Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 41413.44
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Top 40 : 3353.49
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Financial 15 : 12096.10
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Industrial 25 : 47171.07
    UNCHANGED0.00%

  • ZAR/USD : 9.4046
    UP 0.05%
    ZAR/GBP : 14.2711
    UP 0.34%
    ZAR/EUR : 12.0825
    UP 1.94%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.0911
    UP 0.15%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.1670
    UP 0.39%

  • Gold : 1360.1000
    UP 0.37%
    Platinum : 1455.0000
    UP 0.28%
    Silver : 22.2600
    UP 0.16%
    Palladium : 738.5000
    UP 0.61%
    Brent Crude Oil : 104.640
    UNCHANGED0.00%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Sun May 19 16:51:29 SAST 2013

Minister's Facebook ambush

PHILANI NOMBEMBE | 07 November, 2012 09:48
Deputy Minister of Communications Stella Tembisa Ndabeni
Image by: Business Times

Deputy Minister of Communications Stella Ndabeni seems to have found another platform from which to put her communications skills to use.

This week she took to Facebook, on which she claims close to 5 000 "friends", to launch a blistering attack on a former head of the World Bank, Mamphela Ramphele, calling her a "mistress" and even suggesting that she had no right to speak on behalf of Steve Biko's family.

On Monday, Ndabeni wrote on the social networking site: "I wonder why does the Biko family allow his mistress Dr Ramphele to speak on behalf of Biko whilst his wife is alive? Where I come from Mistresses are not allowed to speak in public about their lovers."

Ramphele had a son by the late Black Consciousness Movement leader. Ramphele has been scathing of the government's failures in critical areas such as education.

Ndabeni first posted a link to Ramphele's biography, written by Bonnie Leib. She followed up with the controversial post, which had garnered 57 comments and 54 "likes" by yesterday.

Asked for comment, Ndabeni said she was "Googling women in politics" when she stumbled on Ramphele's biography.

"I shared that thing with my Facebook friends. When you want to make it a public info, I can't be involved in that," said Ndabeni.

"So you will do what you do when you take other people's business and make them public."

Vuyiseka Dubula, general secretary of the Treatment Action Campaign, commented: "Hayibo, Stella, that's too judgemental sisi, when it comes to Biko and women I wouldn't have such strong views about Mamphela. She also has a right to speak about her lover who was well known to be her lover too even the wife was aware. Anyway that's my view."

But former chairman of the parliamentary portfolio committee on public enterprises, Vytjie Mentor, was more hard-hitting.

"He he he, well put comrade Stella Ndabeni Abrahams. Mistress in English means a girl friend or lover of a married man. This is an honest account of what Dr Mamphela Ramphele was to the Icon Steve Biko. Sometimes the truth hurts, sometimes culture is used to cover the truth."

It is not the first time Ndabeni has courted controversy. In July she slated Winnie Madikizela-Mandela on Facebook for publicly criticising President Jacob Zuma's multiple marriages.

"Life can be interesting. Dali Mpofu represented Julius Malema in the national disciplinary committee hearings. Mam' Winnie has always seen a great leader like Madiba in Malema, and now the mother of our nation sees immorality in Zuma. Who is a saint between the two of them?" Ndabeni wrote.

SHARE YOUR OPINION

If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.

Mike123

Posted 193 days ago
Avatar
The vampires, once again, doing their best to avoid the daylight of truth being shone on them.

Sinoyolo123

Posted 193 days ago
Avatar
Typical ANC politicians. They are houlers/noisemakers. They attack the person rather than looking at the issue. Gwede did the same to Reul Khoza, Jackson Mthembu is very good at it, and unfortunately we are going to be fed the same staple for the next seven years with the Kangaman at the helm.

Perhaps it is time that people like Dr. Ramphele consider joining mainstream politics and save us from this populist crowd who lack intellect to engage in a constructive debate. Form a new party please and I will be the first one to sign up.

