Smallholder vegetable farmers aren’t getting the finance they need: This is what it should look like

Fresh efforts are being made to increase the share of black ownership in South Africa’s agricultural sector. This follows decades of missteps and badly designed interventions that have failed to significantly change ownership patterns in the sector.

The latest plan, known as the agriculture and agro-processing master plan, aims to provide, among others, comprehensive farmer assistance, development finance, agricultural research and development and extension services.

It also aims to increase the share of black ownership and the contribution of small-scale producers in the country by 2030.

The master plan has been signed by the government and representatives from businesses and civil society organisations within the agricultural sector. It is the first multi-stakeholder strategic plan in the country. Its aim is to promote transformation in agriculture and agro-processing sectors affected by apartheid.

However, farming is a capital and resource intensive business which requires access to sufficient finance.

In a recent study we looked at the funding challenges facing smallholder farmers in the vegetables value chain. A smallholder farmer is someone engaged in agricultural activities on a small scale, generally farming less than 10 hectares of land and selling part of their crop and farming for subsistence.

The study provides valuable insights that could help inform the implementation of the master plan. For example, one of the main findings is that there is an urgent need for the government to provide “patient” finance, such as longer repayment periods, to allow farmers to build capabilities, accumulate returns and be profitable. The problem with government funding is that it is limited in scale and scope and provided on a piecemeal basis.

This is not to suggest there is no financing available for farmers. What is in contention is whether what’s available helps farmers enter, expand and grow.

How financing is offered affects who farms

Farming needs substantial investment in on-farm infrastructure and equipment. This includes fencing, farming tools, tractors, boreholes and pumps, irrigation systems, shade nets and greenhouse tunnels.

Research by the Centre for Competition, Regulation and Economic Development found it can cost a farmer between R2.5m and R3m to install an irrigation system and greenhouse tunnels on a 5-hectare farm. These are substantial investments for smallholder farmers.

Short repayment periods mean farmers are required to pay back their loans sometimes before they have even become profitable.

The issue of financing is particularly concerning given that smallholder farmers are self-financed or have limited access to debt finance.

As one farmer put it: “The problem why farmers are collapsing and exiting the vegetable farming business is because they get a loan to start farming and they make losses in the first years which means they can’t repay the loan, so they start selling farm assets to repay the loan.”

This is counterproductive. If a farm goes under, all the funding and non-financial support previously provided to get the enterprise started is lost.

Patient funding is the answer. Patient financing in agriculture is financing and support that’s made on a longer-term basis and that recognises the extended time frames and risks associated with agricultural cycles and the time it takes for the farmer to become profitable.

The lack of patient financing also stands in the way of farmers being able to access reliable and consistent markets, such as supermarkets. Supermarkets have stringent requirements which often entail farmers needing to invest further in their farms. The investment required can be in the form of infrastructure such as pack houses, pack sheds, cold rooms, proper financial statements and refrigerated trucks to deliver to the stores.

Government support does not cover weather and climate change-related risks. These are increasingly affecting smallholder farmers who practise open field farming.

Many farmers also complained of complicated application forms and bureaucratic application processes to obtain finance. Often small farmers don’t have all the requirements stipulated on the forms, such as bookkeeping. This limits their chances of getting access to finance. There is also a lack of assistance from the department on how applicants can fill out the forms when they encounter difficulties.

One farmer suggested: “The challenge with government support is that it comes and helps piecemeal and they don’t go all the way. Also, government does not come to visit the farm to check and evaluate or monitor progress.”

What needs to done?

The government needs to provide patient finance to allow farmers to build capabilities, accumulate returns and be profitable.

This will safeguard the participation of smallholder farmers by allowing them to access more reliable and consistent markets. It will also benefit consumers through better quality produce and avoid potential food shortages in the wake of high inflation and the energy crisis in South Africa.

Having the agriculture and agro-processing master plan in place is helpful, but it needs to be put into practice properly. If smallholder farmers are its focus, more emphasis needs to be placed on providing them with access to finance to equip them with the tools to achieve better production.

Karissa Moothoo Padayachie is a researcher for the Centre for Competition, Regulation and Economic Development, University of Johannesburg

• This article was first published by The Conversation