Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 41413.44
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Top 40 : 3353.49
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Financial 15 : 12096.10
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Industrial 25 : 47171.07
    UNCHANGED0.00%

  • ZAR/USD : 9.4046
    UP 0.05%
    ZAR/GBP : 14.2711
    UP 0.34%
    ZAR/EUR : 12.0825
    UP 1.94%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.0910
    UP 0.13%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.1437
    UP 0.13%

  • Gold : 1360.1000
    UP 0.37%
    Platinum : 1455.0000
    UP 0.28%
    Silver : 22.2600
    UP 0.16%
    Palladium : 738.5000
    UP 0.61%
    Brent Crude Oil : 104.640
    UNCHANGED0.00%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Sun May 19 05:13:24 SAST 2013

Mines strike back

TJ STRYDOM | 17 October, 2012 00:1944 Comments
Striking mineworkers at Gold Fields' KDC mine gather on a hill at Mphahlele in Carletonville after being evicted from their hostel by management. File photo.
Image by: MOELETSI MABE

In what could become the biggest mass-dismissal to date, Gold Fields plans to fire up to about 15000 striking mineworkers if they do not return to work tomorrow.

Gold Fields joins Gold One, Anglo Platinum and Kumba Iron Ore, all of which have taken a tough stance against a wave of wildcat strikes that has crippled the mining sector by dismissing thousands of workers.

Gold Fields chief executive Nick Holland said yesterday the company issued the ultimatum after exhausting "all reasonable and lawful alternatives".

This followed a month of paralysis caused by an illegal strike at the company's KDC-West mining complex, near Carletonville, on the West Rand. That strike has since spilled over to Gold Fields' Beatrix and KDC-East mines.

As many as 100000 mineworkerrs joined unprotected strikes in the aftermath of the Marikana shootings, in which 34 miners were killed in August.

Holland said "quite a lot of people are keen to get back to work" but were being prevented from doing so by small bands of "intimidators".

After the collapse of negotiations between the National Union of Mineworkers and the Chamber of Mines earlier this week, Holland believes the ultimatum is the only way "to break the escalating violence on our property".

The mining companies' tough stance against the illegal strikes began two weeks ago when Anglo Platinum dismissed 12500 workers. Gold One followed suit on Monday when it fired 1417 workers at its Ezulwini mine. Operations at the mine have been suspended for at least 30 days.

Kumba not only dismissed 300 workers disrupting its operations at Sishen earlier this week, but also laid charges of extortion, intimidation, theft, trespassing, malicious damage to property and contempt of court against them.

Kumba has a staff complement of 13000 at its Sishen mine. The 300 strikers had seized equipment worth billions of rands and brought operations to a halt at the mine, where workers last year were each paid R500 000 in incentive bonuses and received R15000 in dividends earlier this year and a wage increase a few months ago.

Police removed the striking workers from the mine yesterday morning. The company said it planned to resume operations soon.

But National Union of Mineworkers is worried that dismissals will make things worse.

NUM spokesman Lesiba Seshoka said issuing ultimatums did not take into account the fact that many workers were not taking part in the strikes of their own free will.

"It is very difficult to draw a line between our members and the disruptive forces causing the strikes," he said.

But the "disruptive forces are in charge," he said, threatening NUM members' lives.

Seshoka claimed mining bosses were secretly relishing the opportunity to cut staff.

Holland said, however, that Gold Fields had been more than reasonable in trying to find an amicable solution.

Restructuring, he said, could not be ruled out and it was too early to say whether the strikes had caused permanent damage to the industry.

"We're in uncharted territory," he said.

The longest planned stoppages usually occur over the Christmas break. Operations have now been suspended for nearly a month, stoking fears that production might not return to normal soon.

According to Holland, all Gold Fields workers who report for duty by 2pm tomorrow will benefit from an earlier proposal, tabled by the Chamber of Mines and involving a range of adjustments within the current wage agreements.

The proposal would translate into a 3% wage increase, he said. Holland was, however, quick to say his company was not breaking ranks with the rest of the industry not rewarding illegal behaviour.

