gun?

The country seems to be turning into a farcical parody of an old 1920s gangster movie.

(lovely piece of writing. Nice to see solid, old fashioned journalism again)
Avatar

SecretVoice

Posted 221 days ago
This is as a result of an enlarged hypothalamus in the brain. Emotion overrule reason. Not much you can do about it. The evolution process is a very long process.
Avatar

Gormogon1

Posted 221 days ago
SecretVoice

Haha!! Where did you get this from?
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 221 days ago
Frik,
What would body temperature, hunger, thirst and sleep patterns have to do with this?
Avatar

i_stub_born

Posted 221 days ago
......it must be hippopotamus hypothalamus then...........
Avatar

MicaParis

Posted 221 days ago
You guys are so funny, I enjoy reading your humor! lol.
Avatar

CatsBell

Posted 220 days ago
Hey Momma, I agree about the quality of the report. A big thumbs up to the journalist and all involved in the different stages of its publication!
Avatar

SecretVoice

Posted 220 days ago
Momma in this instance none of your suggestions are valid. The shooter was an overweight top dog in his party and the victim was a well off Zulu family. I am afraid it is the hypothalamus and nothing else. Have a nice evening.

AaronGumede

Posted 221 days ago
Avatar
Carying a spear in protests is ilegal and waving a spear to naybody is a crime, it is like pointing a gun to anybody. It was unfortunate to have took that life but the protester was wrong to confront this guy and wave a spear to him, the guy was only thinking of defending himself. It was a war situation, failure to respond quickly could mean his life, not that his life is better or deserve longer years but it is far more easier to distance oneself from this things. You vote to express your point and make your choice, attend marches which are peaceful but don't associate yourself with spear and totters.
Avatar

Robrt5Mugabe99

Posted 221 days ago
ebengeke esamshaya kwesingezansi as a warning shot
Avatar

DuaneHamann

Posted 221 days ago
to the person below suggesting a warning shot.... where should he have fired the warning shot, off the hip and hit one of his own collegues or at the attacker? think duh?

amaKK

Posted 221 days ago
Avatar
Just 2m from me, an IFP supporter jumped in front of Zulu and raised his spear...Like a cowboy in a western, Zulu took two steps back, drew a firearm from his jacket and fired two shots.

---

Seems to me a clear case of self defense. Wonder if some IFP members would see it this way though.

Someone's got bullseye on his back. Dead man walking?



Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 221 days ago
''''Seems to me a clear case of self defense''''

In SA, to claim self-defense, the victim need to be almost dead before he can retaliate, draw a gun, and kill his attacker !
Avatar

DuaneHamann

Posted 221 days ago
@SuiGeneris not sure where you heard that, if you point a gun, danger weapon like a spear, for example, is an attempt on someone's life, and self defense justified. If you point a knife at me, it is an attempt on my life. Go study the criminal law before talking sh$^$
Avatar

Robrt5Mugabe99

Posted 221 days ago
@DuaneHamann
Posted 1 hours ago


angeke sitshelwe uwe wena, we will sort you out , if you think you have right to kill, legal firearm was not given to kill there are rules you need to follow when using legal fire arm, wait and see with your criminal law of the bush , that fiream will be consficated, uzolandela lo file nawe sqhaza ndini

madalathesnake

Posted 221 days ago
Avatar
What have our beloved country turned into by the year 2012? We are slowly or should I say rather say fast going backwards? Despite all the mayhem and chaos around the country, I hope sanity prevails. May the departed soul rest and peace and the law should take its course.

Snetch

Posted 221 days ago
Avatar
And the media is playing a huge role in perpetrating this violence by not reporting news correctly and in detail....last night on e-news, the spear was never mentioned...
Avatar

amaKK

Posted 221 days ago
Perhaps because the eTV reporter was not privy to that fact? This report appears to be "eye-witness" news. The truth will out one way or the other.

donorfatigued

Posted 221 days ago
Avatar
Yet again the failure of the SAPS to do their job leads to death. As at Marikana the cops failed to apply the law and remove any offensive weapon from any person brandishing it in public. This failure there led to killings and again here.

The NFP guy would seem to have been defending himself against an attack by a spear-wielding thug and it is probably fortunate that he had a suitable weapon for his own defence or he would today be dead.

