The Big Read: Gender's not just Adam and Eve

25 August 2016 - 09:59 By Jonathan Jansen

If she kept losing, there would be no fuss. But Caster Semenya was winning, and winning big, and so the questions started all over again. It was pathetic watching two of the losers hugging each other and appearing to ignore the 800m Olympic champion as she graciously went towards them to acknowledge her competition. Suddenly all three African winners in the 800m (gold, South Africa; silver, Burundi; and bronze, Kenya) were suspected to be "hyper-androgenous women". Sadly, the sporting authorities will start probing Semenya's chemical fluids all over again.However, too much of the local reaction to the questioning of Caster's performance is based on rage. The anger is understandable but we need to develop reasoned responses to the treatment of this talented athlete.One such project committed to this goal is an NGO called Thinking Schools SA, which wants to insert thought and thinking into everyday classroom practice so that children leave schools not only having covered content but having mastered the ability to think their way out of difficult social and educational problems.In this spirit of critical thinking, Malcolm Gladwell and Nicholas Johnson recently engaged in an interesting exchange in the New Yorker magazine on the merits of the Rio performance of Caster, the South African athlete born "with the biological equivalent of a turbocharger".One of them argues that, if we did not have separate competitions for men and women, women would seldom win simply because of a chemical advantage that comes with more testosterone. We consider this discrimination to be fair, goes the argument, given broadly accepted gender variation in physical and chemical attributes.Fine, but why choose testosterone as your marker of discrimination? Why not the extraordinary long legs of high jumpers or the fast-twitch muscle fibres of the Jamaican sprinters or the high-altitude training advantage of the Kenyan long-distance athletes, or the access to hi-tech facilities and expertise possible only in advanced capitalist states?It is hard not to conclude that what is at stake here is prejudice parading as science. Take for example this seemingly innocent commentary as Wayde van Niekerk did the unexpected - breaking away from former champions in the last stretch of his record-breaking 400m final at the Olympics."He had wings on his feet in the last 50m," said the over-excited TV commentator. How should we interpret that revealing comment? That something must have assisted him beyond his natural ability to run that fast? What was "winging" him, in other words?Regardless of the measuring index to be used for comparing athletic performance, here is the question that needs to be taken on - why do we insist on dividing humanity into two neat and tidy genders? We know that intersex and gender-fluid individuals exist. We know that Caster identifies as a woman. The problem, therefore, is not Caster; it is the failure of society to acknowledge what has always existed but been politely denied. To make Caster's testosterone levels the issue is to duck questions about variations in, and the complexity of, human identities and how social norms and measures should take account of these realities.I cannot imagine how demeaning and distressing it must be for Caster and her family when she is continually ogled as a human oddity in a supposedly "normal" society. Comparisons to Saartjie Baartman are no exaggeration. And so. to disagree with Gladwell, this is a human rights issue and not simply a matter of fairness in athletic competition. To make the normal strange, even odd, is to engage in the worst kind of prejudice.Caster's case is not a measurement issue but an educational concern. Biology textbooks for schools need to be rewritten to recognise intersex persons; similarly, law texts need to account for such diversity. Church sermons need to change beyond the simple narrative of "Adam and Eve" as pure, simple categories. Parents must teach their children to accept and embrace these "new" identities among us, for no prejudice rolls away by good intentions alone. The task is political and pedagogical, and it will take time to change attitudes towards persons like Caster Semenya...

There’s never been a more important time to support independent media.

From World War 1 to present-day cosmopolitan South Africa and beyond, the Sunday Times has been a pillar in covering the stories that matter to you.

For just R80 you can become a premium member (digital access) and support a publication that has played an important political and social role in South Africa for over a century of Sundays. You can cancel anytime.

Already subscribed? Sign in below.



Questions or problems? Email helpdesk@timeslive.co.za or call 0860 52 52 00.