"We need to stick to existing wage agreements," he said, adding that it was "quite possible" that other gold mining companies would do the same.

Harmony Gold yesterday said it was still following internal processes to resolve a wildcat strike by 5400 workers at its Kusasalethu operations.

Gold Fields' KDC East mine yesterday applied for a court interdict to have the strike there involving 8500 workers declared illegal.

Holland said he planned to follow the same course at the company's other mines, adding he would soon issue another ultimatum.

To submit comments you must first

Join the discussion & Debate

Mines strike back

For Commenters Consideration | Please stick to the subject matter

COMMENTS [44]

Timbuck10

Posted 213 days ago
Avatar
As the famous saying goes... : "KEEP WALKING ... COMRADES!"
Avatar

buddi

Posted 213 days ago
@Duzulu
Kumba - where workers last year were each paid R500 000 in incentive bonuses and received R15000 in dividends earlier this year and a wage increase a few months ago.

Doesn't sound like peanuts to me!
Avatar

Mushroom-Threads

Posted 212 days ago
Another famous saying..... "the more you have, the more you want."
Some while ago, in negotiations with a union, I asked why my organization was subjected to such excessive pressure, considering that we offered the best-by-far pay and conditions in the field. The union stated that it was important to keep us up front, because it helped in getting better results out of less generous companies.
We could see where that road was headed, so reduced our manufacturing operations, and switched to marketing an imported product. Bye-bye greedy employees.

SuiGeneris

Posted 213 days ago
Avatar
Where does their strike action leave them now ? Unemployed in a country with an abundance of new job opportunities !

No money to feed their families.

The thoughts that are created inside a vacuum are always dangerous and always have dire consequences.

Normally it take form of a demand.

We demand a salary of R 16 000 !
We demand that you give us back our land !
Avatar

Duzula

Posted 213 days ago
So you mean this workers must work for peanuts...
Avatar

Mike123

Posted 213 days ago
No Duzula. It means that it would be nice it labour unions actually used their brains for once.
Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 213 days ago
''......So you mean this workers must work for peanuts...''

Have you ever heard of free will ?
Free will that also includes the fact that you accepted the salary and terms and conditions of employment.

If, at a later stage, you feel that you work for ''peanuts'', then you should discuss an increase with your employer.

Should your employer refuse an increase, then it is up to you to stay or pack your bags and find better pastures elsewhere !

The civilized way !
Avatar

buddi

Posted 213 days ago
@Duzulu
Kumba - where workers last year were each paid R500 000 in incentive bonuses and received R15000 in dividends earlier this year and a wage increase a few months ago.

Doesn't sound like peanuts to me!
Avatar

amaKK

Posted 213 days ago
@Duzula,

Do you read?

From the article above:

Kumba has a staff complement of 13000 at its Sishen mine...workers last year were each paid R500 000 in incentive bonuses and received R15000 in dividends earlier this year and a wage increase a few months ago.

Peanuts, really?

And as Sui said, there's always freewill. They can leave quietly, hopefully with the door hitting them on their way out.

As an aside, is the article correct? R500k per person in incentive bonuses???
Avatar

amaKK

Posted 213 days ago
@Buddi, snap ;-)
Avatar

Duzula

Posted 213 days ago
I do read, but you're only talking about one Company what about the other companies who are exploiting workers...
This have gone far too long...
Avatar

Flavious

Posted 213 days ago
Rubbish Duzulu!! Exploitation of the workers you say?? There would be no "exploitation" if your ANC aligned comrades in Cosatu/NUM were not trying to punch above their weight in the ring of politics which has made them forget about the workers. This same amnesia also brought about by focussing on single-minded wealth accumulation as well.

The unholy "alliance" is always trying to put the blame on others and never takes responsibility !!!

deebee

Posted 213 days ago
Avatar
The thing about this series of strikes is that they are illegal. Let's just understand that first and foremost. These strikes are illegal. If mineworkers think they're being shafted (pun intended) then get rid of the bloated fat cat union bosses. Stop voting for them and their tenderpreneur name-on-a-corporate-letterhead political bosses in the ANC.

