Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 39988.17
    DOWN -1.95%
    Top 40 : 3318.09
    DOWN -2.04%
    Financial 15 : 10922.27
    DOWN -1.75%
    Industrial 25 : 45951.41
    DOWN -1.94%

  • ZAR/USD : 10.3019
    UP 1.13%
    ZAR/GBP : 15.9064
    UP 0.87%
    ZAR/EUR : 13.5838
    UP 0.35%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.1052
    DOWN -0.17%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.4674
    UP 0.18%

  • Gold : 1287.2350
    DOWN -4.18%
    Platinum : 1394.5000
    DOWN -0.96%
    Silver : 19.8000
    DOWN -6.64%
    Palladium : 674.0000
    DOWN -2.18%
    Brent Crude Oil : 104.040
    DOWN -1.96%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Thu Jun 20 12:31:29 SAST 2013

SA has 'lost its compass'

PHILANI NOMBEMBE | 18 October, 2012 00:12
Trevor Manuel currently serving in the Cabinet of South Africa as Minister in the Presidency
Image by: Raymond Preston/ Sunday Times.

Minister in the Presidency Trevor Manuel has questioned parents' involvement in their children's education.

Manuel spoke at the launch of the "SA Child Gauge 2012", a report on children released by the University of Cape Town.

The report says South Africa's children live in "unequal worlds", 18 years into democracy.

"Recent events of the non-delivery of textbooks to [Limpopo] school children, dumping of textbooks and barring of children from attending schools by parents in parts of our country [are] a vivid demonstration... of the journey ahead. These events by parents and people in positions of authority are an indication of how we have lost our compass," said Manuel.

"How did parents not know that their children have not received fresh textbooks for the new school year? Do parents, actually, keep track of whether their children have access to books?

"Where were religious leaders when parents turned against their children in areas such as Olifantshoek and in the John Taolo Gaetsewe district and deprived them of education, their ticket to a better life?"

The report found that the poorest 10% of the country's people received less than 1% of the national income, while the richest 10% received 57% of the income.

It also found that 60% of the country's children lived in households with an income of less than R575 a month.

Racial disparities also exist, with 67% of African children living below the poverty line, compared with 2% of white children.

The apartheid legacy also still has a hold on children. About 43% of young children live in poor conditions in the country's former homelands.

The report found that difficulties in accessing birth certificates and IDs prevented many children from getting child support grants before their first birthdays, when nutritional support is most critical.

"About 44% of healthcare expenditure goes to the private sector, yet it services only 15% of the population," reads the report.

Many children rely on public healthcare, which employs only 31% of the country's doctors, 25% of specialists and 46% of professional nurses. The situation is even worse in rural areas as only 12% of doctors and 19% of nurses work there.

The report also found that though the government spent a lot of money on education, "outcomes were persistently poor and highly unequal across schools".

Said Manuel: "The work we are doing in the National Planning Commission is about the next generation. It is about addressing the forms of inequality that run all the way through South African society, and that, in many cases, affects children, especially in vulnerable and rural communities."

SHARE YOUR OPINION

If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.

PSG

Posted 245 days ago
Avatar
Minister Manuel just imagine what could have been done with the money that was paid for the arms that we can't even use today had you not been party to the dealings when you were the Finance Minister.
Avatar

JohnDoe

Posted 245 days ago
I am going to be a pessimist here and say nothing more could have been done because whether it was squandered on the arms deal or something else there just is not transparency or accountability.

We are not a rich nation but we are also not poor, there is money to achieve what we need to but it needs to be used effectively and not on hotel stays, expensive travel, upgrading of administrative building with fancy furniture, salaries paid to people who do not perform.

Spend the money well, hold people accountable and I bet a lot of the problems we have today would not here
Avatar

PSG

Posted 245 days ago
@JohnDoe, so true that's what I was trying to allude to :-).
Avatar

truthwins

Posted 245 days ago
What we need in South Africa is a government that accepts the GOD that Christ referred to as his father, and not the God of the greedy called MAMMON.
Once we accept the real God we will all prosper and experience real freedom.
Avatar

GregSmith

Posted 244 days ago
That's right blame the parents for no text books, dumping no delivery.

F.U Manuel
Avatar

v_3

Posted 244 days ago
No-one, but no-one is in more need of compass recalibration than Trevor Clever.

This drek was happy to sign away our future, bonding the country to foreign bribe-givers so that he and his cronies could score.