Whilst it may get bloody should the cops enforce the law, they must prepare to do this, in conjunction with overwhelming force of the army, as an example and continue to show these thugs that their carrying of lethal weapons to protests etc will no longer be tolerated.

xivavula

Posted 221 days ago
Avatar
So if the dead IFP jumped in front of Zulu wielding a spear, why is every journalist calling Zulu a killer???? Was he not protecting his life?? Was he supposed to wait for Siya to stab him with the spear he was wielding??? Peo-ple???
Avatar

InExile

Posted 221 days ago
Because he is a killer. Someone who kills is a killer albeit in defense of his life. A killer is not necessarily a murderer: Just an innocent killer.

Saha

Posted 221 days ago
Avatar
Hau, MommaCindy! "This new habit of bringing weapons to a protest is getting out of hand". A new habit really? Have you forgotten the early 1990s, just before the 1994 elections? The term "traditional weapons" was very common then.

Let's just face it, some groups in our country are prone to the singing of war songs - and the carrying of "traditional" weapons as well- as they go on a march or a protest action of any sort. They do so now in the 21st century as they did centuries ago. That's how it is and how it will always be.

People in the south and the south east of the country differ from people from the northern and the north-western parts of our country. The latter group consists of people who'd go to marches "armed" with vuvuzelas and marula tree twigs, LIGHT twigs with fresh green leaves still clinging on them nogal! Surely, poor Zulu wouldn't have drawn his western weapon under such circumstances.

The fact is, migratory labour movements into the new mining areas of the northern and north-western parts of the country have transplated the southern and south-eastern practices to the "the vuvuzela and marula twigs" belt and soon, more guns will be drawn. As we saw in Marikana not long ago.

Facts of life in Mzansi!

MoeaMakhakhe

Posted 221 days ago
Avatar
The Zulus are a warrior nation, warriors would not brandish a weapon infront of Zulu as a token of friendship! Zulu responded in only instinctive Zulu way; shoot to kill! That is the Zulus for you!

Lungig2102

Posted 221 days ago
Avatar
I want to side with xivavula in this one. Was Zulu expected to wait until Dlamini strikes with his spear and when he sees blood oozing out of his body then retaliate. It's a human thing to defend oneself. Perhaps then as one person sees it it depends which side of the country you come from South or North, then we react differently.

RedCoat

Posted 221 days ago
Avatar
Self defence needs to be proven..the fact that Mr Zulu was armed with a pistol means he was as potentialy dangerous as Mr Dlamini carrying his spear, the fact of the matter is that the puported 'lunge' was only witnessed at the scene and not caught on camera to my knowledge.

Furthermore the carrying of traditional weapons is part and parcel of demonstrations and has been for quite sometime,
Was the lunge an actual attack? (Mr Zulu no doubt thought so, and reacted in the manner he did)
i seriously doubt Mr Dlamini was attacking with intent, and it was more a threatening gesture to a percieved enemy.

Mr Zulu should have shown restraint and thought before acting, but that said we are all capable of anything in percieved life threatening situations.

I think a charge of manslaughter should be brought but the guilty verdict limmited to community service and a lifetime ban on ever owning or being in the possession of a deadly weapon.
This coupled with the banning of carrying ANY form of dangerous weapon by any member of the public regardless or cultural rights should ensure cases like this do not repeat themselvs.

But hey who am i kidding? It'll never happen in the real world......

WhatTheHack

Posted 221 days ago
Avatar
People of sober mind please like FB page:
Jacob Zuma Is Not My President

manga2

Posted 221 days ago
Avatar
If the SAPS could do it in Marikana, why not umfo kaMageba (Zulu) eNtuzuma? The Marikana protesters were also carrying spears & pangas but were still a reasonably safe distance away from the cops.
Avatar

Saha

Posted 220 days ago
@manga2
But the question still remains: WHY TREAT A MARCH OR PROTEST ACTION AS A WAR TERRAIN? Why sing traditional war songs and brandish arms as if your employer is an enemy on a battlefield?
Where I come from, traditional weapons are mainly part of traditional ritual ceremonies where they are used as ceremonial artefacts and we hardly carry or brandish them in public. The last time my people - PEOPLE OF THE NORTH - ever carried their traditional arms, was during the Difaqane wars when they were defending themselves against people they referred to as the “naked ones”. You see, “the naked ones” were attacking THE NORTHERN territory from the SOUTH! Rumour has it that, at that point in time, my neighbours in the NORTH-WEST part of the country were so peace loving that they opted to drown themselves in their raging rivers instead of facing the marauding warriors from the SOUTH who were brandishing vicious traditional weapons!
Surely, the Marikana and eNtuzuma tragedies should be spurs for behavioural change. Moreover, many people in our society feel bedevilled by such “traditional” practices. Maybe banning the carrying of traditional weapons should be one of the recommendations of the Marikana Commission.