Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 41836.02
    UP 0.05%
    Top 40 : 3460.70
    UP 0.50%
    Financial 15 : 11971.78
    DOWN -0.24%
    Industrial 25 : 47413.26
    DOWN -0.51%

  • ZAR/USD : 9.5802
    UP 0.35%
    ZAR/GBP : 14.4121
    DOWN -0.38%
    ZAR/EUR : 12.3134
    DOWN -0.12%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.0929
    DOWN -0.28%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.2827
    DOWN -0.88%

  • Gold : 1370.0500
    DOWN -0.28%
    Platinum : 1469.5000
    UP 0.86%
    Silver : 22.2955
    DOWN -0.69%
    Palladium : 746.5000
    UP 0.88%
    Brent Crude Oil : 102.310
    DOWN -0.28%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Thu May 23 00:55:09 SAST 2013

Brutal cops shame SA

GRAEME HOSKEN | 01 March, 2013 00:36

Mozambican taxi driver Mido Macia lay for hours bleeding to death, alone in a cell at a police station in Daveyton, on the East Rand, without medical attention.

For nearly four hours, the 27-year-old - the sole breadwinner for his one-year-old son, Sergio, and 23-year-old wife, Jacquelina - lay dying in a crumpled heap, in his own blood and faeces.

His alleged crime: refusing to obey police officers who ordered him to stop blocking traffic with his vehicle in Daveyton township's main street.

His punishment: being dragged behind a police van for about 500m to the police station, where he was allegedly repeatedly beaten in a sustained attack that prisoners in neighbouring cells say went on for almost two hours.

The police's weapons: allegedly fists, boots, truncheons and torches.

Cellphone footage of the horrific incident went viral yesterday, sparking worldwide condemnation.

President Jacob Zuma, national police commissioner Riah Phiyega and the Mozambican government have all condemned Macia's death as "unacceptable".

Outraged Daveyton people yesterday tried to storm the police station, attempting to pull one of the nine alleged culprits from the unmarked vehicle his colleagues used to race him to safety.

They threw stones at the vehicle before turning on officers barricading the police station.

Repeated threats of force by officers protecting the station failed to calm their anger. The residents promised to kill those responsible for Macia's horrific and agonised death.

Describing his death as "shocking", Amnesty International Southern Africa director Noel Kututwa said: "This appalling incident involving excessive force is the latest in an increasingly disturbing pattern of brutal police conduct in South Africa."

Zuma said : "Members of the South African Police Service are required to operate within the confines of the law in executing their duties.

"The visuals of the incident are horrific, disturbing and unacceptable. No human being should be treated in that manner."

Macia's brutal killing comes as the nation is still reeling from the death of 34 miners after police opened fire on them in Marikana, in August, and from the killing of Free State rights activist Andries Tatane, in April 2011.

Though the officers alleged to have been involved in the arrest of Macia have been identified, no arrests had been made by last night.

Some of the officers reported for duty yesterday and worked throughout the day.

The Independent Police Investigative Directorate would only confirm that Macia, who has lived in South Africa for 17 years, died from severe head and internal injuries.

A preliminary postmortem, according to police sources, found that Macia bled to death. Several organs had been ruptured in the assault.

"It was so bad his organs burst ... some were in pieces ... there was basically nothing left of his insides.

"His head injuries were as bad ... his skull was crushed ... his brain badly damaged. It is clear that those who did this wanted to kill him," said a police source.

Macia's brother, Carlos Mthimkulu, battling to control his emotions, said he did not know what the family was going to do.

"I do not earn enough money to support my family ... how are Mido's little boy and wife going to survive?

"He was their only provider ... the police have killed them ... they have robbed them," he said.

He said that, despite requests for information about his brother's death, the police had ignored the family.

"They are not interested ... we just want to know why they killed him ... why they killed him like a dog."

Independent Police Investigative Directorate spokesman Moses Dlamini confirmed that Macia had died from severe head and other internal injuries.

He said that, given the multitude of allegations, including those surrounding the assault, a second postmortem was to be held to confirm the findings of the first.

Dlamini said two policemen were initially identified as taking part in the alleged assault but further investigations suggested there might be others involved.

"The investigation is at an early stage. We [will] recommend that these policemen be suspended."

Dlamini said the police had received information about another death at Daveyton police station.

"If it has not been reported we will immediately open an investigation," he said.

