Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 41815.36
    UP 1.79%
    Top 40 : 3443.42
    UP 3.06%
    Financial 15 : 12000.90
    UP 1.42%
    Industrial 25 : 47656.81
    UP 1.47%

  • ZAR/USD : 9.5490
    UP 0.02%
    ZAR/GBP : 14.4741
    UP 0.05%
    ZAR/EUR : 12.3348
    UP 0.05%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.0932
    UP 0.03%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.3730
    UP 0.09%

  • Gold : 1376.0900
    UP 0.16%
    Platinum : 1460.5000
    UP 0.24%
    Silver : 22.4546
    UP 0.02%
    Palladium : 744.5000
    UP 0.61%
    Brent Crude Oil : 103.910
    UNCHANGED0.00%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Wed May 22 02:07:34 SAST 2013

Health shambles

KATHARINE CHILD | 11 December, 2012 00:01
Gauteng premier Nomvula Mokonyane. File photo.

GAUTENG premier Nomvula Mokonyane has admitted - after months of excuses - that the health department in South Africa's economic hub has lost control of its finances.

The provincial treasury will step in to clean up the mess.

The health department's struggle for years to manage its finances has resulted in patients dying while waiting for essential treatment.

Admitting the department faced "persistent challenges", Mokonyane announced yesterday that treasury officials would work with the department to build "transparent financial management".

An administrator will be appointed by the end of this month.

The National Treasury stepped in a year ago and brokered agreements with health and finance MECs to fix financial problems in the health department.

National Treasury was meant to assist with supply chain management difficulties.

Mokonyane made her announcement almost four months after the Special Investigating Unit recommended, in an interim report to parliament, that R16.5-million be recouped from corrupt former senior Gauteng health officials.

The SIU was investigating R1-billion tender fraud involving 10 transactions in the department.

In spite of the high-level interventions, problems have persisted.

Gauteng health has made headlines in the past year for failing to pay suppliers. Yesterday, Mokonyane admitted the department owed money to 883 suppliers.

The vice-chairman of the South African Medical Device Industry Association, Jeff Hampton, said suppliers were owed millions.

"Despite promises made at a meeting two weeks ago at the public service commission, subsequent meetings had not transpired.

"Some of the debts run back three or four years," he said.

Details of the implementation of the treasury rescue are yet to be finalised, but Mokonyane insisted the department was not being placed under administration.

"Health MEC Hope Papo will still be running the department.

"We are building the management capacity to run the department [with] effective, efficient financial management," she said.

The intervention is allowed under Section 18 of the Public Finance Management Act. It allows provincial treasuries to investigate financial management and internal controls.

The act allows treasuries to withhold funds to address serious breaches.

The decision to bring in "high-level expertise", said Mokonyane, had been made at an executive council meeting of the Gauteng cabinet on Wednesday.

The administrator would work with teams in the department to deal with challenges in hospital management, human resources, financial management and communication, she said.

One of the most recent scandals involving the department was a severe shortage of medical staff at Johannesburg's Charlotte Maxeke Hospital.

Understaffing - across almost the entire hospital - had been caused by frozen posts and the repeated failure by provincial officials to respond to pleas by senior doctors for more skilled medical personnel.

Papo said yesterday that his department was continuing to fill critical posts at all hospitals in Gauteng.

Finance MEC Mandla Nkomfe said the health department had sufficient funds to pay its bills.

But Section 27 researcher Daygan Eagar said it was difficult to ascertain whether this was true.

"They say that every year," said Eagar.

"What happens is each year the department of health starts out with money owed to service providers from the previous year.

"Because it has not taken old debts into account in its new budget, it has to pay previous years' debts from current funds."

Eagar said the health department needed a budget that took debt from previous years into account.

Even as Mokonyane made her bold announcement about transparency, both she and Papo avoided answering questions about the release of a forensic report on the management of the medicine supply depot in Auckland Park, Johannesburg.

"I have heard it reveals terrible corruption but they are keeping the report under wraps," said DA Gauteng spokesman on health Jack Bloom.

Papo would say only that the report had been read.

Mokonyane said Papo would this week announce disciplinary measures against officials suspected of mismanagement and fraud in the department.

Papo said treasury officials would be examining contracts to ensure the province was paying the correct prices for services and medicines.

Mokonyane and Papo said one of the ways to cut costs would be to reduce overtime paid to health staff.

"Administrators and managers will need to do their work in working hours," said Mokonyane.

Papo promised that doctors and nurses would not be affected by cuts in overtime pay.

SHARE YOUR OPINION

If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.

i_stub_born

Posted 161 days ago
Avatar
Only GAuteng????........ha ha ha ha........The whole Health system is crumbling down thanks to the Fokonyanes of the ANC plus the NEHAWU mafias doing great business, in preparation for Minstrel Motsoaledi NHI success...........
Avatar

nkosipeter

Posted 161 days ago
Corruption kills. A silent deadly killer. There are only victims. No one is ever brought to book.
Avatar

Timbuck10

Posted 161 days ago
Look who is running (sic) the province.... cannot say I am surprised!