TjoVtjo

Posted 193 days ago
Avatar
Hey Stella, Dr. Ramphela has all the right to speak. She never said she was a Biko, she simply stated the facts. She was with Biko, and she as a private citizen feels that your government is sending us upstream without a paddle. There is no need for low blows. It's unbecoming for a so called lady to want to expose another in such a manner. You just appear as a "straatmate".

andmuchmore

Posted 193 days ago
Avatar
i think Mamphele is trying to position herself to a certain party, i am also annoyed by Mamphele.
Avatar

buddi

Posted 193 days ago

Why?

SuiGeneris

Posted 193 days ago
Avatar
''.....Sometimes the truth hurts, sometimes culture is used to cover the truth....."

Didn't we hear this from someone before ?

Just checking ?

Hahaha

JohnDoe

Posted 193 days ago
Avatar
So basically because she was a mistress she is not allowed to have an opinion on her country? If this is what our government thinks then I fear for our democracy. Dr Ramphele is an outstanding citizen of South Africa, that is a lot more than I can say for this deputy minister considering what a shambles out communication industry i.e. telkom is in currently
Avatar

Mahlek'ehlathini

Posted 193 days ago
No, she implies that Mamphele can not speak on behalf of Biko, since she was a Mistress, not that she may not have an opinion. Would it be okay for your Father's Mistress to speak on his Behalf while your mother is still alive?

PSG

Posted 193 days ago
Avatar
I find it very hypocritical of Dr Ramphele to critic the Government on Education when Ali Baba offered her the position and declined it citing her busy schedule.

She had a chance to change things.
Avatar

Robrt9Mugabe99

Posted 193 days ago
She knew she is a biggest failure, losers have big mouths, as she failed at UCT to adress transformation
Avatar

Duzula

Posted 193 days ago
I didn't know that she was once offered the job...
The is nothing wrong to criticize the Government, the only problem problem is that our Government don't want to be told wrong things that their are doing. I am with Dr Ramphele on this one.
Avatar

buddi

Posted 193 days ago
I wouldn't accept a job with the current government either.
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 193 days ago
PSG

..... she has never been ANC so which position was she offered as it couldn't have been as Minister
Avatar

Mahlek'ehlathini

Posted 193 days ago
Momma

Read PSG's comment again please.
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 193 days ago
Mahlek'ehlathini

Yes, but which position was she offered?
Avatar

PSG

Posted 193 days ago
Howzit Momma?

She was offered the very same Ministry that she is always criticizing "Department of Education" before it was give to the current Minister.

You do not have to be an ANC member to be give any ministerial or deputy minister post e.g. during Pres Mbeki's time the Minister of Science and Technology was from Azapo or something, currently the leader of Freedom Front Plus is a Deputy Minister of some department can't recall which one.

Avatar

PSG

Posted 193 days ago
@Duzula

You are very right there when you say there is nothing wrong with criticing the Government.

What I have an issue with is that she was given an opportunity to change things and implement what she thinks others aren't doing right currently. What did she do? Turn the offer down.

Don't you see that as a bit hypocritical of her?
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 193 days ago
Hey there PSG.

Okay, I hadn't thought of that. I just never heard of someone who wasn't politically affiliated to any organisation being a Minister. *sheepish grin* Thats what happens when you don't think things through, ne :)

I didn't know she had been offered it but I'm dreadfully disappointed in her for not taking the opportunity to put some actions where her mouth is. She sure talks a good fight, it would have been great to see that put into action.
Avatar

PSG

Posted 193 days ago
Sure Momma, no worries :-).

If the President wakes up tomorrow and feels like shuffling his cabinet he’ll do so and in/exclude people as he sees fit.

That’s why they say that Ministers and Deputy Ministers serve in these positions at the discretion of the President.

John_JnrJohn

Posted 193 days ago
Avatar
Ya ya truth hurts mme. though you are 100 % correct. The current government lacks leadership. Hence they can refer to your past as a defensive machanism.

Lastly why o be o bulela monna wa mosadi o momgwe dirope mara. hai. and you have the guts to talk or morals.