Phiyega's spokesman, Brigadier Phuti Setati, said "the matter is viewed by the national commissioner in a very serious light and it is strongly condemned".

He said Phiyega had ordered acting provincial commissioner Phumzo Gela to start an internal investigation into the death and report as a "matter of urgency".

"No amount of explanation can justify this type of conduct.

"We have to earn the respect of the communities we serve ... this can only be done by being professional at all times," he said.

Mozambican embassy police adviser Lacarias Cossa said the embassy was trying to understand what had happened.

SHARE YOUR OPINION

If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.

l984

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
Chaos, disregard for any rules or laws, destruction and violence from perpetrators is met with even more barbaric chaos, violence, incompetence and even murder by the police - and this is all being 'condemned' by the very people who are (or are supposed to be!) in charge and in control - but instead are acting like passive observing and disapproving bystanders!

RussellWright

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
And all Zuma can manage is....... unacceptable?
If these cops had been white a sh*ts***m of protest would have erupted.
Oh wait lets blame it on apartheid.
Avatar

Mojongi

Posted 82 days ago
Sad that it has to be that way. btw, I am a pissed off black man

Mafonzo

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
Where is the difference between policemen that tortured Stephen Biko to death and this Mozambican taxi driver? ANC is nothing but a tool of white supremacists? Vukani, Azanians!Vukani!
Avatar

BokfanSaffer

Posted 82 days ago
I agree, Tools they are but please explain the white supremacist bit.
Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 82 days ago
There is no future for you, living in the past !
Avatar

Robrt017Mugabe99

Posted 82 days ago
well said, brilliant stuff, on top of that Hilton Botha who shot a taxi full of passengers , who can forget Uegene de Kok, these people think we are sheeps knowing nothing about their evil
Avatar

TanjaNaidoo

Posted 82 days ago
The freedom fighters eventually become the oppressors - power corrupts.
Avatar

muendanyi

Posted 82 days ago
can u stop politicking just for a once?
Avatar

TjoVtjo

Posted 82 days ago
Izwelethu!!

Jakes_Mathews#

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
Of course, what do you expect in a Department where the Minister is a former taxi driver himself and the Commissioner is a Social worker? People of South Africa are taking gambling with their life by letting Zuma and ANC leading this country, they want to see changes? Well the first thing that must be changed is the ANC before we see any significant changes!
Avatar

Duzula

Posted 82 days ago
Now we blame the ANC on this... wow... ANC got nothing to do with this, this is just bad human behaviour
Avatar

BokfanSaffer

Posted 82 days ago
Duzula

Hey chana your double standards are hanging out like a laundry basket of soiled undies.

Who hired these monsters, who "manages" them at monstrous expense to the taxpayer, who trains the, who promotes them over candidates

My friend, double standards are the tools and mechanisms of morally empty frauds.

Watch yourself.
Avatar

Jakes_Mathews#

Posted 82 days ago
Duzula

Are you crazy? You must had smoked some weed for sure? Who is leading the Police? Who is the Chief Commander of Police? Who is the Commissioner? Well the answer is Mthethwa, Zuma and Phiyega, all of them the ANC leeches!?
You must be one of those stupids idiots who were dancing and singing on behalf of a penis during the famous ''Penis Revolution'' or simply a beneficiary of ANC corruption and nepotism!
You are stupid Duzula, well people who strike for and on behalf of ''their golden penis'' are hopeless idiots such as Duzula who are suffering from ANC schizophrenia!
Avatar

Duzula

Posted 82 days ago
@Jakes
I guess you don't see the bigger picture...
I will not come to your level and start calling you names now.. You just need help
Avatar

Jakes_Mathews#

Posted 82 days ago
Duzula

Of course, only people who strike on behalf of a penis need mental help? People are dying in Marikana but you choose to strike for a penis? You are a hopeless stupid Duzula!
Avatar

Ozgood

Posted 82 days ago
A part of the problem is that the SAPS is not headed by a professional policeman. What was wrong with the previous acting commissioner, Nhlanhla Mkwanasi (excuse spelling)? He was someone who knows the SAPS and came up through the ranks if I am correct.

Zuma should stop interfering and choosing party hacks no matter how educated they may be.