As minister of finance, he oversaw the country's infrastructure investment strike, resulting in load-shedding (causing how many job-losses?) and the degradation of our roads. (It's easier to rename a road than to maintain it). He also was part of the cover-up regimin that expanded under his and Mbeki's and Zuma's rule.

Now he has the cheek to blame the parents. The reason you get that fat salary and the lekker perks, scumbag, is to be a minister and to take collective responsibility!

It was the ANC that destroyed the idea of learning (and the consequent wealth & job creation that educated people make) preferring "liberation before education" - for the masses, while their kids were educated privately or overseas. It is the ANC that messed around with education from firing the best teachers to screwing up university curricula.

SA does not need pompous sanctimonious flakes. Just take the money and go. Quietly.

Iktav

Posted 245 days ago
Avatar
Yes Mr Manuel - this all happened under your party's watch! Don't try blaming Apartheid for this one! The FACT of the matter is this country is being led by an incompetent government headed by a buffoon president. There's nothing I can do about it. Like Zimbabwe, while the ANC continues to be voted into power by a dumb electorate, things will not change. In fact it will only go from bad to worse! Get onto it Mr Manuel. You're in the ANC. Do something!

nkosipeter

Posted 245 days ago
Avatar
Trevor Manuel is a commentator, not a player. He quotes data from a university's research, for heavens sake. Data he should have owned and known, and presented at cabinet meetings for years.

His intellect, which is great, is matched only by his cowardice, hiding away in the ANC's skirts.

muk2

Posted 245 days ago
Avatar
Mr. Mauuel, I once rated you and Pravin very highly. You guys raised the IQ of mininsters; now you both are dissapointing me big time. Do the other cabinet ministers really listen to what you are telling us? I don't think so. These stats you present to us is not new; what we need is delivery and action. How may of the ministries don't spend their allocated budgets? Please Mr. Manual start preaching to you cabinet collagues to execute their mandate.

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 245 days ago
Avatar
One sometimes wonders which country our ministers live in. They certainly don't understand ours.

The government should be grateful for the private industry. If it wasn't for private hospitals and private schools, they'd have to take care of our kids too. Instead, we pay for everything twice which gives them more money to steal.

Schools should be places of learning. Not only academic learning but also social learning. Make schools into what you want the country to become. Clean, disciplined, respectful, healthy places. Give these kids a taste of what they should be striving for. Of course that means getting the thugs of the SAD teachers union out and accountability in.

SuiGeneris

Posted 245 days ago
Avatar
'''''......SA has 'lost its compass'.......'''''

TRUE ! But why don't you call a spade a spade !?

What Manuel are actually trying to say is that the SA government has lost its ability to govern this country effectively !

And this include each and every aspect of government.

Avatar

Mushroom-Threads

Posted 245 days ago
Correction- - Mr M was trying to say something profound, but he fails to speak straight. For years it has been perfectly obvious that the majority of the citizens do not give a fig for formal education, or for any self-starter activism appropriate for digging one's nation out of a bad past.
The style is "arms folded", some-one will provide - -!

Mike123

Posted 245 days ago
Avatar
Perhaps, one day, South Africans will wake up to the fact that the leaders of the revolution (and this has been the case in ALL revolutions that I know of), simply become the new oppressors.
Avatar

QPCLCD308

Posted 245 days ago
As long as its name is called ANC, call it a failure and disaster!
Avatar

Mike123

Posted 245 days ago
In life there are two types of tards. i.e. Mustard and retard. It's easy to tell them apart. The one is yellow and is good on ham sandwiches and hot dogs. The other votes for the ANC.

nkosipeter

Posted 245 days ago
Avatar
Compass? Who needs a compass when you have a spear you can poke in any and every direction....frequently :)
Avatar

FirstLadyNo.3

Posted 245 days ago
ha ha ha!!! good one

Snow

Posted 245 days ago
Avatar
The compass is lost?

No way.

It is to be found in the Western Cape, your home province, and is called the Democratic Alliance, the ONLY party that has a strategy AND a compass.
Avatar

QPCLCD308

Posted 245 days ago
At list certain members of the society are still sane in their head!

Mzungu

Posted 245 days ago
Avatar
Trevor,

How rich are you? Give us your nett worth, yes, the combined value (incl wife).

Only then we can continue discussing, now it's worthless to talk about this.