Stirrer

Posted 193 days ago
Avatar
"Ndabeni said she was "Googling women in politics" when she stumbled on Ramphele's biography"

Typical Jenny-come-lately - didn't even know about Ramphele's massive contribution under trying times during apartheid!
Instead of picking on her well-known and widely documented affair with Bantu Steve Biko, why not disclose how Ramphele overcame the hardships of a black female doctor almost single-handedly starting and operating a medical facility, in a remote township during the height of an illegitimate regime, for the benefit of the community? Something which the current regime cannot mangage, despite all the money it takes from it's taxpayers!
Avatar

buddi

Posted 193 days ago
She thinks she's telling SA people something we didn't know!
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 193 days ago
Don't worry Stirrer, next week the girl-child will google 'presidents' and be shocked to discover someone called Nelson Mandela.
Avatar

MvuyisiMniki

Posted 193 days ago
What did Dr Maphela do during the trying times under apartheid, can you plse remind me Stirrer.
Avatar

Stirrer

Posted 193 days ago
MvuyisiMniki - get yourself a copy of Steve Biko's "I write what I like".

Avatar

Stirrer

Posted 193 days ago
LOL, MommaCyndi!

Imagine her surprise when she decides to google "Stella Ndabeni" and synonyms like wannabe, bimbette and fake-weaves pop up!
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 193 days ago
:) she must learn that you never bring the personal insults into an experienced cat fight when you are wearing a cheapie weave and waving your ignorance around - that is just looking for a hammering

Lungig2102

Posted 193 days ago
Avatar
To Ndabeni:
Sisi when you have nothing to say , learn to shut up. Mamphele has done more good for the impoverished people of SA than most of some women who claim to be in the ANC women's league but let k*k to go on in the name of the ruling party.
Check amongst yourselves and who is not a mistress and never was , hands up !

Stirrer

Posted 193 days ago
Avatar
Typical ANCYL rhetoric - maybe someone should look into her rapid rise to Deputy Minister level (it definitely wasn't due to her educational aptitude).

Wiseguy

Posted 193 days ago
Avatar
Dear Stella Ndabeni......you should learn from the great wise female leaders of the past:
"Great minds discuss ideas; average minds discuss events; small minds discuss people"
Eleanor Roosevelt. "

And here we find you discussing people and events.....so i guess that makes you small minded...average at best, in Eleanor Roosevelts opinion!

Now the woman you choose to critic, she discusses ideas, over and over and over......and yes, she is indeed a GREAT woman!

So, you have proven the great Mrs Roosevelt correct by your actions and words!

Wiseguy

Posted 193 days ago
Avatar
Just maybe as dep minister of communications your time may be better spent working on an amendment to the RICA Act which makes it easier/compulsory for the telecom giants to provide SAPS and private security companies with the co-ordinates of any stolen GPS device to bring criminals to book ?

You do know these GPS enabled devices can be tracked within minutes very very accurately?
You realise that criminals who have these devices can then be caught and prosecuted?
You should also know we have one of the highest crime rates in the world?

Maybe less politicing and more thought, useful ideas and hard work are called for?

Just a thought!

sibujwana

Posted 193 days ago
Avatar
I think this lady is attacking invaluable people in our society ...maybe she occupying a space left by Julius Malema...reasoning minds know better

andmuchmore

Posted 193 days ago
Avatar
i begin to doubt her maybe she sold Biko to the police
Avatar

Stirrer

Posted 193 days ago
The police knew where Biko was - they banished him to the King Williams Town township! And they regularly checked up on him as well. Ramphele was too committed to Steve and the struggle to betray him.

buddi

Posted 193 days ago
Avatar
So what does she have to say about the current president?
At least Dr Ramphela has brains.

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 193 days ago
Avatar
LOL
Sorry timeslive, you are right, she isn't a 'bimbo' she is still a bimbette. My bad. Still would love to know how old she is if she had to look up who Dr Ramphele is.

Poor girl, only cheap plastic at that salon. Rather go natural if you can't afford uptown

i_stub_born

Posted 193 days ago
Avatar
......HE HE HE HE........."Come-rade" Stella. I wonder....Are you a Minstrel for Zuma due to your "generous" qualities ?????.................