Mike123

Posted 161 days ago
Avatar
Shambles: A synonym for the ANC. I'm pretty sure that even their conference in Mangaung will be a shambles.
Avatar

RedCoat

Posted 161 days ago
Omnishambles: Shambolic from all possible perspectives..................
Avatar

Mike123

Posted 161 days ago
Oh yes! I'd forgotten about Omnishambles :)

Omni-impotent should also apply to the morons.
Avatar

RedCoat

Posted 161 days ago
Lol.

Yes, the only problem with the morons is that they read "omni-impotent" as omni-important
Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 161 days ago
malazza
''...so it shall be to eductae ourselves to become experts in leaderhip...''

Starting where ? At school level with the current state of affairs of the education department ?

hahaha
Avatar

RedCoat

Posted 161 days ago
Oh no.......not the race card........
Avatar

Mike123

Posted 161 days ago
@malazza: so you took decades to free yourselves from white supremacy, only to become victims of black supremacy? Good move!

AfricaRevolt2011

Posted 161 days ago
Avatar
The entire health system in this country has collapsed perhaps with the exception in the Western Cape. The local treasury has intervined in many provinces, and unfortunately things get worse for the health personnel and patients, but the suppliers will get paid. I was surprised to realise that Dr Motswaledi has scored an A from DA and personally I was shocked. What Zuma's administration succeeded with was to roll out ARV's to HIV infected patients and it seems that has been done at the expense of the health system, and now that we hear that even HIV rates are no longer dropping it becomes a painful shame. Things have gone so bad that Provincial departments can't pay their nurses and doctors, and health personnels in particular doctors are resigning in large numbers. In some provinces like Gauteng and the EC, doctors are taking provincial governments to court for failing the patients.
Avatar

RedCoat

Posted 161 days ago
Malaza:

Schools dont teach ethics and morals..........
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 161 days ago
Red Coat,
They used to
Now the minister just 'washes her hands' of it all. No more high standards in school or expecting kids to behave whilst there

mahomedmanjoo

Posted 161 days ago
Avatar
In December last year, I was asked to assist the Wits Oral Dept by providing them with T-shirts, candles, etc for a Christmas party related to HIV/Aids.

To date, I am still waiting to be paid!

Yes, no kickback and prices were at nett cost because of the event!

Jimbo56

Posted 161 days ago
Avatar
And they think they'll be able to implement a national health insurance system?
Avatar

malazza

Posted 161 days ago
yes they will, and incase you havent noticed its already a succes in its planning session, hence the DA scored Dr Motswaledi an "A"
Avatar

i_stub_born

Posted 161 days ago
"""""yes they will, and incase you havent noticed its already a succes in its planning session, hence the DA scored Dr Motswaledi an "A"""""

.........stop insulting yourself and the rest of commentators........Anything on paper can be a success. The ANC is full of it. The reality is so evident that even blind people cannot deny it!!!....

deebee

Posted 161 days ago
Avatar
The problems: corruption, nepotism, cadre deployment. The solution: appoint competent people regardless of their fealty or lack thereof to the ANC. The action: keep the incompetent, corrupt cadres in place and throw more taxpayers money at the shambles to try and paper over the cracks. Absolute scum.

SuiGeneris

Posted 161 days ago
Avatar
''...has resulted in patients dying while waiting for essential treatment...''
This by their own admission !....Now teach them a lesson....The families of those who died should take them to court and claim compensation through negligence !

''...The decision to bring in "high-level expertise", said Mokonyane, had been made at an executive council meeting of the Gauteng cabinet on Wednesday...''
The same old story, they will always allow the system to fall apart completely before they will reluctantly admit their [8/10] incompetence. Then they will call in highly qualified experts to come and sort out the problems at tremendous cost. Then we see redeployment to go and mess up some other department.
What a brilliant ANC solution !!!!
All this happens because they are employed in a position that they are not capable of handling to start off with, and they also know that if they do not perform, they won't get fired !
''MY ANC - MY GOVERNMENT'' !!!!!

AaronGumede

Posted 161 days ago
Avatar
Maybe this woman must be fired
Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 161 days ago
Oh No....She is the perfect one to implement and run NHI
Avatar

Black-Moses

Posted 161 days ago
Unfortunately, this is just wishful thinking. The current state of affairs is in turmoil.''Kuyashesha la'' is not the only incompetent cadre, but all of them. Fire the whole lot through a ballot box, hence the status quo, will definitely change for better.

muk2

Posted 161 days ago
Avatar
Just a couple of words of advice premier
1) Hire competent and credible people,
2) Communicate amongst yourself and keep the taxpayers informed,
3) Have a scorecard of your goals and rate yourselves on a monthly basis and publish this.

