Rhodes hypocrisy storm

25 January 2017 - 09:17 By Roxanne Henderson and The Daily Telegraph
subscribe Just R20 for the first month. Support independent journalism by subscribing to our digital news package.
Subscribe now
Rhodes University
Rhodes University
Image: Nigel Forshaw via Facebook

The paradox of being a #RhodesMustFall activist and a Rhodes scholar-elect is not lost on Mbalenhle Matandela, but she believes being in this unique position can help her do good.

Matandela, 23, and fellow #RhodesMustFall activist Joshua Nott are among nine South Africans awarded scholarships of R670,000 each by the Rhodes Trust, to join Oxford University later this year.

Both were involved in the 2015 protests at the University of Cape Town, calling for a statue of Cecil John Rhodes to be removed from its prominent place on campus.

Matandela, who knows Nott from their time as students at UCT, said she regarded the scholarship as an opportunity to learn more about the African diaspora and further her other intellectual interests.

  • Rhodes manages a day of peaceful examsRelative calm descended on Rhodes University on Thursday‚ a day after turbulent protests.

Matandela will register for an M Phil in development studies when the academic year begins at the end of September, hoping to engage in a gender-based analysis of development on the African continent.

She currently works for the University of the Witwatersrand's Centre for Applied Legal Studies' Right2Protest project. Her honours thesis focused on experiences of black women in the #RhodesMustFall movement.

  • Rhodes fees protesers in violent standoff with copsFees protests continued at Rhodes University on Tuesday with students engaged in a day-long standoff with police who fired rubber bullets and teargas to disperse protesters.

This week Nott was plunged into a social media storm in South Africa and the UK, being labelled as a hypocrite for accepting the scholarship in light of his #RhodesMustFall activism.

UCT's #RhodesMustFall Facebook page rejected Nott as a key member of the movement, following the publication of an article by British newspapers.

"Joshua Nott and I have political differences, so I would prefer not to comment on this backlash," Matandela said.

Matandela said she saw the Rhodes Trust's scholarship as reparation for past injustices.

"To me, it's about redress. I'm a person of conviction and so being a #RhodesMustFall activist was about linking up different struggles that highlight the expectations of Rhodes as a colonialist. I've come to think of my being at Oxford and having this specific scholarship, as reparation."

  • Unisa‚ Rhodes and University of Venda rely most on tuition feesStellenbosch University scores from donations‚ South Africa's newest universities rely on government funding‚ while Unisa‚ Rhodes and Univen will be hardest hit if the FeesMustFall campaign results in free tuition as they are most reliant on paying students.

She said the Rhodes Trust did not consider historical disadvantage in its selection criteria and that she now hoped to change this from within, particularly for the Southern African region.

Matandela, who attended Pietermaritzburg private school Epworth on a scholarship, comes from a working-class family.

Her mother was a live-in domestic worker in the Durban suburb of Westville.

She said that her family initially had limited understanding of what a Rhodes scholar was but were excited for her. In her application to the Rhodes Trust, she wrote extensively of her activism.

The Times has not yet been able to reach Nott.

Other South African Rhodes scholars-elect are Fuaad Coovadia, Emily van Heerden, Christiaan van der Walt, Keitumetse-Kabelo Murray, Saul Musker, Abigail Branford and Sizwe Mkwanazi.

subscribe Just R20 for the first month. Support independent journalism by subscribing to our digital news package.
Subscribe now