If the workers at Sishen had followed through and destroyed R3bn worth of equipment, what then? Would the unions have been held liable? More importantly, what are the union leaders (and I use that term advisedly) doing to stop these illegal strikes: they are part of a system that regulates labour and industrial action; they've ensured that it is extremely expensive and time consuming to fire even the worst of workers; they've ensured that the lack of flexibility in our labour laws essentially precludes the unemployed from entering the jobs market - and yet they are too spineless to fulfil their end of the bargain and ensure that industrial action by their members is lawful and peaceful.

The bottom line is that the union leaders in South Africa are spineless, lack any kind of vision, are completely lacking in morality, and like their political bosses, see South Africa as a playground for competing political agendas and to hell with the country. There is not a single union leader that actually looks at South Africa in the context of our collapsing global competitiveness - they can't think that far and are thus a complete liability to South Africa and a prosperous future for all of our citizens.
Avatar

Ozgood

Posted 213 days ago
And COSATU's Vavi still supports Zuma.....When will this end? With the downturn affecting China the Australian mining industry is now feeling the pinch. Australia has a AAA rating. So what do these South African striking miners think that they will achieve?

How many are unwilling participants in this mess?

JohnDoe

Posted 213 days ago
Avatar
This is what happens when unions play in the political arena instead of actually looking after their members. If the UNIONS actually put pressure (legally) on the mines to ensure good working conditions and a decent salary then the workers wouldn't have to resort to these strikes.

I don't condone the strikers actions but I understand them. Imagine paying a union month after month a portion of your small salary yet nothing actually improves?

Also this has created an air of confusion and mistrust, no one know actually how much the workers get paid in the end and how much the mines can afford. If the facts were clear and the UNIONS should have investigated this fully, then an agreement could be reach. Now we have wild cats making demands without all the information needed

There such a massive hole in leadership in our country, in all spheres both public and private no one seems to have a compass pointing in the right direction
Avatar

deebee

Posted 213 days ago
"There such a massive hole in leadership in our country, in all spheres both public and private no one seems to have a compass pointing in the right direction"

Absolutely spot on. As much as the politicians and unions must carry the can for so much of the mess in our country right now (and it's the bulk of it), the 'Captains of Industry' have hardly covered themselves in glory either. Unrealistic bonuses in a struggling emerging economy, slashing workforces (right-sizing, I think is the euphemism) to meet shareholder targets, lacking a common, articulated vision and strategy for South Africa over the long-term and not having the guts to stand up to government and get dirty when it is required.

I see there is a big meeting today with business, government and unions to look at these latest illegal strikes and their impact, but I wonder if anythying realisitc and concrete will come out of it? And who will be the voice of small business in all of this? The engine of employment and growth, so we're told - but I doubt very much anything that comes out of this will take SMME's into account.
Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 213 days ago
There should be legal documentation between all the unions and government that should include a clause whereby the unions will agree that they will.....

1] Always be in full control of any organized strike.
2] Never allow any strike to turn into a riot situation.
3] Shall be liable for any damage caused by a strike action.
4] Compensate any party in full for damages suffered in such event.
Avatar

JohnDoe

Posted 213 days ago
Not gonna happen although I do think it is reason to hold the unions accountable when they clear have made no effort to contain their memembers. I have never heard a union rep admit their members did something wrong. It is usually a 3rd force or something like that.

This is whether government should step in but they are afraid of the union. When violence started to flair up in Marikana a good leader which Zuma is not would have called in the minister of police and said "Go get that area under control, if it is not under control in 1 day, you are fired" at the same time he should have told the Minister of Minerals and water to get the Mine bosses and unions into a room and sort everything out.

But not the government buried their head and let it fester until it exploded
Avatar

deebee

Posted 213 days ago
@SuiGeneris

Absolutely spot on about union accountability - but as JD says, not gonna happen whilst unions get away, quite literally, with murder. Until unions are held strictly accountable for the actions of their members this kind of mess is only political pot-stir away from the surface.

SuiGeneris

Posted 213 days ago
Avatar
Photo.....The pot-belly instigator !
Avatar

jamesnaker

Posted 213 days ago
Photo...1 month later...Potbelly instigator standing at robot with that hat in his hand...eish.
Avatar

BobbyBob

Posted 213 days ago
No dude cant you see he is hungry?