Duzula

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
It seams like everything that South Africans do its turn to be chaos. I know that we're a violent Country but this is going out of hand... Not so long ago we were talking about Marikana now this...
But I guess the only thing thing we do is just talk and life goes on.
Avatar

seangh

Posted 82 days ago
This is sad but true. What do you think it is going to take to change this? 19 years into democracy - should be called de-mockery! There is no democracy - people are blinded by a load of BS that gets fed very election year and a week later we are back to the same old BS.

I think it's time we vote for parties that will restore human dignity and human rights because the current party isn't.
Avatar

l984

Posted 82 days ago

The correct term is 'demoncrazy': A system or country populated and ruled by people many of whom are without conscience. It collapses when they become the majority.
Avatar

BokfanSaffer

Posted 82 days ago
Morning 1984. Looks like this is really going to be the Year of the Prole.
Avatar

l984

Posted 82 days ago

Eish. Morning to you too, Bokfan, mon cheri..
Avatar

DuaneHamann

Posted 82 days ago
The ANC persues the issues of human rights for all, putting the rights of criminals on the same levels as victims. The rights of criminals are secondary to those of the victims, yet all we hear from Zuma and the ANC is the rights of everyone, which suggests to thugs and criminals that they are entitled in some way. It is a fundamental flaw of the current administration. It is linked to failure to establish a country that all law abiding citizens can feel sale and secure. The refusal to relook at the death penalty on the basis of human rights is part of this fundamental flaw of the ANC. They don't see it, but their failure to handle serious crime with utmost urgency has created these criminals that rape and murder old woman and young children who are unable to defend themselves.

The ANC is, without intention of causing this murder, responsible for state of affairs our society finds itself in. The ANC therefore has the blood of these victims on their hands, and I hope for the day where the rubbish that thinks running a government is a party is disposed of and real honest hard working and moral leaders fill this space. Shame on the ANC and Zuma for their "human rights" that has enabled these killers and rapists~

seangh

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
I think what we need to understand is that 200-400 years later South Africa is still deepest darkest Africa as it is in the history books. It is still inhabited by the savages of yester-year and, from the looks of things, will always be.

There is no proof on the horizon of evolution that these savages will ever evolve into anything better - if anything it is only getting worse.

I have zero respect for cops - any type of cop, colour of cop or species of cop. I think it should be bush justice for cops that do this.

However, back to reality - Taxi drivers p1ss everyone off and he was probably being a typical "i don't give a f" taxi driver - so all things said and done - One more sorted. Sad he had a kid but taxi drivers need to abide by the laws too and they don't. No i feel nothing in that regard. I think they should be dragged from the taxis more often and beaten - not killed - just beaten!
Avatar

Duzula

Posted 82 days ago
South Africa is an Angry nation you just proof my point.
Avatar

BokfanSaffer

Posted 82 days ago
Seangh

I used to know a Sean in Belfast during the early 80s. He was deliverivering a meal for a sick colleague when he got torched by a mob of Prods coming back from jeering a Provo funeral . Poor guy was an apolitical atheist . Go figure hey

BokfanSaffer

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
I suppose it is unnecessary to point out that bakkie dragging now appears to be an intercultural thing here in SA. The manufacturers might want to put a label on that says. "Dont use for towing humans."

Then also;Its true the cops brought shame but lets face it cops do that alll over the world. No what really brought my gorge to hurling point was the crowd.

"Shoot him' they bawled "Shoot him"

Now thats a bunch with a different DNA to anyone I would like to know.

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
Can our country not stay out of the lousy end of the international media spotlight for just a week?

The cops have got to start to understand that it is simply not acceptable for them to break the law. Panel-beating a suspect is no different to mob justice and keelhauling a human over tarmac is simply barbaric. They are supposed to be there to uphold the law, not go all Judge Dread on us.

It would be interesting to know how the training and selecting of police is done. Are psych evals still part of the yearly physical?
Avatar

BokfanSaffer

Posted 82 days ago
Psych evals were replaced with psych evils some time ago on instruction of the Misery and Destruction Cluster
Avatar

Mangqeshane

Posted 82 days ago
Nami I am soo worried about how these people are selected. The EX General was right when he said that, those wanting to be SAPS members must do so so because they have the UTMOST desire to SERVE & to PROTECT, not because the police service is the only viable employer.