AlexNagel

Posted 245 days ago
Avatar
I always have and always will have great respect for Minister Manuel. However he always seems to trot out the same old excuses for the inadequacies of the government of which he has been a part for so long. Apartheid, Parents, Religious leaders are now all of a sudden partially responsible for the "Textbook saga" and the blockade of the schools for a few months. Religious leaders have met with government during this period and no doubt raised these issues but to no avail. If schools were being blockaded why were the law enforcement agencies not sent in within days to normalise the situation? Not even the responsible minister was prepared to visit the area due to safety concerns.Please point the finger at yourselves and the inadequacies and prevaricating of this regime.
Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 245 days ago
He was also very quick to implement VAT to fill the government's coffers to the brim and reduce the spending power of the poor with a further 14 %

Who can eat bread and a few other VAT exempted items every day ?

Timbuck10

Posted 245 days ago
Avatar
South Africa "LOST IT'S COMPASS" back on that fateful day in 1994, when a REVOLUTIONARY PARTY took the reigns, WITH NO IDEA OF RUNNING A GOVERNMENT!
If you look back at just the R66 BILLION spent on the Arms Deal fiasco.... and the R31 BILLION spent on WHITE ELEPHANT SOCCER STADIUMS ALONE...
Imagine the SOCIAL UPLIFTMENT that could have happened with that monies...????
That's like almost R100 000 000 000-00.....
Never mind the TRILLIONS of RANDS, already stuffed into the Cadre's BACKPOCKETS......and the other TRILLIONS SQUANDERED on un-neccessary wastage(No receipts-Unqualified Audits)....
Just imagine Trevor.... Just imagine!
THis will continue until SA is on par with Zimboland.... and then it wil be to LATE!

MicaParis

Posted 245 days ago
Avatar
The following words by the poet Bertolt Brecht sums it up!
‘’Study from bottom up,
for you who will take the leadership,
it is not too late!
Study the ABC;
it is not enough, but study it!
Do not become discouraged, begin!
You must know everything!
You must prepare to take command, now!
Study, man next to you!
Study, man in the prison!
Study, wife in your kitchen!
Study, old-age pensioner!
You must prepare to take command now!
Locate yourself a school, homeless folk!
Go search some knowledge, you who freeze!
You who starve, reach for a book: it will be a weapon.
You must prepare to take command now.
Don’t be afraid to question, comrades!
Never believe in faith. See for yourself!
What you yourself don’t learn you don’t know.
Question the reckoning – you yourself must pay it
Set down your finger on each small item, asking: where do you get this?
You must prepare to take command now!’’

A fool(SA Government) will loose tomorrow trying to reach for yesterday!
Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 245 days ago
Sad to say that the greatest majority of people in SA are not in least interested in improving their knowledge.
Their minds are simply not programmed in that direction.
They are simply content with a day-to-day existence.
Avatar

MicaParis

Posted 245 days ago
SuiGeneris

Our ANC cadres think education is defined as a leverage to control tenders and fat administrative posts for their friends, ‘’secret lovers’’ and family members, for them a PhD Degree is a ''Cabinet post'' at which they only guest as masquerading complete hollow suits.

Our ANC cadres are blind to realities other than their own. The ‘’rich/looters’’ might not understand the concerns of the poor. But ignoring what people say because of their alleged ‘privilege’ can also be a disingenuous and lazy rhetorical tactic.

I work with the kin pin mafia chief of them all, Sui, I am telling you trying to rehabilitate the corruption addiction out of an ANC cadre is a complete futile exercise and trying to resurrection a dead moral compass in the movement is like trying to wake-up, a two weeks old corpse from the grave!

Stirrer

Posted 245 days ago
Avatar
Surely it's time for former UDF comrades to emancipate themselves from this fake-ANC, whose pathetic service delivery record they are obliged to protect at all costs.
But I suppose it is too late for most of them, having been sucked into sordid unjust enrichment schemes at the expense of honest tax-paying citizens.
Avatar

muk2

Posted 245 days ago
@Stirrer. UDF has its time in the sun. Those that served on the UDF; have no voices now. The struggle and governing a country are two different beasts. How governing a country has runied lots of the comrades. Egos and greed has taken over. Sad ne? Instead of reading Stalin, Lenin and Karl Marx; they should try reading Mahatma Gandi.

Mercenary

Posted 245 days ago
Avatar
This guys is so clever we need him in government,wait he is and has been for the past 17years #sarcastic tone# You know we in the s#$t when its takes guys like Manual a few year to say what every citizen and the world knows.