If you impliment just these 3 things half your battle is won.
Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 161 days ago
Great advice for the premier !.....something so basic that even a grade 5 child will be able to understand the importance of it.
Avatar

RedCoat

Posted 161 days ago
Sui:

Yes i agree, but its probably too advanced for someone of a, oh lets say grade 3?

malazza

Posted 161 days ago
Avatar
muk2 comments like a sober person who want to help solve the problem not the idiots commented before like they have just had a runnig stomach
Avatar

AfricaRevolt2011

Posted 161 days ago
Malazza, for your information my friend, i'm black like you and it is not about the race issue. I am a medical specialist myself and I have a first hand information on what is happening on the ground. In the area where I work myself, 3 medical specialists and Heads of Department have resigned this month alone, and I am aware of Medical specialists taking the Government of Dr Motswaledi to court in fighting for the rights of patients. When his government can't even pay medical specialists, junior doctors, nurses and can't even purchase the necessary medical equipments, then we have a problem on our hands. Everyone seem to be fascinated with the fight against HIV, which in my opinion the governemnt is doing a good job. But the truth of the matter is the entire Health system in a deep crises and hence many people with experience and the expertise are leaving for greener pastures. You as an ordinary person this information is hidden from you perhaps until after Mangaung.
Avatar

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 161 days ago
Which hole did you creep from? People here knew from long ago that there is nothing like an ANC. It only exists because of the SACP and COSATU, whose mandates come from their elite. Only COSATU is a viable organisation. And a foetus is only viable if it can exist outside its mother's womb. Even Godi's African Party can last longer than the SACP, hence its leaders run the ANC for their existence. Sorry if this is too long for your concentration.
Avatar

muk2

Posted 161 days ago
@malazza. Sometimes I'm sooo disappointed when hearing this sad state of affairs; that I switch to a music radio station. I so want the unity that we see glimpses of when we play national sports to permeate to other sectors.
Avatar

NewFreedomFighter

Posted 161 days ago
@malazza
Everyone has a different threshold level. I have a feeling that one day even you will regret the support you gave to the ANC long after it deserved it. Sometimes something is so broken that it is beyond repair. So, soldier on my friend, but know that even you have a threshold for broken things and this threshold will be reached.
Avatar

Tintagel

Posted 161 days ago
What will happen to all those in charge of the health dept -- the MEC, the SG and the senior directors? Will they lose their jobs? If not why not? At what point and how is responsibility actually taken for creating such a mess in the first place?
ANC apologists almost always never answer these questions. Why?

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 161 days ago
Avatar
Well lets just hope that Hope is more competent and diligent than both the predecessor and the Premier - I don't envy the job of sorting this tangled mess out.

proud-mbongwa

Posted 161 days ago
Avatar
Nomvula Mokonyane duck and diving like her bus jacob zuma. Uyasihlaza sisi.

SibusisoSangweni

Posted 161 days ago
Avatar
eish what is boring about all this comment they always about political parties or racist , i haven't seen a single positive comment that promote and protects that rights of our citizenship
Avatar

Utini

Posted 161 days ago
It is difficult to find positive comment while the Dunning–Kruger effect is apparently in full force and where its results are becoming more and more visible.
Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 161 days ago
Perhaps that aroma in your nostrils, of good proper coffee brewing, are not what it appears to be, and are in fact cheap instant, plastic coffee.
Avatar

Black-Moses

Posted 161 days ago
@sibu

eish get out o' here quickly.
Avatar

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 161 days ago
The Ed must be 'fair' to leeches, and state that they are the best thing to have happened to our taxes. They do not steal, rape, murder. Nor are they corrupt, and all live in ordinary houses. No arms deal, Nkandlagate, our health system is top of the range, education is hunky dory.

Who would even read such c$@p, when even the elite complain of corruption and ineptitude amongst their own? Would you bother to buy lies? Get real!

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 161 days ago
Avatar
The timing for this 'admission' is important. Nomvula has never admitted any corruption, even when her 'investigations' revealed its rampant state.

The ANC must establish its political identity. A system is what it does, and nothing else. And nature does not allow a vacuum. No political party can exist only to 'liberate' 'Blacks'. That trick worked only to win the votes - including yours truly. Without knowing what it exists for, people will always steal the money they find in their hands. No one feels pressured to do anything, because no one knows what to do. But there is always use for money - luxury. No need for education to understand that.

Tokolosh

Posted 161 days ago
Avatar
ANC run Government is full Corruption and incompetence!

Shongweni

Posted 161 days ago
Avatar
"We face persistent challenges"

is ANC speak for

"our cadre deployment has resulted in a complete clusterf*%K"

kevinnaidoo

Posted 161 days ago
Avatar
Anti-Apartheid Movement

Many friends of the ANC who were in the Anti-Apartheid Movement had predicted prior to 1994 that the ANC would never be able to govern South Africa. Mrs Margaret Thatcher had a similar view.

Sad to say BUT their predictions came true.It is only a fool who cannot see that South Africa is "bleeding" and that the DREAM of Tata Madiba is lying in tatters.

TobiasNtuli

Posted 161 days ago
Avatar
Given the current state of out education and health systems, I cannot for the life of me understand the plaudits directed at Ministers Angie Motsegha and Aaaron Motsoaledi respectively!