Mina I suspect that izidomu are the ones that join SAPS bese zenza loshidi eziwenzayo

Duzula

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
Commenting here I don't see the point I only see pain, cause no matter how much we can talk but as long we talk without no action is just the waste of time. People for once less to something.
Avatar

BokfanSaffer

Posted 82 days ago
Change your voting patterns.
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 82 days ago
I agree. Lets do something.
Maybe start with standing for what is right. Refusing to give bribes; recording police brutality and insisting on it being seen to; not being passive; making sure everyone knows their rights; actively involved in your community to recruit them to assist with keeping the cops in line .....

BhekisizweSkhosana

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
This shows disregard for the rule of law what made it worse was the realization that he was a foreigner police seem to have this notion that they don't have any right and they protect each other.Lets wait and see what the government is going to do not say apparently the same culprits are still working going about with their families ,this country is going to the dogs
Avatar

Robrt017Mugabe99

Posted 82 days ago
"................working going about with their families ,this country is going to the dogs............"

==================

this is a problem I 've with black person like yourself who is misguided/disorientetetd doesnt know where we come from. To educate you dumb black person the country was with the dogs (apartheid) before who can forget SAPS of Eugene De Kok the Prime Evil for you to tell us our country goes to the dogs you are living in lalala land.

If I were you making sense of your intellect capabilty I would realise that the current police men we have 65% of them were employed by apartheid nothing else otherthan to skiet n donor eg Hilton Botha, what the ANC govt has done is to establish ICDP a unit to investigate police activities , to ask you did we have this unit during the dogs regime.

Stop being a disgrace black person make use of your intellectual capability and making meaningful contribution to our democrcacy and shut up if dof.

Avatar

BokfanSaffer

Posted 82 days ago
Whys not simplify it for him Mugsy

dark skin good, light skin bad - dark skin good, light skin bad

Thats how you were taught isnt it?

SuiGeneris

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
Why did Africa produce so many generations of idiots ? And then we do a very dangerous thing...we dress them in a uniform and give them power. Or even worse...we allow them in parliament....

muk2

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
If one takes a step back; you will see that SA is in the midst of a volient period. The strikers use violence, crooks shoot their victims, rapes etc. So one cannot single out cops; the patient is entire the South African public. By targeting just the police; you've just patching up the sympthoms. Just as we tackled HIV we need to fight this culture of violence by declaring war on violence. TV soapies need to send out a message of anti-violence is just one solution. Churches, business leaders etc need to preach non-violence at every turn.
Avatar

l984

Posted 82 days ago
While I agree with you, and such ideas or campaigns are to be welcomed - you can only appeal to people's conscience if they have any. How much consciense does a person capable of raping, mutilating, disembowelling and murdering a 17 years old girl could possibly have?

Sasha*-Fierce

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
The President must be serious about Police brutality before we have another Marikana.

muendanyi

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
can u stop politicking only for today? please
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 82 days ago
I wish!
Problem is that without politics and race, people will have to look for a real answer instead of pointing fingers and playing the blame game. That may even make them look at their contribution to the problem and the very last thing they'd want to do is take responsibility for this.

sammax

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
after all that brutality displayed on TV and what went on behind the scenes in that Police Station, Still no arrests have been made. That is more shocking than the incident itself.

Wiseguy

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
I have posted this before, but it seems with each days news there is more and more need to re-address the ills of our society, which definitely needs healing:

I would love to see a day when:

Politicians govern this good country and all its law abiding people using the basic principal of governing "of the people, by the people, FOR the people"! This basic principal should govern all their deliberations, decisions and actions, transparently, honestly and accountably!

Racism in our country is but a distant memory of the "bad old days" and all racial prejudice is but a page in a history book that next generations will learn from!

Abuse in any of it's many many forms(incuding abuse of power by our politicians or police or anyone else for that matter) is not tolerated and actively, honestly and transparently prosecuted and appropriately persecuted, without fear or favour.

The best interests of this nation and all its good people are put first....irrespective!
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
We ALL need to belief in and work hard towards the same goals if we, as a nation, wish to deal effectively with our violent and abusive history, heal ourselves and create a better tommorow for our children and their children!

Our countries "bill of rights" and individuals constitutional rights MUST be taught in every school and every police station in this country!! That is not only a fundamental imperative, but must be MANDATORY!