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 213 days ago
Avatar
The strikes, as well as the employers' response thereto, are re-defining the political and trade union terrain. As a result of the banning of all political organisations, COSATU became the single organisation that broke the back of apartheid. By re-defining itself as a political organisation, after 1994, it then forsake its trade union role, effectively, as experienced in recent events. It may have gained concessions in terms of labour legislation, and influencing of the general political space. But it necessarily pitted itself against the workers, just by joining a ruling elite. Ironically, the ANC has never understood how to account to a broader society, as a ruling party. Its refusal to re-categorize itself as a political party -in fear of playing the game according to the rules - makes it irresponsible, and unable to consider the citizens as worth accounting to.

The seeming benefits of playing the new game according to the old rules may have seemed attractive, but they simultaneously contain the demise, as they were made out of expediency.
Avatar

deebee

Posted 213 days ago
Very nicely put. Pity this dinosaur site doesn't have recommend buttons!

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 213 days ago
Avatar
If the mines do restructure, they will go mechanised. The salaries will be higher but the number of employees will go down to about a third of what it is now. Is that really what they want?
Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 213 days ago
''.....they will go mechanised.....''

Mechanical engineers, specializing in automated machine building, had a roaring trade for the last 15 years.
Avatar

JohnDoe

Posted 213 days ago
Yip and this is how all industries in the country should go. In order to be competitive you need to product more with less and for it to be cheaper. The reason miners in Canda for example get paid so much more is because there are less of them per mine but they produce as much or more than the S.A. mines.

That however doesn't solve the unemployment problem which actually lays bare the fact that our individual problems in South Africa don't have individual isolated solutions.

MsLee

Posted 213 days ago
Avatar
No matter which way you look at it, this is not going to end well ...

Wort

Posted 213 days ago
Avatar
Well, the miners have caved in. They've gone back to work. They sensed that the bosses were not bluffing. So the miners have gained nothing except humiliation.
Avatar

buddi

Posted 213 days ago
Plus several weeks of 'no pay'.

muk2

Posted 213 days ago
Avatar
You and I can see that capitalism is about supply and demand. If the supply of labour is abundant then the salaries will be low. However this is not seen from the eyes of the workers; hence their attraction to socialism and communism. The workers see their bosses getiing millions per year; and this annoys them. How do you bridge this divide?
Avatar

BobbyBob

Posted 213 days ago
Education, a basic right the ANC is denying the country.
Avatar

buddi

Posted 213 days ago
I also think I work much harder than my boss, and proven to be more effective. However, fact of life is, that he gets more money!
Avatar

JohnDoe

Posted 213 days ago
Well then you need to start your own business or find another job where they appreciate you. That is your choice

BobbyBob

Posted 213 days ago
Avatar
From the mine's perspective this makes sense and it plays into eryone's unspoken "I told you so" agenda.For instance, it proves that labour cannot be sensible and understand that they are to blame for heir own misfortune. Jobs are lost and people go hungry. It also "confirms" that the current "leaders" dont understand how to run a country. So the economy suffers and we will move into a Zim or DRC scenario pretty soon. "I told you so".

MicaParis

Posted 213 days ago
Avatar
Mining strikes marked a turning point in the history of our country, but however there are many obfuscated factors left by media, government and civil society campaigns alike.
Every investigative institution relied too much on “official sources” for the essence of what is happening in Mines in S A but however on incidents of repression such sources are often unreliable, as they have a lot to lose by telling the truth.
Precisely a person cannot rest much blame on the strikers basing a contention on how the salaries of the President, Ministers, Premiers and CEO’s are overwhelmingly excessive if not first world standard.
Even though a salary of a person is much articulated by the academic capacity, political superiority and family ownership financial status but however the fact that the elite salaries are way too much high must not be left aloof as it's a very important factor to the hike in strikes.
Moreover they do not really sweat for what they earn except the fact that they are politicians or owners of the properties bringing in the loot, that portray to the workers to feel like being excluded from the ‘’good life’’ which fuels anger into their feelings, which causes strikes.
We must try to be reasonable about how we pay our subordinates and try to treat them with dignity and humanity to avoid off side trauma and agonistic issues that will leave them shuttered and inferior.
Let's pay them reasonable salaries which will make them pass through the rigors of inflation and general coast of living, a 3500 to 10 000 salary scale is very degrading under the present economic conditions, let us not forget the fact that the very same people are taking care of very large extended families, may we please have mercy and try desperately to share whatever we have in the spirit of humanity, after all we are all human beings equal in terms of section 9 of the constitution.
Avatar

