Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 39961.55
    DOWN -2.02%
    Top 40 : 3317.84
    DOWN -2.04%
    Financial 15 : 10891.67
    DOWN -2.03%
    Industrial 25 : 45965.32
    DOWN -1.91%

  • ZAR/USD : 10.2509
    UP 0.63%
    ZAR/GBP : 15.8418
    UP 0.46%
    ZAR/EUR : 13.5326
    DOWN -0.02%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.1047
    DOWN -0.69%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.4402
    DOWN -0.10%

  • Gold : 1302.7850
    DOWN -3.02%
    Platinum : 1401.5000
    DOWN -0.46%
    Silver : 20.2160
    DOWN -4.68%
    Palladium : 676.5000
    DOWN -1.81%
    Brent Crude Oil : 104.450
    DOWN -1.57%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Thu Jun 20 13:46:12 SAST 2013

Phiyega irks families

GRAEME HOSKEN | 24 October, 2012 00:11
Family members of deceased Marikana miners breakdown on watching the Etv footage of miners striking at Lonmin's Marikana mine near Rustenburg, being gunned down by SAPS members, at the Rustenburg Civic Centre during the Marikana commission of inquiry.
Image by: Daniel Born

National Police Commissioner Riah Phiyega yesterday laughed and joked as grim footage of the killing of 34 miners was screened at the Farlam Commission of Inquiry.

Showing scant regard for the families of those gunned down by her officers, Phiyega joked with a state law adviser as a prelude to the killings was screened at the Rustenburg Civic Centre.

Surrounded by her senior officers, Phiyega smiled as she watched one of the four screens.

It was only after screams of horror echoed across the room, as the footage was played without any warning, that Phiyega's humorous demeanor changed to that of an ice queen, blatantly ignoring wailing families.

With social workers, trauma counsellors, paramedics and religious leaders rushing to help, Phiyega stared straight ahead, ignoring a widow screaming at her for answers about her husband's death.

"Why did they do this? Why did your policemen kill my husband? What did he do?" she screamed, tears streaming down her cheeks as she listened to the echoing sounds of automatic gunfire and a policeman screaming: "I shoot you."

The woman's husband was among the 34 miners killed at Lonmin mine's Wonderkop on August 16.

With elderly men openly weeping as they watched footage of their sons dying and paramedics frantically trying to revive several women who had collapsed, Phiyega ignored the pandemonium that played itself out in front of her.

She was, instead, later seen comforting one of the widows of the two policemen murdered along with eight other people in the days before the bloodbath.

Asked repeatedly for comment as to why, as a mother she had not shown any empathy, tried to comfort the bereaved and what she had been joking about, Phiyega lashed out.

"I am not here for that. I am here for the commission and the commission only," she snapped.

A visibly irate Bishop Joe Seroka - who was active in trying to negotiate a truce between the miners and police in the days leading up to the massacre - slammed Phiyega.

"Her behaviour is disgusting. What she did is unbecoming of a person such as her who purports to be a leader of some kind," he said.

"Her actions were disturbing. People were shaken. She sat there laughing and did nothing. You would expect a sense of remorse and empathy which was nonexistent. She should feel ashamed."

SHARE YOUR OPINION

If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.

SecretVoice

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
She is just another incompetent Zuma deployee.
Avatar

GregSmith

Posted 239 days ago
I am quite sure Zuma has a finger in her pie

AfricaRevolt2011

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
It seems she takes pride in what her officers did, they did exactly as she wanted and there are no regrets here. The miners it seems were becoming a threat to society and business, and they had to be permanently removed. Cry my beloved South Africa. Who gave orders to use live ammunition against our people?
Avatar

Black-Moses

Posted 239 days ago
Who gave orders to hack 10 non striking miners, and two policemen, to death prior to the maximum force carried out on the armed strikers?
Avatar

cj715

Posted 239 days ago
And who is showing any remorse for the 10 people killed prior to these miners being killed? Why isnt there a commission of enquiry investigating what led to the killing of the 10 people?

Stirrer

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
Her appointment as Commissioner was just another in a long line of ill-considered deployments by someone who doesn't apply his mind to important matters.
However, she has made decisions which led to this tragedy (possibly politically motivated?). As such, she has to follow through and support the police in this matter, which has become a police versus strikers matter!

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
What is it with our 'leaders' and their inappropriate giggling all the time? Do they feed these people laughing gas?
Avatar

nkosipeter

Posted 239 days ago
Forced, humourless giggling is a self defence mechanism.

Ask any psychiatrist what forced giggling is symptomatic of.

Scary.
Avatar

l984

Posted 239 days ago

... And while at it - ask the same psychiatrist what total lack of remorse and empathy is also symptomatic of.

Even scarier.

Nwanawamukalaha

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
An ugly leaderless someone who sings Zuma's praises which overshadows her IQ level as an academic and an astitute business woman.

Mangqeshane

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
As painful it is to lose a family member. Kepha my view on this matter still stands. Any1 carrying a lethal weapon in public (whether toyi toying, marching etc). Once you brandish a weapon in public like that, you CEASE to be citizen. You are now a PUBLIC THREAT. Therefore all securty agents must eliminate such threats.

If we take the emotions and look at the cold hard facts, a number of ppl will agree with this view
Avatar

Black-Moses

Posted 239 days ago
Point taken!!!
Avatar

AfricaRevolt2011

Posted 239 days ago
Black Moses and Mangqeshane

In your opinion, the killing of 10 people in Marikana is a justification for the massacre committed against our people? It is a justification for using live ammunition by the state on its citizens? I thought we leave in a costitutional democracy where we have a minister in charge of policing and provision of safety and security, was this policing or a cold hearted premediated murder unleashed by those in power against its own citizens? I have seen strikers in this country including COsatu memmers carrying some forms of weapons, why are they not massacred in cold blood?

Wort

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
Is there an endless supply of these useless deadbeats to head up the police? Three in a row now.

InExile

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
Some clever guy once said: Insanity is to keep doing the same thing and expect a different result.
That is nearly the same as what we see in South Africa every day: The news is always the same and yet we keep being surprised.
Phiyega's disgusting behaviour is just another tragic example.
How out of South Africa's history of the past 30 years a crop of people emerged to get to such positions of leadership whilst being so cruelly indifferent to the suffering and plight of their own people who put them there;that is unfathomable. But when they continue to put them back there at the next election; that is insanity.

WhatTheHack

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
People of sober mind please like FB page
facebook.com/JacobZumaIsNotMyPresident