UDFSupporter

Posted 245 days ago
Avatar
Sorry Comrade Trevor but I must disagree with you. We have never owned a compass as can be evidenced by the first thing we did since coming into power in 1994. W spend billions we did not have on weapons we did not need.

ER2

Posted 245 days ago
Avatar
Sorry Trevor, you did have a compass, what you don't have are navigators ...
Avatar

Timbuck10

Posted 245 days ago
LOL.... more like a RUDDERLESS DINGY......
Avatar

QPCLCD308

Posted 245 days ago
The definition of Trevor is a lackey leech government stooge who is currently shivering and begging ''zoomer'' to retain him in the looting train, he can hardly do without a looting spree.
Trevor is a nobody without any say and influence in the current ANC government, he is only gesturing in honor of showing sympathy to zoomer during 2007 Polokwane coup de tat!
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 245 days ago
Therein lies the problem. Bloody hard to navigate even with a compass and a navigator if you don't have a clue which direction you are going in. You end up going in 'squircles'
Avatar

RowanClark

Posted 239 days ago
Yes This ship is at sea not holding a course but drifting ,as the captain has lost the compass and the crew are getting restless as the rations are being wasted away by the officers .The navigator(TM) is busy blaming the older sailors for the younger crew are not getting schooled for life on deck and the rigging needs maintenance but the ships company has chased away all the skilled deckhands .The waters around the boat are getting more shark infested ,the hull has more barnacles and the worm ridden planks and the moth eaten sails are slowing the ship down. The taxes and tolls to use the waters are getting higher and the ship is finding it harder to trade as it has less credit at the ports .the good ship RSA.

WhatTheHack

Posted 245 days ago
Avatar
"it is quite wrong that the next president of the ANC, and thus of the country, should be chosen by a mere 4,000 or so committed delegates of the ANC"

Please like Facebook page:
facebook.com/JacobZumaIsNotMyPresident

PeterPancake

Posted 245 days ago
Avatar
It never ceases to amaze me how ANC comrades come up with comments such as 'lost its compass'. The only reason S.A. has lost it's compass is because the ANC have treated their voters like victims and fed them like mushrooms in the dark, whilst it squanders the countries money on Italian suites, single malt whiskey and German sedans, whilst on every street corner we see young women begging with new-born's on their backs. ( Who is going to pay to support all of these children, when are men going to take responsibility for their actions!). Because of the victim mentality and free everything that permeates our society, the majority can't and won't help themselves- right down to allowing ANC PARTNER!! labour unions- to intimidate children and parents into not getting an education. Trevor, the chickens have come home to roost. You and your kind have been found out and you don't know which way to turn. You cannot manage this country, but you can effectively collect taxes well enough and then question why the country is in disarray when streets are crumbling, education stuffed and a health system that is dysfunctional. It's easy to keep blaming apartheid isn't it. But it's not at all because of BBEE and AA, where many unqualified persons have been 'deployed' to positions they are currently unfit to take charge of, or can't be bothered to take charge of adequately.

QPCLCD308

Posted 245 days ago
Avatar
SA has 'lost its compass', NO NO NO, the heading should read, cACNcer had lost its compass!
A spade should be called a spade!

nkosipeter

Posted 245 days ago
Avatar
Who needs a compass?

Banana anyone?

Now we're talking.

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 245 days ago
Avatar
The only compass the SA'n elite need is a moral one, which involves accountability for public representatives to the electorate.
Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 245 days ago
Your hopes and dreams will be futile.
What happened here over the last 18 years will simply continue into infinity, but on a much grander scale than ever seen before.

Zee_Fire

Posted 245 days ago
Avatar
Just my controversial and conspiracy theory's two cents worth. It is not in the best interest of the ANC to provide decent education to the masses, if they did, people would start realizing that the ANC has done very little to improve their lives. An uneducated society is much easier to control than an educated one.

Anticrooks

Posted 244 days ago
Avatar
Trevor, you're a fine one to talk! Tell us what happened to the billions that were stolen during the arms deal that you approved. You, Mac Maharaj and the Shaiks are all crooks just like most of the other ANC's so-called leadership but you guys want to pretend like the others are corrupt and not you all. No person with half a brain cell will pay attention to anything you have to say; you are tainted and will have to live with that stigma attached to you.