BobbyBob

Posted 213 days ago
What drivel. Its supply and demand. People need to be educated so they can understand that . An education will also teach them how to run their own businesses if they feel so inclined so they can be bosses as well. Its a pity the ANC does not rate education as important.
Avatar

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 213 days ago
Chances are that they will be told to go and work for Malema, just as capitalists referred strikers to Mandela, during apartheid. Fact is that the nation state is a capitalist creation, mainly to enforce monopolistic property laws. On the other hand trade unions are bourgeoisie institutions, living in a parasitic relationship with capitalists, and profiteering from labour sweat. Add the opportunistic BEE to that, and then you have the current confusion.
Avatar

BobbyBob

Posted 213 days ago
m1si2zi3nzo4
Man you are confused. Property rights are not monopolistic. They together with labour and capital make up an economy. There is nothing confusing about that. Perhaps the only issue is that people dont uderstand it, and therefore dont participate in it to their full potential. Back to the ANC's lack of education priorities.
Avatar

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 213 days ago
The idea of 'voting' for representatives originated when people began to question monopolistic property ownership by capitalists. They then developed a confidence trick of epic proportions; and asked people to 'vote' for those they wished to represent them. Ultimately, this led to the formation of the existing nation states, as people 'voted' for different 'representatives', and these, inevitably, cut the globe into different enclaves, ruled by 'elected representatives. Now that the world citizens want to connect with the people of the globe, these dictatorships are resisting for as much as they fear to lose in a global election.
Avatar

MicaParis

Posted 213 days ago
BobbyBob
You have a chronic perpetual lack of knowledge on general South African affairs judging by your one sided none idealistic analysis.
You will never comment more than your knowledge can share if you do not have the relevant reality and facts about the knowledge you straggle so much to internalise.
You sound too much of a ''bornfree''/ freak than a compatriot who knows both sides of the stories as far as South African affairs are concerned, may be you sound too much like Zuma who believe that South African culture only entails Zulus and Xhosas, what about Afrikaners and Koisan, they are also part of our history, never mind the Afrikaner name changes, only!

M1si2zi3nzo4
I wish we had someone like you in the Presidential Economic Advisory Council and Policy Development Council, you would add value indeed, lots of comrades are impressed with your free of insults commentary and innovative intellectual ability in your commentary keep it up, that is what this media space was provided to achieve.
Avatar

UDFSupporter

Posted 213 days ago
@MicaParis: At the risk of repeating myself.... why do you persist in commenting in super-duper educated English when simple and plain English would suffice? What probably annoys most readers is when you try and sound educated put commit so many grammatical errors and mangling well-known expressions to make your "point". I know that you can keep it concise and simple when you really have a point to make.You know about the "kiss" method so why not use it.
Avatar

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 213 days ago
"comrades" impressed with "free insults" Wow! That would be a complete revelation. In fact, if many capitalists and politicians had their way, I would be dead meat by now. My worldview is chalk-and-cheese with the conventional foofaraw, no one dares touch me. In fact, those who dare, do so to enhance their standing, and market themselves. Its so boring, because they try to enslave my opinions to their limited world. Fiercely independent people get labelled as 'insulting', when they speak their mind. In my world every human being has a contribution to make to society. As soon as he succumbs to someone else's intellect,he does not deserve his individuality. He becomes superfluous, someone else's slave. He will never live his life, in fear of material poverty.

WhatTheHack

Posted 213 days ago
Avatar
People of sound mind please like FB page:

facebook.com/JacobZumaIsNotMyPresident