Mangqeshane

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
Truth be told, ASIPHOXILE lamaphoyisa and they DO NOT DESERVE to wear the uniform. What amazes me also is how the media has gone SO BIG on this, ngoba if you go to any RSA township, especially African townships you will hear some of the most heart wrenching stories about Police abuse and brutal nature of their conduct. YES not all SAPS members are bad, however there is a significant number of them that are BAD. In my township we call them OTSOTSI ABAGQOKA i-UNIFORM.

PhillipPhogole

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
Since Zuma came to power morethan 2000 unarmed civilians were killed by the police and no single police officer was arrested for that Shame on you Bro Zuma

Stirrer

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
How tragic and sad - my condolences to the family of the deceased.
I hope that the thousands of dedicated, law-abiding policemen and -women will not lose the faith - especially as they will now lose even more respect from the public. Maybe the solution lies within the police force - they should be encouraged to summarily eject the bad apples in the police force themselves.
Note my intentional use of South African Police Force (as opposed to the euphimistically South African Police Services currently being hurled around by the ANC-led government!)
Avatar

l984

Posted 82 days ago
"Maybe the solution lies within the police force - they should be encouraged to summarily eject the bad apples in the police force themselves. "

Exactly. And this is not only the solution for the police, but also for all other institutions or levels and spheres in society. All 'bad apples' that are unable or unwilling to distinguish between right and wrong and between good and bad must be identified and held accountable for their wrongdoing following the necessary procedures - or isolated and purged if the level of destruction they are causing is not high enough to be detected and sanctioned by the law.

AlistairMorrish

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
What is becoming apparent is the public use of social media to critique the authorities in South Africa - anyone for an African Spring?

The ANC/Government will be able to muzzle the press but they won't be able to muzzle the thousands of witnesses who have cellphones and access to the web.................

I was told of intimidation at the voting booths by ANC cadres, where they required a photo on your cell phone, of your vote - in the appropriate place - when leaving the polling station....this now - the use of cell phones against them seems like good irony!

Mangqeshane

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
How I thought this was about police brutality, when has the baton been passed to Pres Zuma and the ANC?
Avatar

Wiseguy

Posted 82 days ago
When they stood before the electorate of this country and asked to be voted into power, then were voted into power and took over the responsibility for running the show, that is the nation RSA!

i_stub_born

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
...just remember that the ANC-SACP-COSATU triumvirate as a totalitarian coalition wanting to eternize in power, cannot do so effectively unless they have ABSOLUTE control over media which inevitably will inform and report people on the excesses of the bureaucrats...

...ABSOLUTE control over the judiciary, which will legalize and justify those excesses, and will block any attempt to bring them to book.....

...ABSOLUTE control over Army or Police or both, to subjugate the people by fear, violence and murder and so avoid protests and revolts

..This worked perfectly well in the past and with every dictatorship in the world is a success formula, why would it be different here now???....................

BrianKZN

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
This incident raises a host of questions, for instance what part did Xenophobia play in the way the poor man was handled? Where any of the parties under the influence?
We are reaping the fruits of the authorities letting taxi drivers have the impession that they are untouchable and that they own the roads, they get away with many violations and therefore bad habits are the norm. Where are the traffic police?
Also after nearly 10 years of being in power the ruling authorities should by now have in place an hierarchy of command from which leaders who can mentor, train and inculcate the correct attitudes, should be found. Political appointments have a lot to do with many of the bad incidents.
Another aspect is that police should have the attitude that they are "keepers of the peace' not "law enforcers" except in extreme and exceptional circumstances!
We can only hope leasons have been learnt from this wretched man's cruel death!

BhekumuziMdakane

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
who do we go to when you're in danager?
what is ubuntu?
why is it that they get suspended and we all have to except that.
if the videos show enough evidence, why are they still being investgated?
i have lost hope for this country a home that just turned in to hell,
i refuse to carry on my lifetime in a place where i can't trust those that i'm told to being trust worthy.
South Africa will end up losing it's people if this goes on.

the heart of a human.

Sotho-English-Xhosa1

Posted 82 days ago
Avatar
Man has dominated man to his injury. A human cannot rule over another human. Why:
-He is inperfect,
-He is short lived,
-He was meant to rule over animals not humans,
-Unlike Engile, He goes hungry,
-He cannot read minds and heart conditions,
-He can only live for 70 to 90 years, 100 are the lucky. life has been in existance for decades,
-He cannot do everything alone, he needs serious help.
Avatar

Sotho-English-Xhosa1

Posted 82 days ago
Angels